Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Khader Adnan and Now-Normalized Western Justice
Each year, the U.S. State Department, as required by law, issues a “Human Rights Report” which details abuses by other countries. To call it an exercise in hypocrisy is to understate the case: it is almost impossible to find any tyrannical power denounced by the State Department which the U.S. Government (and its closest allies) do not regularly exercise itself. Indeed, it’s often impossible to imagine how the authors of these reports can refrain from cackling mischievously over the glaring ironies of what they are denouncing (my all-time favorite example is discussed in the update here).
In 2010, the State Department included a long section on the oppressive detention practices of China. The “principal human rights problems” of the tyrannical Chinese government include “a lack of due process in judicial proceedings” and “the use of administrative detention.” Indeed, “arbitrary arrest and detention remained serious problems. The law grants police broad administrative detention powers and the ability to detain individuals for extended periods without formal arrest or criminal charges.” Can one even find the words to condemn these Chinese monsters?
Time‘s Tony Karon today writes about the case of Khader Adnan, a 33-year-old Palestinian baker currently imprisoned without charges by the Israeli government on accusations that he is a spokesman for Islamic Jihad. To protest his due-process-free imprisonment and that of thousands of other Palestinians, Adnan has been on a sustained hunger strike and is now close to death. Karon writes:
Israel has not charged Adnan with any crime . . . Israel deals with such cases using a legal framework based on emergency laws left over from British colonial rule to detain any suspect for six months at a time without needing to provide evidence or lay charges against them. When a detainee’s six-month spell has expired, the detention can simply be renewed.
[...]
Of course, the U.S. has its own system of indefinite detention now firmly in place. ...
Read the rest including updates here.


9 Comments so far
Show AllAll in favor of changing the name of this country from the =United States of America= to =Inquisition= signal by answering "Aye". [mutter mutter]
The Ayes have it.
Trylon
?
So he has ended his hunger strike because Israel has agreed to release him on April 17th.
"Adnan’s wife, Randa Mussa hailed the deal as a “victory” for her husband, whom medics said had lost more than 40 percent of his body weight over the past nine weeks.
“He forced the occupation to give in to his demands and I hope he returns safe to us,” she told AFP. "
This isn't a *victory*. He was arrested on Dec 17th. He was sentenced to 4 months of AD the release date of which sentence would be April 17th. The dates are the same. It is a fantasy to think that Israel actually did any bargaining here, they didn't do squat and he is going to serve exactly the sentence he was given. This isn't a victory, it is a humiliating defeat.
It's a vicory if his detention is not extended.
The moron speaketh....
"Mr. Adnan's four-month term was scheduled to end May 8, but Israeli military courts could have renewed the administrative detention for an additional time period. Israel's justice minister said it agreed to shorten the term to account for the weeks he was detained in interrogations by security authorities.
"It's an interesting development,'' said Kadoura Fares, a former Palestinian cabinet minister who helped fund the legal aid for Mr. Adnan's release. "Just a couple of days ago, he was considered a dangerous prisoner who couldn't be released. Now they're saying that he's not dangerous.''
Israeli Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman criticized the decision to release Mr. Adnan, whom he called a terrorist."
Tiny URL: http://tinyurl.com/75xo7op
Original URL: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052970203358704577237541728633540.html?mod=googlenews_wsj
At least in Israel if you are Jewish, you have right to due process. Of course Palestinian citizens are second class citizens and Palestinians in the Occupied Territories have NO Rights whatsoever. (in de-facto terms). Racist imperialist Apartheid at its finest.
In post NDAA 2012 USA, we don't even have the guarantee of due process, unlike Jews in Israel. We can be detained indefinitely, "renditioned", tortured and even killed.
This is too disturbing for most to contemplate, better to remain in denial and believe it won't happen to you, only to "the bad guys". We can always trust in absolute power not to exercise that power, right?
Yes, it seems that most U.S. citizens are quite tolerant of a government that grants itself tyrannical powers over them.
What they will not tolerate, however, is any criticism of that government when it's led by a member of their own political party. That's an unacceptable breach of social etiquette; it's beyond the pale.
It's a story that predates our species - my side, right or wrong.
The self proclaimed right of the Islamic Jihad to kill Jews is rightly denied to their representatives.
You may like that or not, but this has nothing to do with racism or apartheid. If you are a follower of the so called Durban Strategy, then, of course, it has to do something with antisemitism.