WASHINGTON - Freddie Mac secretly paid a Republican consulting
firm $2 million to kill legislation that would have regulated and
trimmed the mortgage finance giant and its sister company, Fannie Mae,
three years before the government took control to prevent their
In the cross hairs of the campaign carried out by DCI
of Washington were Republican senators and a regulatory overhaul bill
sponsored by Sen. Chuck Hagel, R-Neb. DCI's chief executive is Doug
Goodyear, whom John McCain's campaign later hired to manage the GOP
convention in September.
Freddie Mac's payments to DCI began
shortly after the Senate Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs Committee
sent Hagel's bill to the then GOP-run Senate on July 28, 2005. All GOP
members of the committee supported it; all Democrats opposed it.
the midst of DCI's yearlong effort, Hagel and 25 other Republican
senators pleaded unsuccessfully with Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist,
R-Tenn., to allow a vote.
"If effective regulatory reform
legislation ... is not enacted this year, American taxpayers will
continue to be exposed to the enormous risk that Fannie Mae and Freddie
Mac pose to the housing market, the overall financial system and the
economy as a whole," the senators wrote in a letter that proved
Unknown to the senators, DCI was undermining support
for the bill in a campaign targeting 17 Republican senators in 13
states, according to documents obtained by The Associated Press. The
states and the senators targeted changed over time, but always stayed
on the Republican side.
In the end, there was not enough
Republican support for Hagel's bill to warrant bringing it up for a
vote because Democrats also opposed it and the votes of some would be
needed for passage. The measure died at the end of the 109th Congress.
R-Ariz., was not a target of the DCI campaign. He signed Hagel's letter
and three weeks later signed on as a co-sponsor of the bill.
By the time McCain did so, however, DCI's effort had gone on for nine months and was on its way toward killing the bill.
recent days, McCain has said Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae were "one of
the real catalysts, really the match that lit this fire" of the global
credit crisis. McCain has accused Democratic presidential candidate
Barack Obama of taking advice from former executives of Fannie Mae and
Freddie Mac, and failing to see that the companies were heading for a
McCain's campaign manager, Rick Davis, or his lobbying
firm has taken more than $2 million from Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac
dating to 2000.
Obama has received $120,349 in political donations from employees of Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae; McCain $21,550.
Republican senators targeted by DCI began hearing from prominent
constituents and financial contributors, all urging the defeat of
Hagel's bill because it might harm the housing boom. The effort
generated newspaper articles and radio and TV appearances by
participants who spoke out against the measure.
Mac headquarters in 2005, the few dozen people who knew what DCI was
doing referred to the initiative as "the stealth lobbying campaign,"
according to three people familiar with the drive.
They spoke only on condition of anonymity, saying they fear retaliation if their names were disclosed.
Freddie Mac executive Hollis McLoughlin oversaw DCI's drive, according to the three people.
goal was not to have any Freddie Mac fingerprints on this project and
DCI became the hidden hand behind the effort," one of the three people
told the AP.
Before 2004, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac were
Democratic strongholds. After 2004, Republicans ran their political
operations. McLoughlin, who joined Freddie Mac in 2004 as chief of
staff, has given $32,250 to Republican candidates over the years,
including $2,800 to McCain, and has given none to Democrats, according
to the Center for Responsive Politics, a nonpartisan group that tracks
money in politics.
On Friday night, Hagel's chief of staff, Mike
Buttry, said Hagel's legislation "was the last best chance to bring
greater oversight and tighter regulation to Freddie and Fannie, and
they used every means they could to defeat Sen. Hagel's legislation
every step of the way."
"It is outrageous that a congressionally
chartered government-sponsored enterprise would lobby against a member
of Congress's bill that would strengthen the regulation and oversight
of that institution," Buttry said in a statement. "America has paid an
extremely high price for the reckless, and possibly criminal, actions
of the leadership at Freddie and Fannie."
Nine of the 17 targeted
Republican senators did not sign Hagel's letter: Sens. Mitch McConnell
of Kentucky, Christopher "Kit" Bond and Jim Talent of Missouri, Conrad
Burns of Montana, Mike DeWine of Ohio, Lamar Alexander of Tennessee,
Olympia Snowe of Maine, Lincoln Chafee of Rhode Island and George Allen
of Virginia. Aside from the nine, 20 other Republican senators did not
sign Hagel's letter.
McConnell's office said members of leadership do not sign letters to the leader. McConnell was majority whip at the time.
of the targeted senators did sign it: Sens. Rick Santorum of
Pennsylvania, Mike Crapo of Idaho, Jim Bunning of Kentucky, Larry Craig
of Idaho, John Ensign of Nevada, Lindsey Graham of South Carolina,
George Voinovich of Ohio and David Vitter of Louisiana. Santorum, Crapo
and Bunning were on the Senate Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs
Committee and had voted in favor of sending the bill to the full Senate.
Thursday, Freddie Mac acknowledged that the company "did retain DCI to
provide public affairs support at the state and local level." On
Friday, DCI issued a four-sentence statement saying it complied with
all applicable federal and state laws and regulations in representing
Freddie Mac. Neither Freddie Mac nor DCI would say how much Goodyear's
consulting firm was paid.
Freddie Mac paid DCI $10,000 a month
for each of the targeted states, so the more states, the more money for
DCI, according to the three people familiar with the program. In
addition, Freddie Mac paid DCI a group retainer of $40,000 a month plus
$20,000 a month for each regional manager handling the project, the
three people said.
Last month, the concerns of the 26 Republican
senators who signed Hagel's bill became a reality when the government
seized control of Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae amid their near financial
collapse. Federal prosecutors are investigating accounting, disclosure
and corporate governance issues at both companies, which own or
guarantee more than $5 trillion in mortgages, roughly equivalent to
half of the national debt.
Freddie Mac was so pleased with DCI's
work that it retained the firm for other jobs, finally cutting DCI
loose last month after the government takeover, according to the three
people familiar with the situation.
Freddie Mac's problems began when Hagel's legislation won approval from the Senate committee.
did not like the harshest provision, which would have given a new
regulator a mandate to shrink Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae by forcing
them to sell off part of their portfolios. That approach, the Democrats
feared, would cut into the ability of low- and moderate-income families
to buy houses.
The political backdrop to the debate "was like
bizarre-o-world," said the second of three people familiar with the
program. "The Republicans were pro-regulation and the Democrats were
against it; it was upside down."
Sen. Richard Shelby, the
committee chairman at the time, underscored that in a statement
Wednesday, saying that with Democrats already on their side, it was not
surprising that Freddie Mac and Freddie Mae went after Republicans.
"Unfortunately," said Shelby, R-Ala., "efforts then to derail reform
In a sign of bad things to come, Freddie Mac
was already having serious problems in 2005. Auditors had exposed
massive accounting issues, so improved regulation was one obvious
Once Freddie Mac's in-house lobbyists failed to keep
Hagel's bill bottled up in the committee, McLoughlin responded by
secretly hiring DCI.
DCI never filed lobbying reports with
Congress about what it was doing because the firm was relying on a
long-recognized gap in the disclosure law.
Federal lobbying law only requires reporting and registration when there are contacts with a legislator or staff.
have it stealthy, not to let people know who is behind this, in my
opinion is unethical," said James Thurber, director of the Center for
Congressional and Presidential Studies at American University who long
has taught courses about lobbying.
Goodyear is a longtime
political consultant from Arizona who resigned from the Republican
convention job this year after Newsweek magazine revealed he had
lobbied for the repressive military junta of Myanmar.
Freddie Mac's senior vice president for external relations, was
assistant treasury secretary from 1989 through 1992 in the
administration of President Bush's father. McLoughlin served as chief
of staff to Sen. Nicholas Brady, R-N.J., in 1982 and to Rep. Millicent
Fenwick, R-N.J., from 1975-79.
Seven of the 17 targeted
Republican senators were in the midst of re-election campaigns in 2006,
and according to one of the three people familiar with the program,
Freddie Mac and DCI hoped those facing tough races would tell their
Republican colleagues back in Washington that "we've got enough
trouble; you're making it worse with Hagel's bill."
Five of the seven DCI targets who ran for re-election in 2006 lost, and Senate control switched to the Democrats.
Freddie Mac e-mail on May 4, 2006 - the day before Hagel's letter -
details the behind-the-scenes effort that Freddie Mac and DCI generated
to hold down the number of Republicans signing Hagel's letter urging a
full Senate vote. It said:
"What I'm asking is that DCI get a few
of their key well-connected constituents from each state to call in to
the DC office of their Republican senators and speak to the
(legislative director) or (chief of staff) and urge them not to sign
the letter. The following could be used as a short script."
proposed script read: "We can all agree that Fannie's and Freddie's
regulator should be strengthened but unfortunately, S.190 goes too far
and could potentially have damaging effects on Georgia's - example -
According to the third of the three people familiar
with the program, "DCI was asked to help keep senators from signing; it
was a big part of their effort that year and it was viewed as a success
since many DCI targets did not sign the letter."
after the first four months of the campaign was spelled out in a
19-page document dated Dec. 12, 2005, and titled, "Freddie Mac Field
Program State by State Summary Report."
A snippet of a senator-by-senator breakdown of the efforts says this about Maine's Snowe:
Harriman, former state senator, co-chair of Snowe's 2006 campaign,
personal Snowe friend, major GOP donor and investment adviser, has
written the senator a personal letter on this issue. Dick Morin, vice
president Maine Association of Mortgage Brokers, has been in direct
contact with Sen. Snowe's committee staff, has sent a letter to Snowe,
and is pursuing a dozen(s) of letters from his members."
Wednesday, Snowe's office issued a statement saying that she "literally
gets hundreds of 'Dear Colleague' letters seeking support for their
positions that she does not sign. Had this legislation come up for a
vote in 2006, she certainly would have considered it on its merits - as
she does every vote. Just last July, she voted for the housing bill
that established a new, stronger regulator."
Rosario Marin, a
staunch McCain supporter who spoke at the GOP convention in September,
was among the people DCI used in carrying out the campaign.
the U.S. treasurer during the first term of the Bush administration,
went to Missouri and to Montana, Burns' state, where she spoke out
against Hagel's bill.
At the time, Burns, who ended up losing his
re-election bid, was caught up in a Washington influence peddling
scandal centering on disgraced lobbyist Jack Abramoff.
visit triggered a local newspaper story in which the reporter contacted
Burns' staff for comment. Burns' office told the newspaper the senator
was not supportive of the latest version of Hagel's bill.
Wednesday, Marin, now state consumer services secretary in California,
issued a statement confirming that her trips to Missouri and Montana
were in her capacity as a DCI consultant.
The December 2005 summary listing 17 Republican targets outlines the inroads DCI was making.
day one" of the effort, Sen. George Allen of Virginia had not addressed
Hagel's bill and his legislative aide for housing was not assigned to
it, the report said.
"Today," the report added, "the senator is
aware of the issue and ... at the moment he is undecided." Allen's
deputy chief of staff "has said that the senator will take into
consideration before he decides that Freddie Mac is located in Virginia
and is one of the largest Virginia employers."
leaders James Todd, president, the Peterson Companies wrote to both
senators," the report added. "Milt Peterson, the founder and CEO of the
company is one of Allen's major donors."
In the end, Allen, who lost his bid for re-election in 2006, did not sign Hagel's letter.
On the Net:
- Freddie Mac:
- Fannie Mae: