Get News & Views Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Teaching: The Greatest Responsibility and Opportunity
In 1987 I taught several week-long humane education courses to twelve-year-olds in a summer program offered at the University of Pennsylvania. I’ve spoken about the experience of watching those kids turn into activists overnight through in my TEDx talk, “The World Becomes What You Teach,” but what I haven’t spoken about very often is the long-term impact of something as seemingly fleeting as a middle schooler’s summer course experience.
Twenty-two years after teaching that first course, I invited one of those students, now an HIV/AIDS activist working for the mayor of New York City, to come to a talk I was giving in Manhattan. I hadn’t seen him in 18 years, and now the boy I remembered was a 35-year-old man. After the talk I introduced him to friends explaining that he was in the first humane education course I ever taught, and before I could even finish my sentence he interjected, “That course changed my life!”
During the many years I’ve been a humane educator, teaching about the interconnected issues of human rights, environmental preservation and animal protection in an effort to inspire solutionaries for a better world (and now through my work training others through the Institute for Humane Education’s, www.HumaneEducation.org graduate programs, online courses, workshops and resources), I’ve received many letters from students saying the week-long course they took “will stay with me for a lifetime” and “was the most inspiring five days of my life.” But it’s not simply week-long courses. Many times, even a single 45-minute presentation has stuck. I’ve run into several teenagers who’ve told me they remember a specific activity we did or something they learned from one brief visit to their classroom years earlier.
All this is to say that teachers have a profound, life-long influence on their students even through the briefest of interactions. Virtually all of us have memories of a teacher who changed our lives. And since teachers are generally with their students not for 45 minutes or a week, but an entire year or more, that impact could (and should) be tremendous. Which means that teaching may carry both the greatest opportunity and the gravest responsibility of any profession.
There's a couplet by Rudyard Kipling that shines a sometimes too bright light on one of the biggest truths we educators must confront.
No printed word, nor spoken plea can teach young minds what they should be.
Not all the books on all the shelves – but what the teachers are themselves.
The reason why Kipling’s couplet sometimes feels too bright to me is because, too often, I fail to heed it. This is true of other educators as well. We fail our students not just when they haven’t learned what we intended to teach them, not only when we haven’t inspired the best in them and turned those light bulbs on in their eager-to-learn minds, but also when we are not the best role models for them: when we are bored, boring, or disengaged; when we are judgmental; when we listen poorly; when we do shoddy work; when we suspend our own best critical thinking; when we are lazy; when we are reactive; when we not as kind as we should have been; when we stop persevering in our own pursuit of knowledge, even when we fail to care for our bodies through good diets and exercise and thereby fail to model health and vitality.
There are few professions in which being a truly great human being and embodying the best qualities of humanity – compassion, wisdom, kindness, curiosity, generosity, courage, perseverance, and so on – is part of the job description, but teaching is one of them. Despite this call to near sainthood, teaching conveys little status and only a modest salary. And in today’s climate, it is often a thankless job requiring teaching to standardized tests in overcrowded classrooms with little room for flexibility, creativity, and innovation (all qualities that should be modeled for our children but which are being crushed by standardization).
And yet, what greater calling is there? What is more noble than this: the opportunity to make a profound, positive difference by educating the next generation in such a way that they have the embodied the best qualities of human beings and have the passion and knowledge to use their hearts, minds, and hands in their own pursuit of the unfolding of a world that is more peaceful, just, and humane through whatever professions they pursue?
We make this difference as educators each day, as long as we remember that our job goes far beyond the curricula we intend to impart. We have the capacity and the responsibility to awaken in our students their own desire to pursue goodness and greatness. While potentially daunting, while occasionally “too bright” a light on our single life, it is also the most profound opportunity we have to make of our one life such an impact; to live with such meaning; to fulfill the greatest goals we may have for ourselves, and to know that we are living our lives as richly, deeply and well as we can.
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...



12 Comments so far
Show AllUnfortunately, teaching has long been stigmatized in America as a fall back profession for those who couldn't hack it in 'the real world,' and it has only gotten worse as Tea Bagger inspired and funded politicos like Scott Walker has gone after the profession with a vengeance.
As long as culture and politics seemingly conspire to degrade and devalue this needed and vital job; I would not practice it in the USA.
Isn't it odd that the teacher that influenced me the most was someone I remember for his excitement about his subject and not someone who managed to cram the most course objectives down my throat? Because of that teacher's enthusiasm, I went on to take many more classes in that area, becoming reasonably competent in the area he taught. Nowadays, of course, in K-12 education, the teacher who crams those objectives into students gets the rewards. School is about much more than mastering objectives. It is about inspiration, too.
Excellent article that totally misses the point. The goals of education have changed Ms. Weil. Conformist consumers educated just enough to be good cogs in a corporate wheel. That's the goal.
In fact, I often almost come to tears when I think of my kids, getting fed this line that creativity and innovation are so important. I think of the corporations, some global, I've worked in. Without fail, not only do they value conformity, but being creative can actually be detrimental!
As a teacher, I would really like to see that all adults could be able to to what Weil suggests that teachers do on a daily basis. But as Kane Jeeves says, unfortunately, many resist creativity, innovation and non conformity as anathema to the current economic scheme and to public education.
What follows is something I wrote up for out new assistant superintendent when I told him I preferred to "increase student learning" after he said that his job was to provide as many resources to "raise student achievement" He stated the my "opinions" were not the same as his-at least he was willing to listen.
Opinion
view
estimation
belief
judgment
attitude
outlook
Thought
consideration
contemplation
thinking
deliberation
attention
reflection
idea (n.)
notion
brain wave
inspiration
concept
belief
theory
opinion
ideas (n.)
philosophy
thinking
notions
accepted wisdom
planning
concept
design
Opinion in common usage takes on the concept of “end of thought”-thought being the precursor to opinion. In everyday use opinion is banal, i.e., everyone has one just like they have_________(fill in the blank).
Thought connotes, as the synonyms, imply a process of thinking, actively processing sensory data to come to some conclusion as the noun form of thought implies. Thought implies a depth of cognizant awareness that opinion lacks.
And I sent him this about word usage:
Word Usage Matters in Public Education Discourse
Achievement antonym--failure
attainment
accomplishment
success
feat
triumph
realization
reaching
achievement [əˈtʃiːvmənt]
n
1. something that has been accomplished, esp by hard work, ability, or heroism
2. successful completion; accomplishment
3. (History / Heraldry) Heraldry a less common word for hatchment
Learning antonyms--ignorance, illiteracy
knowledge
education
erudition
scholarship
culture
wisdom
learn•ing
noun /ˈlərniNG/
1. The acquisition of knowledge or skills through experience, practice, or study, or by being taught
2. Knowledge acquired in this way
Learning implies an ongoing process whereas achievement implies an end goal.
Should public education be geared towards learning or achievement???
Or should public education be geared towards inquiry, critical thinking, and an appreciation of the arts and research? Or should it be even more--becoming good citizens, appreciating differences among people, understanding the seamless boundary between human beings and the world ecosystem? Learning is certainly something we should never neglect in school and, as you rightly observe, it is different from "student achievement", a bastard piece of educational jargon that denotes one's score on an achievement test. But [academic] learning is only part of what schools should do--not the whole thing.
drosera,
To answer your first two questions, yes and yes. I have argued here and elsewhere that the fundamental purpose of public education is, as exemplified in the Missouri Constitution Article IX, Section 1(a), "A general diffusion of knowledge and intelligence being essential to the preservation of the rights and liberties of the people, the general assembly shall establish and maintain free public schools for the gratuitous instruction of all persons in this state within ages not in excess of twenty-one years as prescribed by law." I assume most states' constitutions have similar wording. It says nothing about "preparing/training" students for work in the business world, the military or for the universities. And, for me, the wording of this legal authorization (at least in Missouri) of public education encompasses all that you ask about in your two questions and must include instruction on our basic rights.
OYE
Ah, the gap between goal and practice. It is rarely bridged.
Actually.... the biggest impact that a decent teacher can make in today's corporate run world, is simply to keep from getting fired by administrators of The Machine and the many many flunky teachers who back stab the few decent teachers still left out there.
I have to compliment Ms. Weil for maintaining such a high level of enthusiasm, along with equally high personal standards, over the duration of 20+ years. If this educational climate, corporately driven, hasn't killed her optimism, the woman (in my view) is close to sainthood!
Teachers are especially important as role models, when children come from dysfunctional families. According to the book, "Homecoming," by John Bradshaw, something in the order of 90% of American families are dysfunctional. Judging by the karmic blowback of war, the idea that "the sins of the father will be visited upon the sons," and mystic Edgar Cayce's spiritual view that family life operates as "the hotbed of karma," the classroom functions as the default position where children might learn not only civility, but what it means to be human. For many, homes are anything but...
In a world of endless problems, a great many of them the result of a for-profit model that's trumped all other considerations, the ideal of turning young people into "Solutionaries" is beautiful.
Thank you Zoe for keeping the faith, and working as a candle to dispel darkness in truly dim times.
I have been teaching on and off since 1956. Many teachers are great. Many do harm. How can the good ones be separated from the others???
Most schools, and therefore, most teachers consider the development of 'patriotism' as part of their mandate. Uniformed troops are invited into classrooms to act as heroes and role models. This is one reason why I now support home schooling instead of government run schools.
Unfortunately you are correct about the armed forces given pretty much free range in schools. Some of us do attempt to combat that as much as possible and try to educate the students to the insanity of our policies of death and destruction but sometimes it feels like spitting in the wind.