Common Dreams NewsCenter
National Conference for Media Reform
 
     
 Home | NewswireAbout Us | Donate | Sign-Up | Archives
   
 
   Featured Views  
 

Printer Friendly Version E-Mail This Article
 
 
A Different Kind of Myth-Making: Rescue of Christian Peacemaker Team Members Goes Largely Unreported
Published on Monday, March 27, 2006 by WorkingForChange.com
A Different Kind of Myth-Making: Rescue of Christian Peacemaker Team Members Goes Largely Unreported
by Geov Parrish
 

Last Thursday, March 23, combined American and British forces, acting on a prisoner tip Wednesday night, stormed a house in a turbulent West Baghdad neighborhood. They found -- bound, but unguarded and (given the circumstances) relatively unharmed -- three surviving Christian Peacemaker Team (CPT) members: 74-year-old Brit Norman Kember, and two 40ish Canadians, James Loney and Harmeet Singh, who had been in captivity 118 days.

It should have been one of those Jessica Lynch type moments, one of the rare instances in three years of war whereby military forces have been successful in rescuing kidnap victims. This was one of the few unequivocal triumphs lately for occupying U.S. forces. But instead, it was one of those stories that in American media came and went, usually with little emphasis, in a 24-hour news cycle.

Perhaps that's because the biggest American connection to the story --- Northern Virginia native Tom Fox, the fourth CPT abductee -- had already been found slain, his body dumped in Baghdad on March 9. But even then, the coverage was spotty and misleading. Aside from the Washington Post, for which it was a local story, few U.S. media outlets gave the discovery of Fox's body much play. And among those that did, most -- including, repeatedly, the New York Times -- followed the lead of Iraqi police and got it wrong.

Police announced that Fox had been tortured before being shot, and most media followed suit. But as CPTer Sheila Provencher writes, "Despite many rumors and several reports that Tom Fox was tortured before he died, the results of the medical examination and autopsy of Tom's body reveal that there was NO torture. Tom died by gunshots to the chest and one gunshot to the head."

Now, in analyzing this discrepancy, it might help to know that Iraqi police, along with Iraq's Interior Ministry, are two of the most prominent Iraqi government branches largely controlled by the Badr Brigade, the independent militia of the Supreme Council for the Islamic Revolution in Iraq (SCIRI). SCIRI is the most powerful of the fundamentalist Shiite political parties dominating Iraq's government, and it is sensitive to extensive evidence that it has been running death squads; literally thousands of bodies of bound, often tortured, and shot Sunni men have been discovered in Baghdad alone in recent months. Since it's largely Sunni groups that have been kidnapping foreigners, what better way to cast aspersions on the other side? Moreover, the U.S. Embassy in Baghdad doubtless didn't mind at all that such news would sicken Fox's family, friends, and admirers, and perhaps even discourage future peaceniks from coming to Iraq. Major media should have known better than to trust such sources.

The original abduction on Nov. 26 wasn't much better: on that occasion, the New York Times didn't even run a story. One of the most basic problems with all of the CPT coverage over the months of the ordeal was that nobody usually relied upon as sources by major media -- not military spokespeople, nor anyone at the American Embassy or State Department, nor any of the reporters or editors in the media outlets themselves -- had any kind of clear idea of what CPT and similar groups do, and what sort of individuals are moved to join their efforts. Most news accounts used words like "pacifist" or "peace activists" and left it at that, creating an imagine of starry-eyed idealists plunging unwittingly into a dangerous war zone.

But as I noted in a Dec. 8 column titled "A Different Kind of Heroism," "The CPT activists were well aware of the risks. For years, Christian Peacemaker Teams has been sending long-term delegations to Palestine (and, more recently, to Colombia and other war zones), helping, by their privileged Western presence, to protect Palestinians from attack by settlers and the Israeli military, and helping with health care, humanitarian aid, and other aspects of ordinary Palestinians' struggle for survival. When the United States threatened to launch war in Iraq, sending teams to Baghdad was a natural extension of CPT's work…. Activists like Fox, Kember, Loney, and Singh know that they are working in a war zone. That's the point. The idea is to save lives, by putting their privileged bodies in the way of violence, whether the threat is from Shiite death squads, Sunni gunmen, or trigger-happy U.S. troops.

Does it work? Iraqis must think so. Without support from host communities, groups like CPT wouldn't last a week. That support, and their own wits, are the only protection such activists have. "

Even having lost a member, the survival rate of Christian Peacemaker Teams delegations is rather better than that of the U.S. military; clearly, they know what they are doing, and in an environment where every American outside the Green Zone is in extreme danger, clearly their good work (usually) protects them. Now, Fox joins the International Solidarity Movement's Rachel Corrie, crushed to death in March 2003 by a bulldozer while trying to prevent Israeli Defense Forces from destroying Palestinian homes in the Gaza Strip, on the list of Americans who've given their lives while having nonviolently prevented the deaths of others in a war zone.

The story of Fox's death, the concern for the lives of the three remaining hostages, and their rescue two weeks later is enormously compelling -- except that U.S. media don't know how to tell it, because they don't understand a war zone story line that doesn't involve bullets, bombs, or official spokespeople. So, the cameras will wilt away, and CPT activists will go back, undissuaded, to their original work: savings the lives of civilians caught in a war zone not of their making. They should be heroes. If only we knew.

Geov Parrish is a Seattle-based columnist and reporter for Seattle Weekly, In These Times and Eat the State! He writes the daily Straight Shot for WorkingForChange. He can be reached by email at geovlp@earthlink.net -- please indicate whether your comments may be used on WorkingForChange in an upcoming "letters" column.

© 2006 Working Assets

###

Printer Friendly Version E-Mail This Article
 
   FAIR USE NOTICE  
  This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of environmental, political, human rights, economic, democracy, scientific, and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
 
 
 
Common Dreams NewsCenter
A non-profit news service providing breaking news & views for the progressive community.
Home | Newswire | Contacting Us | About Us | Donate | Sign-Up | Archives

© Copyrighted 1997-2008
www.commondreams.org