PARIS -- Recently in Japan, traveling to and fro around Tokyo, I was
surprised by the sight -- through a train window -- of the Japanese
"rising sun" flag, or hinomaru. The moment was remarkable because, all
that day, it was the only flag I saw.
If I had covered as much ground in the U.S.A., in an area as densely
settled as greater Tokyo, I probably would have spotted the Stars and
Stripes displayed in hundreds of places -- over post offices, on car
antennas, lapels, policemen’s sleeves, on warehouses, bridges,
front-lawn flagpoles, t-shirts, halter tops and Coca-Cola cups.
The difference lies in history. But a parallel looms, perhaps, in the
future.
In Japan, the end of World War II marked the eclipse of a period of
ultra-nationalist militarism that dated to the 1880's -- when a
demimonde of violent right-wing "societies"{ began to quietly,
ruthlessly subvert Japanese government and culture. Even in the
Empire's death throes in 1945, Japan’s militarists -- defeated
everywhere but on the home front -- dug in their heels and forestalled
surrender, contributing to the national horror that took place in
Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Today these discredited elements linger
stubbornly in Japan's body politic, preventing the ruling Liberal
Democratic Party from becoming either liberal or democratic, and
poisoning foreign relations with China, Korea and Taiwan, among others.
One lamentable legacy of Japan’s imperial militarists is that they
brought shame onto the national flag. Today, flying the hinomaru is a
bitter provocation, suggesting fierce xenophobia and racist aggression.
To be caught in Japan with your flag open is mildly embarrassing, and
totally uncool.
In America today, waving the flag is also devolving into an act of
provocation. Old Glory now -- like the hinomaru during those 65 dark
years in Japan -- has been taken captive by rightist advocates of
military supremacy. This flag demands ritual and submission. This flag
requires a "patriotism" divorced from discourse, diplomacy and dissent.
Any hesitation to pledge absolute allegiance, any reluctance to
virtually worship the Stars and Stripes as a sort of graven idol, is
deemed tantamount to treason.
The far right -- supported apparently by popular opinion -- seeks to
amend the Constitution, so we can imprison people for burning the flag
symbolically. This notion prevails despite the reality that
flag-burning has become so unfashionable among protesters that it's a
sort of quaint relic of bygone days. Besides, according to proper flag
etiquette, the only reverent way to dispose of a worn-out flag is to,
well... burn it.
Obsessive flag-worship is common to both the former Japanese Empire and
an increasingly imperial America. It's appropriate to wonder where the
U.S. stands today, compared to that 65-year arc that brought so much
suffering to the people of Japan. If Japan's Age of Militarist Insanity
began in 1880, the comparable U.S. period might properly date to 1961.
That's when America’s wisest general, Dwight D. Eisenhower, issued his
prescient warning against the rise of a "military-industrial complex"
that -- ironically -- has flourished all the more luxuriantly since
Eisenhower condemned it.
It's been 45 years. The Pentagon today is joined at the teat to a
cartel of huge, greedy and swinishly wasteful defense contractors,
whose campaign bribes bloat the war chests of supine presidents and
guarantee jingoist majorities in Congress. Today's U.S.
military-industrial complex looks more and more like its Japanese
forebear.
For instance, the cost of the military in Japan exploded in the 1930's
and '40’s, impoverishing civil society while stifling any voice that
dared challenge the generals, the admirals, their zaibatsu cronies and
-- especially -- the bellicose politicians in Nagatacho who had never
fired a shot nor shed a drop of blood for their country. Today in
America, Pentagon spending exceeds $500 billion a year. The most
profligate spenders and rabid supporters of "preemptive war," "regime
change," "shock and awe" -- and other martial fantasies -- are not the
veterans of human carnage, but a coterie of draftdodging theorists
(Cheney, Bush, Rumsfeld) who prudently turned to war-mongering only
after they were too old to serve.
The fears of General Zinni echo the lamentations of Admiral Yamamoto.
Japan's militarists also fought "culture wars," demanding religious
piety of every last soul, intimidating media, censoring books, banning
"indecent" music, eavesdropping on conversations to detect glimmers of
sedition, and recruiting informants to root out liberals, agnostics,
artists, iconoclasts, foreigners and other unsavories.
In the 1930'’s, Japan’s unilateralist saber-rattlers used an entirely
mythical union of nations -- called the Greater East Asia Co-Prosperity
Sphere -- to justify their various invasions. Today's cynical White
House formulation for a similar fanciful phantom is "the Coalition of
the Willing."
As Japan's era of militarism reached its climax, the national treasure
was exhausted and the lifeblood of millions of idealistic and loyal
soldiers, sailors and airmen -- the flower of Japanese youth -- was
being squandered under thousands of proudly flapping flags, in a war of
choice that had been lost already before it began.
Plus, they killed a lot of people elsewhere! The Japanese became famous
for bombing civilians and torturing prisoners.
Today in America... well, is any of this ringing a bell?
Right now, America's military-industrial complex is wallowing in
wealth, calling the shots, nourished by secrecy and wrapped in the
flag. The question is: Are we really willing to put up with these armed
sociopaths for 20 more lost, bloodsoaked years before reclaiming our
republic?
Must we, like Japan, end up embarrassed by the sight of our flag?
David Benjamin is a novelist and journalist who splits time between
Madison, Wisconsin and Paris. His latest book is The Life and Times of
the Last Kid Picked.
###