| |
Culture of Life or Culture of Living Death? Culture of Life or Culture of Living Death? Culture of Life or Culture of Living Death? From Terry Schiavo to Iraq
|
Published on Wednesday, March 23, 2005 by CommonDreams.org |
|
Culture of Life or Culture of Living Death? From Terry Schiavo to Iraq |
|
by Rahul Mahajan |
| |
|
The mass mobilization and media circus
surrounding the case of the unfortunate Terri Schiavo offer a rare view of
current American culture and, in particular, of the "culture of life" that
George W. Bush and the evangelical right wing are so fond of talking about.
Right-wing Christians on the ground and right-wing Republicans in Congress
have literally moved heaven and earth to save the life of a woman who has
spent 15 years in a vegetative state and whose cerebral cortex is almost
entirely gone. So far did this effort go that George W. Bush actually cut
short a vacation at Crawford.
Before an extraordinary vote in
Congress asserting the authority of the state over trifling private
decisions like medical care, life, and death (and severely breaking
legislative precedent, which suggests strongly that legislation is about
general principles, not individual cases, which are to be left to the
courts), Tom
Delay said, in impassioned tones, "If we do not act, she will die of
thirst. However helpless, Mr. Speaker, she is alive. She is one of us, and
this cannot stand." Exactly what quality of life Ms. Schiavo actually has
is one under much debate, but there is no doubt that it is little to none
compared to that of even a normal severely disabled person. This outpouring
of compassion comes from the same man who, believe it or not, when called
on to speak at a prayer breakfast for the tsunami victims, quoted Matthew
7:21-27 -- the verse about the foolish man who built his house on sand
and the wise man who built his house on a rock.
This unspeakably
vile Bible-thumper, who could actually suggest in public that the tsunami
victims deserved, suddenly discovers that he has a heart when it comes to
saving the life of a women who has not exhibited anything beyond brain stem
activity in 15 years.
These same people who believe so much in this
culture of life and care so deeply about Ms. Schiavo and about every fetus
seem completely untroubled by the fact that current Republican policies are
consigning thousands of additional children in the United States to death
every year. Not only has the infant mortality rate increased
in the last couple of years, it is more than 10% higher than that of
Cuba, a country that disposes of only a fraction of the resources this
country can. According to Nicholas Kristof, if we had the infant mortality
rate Cuba does, over 2200 American babies would be saved each
year.
These people, and, it must be said, their opponents across the
aisle, cared nothing about the over half a million children under the age
of five who died as a result of the sanctions on Iraq, held on the country
beyond all reason by U.S. pressure.
It is these very same people who
care so much about the sanctity of life who held ecstatic religious rites before the destruction of Fallujah in November, and one of whom said, "The
enemy has got a face - he's called Satan, he's in Falluja, and we're going
to destroy him." Terry Schiavo apparently still has humanity even
without meaningful brain activity, but the 300,000 residents of Fallujah,
most of whom have yet to return to their ruined city, have none to these
adherents of the culture of life.
These are the very people who, in
unguarded moments on talk radio and even TV can be found suggesting that we
really need to exterminate the vile
Arabs because apparently they don't venerate the same God that we
supposedly do.
And, in the right context, these same people, or at
least George W. Bush, are just fine with having the state terminate care to
a patient against the guardian's will, as happened
just a few days ago with a poor black baby in Houston, Texas - killed
under the auspices of the Texas Futile Care Law, signed by Bush when he was
governor of Texas.
This right wing apparently has a belief in
preserving life only where that life is almost devoid of meaning - and
where the HMO industry doesn't interfere. It's not a culture of life; it's
a culture of living death.
And the absurdity and deep offensiveness
of this new culture goes well beyond even such fundamental questions. This
group of authoritarian statists who don't believe in freedom of speech,
don't believe in international law or indeed in any restraint on the power
of their Christian nation, who want to repudiate the Enlightenment and go
back to the harsh world of the Middle Ages, dominated by a stern father in
the sky who has made life a torment to us all and the world a vale of
tears, somehow keep on telling us that they're on a crusade for freedom and
democracy in the world.
Life is not the only term they have drained
of meaning. Democracy is defended only after it has been redefined to mean
American hegemony plain and simple; I doubt that Bush, his advisers, and
his evangelical dittoheads even understand that the two concepts are
distinct in principle. "Freedom" is now redefined to mean not submission to
Rousseau
's idealized "general will" but submission to the conservative,
militaristic state - and the ability to participate in carefully scripted
"political discussions" with the president, if your views exactly accord
with his and you are roughly as fulsome in your praise of him as say a
Russian under Stalin (in his later years).
In 1976, Paddy
Chayefsky's movie Network made famous the phrase, "We're mad as hell and
we're not going to take it any more." For the last 30 years, unfortunately,
it has been the bigots, the crusaders, and the so inaptly named
"right-to-lifers" who have been mad as hell and the rest of us have had to
take it. Well, enough is enough. Let's get mad as hell too.
Rahul
Mahajan is publisher of Empire
Notes.He has been to occupied Iraq twice and was in Fallujah during the
siege last April.
His latest
book, "Full
Spectrum Dominance: U.S. Power in Iraq
and Beyond," covers U.S.
policy on Iraq,
deceptions about weapons of mass destruction, the plans of the neoconservatives, and the face of the new Bush imperial policies. He can be reached at rahul@empirenotes.org
### |
Printer Friendly Version
E-Mail This Article
|
|
|