Get News & Views Updates
Most Popular This Week
- When You're Cutting Social Security, 'Wealthy' Begins at $25K
- In Blind Poll, Republicans Choose Progressive Budget Solutions Over Their Own Party's
- Not Guilty By Virtue of Videotape, Which, Unlike the Police, Doesn't Lie
- The 'Land of 10,000 Lakes' Is Running Dry
- Manning: Before Wikileaks, Leaked Docs Offered to NYT, WaPo
- Yoga Wlll Turn Kids Into Godless Sun-Worshipping Pagans, Lawsuit Charges
- The 'Land of 10,000 Lakes' Is Running Dry
- Big Winner in Italian Election? The Five Star Movement
- A Better Plan Than 'Endless Growth': Enough Is Enough
- In Blind Poll, Republicans Choose Progressive Budget Solutions Over Their Own Party's
Popular content
Today's Top News
The Police State Makes Its Move: Retaining One's Humanity in the Face of Tyranny
For days now, we have endured demonstrably false propaganda that the fallen soldiers of U.S. wars sacrificed their lives for "our freedoms." Yet, as that noxious nonsense still lingers in the air, militarized police have invaded OWS sites in numerous cities, including Zuccotti Park in Lower Manhattan, and, in the boilerplate description of the witless courtesans of the corporate media, with the mission to "evict the occupiers".
Hundreds of NYC riot police forcibly evicted Occupy Wall Street from Zuccotti Park early on Tuesday, Nov. 15, 2011. U.S soldiers died protecting what and who again? These actions should make this much clear: The U.S. military and the police exist to protect the 1%. At this point, the ideal of freedom will be carried by those willing to resist cops and soldiers. There have been many who have struggled and often died for freedom--but scant few were clad in uniforms issued by governments.
Freedom rises despite cops and soldiers not because of them. And that is exactly why those who despise freedom propagate military hagiography and fetishize those wearing uniforms--so they can give the idea of liberty lip service as all the while they order it crushed.
When anyone tells you that dead soldiers and veterans died for your freedom, it is your duty to occupy reality and inform them of just how mistaken they are. And if you truly cherish the concepts of freedom and liberty, you just might be called on to face mindless arrays of fascist cops and lose your freedom, for a time, going to jail, so others might, at some point, gain their freedom.
I was born in Birmingham Alabama, at slightly past the mid-point of the decade of the 1950s. Many of my earliest memories involve the struggle for civil rights that was transpiring on the streets of my hometown.
My father was employed at a scrap metal yard but also worked as a freelance photojournalist who hawked his work to media photo syndicates such as Black Star who then sold his wares to the major newsmagazines of the day. A number of the iconic photographs of the era were captured by his Nikon camera e.g., of vicious police dogs unleashed on peaceful demonstrators; of demonstrators cartwheeled down city streets by the force of fire hoses; of Dr. King and other civil rights marchers kneeled in prayer before arrays of Police Chief Bull Connor's thuggish ranks of racist cops.
In Birmingham, racist laws and racial and economic inequality were the progenitors of acts of official viciousness. The social structure in place was indefensible. Reason and common decency held no dominion in the justifications for the established order that was posited by the system's apologists and enforcers; therefore, brutality filled the void created by the absence of their humanity.
And the same situation is extant in the growing suppression of the OWS movement in various cities, nationwide, including Liberty Park in Lower Manhattan. The 1% and their paid operatives--local city officials--are striving to protect an unjust, inherently dishonest status quo. Lacking a moral mandate, they are prone to the use of police state forms of repression.
Dr. King et al faced their oppressors on the streets of my hometown. Civil Rights activists knew that they had to hold their ground to retain their dignity…that it was imperative to sit down in those Jim Crow-tyrannized streets when necessary in order to stand up against the forces of oppression.
At present, we have arrived at a similar moment. If justice is to prevail, it seems, the air of U.S. cities will hold the acrid sting of tear gas, the jails will again be filled, the brave will endure brutality--yet the corrupt system will crumble. Because the system's protectors themselves will bring it down by revealing its empty nature, and the corrupt structure will collapse from within.
Yet, when riot police attack unarmed, peacefully resisting protesters, the mainstream media often describes the events with standard boilerplate such as "police clash with demonstrators."
This is inaccurate (at best) reportage. It suggest that both parties are equal aggressors in the situation, and the motive of the police is to restore order and maintain the peace, as opposed to, inflicting pain and creating an aura of intimidation.
This is analogous to describing a mugging as simply: two parties engaging in a financial transaction.
Although mainstream media demurred from limning the upwelling of mob violence at Penn. State as involving any criteria deeper than the mindless rage of a few football-besotted students unloosed by the dismissal of beloved sport figure.
Yet there exists an element that the Penn. State belligerents and OWS activists have in common: a sense of alienation.
Penn. State students rioted because life in the corporate state is so devoid of meaning...that identification with a sports team gives an empty existence said meaning…These are young people, coming of age in a time of debt-slavery and diminished job prospects, who were born and raised in, and know of no existence other than, life as lived in U.S. nothingvilles i.e., a public realm devoid of just that--a public realm--an atomizing center-bereft culture of strip malls, office parks, fast food eateries and the electronic ghosts wafting the air of social media.
Contrived sport spectacles provisionally give an empty life meaning…Take that away, and a mindless rampage might ensue…Anything but face the emptiness and acknowledge one's complicity therein, and then direct one's fury at the creators of the stultified conditions of this culture.
It is a given, the cameras of corporate media swivel towards reckless actions not mindful commitment…are attuned to verbal contretemps not thoughtful conviction--and then move on. And we will click our TV remotes and scan the Internet…restless, hollowed out…eating empty memes…skimming the surface of the electronic sheen…
These are the areas we are induced to direct our attention--as the oceans of the earth are dying…these massive life-sustaining bodies of water have less then 50 years before they will be dead. This fact alone should knock us to our knees in lamentation…should sent us reeling into the streets in displays of public grief…
Accordingly, we should not only occupy--but inhabit our rage. No more tittering at celebrity/political class contretemps--it is time for focused fury. The machinery of the corporate/police state must be dismantled.
If the corporate boardrooms have to be emptied--for the oceans to be replenished with abundant life--then so be it. If one must go to jail for committing acts of civil disobedience to free one's heart--then it must be done.
Yet why does the act of challenging the degraded status quo provoke such a high decree of misapprehension, anxiety, and outright hostility from many, both in positions of authority and among so many of the exploited and dispossessed of the corporate/consumer state.
For example, why did the fatal shooting incident in Oakland, California, Nov. 1, that occurred near the Occupy Oakland Encampment--but, apparently, was wholly unrelated to OWS activity cause a firestorm of reckless speculation and false associations.
Because any exercise in freedom makes people in our habitually authoritarian nation damn uneasy…a sense of uncertainty brings on dread--the feeling that something terrible is to come from challenging a prevailing order, even as degraded as it is.
Tyrants always promise safety; their apologist warn of chaos if and when the soul-numbing order is challenged.
Granted, it is a given that there exists a sense of certainty in a prison routine: high walls and guards and gun mounts ensure continuity; an uncertainty-banishing schedule is enforced. Moreover, solitary confinement offers an even more orderly situation…uncertainty is circumscribed as freedom is banished.
The corporate/national security state, by its very nature is anti-liberty and anti-freedom. Of course, its defenders give lip service to the concept of freedom...much in the manner a pick-pocket working a subway train is very much in favor of the virtues of public transportation.
A heavy police presence has ringed Zuccotti Park from the get-go, and whose ranks have now staged a military style raid upon it, a defacto search and destroy mission--because the ruling elite want to suppress the very impulse of freedom. These authoritarian bullies don't want the concept to escape the collective prison of the mind erected and maintained by the corrupt jailers comprising the 1% who claim they offer us protection as, all the while, they hold our chains…all for our own good, they insist…for our safety and the safety of others.
Although, from studying on these prison walls, the thought occurs to me…that what we might need is protection from all this safety.
- Posted in
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...



95 Comments so far
Show AllGreat words from a great heart Mr Phil "Because any exercise in freedom makes people in our habitually authoritarian nation damn uneasy…a sense of uncertainty brings on dread--the feeling that something terrible is to come from challenging a prevailing order, even as degraded as it is.
Tyrants always promise safety; their apologist warn of chaos if and when the soul-numbing order is challenged."
Starve the cop's, occupy the donut shops.
Rambling oratory by a self-absorbed, government-supported, over-educated, air bag, who's only perspective is a childhood reflection. This is not good journalism or good prose.
The infestation of public places by pot-heads, communists and street thugs is the reality of what is happening. Even these were given their say. Citizens deserve to be protected by their local police. The only tyranny is that of the OWS crowd who vandalize, trash and block the doors of legal citizens.
What planet do you live on? Or are you just one of those Fox News viewers who believes everything they hear on there? I think, USDiz2, aka Troll, you need to go back under your bridge where the rest of the trolls live.
Phil Rockstroh ,
thank you once more for providing thought provoking commentary. you're correct - in this empty, hollow society called 21st century america - no true expression of freedom or solidarity can be tolerated by the governing elites, unless it can be commodified or co-opted by these powers. this is not the case w/ the OWS demonstrators who clearly understand the underpinnings of our doomed economic/political system and the ecological wrath/endless war it is projecting on the planet. their message is revolutionary - it is the truth (the system is inherently broken and needs to be restructured).
Those who make peaceful revolution impossible will make violent revolution inevitable - John F. Kennedy
"We declare our right on this earth...to be a human being, to be respected as a human being, to be given the rights of a human being in this society, on this earth, in this day, which we intend to bring into existence by any means necessary." - malcom x
...peace...
Very well said IowaBlackbird. I was born in 1956 so I was young during the civil rights movement but I remember reading the news. The news papers did a much better job back then in my opinion. While reading Phil's article my nerves welled up because I know he is correct. I remember in college I kept saying we are not free but I didn't know how to describe why I felt that way. Between Phil's article here and Joe Baegent (deceased fairly recently) many writings my mind is understanding and I feel so stupid but we really are inundated with BS by the media that we don't even know our lives are crap. I wrote Joe a couple of times and told him he made me feel not crazy. I do believe the former middle class will rebel and I hope I live to be a part of it.
A bit hyperbolic.
I agree we have a bloated military and prison system.
But the next time your house is being burglarized, or you're stranded on a highway somewhere in the middle of the night, should you call a protestor?
And what about the protestors themselves saying the encampments needed more security. That raises the same issues.
You are full of s--t.
So if someone makes comment not in line with the popular stream of thought, they are f..l of S..t? What a cogent argument you present. Filled with logic and fact.
Though why you would call the police if you are broken down on the highway would be a good question too.
We have to be more sophisticated in how we view police , military etc
because NOT all forces, units, etc are tools of capital
and NOT everything they do is evil
It's not difficult, all we should be doing is looking at reality and ALL of reality.
The state corporate combine who gives the orders is unsalvageable but agree blanket trashing of the cops and soldiers isn't helpful when we have ex-Marines and soldiers participating in the occupations.
"So if someone makes comment not in line with the popular stream of thought, they are f..l of S..t?"
On this forum? Yes. If you have any idea that doesn't hue EXACTLY to the party line, you are full of poop and a zionist hasbarist infiltrator... end of story. See the continuous nazi like posts of Progressive101...
Did my comment get moved somehow?
Bad post. Too quick with the send button. I know, for I have been guilty of it as well. Please bear in mind:
1. Yes, our military has been used for private, corporate gain, ordered by members of the MIC. [Generals and presidents].
2. That does not change the fact that we live in a world in which, without a military presence to protect us, we would all be speaking something other than English, and would be under the thumb of some other oppressive regime.
3. Freedom means, among other things, freedom of expression.
4. The article bunches all police officers and all military in the same bundle, and paints them all with the same tar brush. That is an unfortunate outcome of people not thinking clearly what they are saying/writing/proposing. He is dead wrong in that choice of statement.
5. The implication that we do not need a military, or that freedom arises despite our military, is also very wrong.
6. We Veterans for Peace have been part of the OWS movement from almost the very beginning, and our members have been assaulted, beaten, shot and hospitalized as a result.
7. I think you need [as have I in the past] a note on your computer saying think before you hit the send button.
Ironblood, please explain how a military presence protects us. Protects us from whom? From what?
From the Soviets? Post-Soviet declassified intelligence shows there was no real Soviet threat. And many of us knew that all along.
From the "Terrorists?" The only terrorists we need protection from are in our own government. Surely you don't believe the mythology of the 9/11 attacks? And, besides, how can our government protect us from terrorists when they're constantly working with them (birds of a feather, don't you know)? Look at the Libyan "rebels", known terrorists all.
From the Canadians? The Cubans? The Mexicans?
You say that without our military protecting us, we would be speaking something other than English. What would we be speaking? Do you think that the English language is somehow inherent to freedom-loving peoples? Do you think the native populations of the Americas learned English by choice? How did the US Army "protect" the Native Americans? And is it somehow better to have English forced on you than Spanish?
I think you need to think about what you're saying, Ironblood.
Here's a little modern fable. The great dissident Israeli journalist Amira Hass, a militant for Palestinian rights, had an experience some 7 or 8 years ago that illustrates precisely how the military does NOT protect us. At some moment in the neverending destruction of Palestine, she wanted to go and talk with some Palestinians in a besieged area outside an Israeli military post. When she told the Israeli authorities her intentions, they said she would be crazy to go without a military escort, as it would be unsafe. Without missing a beat, Hass told them THEY were the crazy ones. She said she would be much more certain to be fired upon if she went out with an Israeli escort. And so she went out alone, an unarmed middle-aged woman, and of course was not harmed in the least.
Israel feels constantly threatened BECAUSE they are armed to the teeth, you see. If the Zionist settlers had simply been downtrodden Jews escaping persecution and willing to live in peace with the Palestinians already there, instead of ethnoreligious supremacists bent on military dominance, there would be no Israel/Palestine question.
I think your heart is in the right place, Ironblood, but you have to further rid yourself of the indoctrination that was planted in your brain during military training. The military is the problem, not the solution.
And please get rid of that ridiculous cryptonazi moniker. I, for one, believe you're better than that. If you are really for peace, soldier, then live it in every cell of your body.
Most crooks are smart enough to burgle your house when you're not there, the ones who aren't so smart should be given Darwin Awards. That is, if you really think protecting your stuff is worth taking another human life.
But why would you call the police when your car broke down on the highway?
Please Queer Planet pay attention, Peacekeepers different from Tyrants, Peacekeepers Different from Tyrants, Peacekeepers different from Tyrants. I challenge you to absorb and understand that thought for the rest of your days amongst us.
You're wrong Glenn, they are one and the same. When they are doing things *you* like, they are peacekeepers. When they are doing things *you* don't like they are tyrants. Amazing that *you* are the arbitrator of good and evil. Nice job if you can live on the pay...
Nonsense. Glenn is not talking about good and evil, you introduced that red herring. Nor did Glenn claim to be an "arbiter" of anything.
The question is this - whom do the police serve? Yes, when the police serve those in power we are opposed, because that is a threat to us. Should the police ever protect the most vulnerable and the many, then we are not opposed. What is so difficult to understand about that? Nothing.
I would guess that when you go into a store and a clerk refuses to assist you, you become "the arbiter of good and evil" and think that when they do things you like they are good and when they do things you don't line they are evil. But really, by your logic, they are "one and the same."
I guess you are wrong, John.
"But the next time your house is being burglarized, or you're stranded on a highway somewhere in the middle of the night, should you call a protestor?"
That reminds me of those bumper stickers that were somewhat popular in Texas during the '70s which made an attempt at humor with the message that if you are a liberal, you should call a hippie instead of a cop when you are in trouble. And that brings to mind one evening (true story) when I was a teenager stranded on a highway with a broken down car, at midnight, before the age of cell phones, wondering what I was going to do next. I saw a car with lights flashing approaching and I immediately thought that I would be saved from my dilemma by the cops. Nope! Searched me and searched my car (I had long hair and so was a suspect of course), found nothing, and then laughed at my predicament as they hopped into their cruiser and sped off. A long-haired guy smelling of petula oil came by a few minutes later, asked me what the problem was, on my answer said he could go to his house and get his tools and return, then did return a short while later and got my car running and I was on my way.
So yea, I would much prefer calling the OWS protester to calling the cop the next time I have some car trouble or any other kind of trouble.
There was a Texas sheriff who used to waterboard people if they looked like hippies.
I also thought immediately of the low-brow reactionary bumper sticker, "Don't Like The Police, Next Time You're In Trouble Call a Hippie".
Great story, BTW. You couldn't ask for a better latter-day reworking of the Parable of the Good Samaritan, all the more because it really happened.
PS: Just last week, a Philly cop shot a homeowner the cop mistook for a burglar. The homeowner, who reportedly shouted "This is my house!", was in critical condition but is recovering.
There but for the grace of God goes Henry Louis Gates, Jr.
I don't want to speak for the homeowner, but I'd guess that he certainly would have preferred that a "protestor" check out the alleged burglary instead of a cop with an itchy trigger finger.
Thanks for providing the wording of the bumper sticker. I couldn't recall it. After the episode described above, I always had a chuckle whenever I saw it on someone's car.
Are the protesters not citizens? Are they not entitled to police protection? Does the fact that they are protesting an unjust economic system mean that they are not still (theoretically) under the protection of the law?
Loved your reference to theoretical laws. Now that the blinders are off by the discontinuance of the debt prosperity of the past few decades, out society is now forced to look at what remains: a morally corrupt system and its values. The only hope left for civilization to progress is the acceptance of this fact, which ows is trying to encourage others to do (including the powers that be), so we can establish a more moral system, which values our planet and all life thereon. May our hope continue to grow without any further enforcement of dispair by the 1%.
Nietzsche
Excellent!
Thomas Gilbert-
And who do you think is going to help you when you are stranded along some remote stretch of highway? The troopers? Ha! They won't give a shit and stop unless they think they can cite you for something! Your comments show a total lack of experience in the real world. The ones who will help you and give you the proverbial "shirt off their backs" aren't the one percenters or the agents of the state, that's for sure! What planet are you living on, dude?
Somebody else noticed the bullshit about "clashes with police"! Which is exactly what they said about Scott Olsen, whose "clash" consisted of walking in the direction of the police. Which I suppose now counts as "violent moves" or something. Hell, the police evicted protesters occupying an abandoned property in Chapel Hill, NC yesterday because their banners "obscured the windows". And Eric Blair looks on from the afterlife and sips the perfect cup of tea and says "I tried to warn you people, I really did..."
Phil Rockstroh - I will remember your name and this article - superb - quality.
"life in the corporate state is so devoid of meaning" (Phil)
Which is why I left to climb mountains for seven years, a full-time amateur - " for to see an' for to admire " (RLS).
"Although, from studying on these prison walls, the thought occurs to me…that what we might need is protection from all this safety." (Phil)
"the oceans of the earth are dying…these massive life-sustaining bodies of water have less then 50 years before they will be dead." (Phil)
The environment as leading indicator - right on Phil - the environment and politics are not separate.
"The World is Blue - How our fate and the oceans are one", Sylvia A. Earle, 2009, former National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration chief scientist, now explorer in residence at National Geographic.
"Impact from the Deep", by Peter Ward, paleontologist, University of Washington, in 2006 Scientific American - what a greenhouse extinction event probably looks like - it is thought to be caused by a stratifying ocean - and CO2 induced.
Manysummits
========
M.D. The same lines & issues touch me, too. It's interesting that even in this forum, more voices are raised over the horse-race issues that focus on candidates & elections, than in the thing fundamental to life (and thus all of us) itself. Perhaps facing the truth here is too awe-full, or, persons feel powerless, so they empower themselves with chatter about candidates' positions and personality flaws.
Well said Phil.
Queerplanet: In Texas we don't call police on home invaders we call the medics.
I gotta remember that one. Classic!
"The U.S. military and the police exist to protect the 1%."
True, but in what country and what historical epoch has it ever been any different?
Even in Communist societies the plutocracy is replaced by a bureaucracy.
It's unavoidable. All large societies form social strata and a food chain, just like in nature. Each layer of the human social strata feeds on the layer below it, and provides food for the one above it. This "food" consists of property, and human energy. Money is a measure of human energy, a store of human energy, and a means to exchange human energy. Those who control the most money control the most energy. Top-level private bankers control the money. Therefore everyone is a slave to top-level private bankers.
Refusal to acknowledge these facts is precisely what keeps the game going.
In nature all species are part of the web of life which includes a web of nutrition between species. In a single species it is unnatural for members to prey on other members. Some species are egalitarian, some have leaders equal or supierior to others and some have queens. Money can only capture material energy though it attempts to control spiritual energy. We acknowledge the "game" we demand evolution, after all we are animals with free will.
Very nicely said, Richard. Don't I know you? VFP 111?
I called the police when a person was stabbed outside my apartment door; by the time the police arrived, which took longer than half an hour, the victim had walked away from the scene of the crime, leaving behind a trail of blood. (This happened in New York City.)
"There have been many who have struggled and often died for freedom--but scant few were clad in uniforms issued by governments."
Beautiful.
When politicians frame the issues and manipulate the limits of what can and cannot be done, it is a God send to have a gifted free person step up to the public microphone and tell it like it is. The politicians may not get it but the people do.
Hear this and know that we will change this world; pass it along for others to hear. Learn it, sing it.
http://makanamusic.com/?slide=we-are-the-many
Out here in flyover country it is not unusual to hear rabid right-wing nut-jobs giving three minute “Reports” on the radio, even on stations that program music most of the time.
Yesterday (Monday) I heard the “Huckabee Report” on my local “Oldies” station, here’s my transcript of Mike’s lead story;
"Local officials around the country are finally starting losing their patience with the Occupy Wall Street protestors and they’re serving eviction notices and clearing out tents, they tried it Sunday in Portland Oregon but thousands of protestors swelled their ranks and the mayor backed off.
We’re getting daily reports that the camps have devolved to the “Lord of the Flies” stage with reports of robberies, rapes, extortion, vandalism, drug overdoses, cutting attacks on two Oakland police officers and the suicide of a military veteran at a protest in Vermont. Between the rotting trash, the lack of toilets and the moldy wet cardboard signs some of these camps have been branded cesspools of disease, there was even a report of an outbreak drug resistant T.B. among Atlanta protestors but leaders say the victims were homeless people, not protestors, still, do you know how homeless people get T.B.? That’s from living like Occupy Wall Street protesters do.
Seriously, you’ve made your point. If you’ve got a home it’s time to return to it and be grateful for it. And will someone answer this; why are the Occupy protestors allowed to set up tents in clear violation of zoning laws but real homeless people, including homeless veterans, are not allowed to sleep in parks or on streets.
Up next the shocking results of Obamacare…."
http://radio.mikehuckabee.com/ click on Monday, Nov. 14, afternoon to hear the report.
The timing of the police action to clear the Occupy Wall Street protestors from New York and the other actions against the Occupy movement across the nation was no freakin coincidence, they even used right-wing talk radio to spread propaganda in advance of the attacks; you can bet the farm that this was coordinated out of the Department of Homeland Security and had the blessing of President Obama.
Although the police does provide help at times, its function is overhwelmingly that of an enforcer of an economic and political order that, by now, is no longer an order that the majority has chosen, and, in fact, is downright inimical to the interests of the majority.
Very well said.
The dictator Mubarak in Egypt fell when the soldiers refused to be ordered to attack the protesters but instead allowed them to climb on the tanks. We may see a similar situation here if more and more veterans who are disenchanted by the slim prospects for jobs and a good life that confront them when they come back from Iraq and Afghanistan.
The powers that be have the full range of U.S. Government military equipment at their disposal to defend the bankers. So did the Egyptian army. But when the hearts of the troops understand loyalty to home and family and country means more than following the orders of the corrupt the weapons won't matter.
Some of the comments about police are just laughable. "Everyone is the same" comments often are. It sounds like a RW'er saying "All them damn liberals are......"
Any comparison of Egypt to the US or their protestors is again laughable. There is no danger of losing life here by going out into the streets, little risk at all. The comparisons of our police force and those in Syria, etc are again laughable for the economy of intellect and fact used in the comparisons.
And Egypt is now a military dictatorship. Something that historically occurs after a revolution. The French revolution is a prime example.
Hyperbole as argument is seldom convincing.
Rubbish. Egypt is still in the process of attempting to rid itself of the Mubarek machine. It is NOT comparable to the French Revolution.
Egyptian activists, themselves, have come to see Zuccotti Park and claimed that it is, indeed, the very same spirit: People want a different world, one without obscene social injustice.
You, sir, have proven you know nothing; you don't even seem to reflect the consensus of readers here. In that way, you seem like a specter of the state itself. This is not the first time. Why are you here?
Stiv: If you realized that "left Home" has also posted as Thomas More, Caligula, Mighty Mite and other screen names, perhaps you'd recognize where the narrow views originate.
Oh for the love of God! Another name? Lol
Siouxrose, two points
[1] I love all your comments and agree with them 300 percent. Indeed you are one my very favorite commentators here at CD.
[2] I use the name "Caligula" on a friend of mine's blog. There only, and nowhere else. I do not know who "Thomas More" or "Mighty Mite" are. I don't recall seeing those names.
Just to avoid confusion.
Richard,
Siouxrose was referring to the commenter "lefthome" If I am not mistaken, it is believed one of this contributors screen names is alugilac...Caligula spelled back words..
I only have one. I cannot think of any reason why anyone would wish to post under several screen names.
Thomas Gilbert-
Yes generalizations about groups of people are to be avoided. You do in fact risk death in nonviolent resistance police kill nonthreatening people almost everyday in the USA, and Vet Scott risked death in Oakland. Eygpt is a work in progress. And Love is the best way to achieve the necessary non-compliance by security forces as in Egypt and Gandhi India.
I agree.
I don't know how homicide detectives, traffic police who rescue people, detectives who hunt rapists and pedophiles, for example, are serving the 1% .
People talk about the thin edge of the wedge. Well, it doesn't work like that.
It's all or nothing and we would know it the first day of totalitarian power.