During a private dinner to honor John Stossel (Portland, Oregon 2/5/06)
the self-proclaimed "libertarian reporter" introduced me to a group of
his followers: "John is a teacher who goes around the country telling
people I am a corporate shill." I had just handed an email to Stossel
and its contents were very telling. An industry front group was soliciting
individuals to badmouth environmental concerns: on behalf of John
Stossel. I told Mr. Stossel, "use this information in your talk
tonight." It would never enter his address.
I was there in person to ask Mr. Stossel three major points. One, why
does he manipulate data to create news? Secondly, why was his "Tampering
with Nature" program a "rigged event" where teachers and children were
duped into a scathing misrepresentation of environmental education (that
email was tied to this program)? And lastly, why wouldn't he answer a
single phone call or email (after dozens of tries)? Reviewing pieces I
have written about John Stossel, I did not come across the term
"corporate shill." What I learned about John Stossel that evening is
that he is indeed "a person considered as having compromised principles
for personal gain." He is indeed a "corporate whore", where truth is
meaningless, statistics can be manipulated and journalistic integrity
perverted. He is the poster boy of a non-existent liberal press: where
facts are cherry-picked and the hard questions are avoided.
Thankfully, a friend picked up the $125 tab to break bread with John
Stossel. A private dinner would follow with one of Mr. Stossel's
"anti-regulatory homilies." Held at the impressive Multnomah Athletic
Club in Portland, courtesy of the Cascade Policy Institute, Stossel
titled his discussion, "Freedom and its Enemies." The private dinner was
awash with free-market boosters, where environmental regulations are
seen as "anti-growth" and overbearing. Stossel's talk was a generic and
entertaining attempt to belittle environmental and other safety
regulations. Apparently, Mr. Stossel has little acquaintance with
environmental data and casts doubt on everything from climate change to
the dangers of pesticides.
I have written extensively about John Stossel's attempt to belittle
environmental education. "Disney and Stossel Dance in the Gutter with "Tampering with Nature" 6/19/02 and "Teachers, Before Buying "Tampering
with Nature" for the Classroom, Know the Truth about John Stossel"
8/04/04 both on CommonDreams.org.
Stossel, once known for his investigative reporting, apparently got
religion: the corporate kind. Stossel is aligned with the Competitive
Enterprise Institute (CEI), a free-market, anti-regulatory think-tank.
The Center for Media and Democracy has done extensive studies on CEI,
especially a subsidiary group: The Cooler Heads Coalition. The
Center states that the Cooler Heads Coalition,
"are chaired by former CEI director Marlo Lewis and
directed by Myron Ebell, CEI's Director
of Global Warming and International Environmental Policy. The Cooler
Heads Coalition was formed on May 6, 1997, "to dispel the myths of
global warming by exposing flawed economic, scientific and risk
analysis." In March 2001, the nonprofit Clean Air Trust named Ebell its
"clean air villain of the month," citing his "ferocious lobbying charge
to persuade President Bush to reverse his campaign pledge to control
electric utility emissions of carbon dioxide."
Interestingly, CEI has been an outspoken opponent of environmental
education as well. Is it just concidence that John Stossel is an avid
opponent of environmental education and often casts doubt on climate
change information? Ironically, Stossel casts doubt on climate change in
his "Tampering with Nature" misinformation piece: using scientists like
Patrick Michaels. Exxonsecrets.org has published data on Patrick
Michaels and it is damning:
"Michaels publishes the "World Climate Review," a newsletter on
global warming funded by the Western Fuels Association. Dr. Michaels has
acknowledged that 20% of his funding comes from fossil fuel sources:
(http://www.mtn.org/~nescncl/complaints/determinations/det_118.html)
Known funding includes $49,000 from German Coal Mining Association,
$15,000 from Edison Electric Institute and $40,000 from Cyprus Minerals
Company, an early supporter of People for the West, a "wise use" group.
He received $63,000 for research on global climate change from Western
Fuels Association, above and beyond the undisclosed amount he is paid
for the World Climate Report/Review. According to Harper's magazine,
Michaels has received over $115,000 over the past four years from coal
and oil interests. Michaels wrote "Sound and Fury" and "The Satanic
Gases" which were published by Cato Institute. Dr. Michaels signed the
1995 Leipzig Declaration."
So much for objective reporting Mr. Stossel, you should be ashamed of
yourself. But, it is obvious that shame is not one of Stossel's stronger
character traits.
During the exclusive and charming dinner with Stossel, I found him
surrounded by his "groupies" and decided to ask him a few questions.
Upon learning my name, he prefaced my questions with the proclaimation
that I was calling him a corporate shill. This brought giggles from his
admirers. I asked him why he would manipulate children in his attempt to
debase environmental education and why his producer, Ted Balaker, lied
to me on three separate occcasions? He side-stepped the questions.
Growing impatient of my direct, yet polite questions, his handlers tried
to nudge me away. I told Mr. Stossel, I would, "ask some questions in
front of the audience during his lecture."
True to form, Mr. Stossel, refused to answer my three questions in front
of some 250 plus people in the general audience. He deftly side-stepped
direct questions, giving an array of generalistic and obfuscating
replies to my simple requests for some truth. I received some hisses as
I left the microphone.
"Some truth" is an endangered species on the mainstream media's
airwaves. ABC is a lapdog to the corporate giant, the Disney
Corporation. Despite repeated attempts to have a dialogue with the
powers at ABC/Disney, I have found myself a common citizen with no
access to the powerful brokers of half-truth and omission.
John Stossel used children to further his anti-environmental education
agenda and his vehicle was the "Wonderful World of Disney." Think tanks
can buy access and fabricate news. The little guy, like me, can only
hope that a remnant of the "liberal press" will hear our stories and put
us on equal footing with the likes of John Stossel. John Stossel is not
in my league when it comes to the truth, yet, his ability to invent news
is endless: he has a venue on ABC's 20/20 program.
I urge Anne Sweeney, President of Disney's ABC Television Group to
investigate Stossel's pre-determined "investigative reporting." I
suggest that common citizens email the 20/20 program at 2020@abc.com and tell John Stossel that he is indeed a
corporate shill and should report on issues, not subvert them.
The "liberal press" is missing in action, as stories like mountain top
removal of coal and climate change go under reported. At least, 60
Minutes did a good job of reporting climate change this past Sunday
evening. I wonder if John Stossel watched? He could learn a thing or two
about the importance of a free and unbiased press.
John F. Borowski, is an environmental and marine science teacher from
Philomath, Oregon. His pieces have appeared in major newspapers and
websites. He currently works on an "Honest Education Program" for the
Native Forest Council. He can be reached at jenjill@peak.org
###