It was once a day to remember peace, and then a day to
remember war, but now perhaps, it's just a day to
forget.
It's past midnight, on the morning of November 11,
2004, but Ollie's Noodle Shop and Grille off 42nd
Street in New York is just filling with people. At a chrome-edged table, I sit with my wife, eating a bowl of steaming noodles.
Above us, along the wall, runs a blue neon light past pictures of medieval Chinese peasants stopping at a Buddha's head.
My wife and I arrived in New York just a couple of
hours earlier. We came to New York, in part, to enjoy
the city. But I've returned, in part, to stand at the
spot where I had stood in March of 2002, looking for
some meaning in Ground Zero - only to find none. Two
and a half years later - after two wars, tens of
thousands of dead, and tens of thousands of words
written trying to make some sense of it - I came to
look again, to see if I had missed something then or
if some kind of meaning had arrived since.
We finish our noodles and beer, pay the bill, and walk
back through the lights and sounds of Times Square to
our hotel to sleep, but my sleep is fitful.
Early the next morning we take the subway south to the financial district, and emerge near Ground Zero. The sky is cloudless and the
air cool as I take a deep breath and cross the street to the site.
I stand at the new ten-foot-tall, chain-link fence and
look at Ground Zero, now devoid of the blackened
debris and the acrid smell of burnt paper and metal.
The steel girders, in the shape of a cross, are the
only familiar point of reference to March 2002. We
walk further along the chain-link barrier, stopping
every twenty steps or so to look at large wooden
billboards affixed to the fence, each telling a
different chapter in the history of the New York
skyline and the building of the Twin Towers.
We come across some people having their pictures taken
with the site as backdrop. One guy in a red
windbreaker and blue ball cap with the words "North
Carolina" on it stands by the fence, smiling, his arms
raised. His wife - holding out the digital camera in
front of her - snaps the family photo.
We walk on. At the corner of the fence, attached at
the top, is a makeshift memorial - a large plaque of
sorts, dedicated to the "fallen heroes." I wonder
about the choice of the word "heroes." It wasn't such
a leap from "victims" to "heroes," I think. How much
longer before "heroes" become "martyrs?"
Or has that already happened?
A young man in a suit disrupts my thoughts. He walks
by us, talking business, rapidly and loudly, into a
small black cell phone. Though he walks along the
length of fence overlooking Ground Zero, he never once
looks at it.
Two years earlier, American flags were everywhere and patriotism burned white hot. But now New York seems apolitical. In the course
of the morning, we've seen only a few American flags and no one talks of patriotism - or, for that matter, the election that just
took place, or even about the Iraq war.
I look again at the Ground Zero site - busily being
primed and prepared for new construction - and it
occurs to me that Ground Zero is no longer a physical
place. It has become a pure idea, to be bought, or
sold, or manipulated. Or put another way, Ground Zero
no longer resides in New York City. It exists only in
the minds of those who give it meaning.
We leave the site and walk through the financial
district to Chinatown. From there we stroll through
the lower east side and then cut back through
Washington Square. By now it's sunny and comfortably
cool, and people are everywhere - buying and selling,
begging and walking, talking and laughing.
From the stone arch of Washington Square we start
walking uptown. At first we walk along Fourth Avenue,
taking in the shops and sights. But after a few blocks
we move over to Fifth Avenue - and discover a parade.
It's then that we remember the date: November 11,
Remembrance Day in Canada - Veterans' Day in America.
We find a spot on the curb and watch as groups of war
veterans and ethnic organizations, city floats and
junior high school bands march up Fifth Avenue. Active
duty troops march too, smiling and waving. For a
Veterans' Day parade during wartime, few people are
standing along the sidewalk. They graciously applaud
the floats and war veterans - but for the active duty
reservist they applaud gently, politely.
Standing at my left, two middle-aged men comment on
the groups marching by. When the reservists pass, one
man says to the other, "Hey, you know why George Bush
isn't marching here?"
"No," he says. "Why?"
"'Cause," says the first guy, "he didn't fuckin' serve
his country." They both laugh.
A little more than a week since the presidential
election, and their anger is palpable.
As I listen, I watch the Army reservists. About
fifteen men in green fatigues, smiling and waving,
walk alongside a green, armored vehicle with an open
hatch in the back. From the open hatch, three or four
of the soldiers are pulling out yellow water bottles,
which - when they spot teenage boys among the parade
crowd - they toss football style.
A young boy in a blue jacket next to the two
middle-aged men catches one. I step back to look at
the boy and the bottle. On one side of the bottle are
printed the words "Join the Army Reserve" in dark
green letters. On the other side of the bottle is an
American flag.
Later that night, we eat at an Italian restaurant. The
crowd is well-dressed, eating dinner before taking in
the shows along Broadway. We ask the waiter about the
menu and decide on a pasta plate. On the walls around
us hang dozens of photos of Italian Americans from the
late 1890s to the 1950s.
Sharing a bottle of red wine and a plate of pasta, my
wife and I talk about the day - Ground Zero,
Chinatown, the Lower East Side, the parade on Fifth
Avenue. Save for the parade, and a gaudy display of
fifty American Flags outside Rockefeller Center, we
saw nothing that spoke of patriotism. I keep thinking
about the changes at Ground Zero, and about the
passage of time.
When we finish eating, I get up to pay the bill. I
cross the center of the room and approach two waiters
standing at the register. They are talking about the
Veterans' Day holiday.
"I remember when this was a day to celebrate peace,"
says the older waiter to the younger. "It was a day to celebrate the end of World War One."
"Really?" says the younger waiter.
"Yeah, I can't remember the name of the day," said the
older waiter as he rings a bill into the register.
"But when I was kid - I think it was sometime in the
'50s - the politicians didn't want a peace day, so
they turned it into a celebration of soldiers."
Perhaps because of the red wine, I feel talkative. So
I interject, "It was called Armistice Day."
"Yeah, that's it," said the older waiter, turning in
my direction. "It was called Armistice Day, a day for celebrating peace."
"In Canada," I tell them, "they call it Remembrance
Day."
"Remembrance Day?" he says. "I like that - Remembrance
Day. It's almost like a day for peace." He hesitates
and then adds, "Right now, we could use a day like
that."
I smile and nod, then hand him my bill. He rings it
in, and after I pay, he wishes me well. As we leave
the restaurant, and walk to Times Square, I think
about what the older waiter said, "Almost like a day
for peace."
And I think: He's right. We could use a day like that.
Steven Laffoley is an American writer living in
Halifax, Nova Scotia. He is the author of Mr. Bush,
Angus and Me. E-mail: stevenlaffoley@yahoo.ca or steven_laffoley@yahoo.com.
###