Where Have all the Protest Singers Gone?
One would think the time is ripe for an explosion of protest music.
witnessing what pundits are calling a historic presidential race at a
time when even the party holding the Oval Office admits that a big dose
of change is needed. We've been at war on two fronts for years with no
end in sight, while there's less than a month to go in the election.
The economy appears to be in free fall. The race is close, and the
rhetoric is heating up fast as each side lobs verbal grenades at each
other almost daily.
So where are all the protest songs, calling for one brand of change over the other?
Protest music is rare from conservative artists, but even the liberals songwriters seem to be sitting this one out.
are overwhelmed by the corruption of our government," says Paul
Kantner, a founding member of Jefferson Airplane and Jefferson
Starship, who just released a new Starship record, "Jefferson's Tree of
Liberty. "They don't think their vote counts "... people don't have
In other words, even if we have two new candidates
promising change from an outgoing and unpopular administration, it
might just be that musicians aren't feeling they can make a difference,
especially after the outpouring of activism in 2004.
That was the
year John Kerry had the support of Bruce Springsteen, Pearl Jam and
Dave Matthews, among other big-name artists, performing on the "Vote
for Change" tour. Linda Ronstandt was grabbing headlines
for speaking out in the face of open hostility at many of her shows. It
was the year that gave us songs like Ani DiFranco's "Animal," the
Beastie Boys' "It Takes Time to Build," and the Roots' "Why (What's
Goin' On?)," among others.
Even two years later, just in time
for midterm Congressional elections, there was still an echo of the
outrage, most notably in Neil Young's "Living With War" record and his
passionate summer tour with Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young.
of the stalwarts are still around, such as Bruce Springsteen, doing
benefits for Barack Obama. And bands that are almost always political,
like Bad Religion, are still addressing the issues. Punk
singer-songwriter Ted Leo just wrote and recorded a four-song EP after
witnessing the treatment of protesters at the Republican convention,
the timing of which made it only available on his Web site. And people
like John Legend and Billy Joel have also appeared at events.
all in all, the desperation that was apparent among artists willing to
sing protest songs four years ago is largely absent at this year's
political crunch time.
"There's baggage to becoming a protest
singer," says Chris Walla, guitarist for Death Cab For Cutie and an
admitted political junkie, whose band has played Obama rallies.
"Because of the media portrayal of the protests, nobody wants to be
associated with it. I don't think it would work with our audience all
Plus, Walla says, there's a strong perception that,
unlike Kerry in 2004, Obama doesn't need the help. And there's no
George W. Bush in the race to focus on.
"When your candidate is a
rock star on his own, why does he need Death Cab for Cutie?" Walla
says. "What Obama needs is 'Rednecks for Obama.'"
Nathan Berg, a
professor of economics and sociology at the University of Texas at
Dallas, is the singer for the Halliburtons, one of the few bands out
there continuously making political music.
more quiet regarding the musical discourse this year," he says. "I
think there are those of us who thought 2004 was important and thought
things would change. It's hard to see strong rebuttal for pessimism."
speculates that Kerry's loss deflated musicians. They're getting change
one way or another this year, which de-focuses years of targeting
President George W. Bush.
"My band played at Dealey Plaza on the
anniversary of the Iraq war, but I'm feeling my time is better spent
speaking as an economist and social scientist," says Berg, whose band
has toured Ireland and Germany. "There's actually much more of an
anti-Bush and anti-war scene in Europe." There's also some low-level
recorded activism, coming at a lower profile from groups like metal
band Testament and bluegrass group the Del McCoury Band, an indication
of big names laying low this year. McCoury's new record is called
Kanter says that with each passing year,
technological distractions and a corporate media unwilling to take
chances make it more difficult for musicians to make a difference.
are overwhelmed by modern times," he says. "There's an overflow of
information and they become confused. In the '60s we thought we could
change the world - and we did change some of it," he says. "People
today don't have that hope."