Published on

McCain's Plumber No Ordinary Joe

Carrie Budoff Brown and Amie Parnes

Democratic presidential candidate, Sen. Barack Obama, D-Ill., facing camera, talks to plumber Joe Wurzelbacher in Holland, Ohio, Sunday, Oct. 12, 2008.A day after making Joseph Wurzelbacher famous, referencing him in the debate almost two dozen times as someone who would pay higher taxes under Barack Obama, McCain learned the fine print Thursday on the plumber's not-so-tidy personal story. (AP Photo/Jae C. Hong)

NEW YORK - John McCain hung his final presidential debate performance on an Ohio plumber who campaign aides never vetted.

A day after making Joseph Wurzelbacher famous, referencing him in the
debate almost two dozen times as someone who would pay higher taxes
under Barack Obama, McCain learned the fine print Thursday on the
plumber's not-so-tidy personal story: He owes back taxes. He is not a
licensed plumber. And it turns out that Wurzelbacher makes less than
$250,000 a year, which means he would receive a tax cut if Obama were
elected president.

McCain likes to say that he isn't George W. Bush - and in this case of
bungled public relations, it is clear he is not. The
famously-disciplined Bush campaign operation would likely have found
the perfect anonymous citizen to illustrate a policy proposal, rather
than spontaneously wrap itself around an unknown entity with so many

While the arc of Wurzelbacher's breakneck trip through the news cycle -
from private citizen to insta-celebrity to political target - offers a
curious insight into the political media culture, it also appears to
offer a glimpse into the McCain campaign's on-the-fly decisionmaking

A McCain source said Thursday that the campaign read about Wurzelbacher
on the Drudge Report, while another campaign aide confirmed that he was
not vetted. Senior McCain adviser Matt McDonald told Politico after the
debate that Wurzelbacher was not aware that he would become central to
the candidates' third and final showdown, although Wurzelbacher told
reporters Thursday that the McCain campaign contacted him earlier in
the week to ask him to appear with the candidate at a Toledo rally
scheduled for Sunday. (He may not make it, now that he's scheduled to
be in New York for TV interviews.)

"Joe, if you're watching, I'm sorry," McCain said Thursday, referring
to the press attention that the Ohio man had received, during a taping
of the Late Show with David Letterman.

 McCain said he has not spoken to Wurzelbacher yet. Aides have reached out, hoping to get him on the stump at some point.

By Thursday evening, though, the McCain campaign had tied itself even closer to Wurzelbacher than the night before. 

campaign released a web ad titled "Joe the Plumber." McCain opened his
rally in Downingtown, Pa., with a shout-out to Wurzelbacher.

"We had a good debate last night. I thought I did pretty well, but
let's have a little straight talk: the real winner last night was Joe
the Plumber," McCain told 1,000 people. "He won and small businesses
across America won, because the American people are not going to let
Senator Obama raise their taxes in a tough economy."

For a few moments, the crowd chanted, "Joe! Joe! Joe!"

"Joe's the man!" McCain yelled back.

Obama veered from his prepared remarks in Londonderry, N.H., to
question McCain's use of Wurzelbacher, saying the Republican senator's
tax plan would do more for corporations and wealthy individuals than,
say, a plumber.

"He is trying to suggest that a plumber is the guy he's fighting for,"
Obama said told a rally with 4,100 people. "How many plumbers do you
know making a quarter of a million dollars a year?"

Obama's remarks echoed those of his vice presidential nominee, Joe
Biden, who criticized McCain for "the notion of this guy Joe the

"I don't have any Joe the Plumbers in my neighborhood that make
$250,000 a year that are worried," Biden said on NBC's Today show. "The
Joe the Plumbers in my neighborhood, the Joe the Cops in my
neighborhood, the Joe the Grocery Store Owners in my neighborhood -
they make, like 98 percent of small businesses, less than $250,000 a
year. And they're going to do very well under us, and they're going to
be in real tough shape under John McCain."

Wurzelbacher, 34, a single father and self-described conservative,
emerged as a symbol for a tax debate that has become a mainstay of the
give-and-take on the campaign trail, and also of the white
working-class voters who have been pursued so vigorously by both

The exchange between Obama and Wurzelbacher that first brought him to
the McCain campaign's attention, occurred Sunday while the Democratic
nominee was canvassing for votes in Toledo.

"I'm being taxed more and more for fulfilling the American Dream,"
Wurzelbacher told Obama, adding he was concerned about having to pay
more taxes as he worked towards his goal of buying his own plumbing
business, which could draw income of $250,000 a year. "Your new tax
plan is going to tax me more, isn't it?"

Obama said that, under his proposal, those making $250,000 or less
would not pay more in taxes, but incomes above that level would be
subject to a higher tax rate.

"It's not that I want to punish your success, I just want to make sure
that everybody who is behind you - that they've got the chance at
success too," Obama told Wurzelbacher. "I think that when you spread
the wealth around, it's good for everybody."

Since then, the encounter has also provided fodder for conservatives
alleging his tax plan would amount to a massive redistribution of

McCain said Obama's plan would stop entrepreneurs such as Wurzelbacher
from investing in new small businesses and keep existing ones from

Even before the debate concluded Wednesday, local TV stations, network
producers and journalists from around the country were trying to reach
Wurzelbacher. By Thursday afternoon, he had been picked to pieces.

Wurzelbacher acknowledged to reporters that he doesn't have a plumber's
license, but said he didn't need one because he works for someone else
at a company that does residential work. State and local records show
Wurzelbacher has no license, although his employer does.David Golis,
manager and residential building official for the Toledo Division of
Building Inspection, said Wurzelbacher still would need to be a
licensed apprentice or journeyman to work in Toledo.

Wurzelbacher also owes the state of Ohio $1,182.98 in personal income
tax, according to Lucas County Court of Common Pleas records. The Ohio
Department of Taxation filed a claim on his property until he pays the
debt, according to the records. The lien remains active.

The McCain campaign weighed in on Wurzelbacher's behalf, using the opportunity to take digs at two frequent targets.

"It's an outrage that the Obama campaign and the media are attacking
Joe the Plumber for asking a legitimate question of a presidential
candidate. This is why voters still have so many questions about Barack
Obama. Instead of answering tough questions, his campaign attacks
average Americans for daring to look at the reality behind his words,
said Tucker Bounds, spokesman the McCain-Palin campaign. "John McCain
will continue to fight on behalf of all hardworking Americans like Joe
for policies geared toward increasing prosperity and reducing the
burden on taxpayers -- not 'spreading the wealth around' for Senator
Government to distribute as he sees fit."

Leaning against his black Dodge Durango SUV, Wurzelbacher at first was
amused by it all, then overwhelmed and finally a little annoyed.

"I don't have a lot of pull. It's not like I'm Matt Damon," he said "I just hope I'm not making too much of a fool of myself."

Ben Smith and Jonathan Martin contributed to this story, which also includes information from the Associated Press.


This is the world we live in. This is the world we cover.

Because of people like you, another world is possible. There are many battles to be won, but we will battle them together—all of us. Common Dreams is not your normal news site. We don't survive on clicks. We don't want advertising dollars. We want the world to be a better place. But we can't do it alone. It doesn't work that way. We need you. If you can help today—because every gift of every size matters—please do.

Share This Article

More in: