Get News & Views Updates
Most Popular This Week
- In Blind Poll, Republicans Choose Progressive Budget Solutions Over Their Own Party's
- Not Guilty By Virtue of Videotape, Which, Unlike the Police, Doesn't Lie
- The 'Land of 10,000 Lakes' Is Running Dry
- Manning: Before Wikileaks, Leaked Docs Offered to NYT, WaPo
- Bob Woodward Embodies US Political Culture in a Single Outburst
Popular content
Today's Top News
San Francisco Bay Area’s BART Pulls a Mubarak
What does the police killing of a homeless man in San Francisco have to do with the Arab Spring uprisings from Tunisia to Syria? The attempt to suppress the protests that followed. In our digitally networked world, the ability to communicate is increasingly viewed as a basic right. Open communication fuels revolutions—it can take down dictators. When governments fear the power of their people, they repress, intimidate and try to silence them, whether in Tahrir Square or downtown San Francisco.
Charles Blair Hill was shot and killed on the platform of the Bay Area Rapid Transit (BART) system’s Civic Center platform on July 3, by BART police officer James Crowell. BART police reportedly responded to calls about a man drinking on the underground subway platform. According to police, Hill threw a vodka bottle at the two officers and then threatened them with a knife, at which point Crowell shot him. Hill was pronounced dead at the hospital.
When governments fear the power of their people, they repress, intimidate and try to silence them, whether in Tahrir Square or downtown San Francisco. (photo: blmurch)
Hill’s killing sparked immediate and vigorous protests against the BART police, similar to those that followed the BART police killing of Oscar Grant on New Year’s Day 2009. Grant was handcuffed, facedown on a subway platform, and restrained by one officer when another shot and killed him with a point-blank shot to the back. The execution was caught on at least two cellphone videos. The shooter, BART officer Johannes Mehserle, served just over seven months in jail for the killing.
On July 11, major protests shut down the Civic Center BART station. As another planned protest neared on Aug. 11, BART officials took a measure unprecedented in U.S. history: They shut down cellphone towers in the subway system.
“It’s the first known incident that we’ve heard of where the government has shut down a cellphone network in order to prevent people from engaging in political protest,” Catherine Crump of the ACLU told me. “Cellphone networks are something we’ve all come to rely on. People use them for all sorts of communication that have nothing to do with protest. And this is really a sweeping and overbroad reaction by the police.”
The cellular-service shutdown, which was defended by BART authorities who claimed it was done to protect public safety, immediately drew fire from free-speech activists around the globe. On Twitter, those opposed to BART’s censorship started using the hashtag #muBARTak to make the link to Egypt.
When the embattled Egyptian dictator Hosni Mubarak shut down cell service and the Internet, those in Tahrir Square innovated workarounds to get the word out. An activist group called Telecomix, a volunteer organization that supports free speech and an open Internet, organized 300 dial-up phone accounts that allowed Egyptian activists and journalists to access the Internet to post tweets, photos and videos of the revolution in progress.
“We were very active—Tunisia, Egypt, Libya, Syria—trying to keep the Internet running in these countries in the face of really almost overwhelming efforts by governments to shut them down,” Telecomix activist Peter Fein told me. “Telecomix believes that the best way to support free speech and free communication is by building, by building tools that we can use to provide ourselves with those rights, rather than relying on governments to respect them.”
Expect hacktivist groups to support revolutions abroad, but also to assist protest movements here at home. In retaliation for BART’s cellphone shutdown, a decentralized hacker collective called Anonymous shut down BART’s website. In a controversial move, Anonymous also released the information of more than 2,000 BART passengers, to expose the shoddy computer security standards maintained by BART.
The BART police say the FBI is investigating Anonymous’ attack. I interviewed an Anonymous member who calls himself “Commander X” on the “Democracy Now!” news hour. His voice disguised to protect his anonymity, he told me over the phone: “We’re filled with indignation, when a little organization like BART ... kills innocent people, two or three of them in the last few years, and then has the nerve to also cut off the cellphone service and act exactly like a dictator in the Mideast. How dare they do this in the United States of America.”
Denis Moynihan contributed research to this column.
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...




13 Comments so far
Show All"''How dare they do this in the United States of America'"
They so dare BECAUSE they are in the United States of America.
q
let's all hope that von obummer doesn't pull a mubarak and start shooting citizens in the streets
i wouldn't put it past him
i feel some kind of empathy for mubarak - a loyal cia employee for 40 years abandoned in his hour of need by the americans
he worked for israel too and helped in the siege of gaza but at least they offered him safe haven
the spectacle of this 83 year old man - cancer stricken, just out of a coma, wheeled into the court on a hospital bed to proclaim his innocence - wow
man that's one for the books
makes the saaddam trial look good by comparison
i was looking in the prisoner docket for bush cheney rummy condi powell blair
where were they..........
I have no idea why peter fein was used in this interview. Hes a moron. That's the truth. How do I know?
X and I helped organize it. We would be willing to speak about it, if you are interested.. as long as our identities are protected.
Fein tekes credit for all of the heard work of others. The man is an expert con man.
Excellent story, however. It is good to see interest in this. Thank you. <3
foolish it will be to rely on electronics when the shit hits the fan...
foolish it is to do so now...
these are but temporary toys, and not necessarily yours, in the end...
to argue they are inherent rights is insane...
Dumbet- Is the constitution something to be protected? The right to free speech is a human right. What are you fighting for-if not human rights?
no, the constitution is not to be protected...it is one of our largest obstacles to true freedom...
speech and a phone are not the same thing...
speech and action are not the same thing...
what am I fighting for? a viable planet...
why would I fight for human rights that destroy my only planet?
human rights, if held at the expense of the living world, are insane...
is electricity a human 'right'?
do you realize the manufacturing and use and disposal of these phones, and all like electrophilia, is killing the living world? that this is just one industry contributing to such destruction?
is that, sort of, not really important to you?
How truly dismal: BART following in the totalitarian footsteps of Middle Eastern dictators.
O/T: Tax cuts lead to job cuts because tax cuts lead to lower government revenues and then GOPs demand program cuts to lower deficits. Program cuts cause less demand for goods and services and workers are laid off. Worked fine for Hoover, Bush 2 and Obama.
Obama campaigned as a Democrat, but once he became President, he has governed as a Republican. More tax cuts in a so-called "stimulus" bill are just poison pills, which reduce the stimulation to the economy...
"How dare they do this in the United States of America?”
hi, amy!, i enjoyed that interview with "x" because i so appreciate that people realize the importance role played by knowledge should we ever hope to find the path toward an aware, self-reliant free and democratic society. you and your on-the-ball production team and partners do an admirable job of keeping us informed. thank you, so very much!!!!!! i think it jefferson, who said something to the effect that knowledge or information is the true currency of democracy.
i noticed some poster who needs meds to make it thru the day, immediately slurred the president. i bet the okay came from city "authorities" not the oval office.
uh-oh, "x" may have given the fbi a clue. he said travels from place to place, coffee shop to coffee shop. well, were i an agent, i'd sent spies to every bay area starbucks till i found that guy wearing a silly grin on his enormous, oversized head!
Hummingbird- Your admonishment is ridiculous.
really, how so?
Wow. Hummingbird, need to get back on your meds, try to finish high school (judging by your grammar and spelling), or both. Please, both. Also, this really isn't a great forum for cheering and slavering (look that word up at dictionary.com, sweetie) over your little messiah, Obomba. You're more than welcome to, of course - free speech and all that - but not a lot of Obomba lovers on this site. Most of us here actually pay attention to things like his claiming the right to assassinate anyone on the earth, putting social security and medicare on the chopping block, etc., even if you and your Obama-worshipping ilk do not.
Just an FYI - judging by the rapidity (again: dictionary.com) with which your messiah has been shredding the Constitution these past few years on an almost daily basis, your shock over the possibility of his ordering the shutdown of a cellular service to prevent a free and legal protest is rather naive to say the least. Along with resuming your meds, I'd recommend a daily dose of truth and reality, along with a generous dose of shedding the scales over your eyes. Darned healthy regimen, hummingbird.
I am little perplexed why we are "celebrating" the acts of "hacktivists" after the act by Bart of shutting down cell service, and not demanding that our elected public officials, charged with protecting our civil rights under the constitution weigh in on the event.
What Is the Mayor saying about it, what is the Governor saying about it? What is the director of Homeland Security or the President saying about it? I don't remember media even posing the question to any of them. What they never saw this coming? They have to clear their responses with their teams of attorneys first?
Bart is a public transit system, it doesn't operate in a vaccum. There are government bodies charged with it's oversight and regulation, especially post 09/11. Why haven't we heard from them? As a citizen and consumer in this state and nation, I want to know if this is an isolated hysterical action on the part of Bart, of just the first of a further erosion of my civil rights that I will have to swallow and pay a premium for.
Kind of ironic all of these public officials and departments have twitter and facebook accounts and use them, yet public "utilities" and possibly our government now have a right to shut them down in mass on whim.