PARIS - An average person in France
could not help but be familiar with the case of Betty
Lou Beets, the Texas woman who was executed on
Thursday for killing her fifth husband. Her story,
with particular attention to her assertion that she
was abused by her father and husbands, has been on
the front page of many newspapers here.
The French also know about Odell Barnes, also
of Texas, who is scheduled to be executed March 1,
and who has been the subject of several articles by
journalists and editorial writers here contemplating
whether he is innocent. A few months ago, thousands
of Parisians took to the streets in support of another
American inmate: Mumia Abu Jamal, a former
Black Panther convicted of murder.
The United States may have become accustomed
to the revival of the death penalty, but much of
Western Europe is appalled by it. While executions
get little notice in American newspapers anymore,
the United States' willingness to put prisoners to
death is often scrutinized here.
In fact, there is so much political mileage to be
gotten from criticizing the executions that a candidate for Paris mayor recently went all the way to
Texas to meet with Mr. Barnes.
Many Europeans find it a contradiction that the
United States claims to be a leader in protecting
human rights when it executed more than 75 people
last year. Since the 1976 Supreme Court ruling that
allowed the reinstitution of executions, 38 states have
adopted a death penalty.
To many French citizens, deploring the rise in
executions in the United States is no different from
taking a stand against Serbian attacks on Kosovo or
the Russian bombardment of Chechnya. All European Union countries either ban the death penalty or
long ago placed a moratorium on its use.
"For us, what the Americans are doing is completely incomprehensible, that such an advanced
country can be involved in such an act of barbarism,"
said Henry Leclerc, the president of the Human
Rights League in Paris, "No European country does
this. No advanced country does this. America is doing
it along with countries like China and Russia and
other countries that have terrible human rights
records. To us, it looks the same as if the Americans
were endorsing torture or slavery."
France gave up the guillotine in 1981, after long
and heated debate, even though polls showed that the
majority of the French still favored executions. But
the numbers have changed significantly since then. A
recent poll indicated that only 46 percent still favored
the death penalty.
France's neighbors feel much the same. Last
year, the European Union announced that it would
submit a resolution to the United Nations Human
Rights Commission calling for an end to the death
penalty. The move was seen as a criticism of the
United States, though it was not mentioned by name.
In Italy, sentiment against the death penalty
runs particularly strong. More than two million people have signed a petition calling for the death
penalty to be abolished worldwide.
The Colosseum is
illuminated in gold whenever a death sentence is
commuted anywhere around the world.
One of Italy's leading clothes manufacturers,
United Benetton, has been running an ad campaign
with photographs of American inmates on death row
in seven states. The "We, on death row" ads have
caused a uproar in the United States. Sears, Roebuck
& Company says it will stop sales of Benetton USA
apparel, and Missouri officials have sued the company, saying those who photographed the inmates
misrepresented what they were doing.
Some French rights activists believe that Mr.
Barnes may have been framed for the murder of a
friend. Jack Lang, who on Thursday declared his
candidacy for Paris mayor, made news recently
when he traveled to Texas to see Mr. Barnes.
Patrick Baudouin, the president of the International League of Human Rights, pointed out that
France also takes other countries to task for sentencing prisoners to death. But he said the outrage
reserved for America was special.
"We think of America as being in our camp -- a
democracy that defends liberty and human rights,"
he said. "Of the countries we consider in our camp, it
is the only one that goes on with the death penalty."
He says he is well aware that Americans are not
listening to European opinion on the matter.
"We know that when we have a press conference
here, it does not do a lot," Mr. Baudouin said. "But 15
years ago, no one would have guessed the Berlin Wall
was coming down. You keep pressing ahead. We are
in an age of globalization, and sometimes our American friends have a lesson to teach us, and maybe
sometime we have a lesson to teach them."
###