I want to start the New Year by proposing that we remove the term
9/11 from our vocabulary and let the people who were killed in that
tragic event rest in peace. Since September 11, 2001, 9/11 has become
the ubiquitous term for everything that has gone wrong in the 21st
century.
Since that day I estimate the term has appeared hundreds of thousands
of time in print. In a cursory Lexis/Nexis search of 50 major
newspapers worldwide the term 9/11 has been used 977 times in a
headline in just the last 6 months. The New York Times used it 92
times, The Washington Post 53 times, and the L.A. Times 50. A brief
sampling shows the international press has been a bit more restrained
during the same time period: European news sources used it as a
headline 525 times, Asia/Pacific new sources 226 times, and Middle
East/African news sources 121 times.
The biggest offenders, of course, are those at the White House who
drone on ad nauseam about 9/11. For them it has been a Godsend as
they use the term daily to mask the myriad of screw-ups they have
authored since that fateful day. Bush must have had that term
tattooed on his ass, because that event saved it and him from being a
one-term president, and quickly forgotten. It's hard to remember a
speech where he hasn't invoked the term or the words that have now
become synonymous with it, liberty, freedom, and terrorism, which he
used 105 times in the 2005 State of the Union Speech.
Contrary to the popular rhetoric, nothing has changed for most
Americans since 2001. We blithely go about our lives unfazed by the
events of that day. We have not made any sacrifices other than the
slight inconvenience we may experience at the airport.
We continue our spending frenzy, piling up masses of public and
private debt for our grandchildren. We shop and party disconnected
from what is being done in our names in Iraq and around the world.
The perfect metaphors for this disconnect are the Bush twins whose
partying around the D.C. area is routinely reported in the Style
section of the Washington Post. That coverage is nicely juxtaposed
against the front-page news where their father, often pictured
surrounded by soldiers, pays lip service to the words duty,
sacrifice, and service to one's country. The girls, like the rest
or us, just want to have fun.
But nowhere is the party grander than in Congress. They love the
phase 9/11 and use it to justify every piece of pork they can
produce. Invoking the term 9/11 means you can even build a bridge to
nowhere as Alaska's Senator Stevens has artfully shown. The Federal
Mint can barely print money fast enough to keep the troughs filled
for the record amounts of wasteful spending that has ensued since 2001.
Under the con of making the country more secure, Bush and Congress
have created three bottomless money pits: The Department of Homeland
Security, The Transportation Security Administration, and the war in
Iraq. All of which have contributed substantially to the Gross
National Product, but have done nothing to make the world or us safer.
Unfortunately for the world, as events have confirmed, we had the
wrong man in office at the wrong time on that September day in 2001.
While the smoke was still billowing from the ashes of the Two Towers
we chose the wrong path for humanity, and the right one for the
weapons manufacturers, the defense contractors, and the warlords.
Since that day the United States government has been committing
atrocities around the world by slaughtering and torturing people,
while wiretapping and lying to citizens at home. In Iraq alone,
Bush notes that we have freed 30,000 Iraqi citizens from the bonds of
enslavement by killing them. At our covert gulags around the world,
we lock up anyone we choose, for as long as we like, and deny them
basic rights.
To much of the world we have become a monster. Lying, killing, and
torturing are now justified and accepted by many Americans as
necessary ingredients to keep us safe from another 9/11. We are an
uglier, meaner, less compassionate country. In letters to editors
around the country people routinely support and even advocate for
more control, more sanctions, more government intrusion into our
lives. Have we lost our minds? We have certainly lost our way.
I don't want to live in a country where anyone's rights are abridged,
even terrorists. Where the government operates in secrecy and
abuses it power and it's people. Where the president can commit
crimes and not be held accountable. I don't give a damn about living
securely if I have to give up one tiny bit of my freedom guaranteed
by our Constitution and Bill of Rights. Not one bit!! In this regard
I consider myself in line with the patriots of New Hampshire whose
motto "Live Free or Die" is right on! There can be no erosion of
these Rights if we are to remain free. These Rights are the bedrock
of our security, of our freedoms, and our liberty. Let's reaffirm
those rights for everyone, especially those who died back in 2001.
Let's sing Auld Lang Syne to the term 9/11.
Bud A. McClure is a professor of psychology at the University of
Minnesota Duluth. He is on sabbatical this year living near
Washington D.C. He can be emailed at bmcclure@d.umn.edu.
###