The year 2006 will
be historic for the
nation, and probably
for humanity. Texans
Bush and Rove and
their conspirators
in the second Bush
presidency have disgraced
American democracy
at home and in the
world with debasements
of our nation and
our values that have
now entered their
climactic phase.
What part will the
rest of us Texans
play in this decisive
year?
As I have written
in a review-essay
that appears in
the tenth-anniversary
spring issue of
Yes!,
the quarterly of
new solutions published
in Washington state
by David and Frances
Korten (YesMagazine.org),
we are living and
working in the
very days and nights
of the American
Emergency, the
climactic American
Crisis. Our elections
are bought, and
our government
is run by and for
the major transnational
corporations. Bush
announced in 2002
his illegal presidential
policy that the
United States can
and will attack
other nations first,
waging war on them,
when he so decides.
He is now waging,
as if he were doing
it in our names,
a bloody war of
aggression against
Iraq, which on
the face of it
is a crime against
humanity under
the Nuremberg principles
that we and our
allies established
and enforced with
hangings after
World War II. The
President, the
Vice-President,
and their factors
sold this war to
Congress with twistings
and lies that were
crafted to infuriate
and terrorize us
about Iraq’s
alleged connections
to Al Qaeda and
mass-murder endangerments
to us from Iraq
itself, all of
which literally
did not exist.
In polls now six
of 10 Americans
do not believe
the president is
honest. Yet he
has three more
years of dictatorial
control over our
nuclear and other
arms and our Army,
Navy, Air Force,
and Marine Corps
and seems now to
be maneuvering
to use that control
to wage another
aggressive war
on Iran, with literally
incalculable consequences.
We Texans are a major
source of this deterioration
into crisis. The
leading Democrats
of the state so dishonored
the liberal traditions
of their party that
in the resulting
political vacuum,
Bush was elected
Governor here, and
from Austin he mounted
the campaign that
a 5-4 majority of
the U.S. Supreme
Court illegally decreed
made him President.
After that, House
Majority Leader Tom
DeLay, from Sugar
Land, crafted his
scheme to use corporate
money to widen the
Republicans’
majority in the Texas
delegation to Washington,
D.C., battening down
right-wing GOP control
of the House and
the Congress. The
third President from
Texas and his Republican
Congress then waged
aggressive war on
Iraq, drove the nation
into insolvency to
further enrich the
already rich, and
just for good measure
tore up the Constitution.
As we in Texas bear
guilt for this we
have also begun to
join the resistance
and revolt against
it, starting with
Cindy Sheehan’s
brigades in Crawford.
By happy accident
the Texas trip-root
that now threatens
to help bring the
Bush presidency crashing
down, crushing itself
under its own arrogance,
hubris, and criminality,
is a law against
corporate money in
Texas elections that
was passed a century
ago in the state’s
populist afterglow. To
uphold that law,
Travis County District
Attorney Ronnie Earle
has braved ruthless
contumely, as he
had done often before
in order to prosecute
public officials
he believed had violated
the laws. While it
is merely seemly
to await the outcome
of the trial of DeLay
and his co-defendants
on the charges that
they laundered corporate
money through Washington
to elect Republicans
to the House from
Texas, in a speech
in September Earle
declared what he
believes his prosecution
is all about. “Corporate
money in politics”
has become “the
fight of our generation
of Americans....It
is our job—our
fight—to rescue
democracy from the
money that has captured
it,” he said. “The
issue that we’re
faced with is the
role of large concentrations
of money in democracy,
whether it’s
individuals or corporations,
the issue is the
same.”
Since 1994, although
the polls show
a majority of Texan
citizens support
progressive reforms
such as adequate
taxation for equal
education for Texas
schoolchildren,
the leaders of
the disappearing
Texas Democratic
Party and their
statewide candidates,
finking out on
every ethically
important political
issue, have proved
again and again
that nothing fails
like failure. Rot-gut
Republicans have
swept every statewide
office and achieved
mercenary domination
of the Texas courts,
too. In my opinion,
Texas Democrats
ought to have concluded
by 2002 at the
latest that they
should be choosing,
from among the
waves of the on-comers,
entirely new sets
of state and local
party leaders and
candidates. For
example, rather
than be taken in,
even a jot, by
the torrent of
contemptuous abuse
directed at Ronnie
Earle by Tom DeLay,
his lawyers, and
that ilk, Texans
should be realizing
that—just
as the dramatic
prosecutions of
Thomas E. Dewey
in New York made
him a Republican
presidential candidate
and now the populist
prosecutions of
Eliot Spitzer in
New York State
are making him
a national figure—Ronnie
Earle has fully
qualified himself
as a front-rank
leader in Texas
politics. For another
example, this year,
in my opinion—shared,
by the way, by
Jim Hightower—Texans
are very fortunate
to have running
for Attorney General
the lifelong labor
lawyer and Democratic
firebrand David
Van Os of San Antonio. The
Observer does
not make political
endorsements, but
I may say here
for myself alone
that David, in
my carefully considered
personal judgment,
is the Ralph Yarborough
of his generation.
The national
resistance to Bush,
Cheney, Rove, et
al., is coming
into focus, too.
John Conyers, the
ranking Democrat
on the House Judiciary
Committee, which
is the logical
source for impeachment
initiatives, has
taken the significant
step of calling
for an investigation
of Bush and Cheney
with a view to
censure, which
obviously could
metamorphose into
impeachment. Tom
Daschle, until
recently the Minority
Leader in the Senate,
Sen. Edward Kennedy,
and Nancy Pelosi,
the House Minority
Leader, are all
calling for investigations
of Bush and Cheney.
Elizabeth Holtzman
writes for impeachment
in the current
Nation,
and the Internet
is on fire with
initiatives to
impeach Bush and
Cheney for crimes
committed in office,
foremost among
them lying our
nation into a war
of aggression. Impeachment
is unlikely as
long as the House
remains firmly
in GOP control,
but this year it
would be gratifying
to see citizens
seeking the election
of House candidates—whether
Democrats, Republicans,
or independents—who
promise explicitly
to vote, if elected,
to impeach Bush
and Cheney.
If impeachment does
not become possible,
let me broach with
you the idea that
a grand jury, federal
or state, should
indict Bush and Cheney
for their manifold
official crimes.
Are we, as we are
so often piously
assured, “a
nation of laws and
not of men,”
or is the President
above the law if
his party controls
the House and can
block impeaching
him?
The Constitution
is silent on whether
a seated President
and Vice President
can be indicted,
while in office,
for crimes committed
while they have held
those offices. Constitutional
lawyers are congenitally
prone to announcing
that this cannot
be done because it
would disrupt the
ongoing business
of the government.
But it is time to
do it, if necessary
absent impeachment,
for exactly that
reason—to disrupt
the continuation
of THIS government.
I have not yet found
one constitutional
lawyer who can cite
a Supreme Court case
or any other judicial
precedent prohibiting
their indictment—if
you know of one please
let me hear from
you. In 1973 Nixon’s
attorney general
said the President
can’t be indicted,
but why should Nixon’s
attorney general
bind us?
Committed to nonviolence,
determined, in this
post-Gandhi era,
against violence,
nevertheless we are
once again in the
position of the Framers
of the Constitution.
In the post-revolutionary
emergency, the Founding
Fathers took things
in their own hands,
violating their clear
instructions from
the states by proposing
to create the United
States, which the
states then created.
In the crisis we
are in now we must
not be misled by
expostulating lawyers
or posturing politicians. We
the citizens can
make up our own minds
whether we can indict
Bush and Cheney and,
if they are convicted,
throw them out.
May we close
here, then, as
we began two centuries
and more ago, with
the words of Tom
Paine. “We
have it in our
power to begin
the world over
again,” he
said. “The
birth day of a
new world is at
hand… We
are a people upon
experiments. It
is an age of revolutions,
in which everything
may be looked for.”
Ronnie Dugger
is the founding
editor and former
publisher of The Texas Observer. Author of presidential
biographies and
other books and
articles, he writes
now from his office
in Cambridge, Mass.
© 2006 Texas Observer
###