EMAIL SIGN UP!
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
The Long Shadows of Nixon and J. Edgar Hoover
Edgar Hoover passed away on May 2, 1972. The legendary FBI director lay in state at the Capitol rotunda, the doors kept open all day and night for the convenience of mourners.
I remember because I was still at college in Washington then, and around 3 o’clock in the morning a bunch of us drove up there, not to pay our respects, but to make sure he was really dead.
In those pre-9/11 days, you could still do that sort of thing.
Richard Nixon & J Edgar Hoover conspire.The memory of our predawn visit came rushing back last week as I introduced a screening of J. Edgar, the new film directed by Clint Eastwood, and interviewed its screenwriter Dustin Lance Black, who won the Oscar a couple of years ago for the movie Milk.
There’s a sequence toward the end of J. Edgar right after Hoover dies: President Richard Nixon appears before the cameras to solemnly announce the news. Cut to Nixon in the Oval Office ordering chief of staff Bob Haldeman and other members of his Praetorian Guard to seal off Hoover’s offices and seize his fabled stash of secret files on every prominent politician, past and present. Meanwhile, Hoover’s faithful secretary, Helen Gandy, has locked herself away with a shredder and dutifully eliminates the evidence.
The movie loops chronologically back and forth across Hoover’s law enforcement career of more than half a century. Eastwood and Lance Black maneuver an intriguing tightrope walk between the Hoover who sees himself as a crime-busting patriot protecting his country and pioneering forensic investigative techniques, and the paranoid, power mad, status obsessed Washington insider who would go to any lengths to pursue anyone he thought subversive or simply critical of him and his methods.
All of this is crammed into a repressed, mother-ridden, anguished individual whose decades-long relationship with his second-in-command, Clyde Tolson, was the closest he ever got to real love -- at a time in America when you could walk into the Capitol building unchallenged by security but homosexuality truly was, as the old cliché goes, the love that dared not speak its name.
As Lance Black told the San Francisco Gatein a recent interview, "If you are robbed of the ability to love who you love, you will fill that hole with something else. For him, it was power and a nation’s admiration... he started to do things that were heinous to hold onto it."
David Denby adds in his review of the movie in The New Yorker, "Again and again, he goes too far, treating Communist rhetorical bluster as the first stages of revolution, assembling lists of people whose opinions he considers suspect, fabricating documents, planting stories in the newspapers, bludgeoning potential enemies with his file drawers of sexual gossip" -- files that notoriously included John F. Kennedy and Martin Luther King, Jr., not to mention Louis Brandeis, Eleanor Roosevelt, Albert Einstein, Marilyn Monroe and Mary Pickford.
According to attorney Kenneth D. Ackerman, author ofYoung J. Edgar: Hoover and the Red Scare, by 1960, "the FBI had open ‘subversive’ files on some 432,000 Americans."
Last week, as if cued by the release of J. Edgar, there were new developments in the life stories of both Hoover and Nixon. By way of a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request, The Los Angeles Times received old FBI files on Jack Nelson, the journalist who eventually became that paper’s Washington bureau chief.
"Hoover was convinced -- mistakenly -- that Nelson planned to write that the FBI director was homosexual," the Times reported. "As he had done with other perceived enemies, Hoover began compiling a dossier on the reporter... John Fox, the FBI's in-house historian, said Nelson arrived on the scene at a time when Hoover was feeling vulnerable. A published report that the director was gay could well have ended his career, and that possibility -- unfounded or not -- had Hoover on edge."
In memos, Hoover, who had a penchant for smearing his real and imagined nemeses with names from the animal kingdom, variously called Nelson a jackal, rat and -- most charmingly -- a "lice-covered ferret." He tried to have the reporter fired and met with the paper’s head man in Washington, Dave Kraslow. "The spittle was running out of his lips and the corners of his mouth," the now 85-year-old Kraslow recalled. "He was out of control."
Kraslow refused to fire Nelson but did ask him to send Hoover a response which read, in part" "I emphatically deny that I have at any time under any circumstances ever said or remotely suggested that Mr. Hoover was a homosexual."
Meanwhile, the National Archives released the latest batch of tape recordings and transcripts from the Nixon Presidential Library, also known as the House of Mirth.
Among the treasures untroved was the 278-page transcript of Nixon’s grand jury testimony in June 1975, part of the Watergate Special Prosecution Force’s investigation into what litigator and author Glenn Greenwald calls in his new book, With Liberty and Justice for Some, "one of the clearest cases of widespread, deliberate criminality at the highest level of the U.S. government."
There are no smoking guns in the new materials but at a time when -- in comparison to the current crop of GOP candidates -- Nixon’s reputation is undergoing a bit of a positive facelift, it’s always good to be reminded of the whiny, self-pitying, defensive, dissembling reprobate we knew and loathed back in the bad old days.
He brushes off the whole sordid scandal as "this silly, incredible Watergate break-in" and says, "I want the jury and the special prosecutors to kick the hell out of us for wire-tapping and for the plumbers and the rest because obviously you may have concluded it was wrong." So sayeth the man made safe from prosecution by a presidential pardon.
He tells the grand jurors and investigators that he was upset about the White House tape with the infamous 18 and a half-minute gap (it was of a conversation between Haldeman and Nixon three days after the burglary attempt) -- not because of the erasure but because he mistakenly thought it wasn’t going to be turned over to the authorities. "I practically blew my stack," he blusters, claims the gap was an accident and that he had no idea what was discussed in those missing minutes, then blames the whole thing on his own faithful secretary Rose Mary Woods. What a guy.
Certainly, nothing in the freshly released Dictabelt tapes and transcripts changes what we always figured -- Nixon was not contrite over any of it but simply angry that he’d been caught. "It’s time for us to recognize that politics in America... some pretty rough tactics are used," he says. "Not that our campaign was pure... but what I am saying is that having been in politics for the last 25 years, that politics is a rough game."
He speaks about using the IRS to investigate Democratic campaign donors and the ease with which he could raise massive cash contributions from big business. He denies swapping ambassadorships for political donations but notes, "Some of the finest ambassadors... have been non-career ambassadors who have made substantial contributions." In that simultaneously priggish but smarmy way of his, Nixon recalls that President Truman made Washington social maven Perle Mesta ambassador to Luxembourg not "because she had big bosoms. Perle Mesta went to Luxembourg because she made a good contribution." (Her appointment was immortalized in the Irving Berlin musical Call Me Madam.)
Perhaps the strangest artifact in the latest document dump isn’t the grand jury testimony but Nixon’s recollections of the famous incident at the Lincoln Memorial in 1970 early on the morning of a massive antiwar demonstration just days after the killings at Kent State. He paid an unannounced visit to the monument and talked with a group of the student protesters camped out nearby.
"I know you, probably most of you think I’m an SOB but, ah, I want you to know that I understand just how you feel," he says he told the demonstrators. "What we all must think about is why we are here... What are those elements of spirit which really matter?
"... I just wanted to be sure that all of them realized that ending the war and cleaning up the city streets and the air and the water was not going to solve the spiritual hunger which all of us have, and which of course has been the great mystery of life from the beginning of time."
As he leaves, he tells one of the students, "I just hope your opposition doesn't turn into blind hatred of the country. Remember, this is a great country for all of its faults."
Of course, as Nixon got down with the kids, J. Edgar Hoover’s counterintelligence program, COINTELPRO, was getting down and dirty, not only spying on and infiltrating the antiwar movement but also deliberately trying to subvert and disrupt it -- with Nixon’s approval.
Such violations of civil liberties echo through to the present day: obstructions of justice, abuses of power, the tapping of e-mails and phone calls, black site detentions and "enhanced interrogations," to name just a few. In his new book Glenn Greenwald recalls the words Abigail Adams wrote to her husband John: "Remember, all men would be tyrants if they could."
J. Edgar Hoover and Richard Nixon remind us of that essential truth. They’re not so dead after all.
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...


7 Comments so far
Show AllI loved the line: A bunch of us went to the rotunda not to mourn Hoover, but to make sure he was really dead !
If our government was not soooo corrupt, Hoovers name would have been removed from the F.B.I. building in Washington De. Ceit a long time ago. It is like if the police headquarters in Germany, was named: THE HITLER BUILDING!
For decades, J Edgar Hoover was the most universally feared, politically untouchable figure in Washington DC because as founding Director of the FBI, he perfected the dark art of behind-the-scenes blackmail, having the most sophisticated electronic surveillance technology and network of undercover human intelligence resources imaginable at his personal disposal for nearly half a century. He lawfully used, and grotesquely abused, his enormous powers, almost invariably to advance a right wing ideological agenda.
Hoover's vicious efforts to blackmail Reverend Dr. Martin Luther King into silence with real and fabricated character smears are now a matter of public record, as are many of the blatently illegal, reprehensible police state tactics employed against the civil rights and Vietnam era antiwar movements under the FBI's COINTELPRO program. What has emerged less (as of yet) into the public domain, but which is also of enormous historic significance, is the degree to which J Edgar the blackmailer was also a blackmail victim, and how that effected federal policies throughout his long run as the nation's top cop.
Rumors about Hoover's private sexual proclivities with Clyde Tolson and others (including rumors of Hoover photographed in drag, and Hoover captured on film in flagrante delicto) did not publicly surface until after his death. Supposedly, both the CIA and organized crime figures had access to such smoking gun materials. Who knows for sure? Similarly, J Edgar was known to gamble and loved to go to the track and bet on the horses - not exactly the type of lifestyle that would insulate one from contact with some pretty shady characters.
We know a lot more about what J Edgar Hoover did with his official powers than what likely may have constrained or distorted his proper use of them. That's what happens when blackmail becomes a tool of potential use, a part of one's standard operating procedure.
Bill from Saginaw
It appears Clint Eastwood & Dustin Lance Black [screen writer for the movie on San Fran's Late Harvey Milk] is more interested in 'Outing' Ole Gay Edgar- & also his much hyped career as the US top 'law' enforcer, w some references to his notorious files on notable people & his attacks on communists & attempts to smear Rev Dr ML King [Note I'm basing this on review summaries - I haven't yet seen the movie]. I suspect the movie doesn't really come up w any 'smoking guns' about Ole Gay Edgar's homosexuality & thus is suggestive, probably based more-so on innuendo.
But Hoover's attacks on & prolonged determined effort to destroy Black leadership thru-out his career from the get-go; starting w Marcus Garvey & including the NOI's Elijah Muhammed & Malcolm X, Paul Robeson, MLK, Kwame Toure' {aka Stokley Carmichael}, the Black Panther Party - including that notorious Dec 4 1969 FBI / CPD Execution-Hit on Fred Hampton [while sound asleep] & Mark Clark- under COINTELPRO is Beyond Speculation - Its Documented FACT [Note: Hoover said it was all about stopping the 'Rise of a Black Messiah' that could unify & electrify the Black Freedom Movement...]!
And his dedication to Real crime fighting is Over-Hyped! He made his mark using the FBI's G-men to hunt down roaring 20s out-laws who were bank-robber throw-backs from the Old Wild-West Days [IE: Bonnie & Clyde, John Dillinger, etc -of the so-called 'legendary' Most Wanted List]. Many even think he had a hand in taking down Al Capone but, that credit rightly belongs solely w the ATF & Elliot Ness! In fact Old Gay Edgar spent most of his career pretending that the nation's Mafia Crime Syndicate, Did NOT Really EXIST! If Eastwood & Black had pursued why Hoover's Ole 'Sgt Schultz' routine regarding the Mafia- they would definitely had to talk about his passion for betting on race-horses at Mafia controlled Race-tracks -&- Would probably had to talk about reports that top Mafia figures had Photo Evidence of Hoover's Homosexuality - Which They Used to SILENCE Hoover about the Mafia!
As for 'Tricky Dick' Nixon- I, like many, thought that the Watergate Investigation were truly an investigation as opposed to a Cover-Up Masquerading as an investigation [IE: The Warren Report {which Hoover had a big hand in}, The Iran-Contra Hearings, & The 9-11 {c}Omission, etc...]. But it turns out that the Watergate Committee steered clear of " That 'Bay of Pigs' Thing- ['This E Howard Hunt guy could cause real problems on that 'Bay of Pigs Thing'] "- which was Nixon Speak for the JFK HIT! Eastwood & Black, in their 'Hoover' movie, could have also talked about [but apparently didn't] why Hoover, who had secretly recorded top Mafia figures discussing hitting both RFK & JFK who both were Hoover's Bosses at the time, apparently failed to inform either JFK &/or RFK, nor hauled those Mafia guys in for some serious questioning neither Before nor AFTER JFK's Assassination! By comparison Penn St's Joe Paterno was just fired for his mishandling of this Sandusky Pederasty Scandal - even though Ole Joe-Pa DID Alert his Bosses!
Ford's blanket pardon set the stage for the coup 26 years later -- it proved that the idea that oligarchs could be imprisoned was a phantom. The French Republic, on the contrary, was founded on the demonstration that even well-intentioned autocrats & oligarchs can be held liable for their criminal acts.
Nixon and Hoover were both restored to their former positions. Their only problem was it was in HELL! Good riddance, you murdering, treasonous, bastards.
I honestly once felt respect for nixon when, at the end of his miserable life, he asked not to be put on life support.
i'm working from memory here, but do recall reading that tolson became an embarassment to hoover because of his stroke-related impairments.
when tolson fell at the racetrack, hoover's goons tried to help him to his feet but hoover barked, 'let the asshole get himself up!'
prince of a guy, the blackmailer-in-chief.