EMAIL SIGN UP!
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
From War Games to Peace Games, It’s Time to Stop Playing Games
I am having an uncomfortable feeling of déjà-vu as the winds of March come up, blowing us headlong into an uncertain spring.
Ten years ago we were reeling in the aftermath of the 9/11 attacks. Governments and the media were howling for retaliation, and the massive U.S./NATO war machine was gearing up for a fight, first with Iraq, and then with Afghanistan.
Now it’s an Iranian president who is talking tough and daring the U.S. and Israel to bring it on.
Have we learned anything from our misadventures in Iraq and Afghanistan?
We have a different, much more cautious and diplomatically-minded president minding the store.
But what can he do when American troops are so stupid—even ten years after being embroiled in on-going nation-building efforts in the Islamic world—as to defame the holy Koran?
How can he possibly convince potential Islamic allies that the US means well when it’s so glaringly obvious that we are insensitive, boorish bullies?
It’s shocking that the troops were so mismanaged that such a huge mistake could have been made.
First there was a report from some remote province in Afghanistan that a few Marines had urinated on dead Taliban fighters. That was bad enough, but no—the US military had to take it further and actually start BURNING A WHOLE TRUCKLOAD of Korans.
WTF?
I mean really! How would we like it if a bunch of Muslim soldiers came to one of our states and starting burning Bibles and Torahs? It smacks of unbelievable cultural arrogance, coupled with unbelievable tactical stupidity.
So now two American officers have died in the ensuing protests in Kabul, along with two other American soldiers killed in one of the outlying provinces.
Killing an American military officer in Afghanistan is like killing a police lieutenant in New York City. Do that and you’re asking for it.
Sparks are flying everywhere these days, and there’s way too much dry tinder sitting around. It’s impossible to see exactly where all this is heading, but it sure isn’t in a “and they all lived happily ever after” kind of direction.
Once again, it’s necessary for ordinary American citizens to stand up and be the friction that stops this war machine from advancing.
Occupy has gone underground for the winter, it seems, but it’s time for all of us Americans to start sending messages to our leaders, in no uncertain terms.
We do not want war. We want peace. We want to live harmoniously with our neighbors and fellow global citizens on this planet and we demand that our military representatives respect other cultures, as we would want to be respected ourselves.
I know I will be patted on the head and told that it’s more complicated than this.
But it’s not. It’s very simple. This is how it is:
Human beings have over-populated the planet. We are now fighting over limited resources like water, arable land, fossil fuels and natural resources. That is what the fuss over Afghanistan, Iraq and Iran has been about. That is what is going on with Syria, Sudan and Libya as well.
It’s all about the dangerous and difficult demise of the premise of unlimited growth and a globalized economy.
We now face the prospect of more war for two reasons:
- so that we can burn up a lot more resources and have to rebuild them, thus cranking up our military-industrial complex and giving a boost to the economy in an election year;
- so that we or our allies can gain control of valuable and strategic resources.
High-minded ideals like democracy, human rights and humanitarian aid have nothing to do with it. They are what you bring in to mop up when the resisters are lying belly-up in despair.
And meanwhile climate change looms over us all. All these little diversions are just so many more irrelevant goose chases that keep us from focusing on what’s really important: working feverishly to mitigate and adapt to climate change before we are swept away.
World leaders are playing a dangerously, devilishly simple zero sum game. But we need to change the rules of the game now so that all of us can win. Because if we don’t, one thing is certain: we will all lose, even those who currently seem invincible.
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...


17 Comments so far
Show AllRight on Jennifer!
I wish you were the head of the United Nations and had just made this speech before the General Assembly.
I wish people weren't so scared all the time.
I wish we had an education system with one purpose - to tell it like it is and to turn out adults - not permanent adolescents, which is what we do in fact turn out.
And I will keep on wishing, and attempting to tell it like it is, even as we spiral in. Until we actually hit the ground there's always a chance.
And I hope that you will continue to write on.
Manysummits
=====
This was an excellent insight:
"It’s all about the dangerous and difficult demise of the premise of unlimited growth and a globalized economy."
However, I found 3 remarks that were slipped into an otherwise good article, that beg for scrutiny.
First:
"We have a different, much more cautious and diplomatically-minded president minding the store."
This is an absurd premise given the policies Mr. Obama has followed. From increased drone attacks to his investment in yet more weaponry. Need I remind readers that Obama has also gone after whistle-blowers and passed the insidious NDAA, likely designed to silence those who oppose the sickening policies of the nation. Although the lords of marketing (think: Peace Prize) would have us believe this is a peace-oriented president, the facts suggest something quite to the contrary.
Second:
"Now it’s an Iranian president who is talking tough and daring the U.S. and Israel to bring it on."
I've made it a point to lately listen to NPR when I have to drive somewhere, and it's clear from their "expert" commentary that the American public is being massaged into seeing an equivalency where there is none. I'm assuming that Ms. Browdy gets her info from that source... at least on this matter.
If a nation is being surrounded by war ships, if its economy is being bludgeoned by sanctions, and if its nuclear scientists are being gunned down like something out of a Chicago Mafia scenario... then that nation is placed on the Defensive. It is not the one "bringing" it on. (The rape victim is not equivalent to the rapist.)
Third:
"Human beings have over-populated the planet. We are now fighting over limited resources like water, arable land, fossil fuels and natural resources."
While this IS true on its face, it says nothing about scale or degree. Americans use a profligate 25% of the world's fossil fuels, added to all sorts of other resources, while natives of foreign lands use a fraction of that amount. So while rising population numbers are indeed a major strain on the Earth Mother, not all usage patterns (by region, or financial class) are equal.
I thought these errors needed to be pointed out.
While it is true that the US (and Canada) use a disproportionate amount of the available resources, you have to remember that 50+ years of US propaganda have indoctrinated much of the world into aspiring to live an 'American' lifestyle of conspicuous consumption, with India and China leading the pack. India has become notorious as the 'go-to' location for inexpensive IT tech-support, and China is is routinely excoriated by the US right-wing for stealing 'American jobs' (which are exported by the very people who finance the US right-wing), producing the cheap, resource consumptive consumer crap that 'The American Dream(tm)' demands.
We have systemic infection that is killing us. Civilization is the disease. War over resources and deception about those wars are the symptoms.
In re: China & India recall what SRose said..."not all usage patterns (by region, or financial class) are equal," because the resource consumption being done by industry is being promoted & developed by a relatively small elite in those nations. Not that I disagree with your premise that "Civilization is the disease."
Total acuerdo with Siouxrose's comments. The mass murderer in chief has about as much diplomacy as his terrorist drone strikes. His slick silver tongued deadly lies, along with the empire controlled msm, allow obomber to continue to get away with murder !
You hit on the head with the following sentences:
I know I will be patted on the head and told that it’s more complicated than this.
But it’s not. It’s very simple.
Enough said.
This article centers upon the idiocy of war.The Occupy movement, which it mentions in passing, might do well to focus upon these closing passages of Dalton Trumbo's classic work Johnny Got His Gun and the relevance that it has to today's world. The actor Donald Sutherland gave an electrifying rendition of these words at the end of the documentary FTA.
"If you make a war if there are guns to be aimed if there are bullets to be fired if there are men to be killed they will not be us. They will not be us the guys who grow wheat and turn it into food the guys who make clothes and paper and houses and tiles the guys who build dams and power plants and string the long moaning high tension wires the guys who crack crude oil down into a dozen different parts who make light globes and sewing machines and shovels and automobiles and airplanes and tanks and guns oh no it will not be us who die. It will be you.
It will be you-you who urge us on to battle you who incite us against ourselves you who would have one cobbler kill another cobbler you who would have one man who works kill another man who works you who would have one human being who wants only to live kill another human being who wants only to live. Remember this. Remember this well you people who plan for war. Remember this you patriots you fierce ones you spawners of hate you inventors of slogans. Remember this as you have never remembered anything else in your lives.
We are men of peace we are men who work and we want no quarrel. But if you destroy our peace if you take away our work if you try to range us one against the other we will know what to do. If you tell us to make the world safe for democracy we will take you seriously and by god and by Christ we will make it so. We will use the guns you force upon us we will use them to defend our very lives and the menace to our lives does not lie on the other side of a nomansland that was set apart without our consent it lies within our own boundaries here and now we have seen it and we know it.
Put the guns into our hands and we will use them. Give us the slogans and we will turn them into realities. Sing the battle hymns and we will take them up where you left off. Not one not ten not ten thousand not a million not ten millions not a hundred millions but a billion two billions of us all the people of the world we will have the slogans and we will have the hymns and we will have the guns and we will use them and we will live. Make no mistake of it we will live. We will be alive and we will walk and talk and eat and sing and laugh and feel and love and bear our children in tranquility in security in decency in peace. You plan the wars you masters of men plan the wars and point the way and we will point the gun."
"Human beings have over-populated the planet. We are now fighting over limited resources like water, arable land, fossil fuels and natural resources. That is what the fuss over Afghanistan, Iraq and Iran has been about. That is what is going on with Syria, Sudan and Libya as well.
It’s all about the dangerous and difficult demise of the premise of unlimited growth and a globalized economy."
These two utterly true simple statements should be copied and distributed as far and wide as possible. Glued to store windows, inserted under windsheild wiper blades, left on public transit... everywhere. Every time a politician opens their mouth, this should be the first thing said to challenge them. Every time a CEO or Corporate PR flack appear in public, they should be made to answer to this.
That simple act would do more good than all of the effort expended by OWS recently.
Jennifer: You’re probably familiar with Tolstoy‘s – Master and Man. In this story the protagonist, against his better judgment at nature’s warning chooses to gamble with the elements and ends up paying for it with his life by freezing to death in a relatively small radius not too far from his home. As a teacher of comparative literature, you’ll easily draw the parallel between the fate of a fiction narrative with that of citizens trying to be friction to the machine.
In Tolstoy’s story, the tension is created with a dual rhythm by pitting a rational individual against the powers of nature on a bad day. The theme builds quickly as a musical score and at no point do you feel the conductor is waving his baton and saying [WTF]. You follow the score and turn to the next page.
To blame is a common refrain in the human psyche. We never exhaust the endless probabilities as, there the problems lie in which to assuage one’s conscience and lifestyle - in essence aiding the machine and paying only with verbal disobedience to subdue it. You see, we are well acclimatized to our conveniences. We know where the fridge, stove, dishwasher (the list is long) is as well as Tolstoy’s fallen hero. When we loose sight of the Powers greater than the first person (I) the ending is all too familiar one and you high light many of these issues.
You mention the scarcity of resources and human overpopulation. This I do not believe is the problem in as much as the overpopulation of greed as the model set forth by our economic masters whose model is endless growth with calculators in hand.
I don’t know if you are aware, but The Department of Energy has banned the sale of shower faucets that consumes more than 91/2 liters of water per minute in your home. There is no similar legislation or concern on gas consumption as long as it’s not called a car; hence, the gas guzzler SUV and Trucks that populate the landscape. During the Iran/Iraq war there was some concerted effort to down size and GM made its first four cylinders Cadillac but the effort was short lived. The nineties that were to bear fruits to efficient automobiles - instead, became the exception and not the rule. We know today what litters malls and parking lots. Had the simple aggregates chosen to counter the friction by buying more efficient cars with little sacrifice to his/her lifestyle, there would be a daily oil well discovery everyday! And we would not have to go to jail for having grease in our hands as Thoreau did for his cause.
The other issue I like to point out: the rhetoric on higher education enters this forum quite frequently and unfortunately it’s seldom made clear what this gift horse is to look like. However, we do know that the heightened voices of modern sages are excluded from the decision making process. Philosophy and natural wisdom as become currency like monopoly money, and this has to change or Damocles’ sword has every right to fall.
Jennifer this is not a critique to your article but an exchange in conversation.
"Have we learned anything from our misadventures in Iraq and Afghanistan?"
Yes, we've learned that there are two very different "we" in Merka: We the people, and they the elites and elite apologists/water carriers. We're not part of they. If they want solidarity, they can walk this way. Until then, they face a growing throng of dissenters with a really great plan, in solidarity with like-minded people worldwide. Exciting times for the people. Dark future for elites.
Great critiques here, everyone! I especially appreciate your corrections regarding proportional use of resources--point taken. Anyone who has been reading my blog knows that I am always trying to raise the awareness of the privileged about how very privileged we have been, and how our blindness as to the impacts of our lifestyles is now coming boomeranging around to knock us all down. It is a continuing puzzle for me to figure out how to appeal to the privileged...what will move them (us) enough to get us out in the streets saying enough is enough! Thanks for the encouragement here and the feedback. Much appreciated. Onward!
*We have a different, much more cautious and diplomatically-minded president minding the store.
But what can he do when American troops are so stupid—even ten years after being embroiled in on-going nation-building efforts in the Islamic world—as to defame the holy Koran?*
lets get this straight
so we've a *diplomatically minded* [sic] prez in the wh
too bad his effort in *nation building* [sic] in afpak etc is being undermined by those *stoopid* koran burning grunts on the ground
is this the new *narrative* on cd ?
We're living in luxury compared to the rest of history!
Paved roads, indoor plumbing, modern heating & air,
quality control of food & water, planes/trains/autos,
1000 types of entertainment, tons of leisure time,
cheap ready-made clothing, cheap oil does all the work,
etc etc. How greedy are we gonna get??
We need to control population by stopping the suppression
of influenza, malaria and tuberculosis, out of respect for
future generations!
We need to control population by stopping the suppression
of influenza, malaria and tuberculosis, out of respect for
future generations!= austerity
"How can he possibly convince potential Islamic allies that the US means well?".........
"but it’s time for all of us Americans to start sending messages to our leaders, in no uncertain terms.".....
hey jennifer, "everybody knows, the war is over and the good guys lost"...i am reminded again of the franco-fascist battalion flag which was the words "long live death", mentioned by camus....sure let's write to our leaders....
in the privileged position you have jennifer you might consider studying teaching and applying camus' play, state of siege, and novel, the plague...