It's a dark time for peace when pacifists are lunatics
and pro-war means pro-life.
Listen:
On the recent second anniversary of the Iraq War, I
was driving along Interstate 95 in the early
afternoon, somewhere outside Bangor, Maine, when a
cherry red SUV pulled into my lane. Looking down, I
noticed a yellow bumper sticker in the shape of a
ribbon. It read: "Support Our Troops."
I felt guilty. It was a phrase that has haunted me for
two years.
I started looking for similar stickers. And over the
next few hours, I saw about 20 (inexplicably they were
always on SUVs, Mini-Vans, and trucks - never on
cars). I also saw a handful of Bush/Cheney stickers
and Kerry/Edwards Stickers. Interestingly, I didn't
see a single anti-war bumper sticker.
Not one.
Why? I wondered. After a while, I decided the reason
was this: pacifism in America is an admission of
insanity.
Let me explain: I don't support the war in Iraq. And I
don't support the president who started it. So,
logically, I don't support the troops who fight it -
though, certainly, I don't wish them any harm.
But by not "supporting the troops," I have been
accused of supporting demonic dictators, Iraqi
militants, Islamic terrorists, and chemotherapy for cancer-ridden cows.
Here is an example: since the start of the Iraq War,
I've worn a small peace button, an old yellow and
black relic of the early seventies, borrowed from a
colleague at the school where I teach. The button fits
nicely on my coat, so each morning I clip it on and go
about my day.
One morning, I was standing in line at a coffee shop.
In front of me was a tall, barrel-chested man in his
fifties. He wore a Red Sox ball cap and a dark-blue windbreaker. The line was long and slow moving, so the man turned a bit to make small talk - the weather, the sports scores.
At one point, his eyes drifted down to my peace
button, and he stopped talking. Then, after a long
pause, he said, "Hey buddy, don't you support the
troops?"
"Well, no," I said, "I don't support the troops. I
support peace, right?" I pointed at the button and
managed a thin smile.
"What d'ya mean?" he said, turning full toward me.
"You know," I tried to explain, "guns and bombs, no
matter what their owner's intentions, are not
particularly peaceful, right?"
The fellow looked angry. His chin went up, his chest
went out. "So," he barked, "you support the
terrorists." When he said "you," his index finger
jabbed at my button.
"Well, no, I mean, that's silly," I said. "Anyone who
gasses his own people to death or knocks down
buildings with airplanes is scum. But, you know, that
said, violence doesn't come in the humane and inhumane
variety, right?" I kept smiling, hoping somehow to
mollify my line-mate, and wondering why the line was
moving so slowly.
"Typical liberal," he said with disgust, "your kind
just encourages more terrorism. You should take that
pin off and keep your mouth shut."
Did I open my mouth? I just wanted coffee.
The fellow shook his head and walked away, frustrated,
no doubt, by my obvious support of the Axis of Evil.
That evening I called a childhood friend who lives
outside of Boston. Politically, he had always been a
moderate, often even liberal on some issues. So,
during our conversation, I felt safe mentioning my
little peace button and my conversation at the coffee
shop.
My mistake.
"Frankly," my friend said, "I don't like these war
protesters and their criticisms of America." He
complained about a "peace type" who brought his
three-year old son to a protest march marking the
first anniversary of the war. At the march, the "peace
type" with the child was arrested. "Irresponsible!" my
friend howled.
Needless to say, I didn't mention having brought my
four-year-old daughter to a similar protest march.
Then my friend related a story about another "peace
group," this one in Boston. They were "a bunch of
crazed vegetarians," he said, "raising money for
chemotherapy - for a cancer-ridden cow!" His anger was
rising. "My god," he said, "these peace types are just
crazy. They don't support our troops in Iraq, but they
want to save some stupid cow with cancer!"
The conversation ended. But his words stayed with me -
in fact, they have stayed with me from that morning in
the coffee shop until that day on Interstate 95. And I
still feel guilty.
Why do I feel guilty?
Consider: the accusation of "not supporting the
troops" is a foolproof means of undermining pacifism.
It plays like the old Groucho Marx joke: "So, have you
stopped beating your wife? Answer yes or no." No
matter how you answer the question, you sound guilty.
Or in my case, you sound like the dupe of nefarious, woolly-minded, liberal peaceniks whose secret plan - if I understand the logic
- is to support dictators, Islamic extremists, terrorists - and chemotherapy for cancer ridden cows. That is to say, pacifists are lunatics.
Meantime in Florida, Pro-Life protesters maintain a
deathwatch outside the hospital of Terri Schiavo. They
loudly demand that all Americans value each individual
life - even to the point of subverting the law. Yet, ironically, they - and millions more who agree with them - vote overwhelmingly to support the continuing two-year, open-ended slaughter of Iraqis by the
thousands: men, women, and children. That is to say,
pro-war means pro-life.
So you tell me: who should feel guilty?
It's a dark time for peace when pacifists are lunatics
and pro-war means pro-life.
Steven Laffoley is an American writer living in
Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada. You may e-mail him at stevenlaffoley@yahoo.ca or steven_laffoley@yahoo.com.
###