This article is a sequel to David Orr's first submission: The Imminent Demise of the Republican Party: Part One.
In truth the moderate Republican Party of Dwight Eisenhower died several
decades ago, to be reborn in the 1990's as the extreme right-wing and
highly disciplined party of Newt Gingrich, Karl Rove, George Bush, Dick
Cheney, Tom Delay, and Grover Norquist. Those and a few others
orchestrated the nightmare that James Madison described in /Federalist/
#10-in which executive, legislative, and judicial power was concentrated
in the hands of a single faction. But it is worse than Madison feared
because the power of that faction includes control over a mostly
compliant and increasingly centralized media, a vast military
establishment, and the intelligence agencies.
The nightmare, however, is nearing its end and the reasons are daily
coming clearer. But the Democratic Party, lacking grit, direction, and
ideas, will have played little role in the end of the radical Republican
Party, nor can it be assumed that Democrats will be the beneficiary. The
self-induced coming collapse of the Republican Party will most likely
leave a power vacuum in American politics and perhaps a time of national
drift and decline.
The Republican Party has always been the party of business and it was
once the party of law, fiscal conservatism, probity, and small
government as well. But things have changed and it bears no resemblance
to the party of Lincoln, Teddy Roosevelt, Robert Taft, Dwight
Eisenhower, and even Richard Nixon. After Watergate, the Iran-Contra
scandal, and the Impeachment of Bill Clinton, the Party was effectively
taken over by radicals determined to win at all cost. They forged an
alliance between Southern racists, the extreme Christian right, big
business, neo-conservatives, and a group of right-wing financiers
willing to invest billions over several decades to build ideologically
driven think tanks and a nation-wide media echo chamber to mislead the
public and return the country to the world of the Robber Barons of the
19^th century. They played the public for fools, covering their tracks
with patriotic and religious rhetoric and devising ruinous policies too
complex to be widely understood. But, driven by an extremist ideology
and directed by ruthless leadership, radical Republicans will fall
victim to overreach and its own particular kind of blindness. The recent
legal difficulties of Lewis Libby, Tom Delay, Bill Frist, and Jack
Abramoff are only the tip of the iceberg. Other revelations are coming
about the fabrication of the reasons for the mistaken war in Iraq. Still
others will show a pattern of corruption and fraud at a scale for which
we have no national precedent. Perhaps it is only a sign of hubris, but
more likely it is growing evidence that the national Republican Party,
having marginalized its wiser leaders and tossed good judgment overboard
became a criminal enterprise given to deception and mendacity in order
to cover grand theft at a national scale, all on behalf of something
called their "base." But its mounting legal difficulties and decline in
recent polls are evidence of deeper causes that will soon bring the
entire enterprise to ruin.
Events surrounding hurricane Katrina are symptomatic of the kinds of
forces that will terminate the Republican Party. Its leadership chose to
ignore scientific warnings about the links between climate change and
the use of fossil fuels that is amplifying the number and severity of
storms to say nothing of the warnings about inadequate levies in New
Orleans. As a result they have no plans to avert the worst of climate
driven planetary disruption coming in the years ahead which, beyond some
unknown point, will be catastrophic for everyone.
The war in Iraq is symptomatic of deeper flaws and self-delusion as
well. Reliable witnesses report that the reasons given for the war were
conjured, which is to say that they were a lie. We know as well that the
level of understanding about the Middle East was astonishingly low and
preparation for the post-war reconstruction of Iraq utterly incompetent.
This debacle was decidedly not primarily a failure of the CIA, but
rather a matter of deliberate deception by the administration for which
the appropriate words are "high crimes" and the appropriate course of
action is impeachment.
The list of malfeasances and bad judgment could go on, but the point is
clear: the present leadership of the Republican Party has chosen to lead
by deception, ignore economic reality, refute science when its findings
are inconvenient, foster class divisions, snub the poor, vitiate laws
and regulations that protect the environment and public health by
stealth, destroy venerable alliances, flaunt international law,
undermine the foundations of democracy at home, and destroy the capacity
of government, painstakingly created over many decades by Republicans
and Democrats alike, to solve serious public problems. The Party of
Lincoln has become a gang of thieves given to cutting taxes for the
wealthy and willing to "do whatever it takes" to stay in power as Karl
Rove once put it. The results include a cascading national debt, a
federal government unwilling and increasingly unable to act on the most
important issues of the 21^st century, and growing isolation from the
world community. Not the least, the combined effect of the radical
conservative blunder in Iraq is that the United States is more
vulnerable to terrorism than before 2001 and is highly dependent on the
willingness of the Chinese and others to prop up an increasingly
vulnerable economy.
When their reign collapses and the full extent of the wreckage assessed,
there will be no time for gloating. There will be, at best, a small
window of opportunity to set the country on course again and restore a
government of the people, by the people, and for the people, not one for
the wealthy few. Equality before the law, transparency, accountability,
competence, and foresight are the standards for good governance. The
first order of business will be to restore a truer democracy and greater
participation in public life now more characteristic of European
countries than our own. That will require, in one way or another,
reducing the power of money in U.S. politics and rebuilding a fair tax
system. We will need to quickly regain public control over the public
airwaves beginning with the restoration of the fairness doctrine, tossed
out by the Reagan administration in 1987. We will need to take immediate
steps to implement energy efficiency and solar power, long known to be
technically feasible, economically advantageous, and the antidote for
adverse climate change. We must get America on track again, rebuilding a
national rail system that will reduce our dependence on imported oil
while reversing urban sprawl. We will need policies to rebuild blighted
urban areas and restore widespread prosperity to rural areas-flip sides
of the same coin. We will need to rebuild federal, state, and private
capacity to protect our common air, water, lands, and natural heritage.
And we will need a foreign policy once again grounded in international
law and a decent respect for the opinions of humankind.
Most important, however, we will need to be summoned back to greatness
and away from fear, division, culture wars, and greed. We need a renewed
sense of an inclusive America and what it means to be an American. At
our best we are a democratic people governed by law. We are a pragmatic
people, adept at solving problems. And if wisely led, we can be a
compassionate people capable of acting on behalf of the less fortunate
and for posterity. It was once said that America is the last best hope
of humankind, and perhaps one day we will live up to that standard.
David Orr is a Paul Sears Distinguished Professor at Oberlin College and author of The Last
Refuge:Politics, and the Environment in
an Age of Terror (Island Press, 2005).
###