ISLAMABAD, Oct 19 (IPS) - Addressing the American people on Oct.
11, U.S.
President George W Bush seemed as perplexed as millions of
Americans about
the ''vitriolic hatred for America in some Islamic countries''. He
added:
''Like most Americans, I just cannot believe it because I know how
good we
are.''
The day after Bush's remarks, Pakistan, Nigeria, Indonesia,
Egypt and
Palestine witnessed more violent anti-American protests. What
accounts for
this dichotomy between the American self-image and how others,
particularly
Muslims, view them?
For any foreign visitor to America, the goodness of the average
American, and the fact that immigrants rightly perceive America as
providing opportunities and freedoms denied at home is certainly
an
important ingredient that makes the United States the world's most
popular
destination. Their deeply ingrained empathy, candor, humor and
hard work
endear Americans to all those who interact with them.
How is this 'good guy' transformed into the 'bad guy' abroad?
The
problem is that American goodness is hardly ever exported,
remaining
confined to its shores. This gap between what American says at
home -
liberties, rule of law and democracy - is rarely practiced in
American
foreign policy.
After all, what was common among a diverse group of leaders
like Mao
Zedong, Ho Chi Minh, Gamal Abdel Nasser, Fidel Castro or Dr
Sukarno?
They were all great admirers of America and the American
Revolution
prior to assuming office. They all looked up to the United States
of
America, whose 20th century role and ideology had been defined by
Woodrow
Wilson as supporting the 'right of self-determination' of
subjugated
peoples and colonies.
An enterprising American journalist, Edgar Snow, whose
sympathetic
account of the Chinese Communist Party's struggle, 'Red Star over
China',
remains a classic, launched Mao on the international stage.
When Ho Chi Minh declared Vietnam's independence from France on
Sep. 2,
1945, he borrowed the opening words from the American Declaration
of
Independence regarding the ''inalienable right of people to life,
liberty
and the pursuit of happiness'', so inspired was he by American
ideals.
Before the July 1952 overthrow of the Egyptian monarchy which
he and 12
other members of the Free Officers Movement initiated, Nasser was
very
close to the Americans, including the Middle East chief of the
Central
Intelligence Agency (CIA) of that period, Kermit Roosevelt, who
was
covertly communicating with Nasser through Anwar Sadat.
Sukarno idolized Thomas Jefferson and his speeches were laced
with
Jeffersonian quotes. And when Castro launched the Cuban
Revolution, he was
confident of receiving American support.
But then, what happened? After coming to power, they became
implacable
American foes after a rude shock that the America they admired and
idolized
and the one they had read about in history books was different in
real life.
Then there were two events which were to prove a forerunner of
the
emerging patterns of American policy: the first successful CIA
coup against
a popular, democratic government because it was perceived to be
acting
contrary to U.S. economic interests, DR Mossadeq in Iran in 1953.
A decade later, the CIA engineered the ouster and assassination
of South
Vietnam's President Ngo Dinh Diem, a friend and ally of the United
States
simply because he had outlived his utility to American interests.
From ousting an elected nationalist to killing a friend, the
U.S.
persona was now being defined as an amoral, ruthless power whose
foreign
policy instruments were capable of anything, irrespective of
friend or foe.
It was perhaps in this context that DR Henry Kissinger once
remarked, ''to
be an enemy of America can be dangerous, but to be a friend is
fatal.''
Negativism about America has largely been derived and shaped by
predominant popular perceptions in three areas: dignity, double
standards
and democracy.
The leading London-based Saudi-owned Arabic newspaper, 'Al
Hayat',
recently carried a poet's lament on the plight of the Arabs that
includes
lines such as ''Children are dying, but no one makes a move.
Houses are
demolished, but no one makes a move. Holy Places are desecrated,
but no one
makes a move.
I am fed up with life in the world of mortals.''
The author of these lines is not some raving radical in a
Palestinian
refugee camp, but Saudi Arabia's ambassador to Britain, and the
sentiments
he has expressed represent what is by now almost a universally-
held belief
among Arabs, the poor and the elite alike.
For Muslims, the double standards they see reinforced this
hostility.
For instance, when United Nations resolutions apply to Iraq, they
exempt
Israel. And nuclear weapons are even given religious labels, such
as
Pakistan's 'Islamic' bomb. Or terrorism is treated as a virtual
Muslim
monopoly, forgetting that Timothy McVeigh, DR Baruch Goldstein
(the Jewish
settler who gunned down 29 worshippers in a Palestinian mosque in
1994) and
the Tamil Tigers, who blew up Rajiv Gandhi, were not Muslim.
Democracy, or its absence in countries that are American
allies, is
another key ingredient of anti-Americanism, more so when the
United States
has conspired or connived to undermine the democratic process.
Patrice Lumumba was ousted in 1960 in the Congo and replaced by
General
Mobuto. In 1965, Sukarno's replacement by General Suharto was
followed by a
massacre of almost 500,000 Indonesians, some of whose names were
in lists
proved by the American Embassy to Suharto's men. And in 1973, the
elected
leftist President of Chile, Salvador Allende, was ousted and
killed in a
CIA-backed military coup.
It is no surprise that those peoples in these countries traced
their
plight at home - the injustice, the police state repression, the
poverty,
and the corruption - to American actions.
However, not many Americans were aware of the adverse impact of
American
foreign policy on billions of lives overseas.
All that changed on Sep.11, 2001. Nineteen suicide bombers have
done
more damage to America's self-confidence than World War II,
Vietnam or the
Cold War combined. On Oct. 7, after returning from bombing
Afghanistan that
Sunday night, Commander Biff, head of an F-14 Tomcat squadron,
told the
media: ''Tonight was about restoring America's confidence.''
However, restoring America's confidence must not be at the
expense of
renewing America's relationship with the Muslim world, which is
facing
severe strains. Hence, the crisis needs to be handled with
patience,
maturity and wisdom.
Of all the hordes of Western journalists who have been in
Pakistan after
Sep. 11, not one has reported any hostility or harassment from the
people
they encounter in the streets, even those in anti-American
demonstrations.
There is no personal animosity toward any American or Westerner
from
people they have met, only a strident political critique and
resentment of
American foreign policy, which is where the roots of anti-
Americanism lie.
Copyright 2001 IPS
###