Breaking News & Views for the Progressive Community
We Can't Do It Without You!  
Home | About Us | Donate | Signup | Archives
   Featured Views  

Printer Friendly Version E-Mail This Article
Just Don't Say the R-Word
Published on Wednesday, January 10, 2001 in the Toronto Globe & Mail
Just Don't Say the R-Word
by Naomi Klein

That's me throwing off the National Post's new "R-Word Index," which claims to predict whether or not we are entering a recession based on how many times the word appears in that paper and this one.

The index is a Canadian version of The Economist magazine's indicator, which attempts to predict U.S. downturns based on the R-word's appearance in The New York Times and The Washington Post.

Of course, it's not just journalists who have the power to destroy the lives of millions with their careless word selections. After Dick Cheney used the R-word last week, the Clinton administration's chief economic adviser accused the Bush team of "talking down our economy." Don't they know about the S-words? Slowing, softening, slipping and -- if absolutely necessary -- slumping.

There's a name for vesting the repetition of a word or phrase with the power to change real-world events. It's called magic. And we all know the economy of the 21st century isn't based on magic. It's based on carefully calibrated rules of supply and demand. I can't bring about a recession just by writing about it, can I?

Oops, as Britney might say, I did it again.

The global economy is now at the mercy of enchanted words because words are what brought on this "period of unprecedented prosperity" in the first place. Think venture capitalists writing $20-million cheques based on a doodle on a cocktail napkin and a promise about a "new new thing." Think soaring IPOs for companies that, by all traditional indicators -- sales, assets, profits -- simply do not exist. Think

What were investors buying into when they sent the Nasdaq soaring? As Thomas Frank outlines in his new book, One Market Under God, they were buying ephemeral, magical things. Earning potential. Brand image. Buzz. Spells cast by market mystics such as George Gilder.

According to Harvard economist John Kenneth Galbraith, market booms are always brought about by "incantation" -- the hypnotic recitation of phrases over and over. This stock will soar to unimagined heights. This executive sees the future.

In his book, The Great Crash, Prof. Galbraith describes the "speculative orgy" in 1928 as a "mass escape into make-believe. . . . Men sought not to be persuaded of the reality of things but to find excuses for escaping into the new world of fantasy" in which stock prices, increasing by "vaulted leaps," bore no relationship to corporate earnings.

The same flight into fantasy characterized the dot-com frenzy, only our make-believe worlds are even more fantastic, powered as they are by Intel and available on DVD. The high-tech boom of the past few years has not only been fuelled by a real-world demand for high-tech products; overwhelmingly, it has been powered by technology's ability to super-amplify our incantations. Put simply: New toys let us cast spells on stocks like never before.

Our modern prayers for prosperity are blasted all day long on CNN, CNBC and Bloomberg, as well as their on-line equivalents. It is there that reporters, pundits, economists, investment bankers and corporate executives collectively willed the economic boom into being, breaking only for commercials selling wireless gadgets that let you trade on-line any time, anywhere. Think of it as the corporate-world equivalent of the Natural Law Party, which believes that if enough people simultaneously bounce up and down on yoga mats, peace, enlightenment and prosperity will follow.

That's why, during the boom, there was never much time for bad economic news inside the prayer circles on CNBC. Market agnostics were not invited to point out stagnant income levels for low-wage workers or widening disparities between rich and poor. There was scarce talk of increasingly casual employment relationships, or soaring rates of U.S. incarceration, both masked by low employment rates. There was simply no room for such heresy: In a faith-based economic boom, it takes uninterrupted hand-holding and visualization to keep the boom alive.

And it worked, for a while. The satellite-beamed incantations and temples of Internet trading have brought more people into the market than ever before. Investing has become an international pastime, Buffettology a global religion.

But in recent weeks it has been revealed that there is a flip side to this faith. If incantations can bring us into a boom fuelled by vastly overvalued stocks, then incantation of another sort -- the recitation of the dreaded R-word -- can trigger a bust as well. And not just on the stock market, but also at the mall, as consumers stop shopping because their portfolios have collapsed.

Put another way, we talked our way into this boom, we can talk our way out of it, too. Like magic.

Copyright © 2001 Globe Interactive


Printer Friendly Version E-Mail This Article
Breaking News & Views for the Progressive Community.
Independent, non-profit newscenter since 1997.

Home | About Us | Donate | Signup | Archives

To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good.