THE BIGGEST THREAT to democracy in the United States today is economic
prosperity. That observation isn't motivated by a desire to see people suffer,
but rather is a challenge to the celebration of a certain kind of prosperity,
distributed in a certain fashion, in the service of certain kinds of
institutions, in which it turns out lots of people don't do so well after all.
In a real democracy, one would expect economic growth and prosperity
steadily to shrink the gap between rich and poor so that eventually political
equality is mirrored in a rough kind of economic equality that can give people
the space and security to maximize use of their freedoms.
In a real democracy, one would expect the workplaces within which people
spend a third of their day to be participatory and, well, democratic.
Neither is the case in the contemporary United States, which means
democracy is in trouble.
From the late 1980s to the late 1990s, the average income of the
lowest-income families grew by less than 1 percent, while that of middle-income
families grew by less than 2 percent. But for high-income families, the growth
was 15 percent, according to an analysis of Census Bureau data by the Center on
Budget and Policy Priorities and the Economic Policy Institute.
One of the economists who helped write that report calls the unequal
distribution of wealth from the recent prosperity "our nation's most serious
economic problem," pointing to evidence that societies with higher levels of
inequality grow more slowly. Our government's only response has been to push
massive tax cuts that mostly benefit the rich.
The economy that produces the grotesque level of inequality is dominated by
huge corporations that internally are structured like tyrannies-power
concentrated at the top, hierarchal management systems, and no freedom for
employees at the bottom, except the "freedom" to leave to find a job in some
equally tyrannical competitor.
People, even those who often are loyal to corporations for which they work,
have few illusions about this, which is why a Business Week poll last summer
found that three-quarters of people agreed that "business has gained too much
power over too many aspects of American life."
Apologists for the corporations argue that the rich-getting-richer should
be of no concern, so long as the economy continues to grow and the
poor-aren't-getting-poorer. The rich are doing their job, this argument goes,
by creating a dynamic economy that will, in the end, help everyone.
That's a story that's been peddled to working people and the poor for a
long time and is no more compelling today than it ever was to folks at the
bottom who are working longer hours to try to hold on to their standard of
living.
So, we have economic institutions built on anti-democratic principles that
produce inequalities that make democracy outside the workplace increasingly
difficult.
There is no denying that this economic system is very good at producing
vast numbers of products. There's also no denying that it is not very good at
producing free and fulfilled human beings. Work is, for most people, something
to be endured, not a site for individual development or the enhancement of
communities.
Though the overtly corporate-hugging Republicans and the pseudo-populist
corporate-hugging Democrats sometimes engage in rhetorical clashes, neither is
willing to speak to a simple question: How can we have a meaningful democracy
at home, or promote democracy abroad, if we live most of our lives under the
thumbs of authoritarian institutions that concentrate wealth and power in the
hands of the few to the detriment of the many?
Working people at the end of the last century understood this as they
fought what turned out to be a losing battle to stem the emerging power of
large corporations. A century later, the basic struggle to democratize America
is no different.
Robert Jensen is a professor in the Department of Journalism at the University of Texas at Austin. He can be reached at rjensen@uts.cc.utexas.edu. Other writings are available online at http://uts.cc.utexas.edu/~rjensen/freelance/freelance.htm.
Copyright 2001 © Newsday, Inc.
###