Get News & Views Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
What Did You Learn in School Today? (The Texas Version)
Millions of Texas students head back to school this week confronted by a dramatically altered, state-mandated social studies curriculum.
The contentious hearings of the Texas State Board of Education received considerable attention in the spring of 2010, but seem to have fallen out of the public consciousness as the new school year begins. The new curriculum, officially called the Texas Essential Knowledge and Skills, deserves renewed attention, as it will undoubtedly surprise most Texans.
The fiercest battle during the board's hearings was fought over the 11th-grade history curriculum, which in Texas is "United States History since 1877." The exception to that timeline is the new state-mandated "Celebrate Freedom Week," during which students will learn about our founding fathers. That sounds simple enough, except that the only founding fathers included in the curriculum are Benjamin Rush, John Hancock, John Jay, John Witherspoon, John Peter Muhlenberg, Charles Carroll and Jonathan Trumbull Sr. What about George Washington, Thomas Jefferson or John Adams? They are nowhere to be found in the new high school TEKS. Students apparently learned everything they need to know about them in eighth grade.
As part of the board's effort to emphasize the positives in American history, students will no longer learn about "American imperialism." Instead students will discuss "American expansionism" and come to understand how "missionaries moved the United States into the position of a world power." The board eliminated mention of our government's use of propaganda during World War I, and instead of analyzing Truman's decision to use the atomic bomb at the end of World War II, students will now analyze the development of the bomb. Additionally, students will now "evaluate efforts by international organizations to undermine U.S. sovereignty."
The board included Estee Lauder in the state curriculum, but not George Washington.
Perhaps you have heard something about a labor movement in the 20th century? No longer will your children. The only reference to a 20th-century labor movement will come when learning about Cesar Chavez and Dolores Huerta. No mention of the Fair Labor Standards Act or the National Labor Relations Act. No mention of strikes or any labor dispute. The words "labor movement" were taken out of the TEKS. Perhaps there is not enough time because students must now "understand how the free enterprise system drives technological innovation ... such as cell phones, inexpensive personal computers and global positioning products."
Students will learn about the contributions of Jerry Falwell's Moral Majority. Maybe the students will read Falwell's claim that feminists and homosexuals were partially responsible for the 9/11 attacks. Phyllis Schlafly, the Heritage Foundation and the NRA are all included. Students will also be required to "discuss the meaning of ‘In God We Trust.' "
History in Texas classrooms will be decidedly different from when we were students. I never learned "both the positive and negative impacts of ... country and western music" in my high school history class. Where would you rate Estée Lauder in terms of historical importance to our country? If you think she is one of the 68 most important historical figures, you agree with the board. Yes, the board included her in the state curriculum, but not George Washington.
I also never learned that the findings of the House Committee on Un-American Activities were confirmed, perhaps because it is not true. It puts teachers in an awkward position by asking them to teach something that is historically inaccurate. I will not have to deal with that issue in some of my classes because my Advanced Placement U.S. History classes are not required to follow the state curriculum. I am guessing that the Texas Education Agency realizes that students could never pass national exams while learning the state-mandated curriculum.
During the next decade, we should not be surprised when university professors lament that Texas students are not prepared for college. Malcolm X once said, "Education is the passport to the future, for tomorrow belongs to those who prepare for it today." You might remember a historical figure named Malcolm X, but your children won't. Malcolm X is not in the social studies curriculum in Texas. Now if you will excuse me, I have to do some research on Estée Lauder. She was not mentioned in any of my graduate history courses, either.
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...


118 Comments so far
Show AllWith his negative attitudes, it is clear that Mr. Studer will not become President Rick Perry's Secretary of Education.
Given his antediluvian, secessionist attitudes, it is clear Rick Perry should never become President.
There is nobody in the current candidate pool, including B.O., who "should" become President.
No, I'm sure Perry is saving that position for Estee Lauder.
He could round out his cabinet appointments with none other than Calvin Klein.
Texan politicians and powermongers won't be happy until everyone knows as little about everything as they do. I always thought that letting the blind (or in this case the willfully ignorant) leading the blind was not something that was considered a good thing.
Ah well, at least we'll have many more things to make fun of them about, Small comfort that tho...
Gee and nobody in the MSM says once to any of these people:
YOU ARE F*CKING FASCIST NUTJOBS!
STOP F*CKING WITH OUR KIDS!!
Couldn't be that TPTB would support such dumbing down of the populace, huh?
Nah.
I'm sure we all want polycarpe to mentor our children.
Sounds like a Harvard graduate.
"Who controls the past controls the future; who controls the present controls the past."
--George Orwell, "1984"
Lol. I was just about to post that exact quote.
What a relief to know that our children and grandchildren (at least if they are educated in Texas) will never hear of George Orwell.
important to remember how 1984 ended...
not well, Orwell...
The Texas school board (or ministry of truth) will send their kids education down the memory hole. Double plus good.
"All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others." ("Animal Farm", George Orwell) Apparently this also applies to Founding Fathers. Yes, there is a place for an Orwell quote every day of late.
I can't tell you how much even some of the good progressives fall for that classist "more equal than others" trap. They stand to dishonor their integrity like that.
Thanks for that quote. For some reason I didn't have it in my "collection".
Evolution in Texas: Stupid is the new smart. Dumb is not confined to Texas. however, witness the rise if Rick Perry. If I ran the zoo, H. Zinn's Peoples History would be required reading for high school students.
The amerikan public is so susceptible to indoctrination that willful ignorance has become the new intellectualism.
Texas - it is indeed a "whole 'nother country."
There will always be a few teachers who give token time to the state curriculum while in fact telling their students the truth.
Ah, but they will not be teachers for long. Once fired for insubordination, you might get a job at McDonald's.
Firing a teacher is an extremely difficult and time consuming task for the administration. Most administrators are too lazy to bother with it. Besides, "Nobody will stop you from leaving prison unless you leave your shackle against somebody else's leg"
----Kahlil Gibran. Translation: You can do almost anything you please as long as you do not expect credit for it, or care if somebody else gets the credit, and be quiet about it.
The "Star Spangled School House" just turned into a good outhouse. Bring your own toilet paper!
Wow....excellent!!!!!!
I truly, hope to h*lll so....
I truly hope to h*ll they do ......
Okay, okay, I'll leave out the colorful language, that I even cloaked......twice I posted a simple reponse to you Nietzsche......I truly hope to............that they do.....this one is more cloaked....
Why is my reply to this person not being allowed....it is very simple and certainly a positive response...?
Where are you looking? You've got four responses in a row here.
I foresee a whole new market opening up. Anyone taught from these books and this curriculum will need remedial education to bring them back up to normal educational levels. The need for history tutors will be HUGE.
Anyone wanting to leave the state and take their kids will have to re-educate those kids before even TRYING to put them in school anywhere else. And once everyone in Texas realizes that that the only jobs there pay minimum wage, there should be an exodus from there. The profit possibilities will be HUGE!
The board who approved this needs to be removed and FAST. They are turning Texas into not just a laughing stock of the country, but the world. And THIS is what these people think SHOULD be done? Don't like your history, make it up? And then teach bullshit to your kids? SHAME ON YOU.
Estee Lauder? Give me a freaking break. Those poor, poor kids. They will be the biggest joke in the country before long.
Texas traditionally sets the curriculum for the entire United States. Most publishers don't want to spend the extra money to print multiple editions of a textbook for each individual state and because most textbooks are printed in Texas, most publishers follow their curriculum. Alas, Texas will be responsible for dumbing down everyone's children. FTW!
Yes, but once this started coming out, there have been several states who have publicly announced that they will use older books or find alternate texts rather than have to teach obvious and glaring untruths. The book publishers were even taking about having to do 2 editions, one for Texas and one for the rest of the country. I think even they are embarrassed by having to put their names on such drivel and nonsense.
Given the growth of Texas and the influx of Americans from other states. It appears that we have voted for the Texas version. All this reactionary appoplexy from the progressive educators is humerous. After decades of politically correct revisionist rewrites of American history, you now know how it feels to be ignored by the ruling elite. Your stereotypical slander of Texas and all things Christian in our culture has brought our nation to its knees in many ways. Don't mess with Texas either.
Isn't one of the Ten Commandments, "Thou shall not lie"? I wouldn't lie to my dog the way teachers in Texas are being told to lie to our children. You call it "stereotypical slander". I call it willful ignorance.
If you are going to insist on behaving like idiots in Texas, don't get mad when the rest of the world calls you idiots.
Can we start a campaign to encourage Texas to secede?
The phrase "Don't mess with Texas" started as an anti-litter campaign. Seems to me, there is a lot of garbage to get rid of in Texas.
Close! "Don't bear false witness". However, neither God or Texas grades on the curve.
Ignorant indeed! Thanks for the civil discourse. So everyone who disagrees with professor Ravenswood is a liar.
Please cite examples of "revisionist history" that offend you so. As far as what has brough this country to it's knees I'd say it was 30 years of trickle-up economics, the evisceration of financial regulations, a military budget far beyond the need to protect the borders, an inability - or unwillingness - to transition away from fossil fuels for energy, support for too many brutal governments to name, and a host of other policies that are the exact opposite of what a "Christian" nation would follow. Assuming of course that Christian actually means following the teachings of Christ and not just thumping a bible.
Texas has a notorious history of stupid attitudes toward education. A former Texas governor said that if English was good enough for Jesus Christ, it was good enough for the children of Texas. Unfortunately, the English language did not exist during the lifetime of Jesus Christ, and he actually spoke Aramaic. So, English was NOT good enough for Jesus Christ and the children of Texas should be able to receive instruction in their own languages when that is necessary. No slander there, sweetie. Just facts. One story I have tried to track down is the claim that the Texas legislature passed a law that the value of Pi is 22/7. If Texas engineers were required to use that value, any submarine built in the state of Texas would leak so badly it would probably sink on its maiden voyage. Can anyone else find a reliable source online for that story? Or can anyone find a reliable source online debunking it?
English did exist at the time of Jesus Christ, but back then it was called German.
"During the next decade, we should not be surprised when university professors lament that Texas students are not prepared for college."
Have no fear Mr. Studer! To satisfy most degree programs required courses on social studies and history can be counted on 1 or 2 fingers! It is painful how little some of my most "educated" friends know of the history of the United States. But... a proper education, according to the powers that be, teaches the population to be obedient, subservient, and unquestioning of the dominant structures of power.
Our current economic policies are testimony to how little knowledge our leaders have of Economics.
UNTRUE! Our current leaders DO have an extensive knowledge of economics, that is why our economy is falling apart!
Unless Harvard has moved, I don't think our current economic leadership attended any classes in Texas. Last I heard, Texas is doing much better without enlightened progressive policies.
Yes, they're leading the way to a low wage future... A Hobbesian paradise where life is nasty, brutish and short for those who don't submit to their 'betters'...
"To satisfy most degree programs required courses on social studies and history can be counted on 1 or 2 fingers! It is painful how little some of my most "educated" friends know of the history of the United States. But... a proper education, according to the powers that be, teaches the population to be obedient, subservient, and unquestioning of the dominant structures of power."
You can make this complaint about any subject that a student is not majoring in. The amount of math / science that a social sciences / history / humanities major has to do, can be counted on a few fingers, something like 2 math and 2 sciences. Conversely, someone not majoring in the social sciences / humanities would take maybe 2 history classes, 2 arts / humanities classes or something like that.
This is how a liberal education works. It is far more preferable to a non-liberal one, a subject specific one, such as the used in the UK, and countries (former UK colonies) that model their system after the UK.
And 2 history classes ARE enough to get students questioning and thinking, if the curriculum is properly designed, and students are taught historiography, instead of just regurgitating names and dates.
I am not familiar enougth to figure out what 2 history classes mean in the US system. I learned history in the French system (including American, Russian, Chinese, Ancient Egyptian, Greek, Roman empire history) from age 8 to age 18.
Classes were mandatory whether U went in scientific sections or humanities. In the science section where I was we had 2 hrs of history/week form age 10 to 18 (Yes philosophy was also mandatory for Mth/science majors).
I feel like most French that it allowed me to understand politics and vote and if may explain why so few are "undecided" in France even 1 year before major elections and why decisions impacting the people negatively are followed by massive prolonged and occasionally general strike.
A coup, like the one in 2000 with G Bush been put in power with no vote recount would have for sure brought the country to a TOTAL standstill until votes could be counted or elections canceled with the consequence we ALL (??) know: A Gore was the winner. When i tell my neighbor in the US she still doesn't believe me: Rush Limbaugh never told her.
Chinese and Russian history are generally censored from most American school curriculms except when those two countries are attacked on communism. I'm no good at speaking French but their teaching looks promising. I hope their educational system doesn't get compromised in the midst of the rightwing "austerity" packages causing trouble.
The French system is similar to the American system, they are both liberal education systems, based on the (ancient) Greek / Roman idea of a liberal education, of the liberal arts (the trivium and the quadrivium), in contrast to the British system, where students specialise very early.
"Classes were mandatory whether U went in scientific sections or humanities. In the science section where I was we had 2 hrs of history/week form age 10 to 18 (Yes philosophy was also mandatory for Mth/science majors)."
This is exactly how it is in the American system too. Hence in university, students majoring in arts / humanities / philosophy have to study math and science too; conversely students studying math or science subjects have to take arts / humanities subjects too (obviously someone majoring in physics or math, will not study history to the extent that someone majoring in history does, similarly someone majoring in history, will not study math to the extent that someone majoring in math does)
2 history classes means a year of them (or more accurately about 9 months), in a semester system, that would mean one class in the spring semester, and one class in the autumn / fall semester. That means about 3-4 hours per week for about 9 months.
Howard Zinn just rolled over in his grave...
Just remember if you are in a position hire anyone that you need to give anyone from Texas special scrutiny, since they are so likely to be nincompoops. Certainly you should be very leery of putting a factory or business there.
But business likes its lower level workers to be just smart enough to do what they're told and dumb enough to never question anything. Sounds like a Texas eddication would be just fine for that.