Get News & Views Updates
Most Popular This Week
- 37 Percent of People Completely Lost
- An Open Challenge to Michelle Rhee and the Corporate Education Zombies
- If Corporations Don’t Pay Taxes, Why Should You?
- Introduced Constitutional Amendment says: 'Democracy for People, Not Corporations'
- Which Members of Congress Are Standing Up for Economic Decency – And Which “Progressives” Aren’t
Popular content
Today's Top News
Sacrifice-Lite: The American Way
Post-9/11, doesn’t it seem as though all American experience is blending into a single experience whose label is “your safety”? Which means, in practical terms, you get poked, prodded, searched, and surveilled wherever you go.
The other day, I went to the ballpark to see my team, the Mets, play the Florida Marlins. It’s always a shock these days to make your way into the team’s new stadium, Citi Field (named, charmingly enough, after one of the financial institutions that took us down in 2008 and somehow came up smelling like roses). No more is it just tickets at the turnstile. What’s involved now is that peek into your backpack or bag, followed by the full-scale search of you, body wand and all.
I always have the urge to shout: I’m here for a ballgame, not the Global War on Terror! Instead, of course, I just lift my arms and let myself be wanded. It’s like an eternal reminder that, for Americans, 9/11 did change everything -- and for the more intrusive at that. Once inside, past all the restaurants and clubs, memorabilia shops and sports-clothing stores that now add up to the baseball (basemall?) experience, it turns out you haven’t left America’s wars behind.
In about the fourth inning of this particular humdrum game, only modestly attended on a Monday night, the looming Jumbotron in the outfield (where I was sitting) suddenly flashed a shot of an Iraq War veteran in the stands. Caught in the camera’s eye, he stood up to wave, bringing the sparse crowd to its feet cheering. Then, former Mets great Tom Seaver came on screen making a pitch for vets, which he concluded this way: “They’ve made their sacrifice. Now, it’s time for us to do the same.”
And then, of course, everybody sat down, went back to hotdogs and peanuts, and the game proceeded. As Andrew Bacevich, author of Washington Rules: America’s Path to Permanent War, points out in a particularly striking way in his piece “Ballpark Liturgy: America’s New Civic Religion,” it’s no mistake that pleas like Seaver’s end in mid-air on nothing whatsoever. Like the Bud Lite being sold all over that stadium, sacrifice-lite is being sold all over America when it comes to wars that most of us are almost completely detached from (until the bills start coming in). Sacrifice-lite turns out to have less body and isn’t filling, but nobody’s about to complain. Not in America.
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...




25 Comments so far
Show AllComplacency instead of critical thinking seems to be the causa sine qua non for being an American these days. Instead of going along with the program Americans would be much better off keeping in mind what Benjamin Franklin once wisely observed:
"They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety."
When the government tells its citizens here in the United States to jump [or to bend over or to be subjected to indignities and humiliation] they usually inquire of that government official- how high? instead of a resounding NO.
One would think this was common sence? but alas no I've simply given up! no more fairs, events! anywhere the American Constitution is no longer in force!, I nearly got a ticket a few nights ago walking my dog, she a good american had all her Id in order! I did,not. Because of my back I usually don't carry a wallet anymore, I did have my Co/State Id as I had just come hame from work, this I fear was insufficent. "Not my Problem I stated as I turned to walk away. Next think I know he was trying to throw me over the cars hood to lay on manicales... That didn't go so well. The long made short is the sargent decided to let me go as the officer was ashamed to be taken down by a crippled, old computer nerd.
This is getting serious, I will not submitt to this kind of treatment, noone should. I offered no violence, and certinally saw no need to be attacked by some clown with a badge! Someday wone of these civil heros I'm sure will end up shooting me dead as I stank on the firm floor of my rights. >^^<
Well said, Erroll. In particular your last paragraph - it brings immediately to mind the long lines of complacent sheep at airports, dutifully going through the body scanners or one by one waiting to be groped and pawed by the TSA thugs. Not a complaint or protest from most - ho-hum, we're conditioned to this now, no big deal.
"So this is how democracy dies - with thunderous applause." (Star Wars Episode II)
"...former Mets great Tom Seaver came on screen making a pitch for vets, which he concluded this way: 'They’ve made their sacrifice. Now, it’s time for us to do the same.'"
I do not know the full context of Mr. Seaver's remarks, but to me it sounds like he is saying that the little people in the armed forces have made their sacrifices so the plutocrats, our betters, can prosper, and now it is time for the other little people to make sacrificies, maybe including giving up their Social Security and Medicare, so that the plutocrats can further prosper. Until the plutocrats are required to make the big sacrifice, and become little people themselves, it seems foolish for the little people to make any more sacrifices.
Seaver's and others gunning for the plutocrats will find an audience fully supportive of the reverse Robin Hood model (of taking from the workers and poor and giving to the wealthy) at professional sports events where fans pay outrageous prices to further enrich the multimillionaire players and billionaire team owners.
"Sacrifice-lite turns out to have less body and isn’t filling, but nobody’s about to complain. Not in America."
Although these calls for "sacrifice" might seem boring and innocuous, they are much more insidious and malevolent than it first appears.
Just as TV commercials and product placement in movies, etc, subliminally inure the consumer into accepting his/her role as a participant in the American consumption culture, the calls for "sacrifice" are the elite's attempts to habituate American citizens to their new roles as serfs and peons.
Look at these soldiers, they kill innocent people for their fascist overlords.
They have given up their vestiges of being human beings.
What, dear citizen, is the role you will fill? What will pieces of humanity will you sacrifice for the elite?
Just as the inane/mundane creatures that inhabit reality television, where the common talentless person can rise to the level of exalted celebrity, the citizens tasked with killing innocent people abroad for the benefit of the fascist elite now can hope for their "turn in the sun" by being honored at one of the countless sporting events where their obedience in doing their master's dirty work and bidding will be full recognized and clapped at during innings and quarters.
USA!
POLY: Ultra-keen assessment. Thank you for posting your insights.
Very-good!!! let's not forget they willingly signed on to go kill or be killed, Defence of the american pocketbook never came up, They went for colege grants and a better life. If they lost, they need just buy another ticket like every other lottery! >^^<
I've found it truly discouraging to encounter overwhelming apologism for the military from liberals who often even consider themselves "pacifists," simply because the military provides an income to someone who made bad life decisions, who finds comfort in the authoritarian structure of the military, or who embraces violence and jingoistic nationalism as a point of personal pride.
"Just following orders" has been accepted as a valid excuse for almost any complicity or atrocity, as has the maudlin "just trying to support their family."
Thanks to the above posters for reminding me that some resistance to militaristic mindset still exists....
Satyrich
Well said as so many liberals feel somehow obligated to utter that banal phrase "I support the troops" which, as David Swanson points out in Chapter 7- Wars Are Not Prolonged For the Good of Soldiers, in his extremely well written book War Is a Lie, is akin to supporting mass murderers.
Swanson also points out in his book how the media will often refer to those who oppose war as being anti-war while labeling those who support the militant policies of the government as being pro-troops. What the media rarely, if ever, do is to call that particular group "pro-war." That type of honesty is something that one will not see from our patriotic, corporate media.
The question we asked during the sixties needs to be asked again: What if they had a war and nobody showed up ?
Answer: It wouldn't be much of a war, would it ?
Conclusion: The soldiers ARE THE PROBLEM.
In 1964 Buffy Sainte Marie wrote (and Donovon made a hit of) UNIVERSAL SOLDIER.
Its time to hear those lyrics again.
"Just following orders" has been accepted as a valid excuse for almost any complicity or atrocity, as has the maudlin "just trying to support their family'
No, a thousand times no...this excuse was not accepted at Nuremberg and its NOT acceptable now.....it is especailly not acceptable now. There are mechanisms which allow a soldier to refuse to follow an illegal order or better yet be ecconomically pressed into fighting in an illegal war. In so many ways the Armed Services provide the young with the same benefits as a gang....the feeling of belonging, the camaradarie, the excitment, adrenaline rushes, rights of passage etc etc. Bring them all home NOW.
A "Democracy" of Idiots
Bring back the draft and suddenly every war will end quickly. Which, of course, is why they don't bring the draft back.
Make it illegal to profit from wars and peace will break out.
They don't need a draft as long as the unemployment rate for young Americans is 25% and rapidly escalating.
Demonstorm
Perhaps you and others may be in agreement with one of my buttons which states:
Draft the Rich: It's Their War
That's nothing.
I have heard that you are at Yankees game, and don't stand up during the national anthem (or "God Bless America sung at the 7th inning stretch), or head to the aisle to find the bathroom, you are ejected from the ballpark by the ushers and security.
"Patriotism" - particularly the idolatrous USAn variant - is one of the most vile, filthy aspects of the human animal - right down there with the smell of their fucking shit. I laught out loud at the imbecility of its various expressions.
Gee, I can;t wait for that lol I quit standing when it went from the United States of America, to the United Empire of America! I they ever decide to bring back the Republic I might consider it! >^^<
I heard that too pjd, and have experienced it personally in other venues. One point: "patriotism" and "nationalism" are completely different things, and I believe what you are referring to is the latter. It is also one of the signs of a fascist state, a rabid nationalism - flag worshipping (lapel pins, bumperstickers, etc), mass participation in nation-worshipping anthems and such (like your ballpark ritual example), "God Bless America" type slogans, and so forth.
Ever notice that every President nowadays - and Obomba especially - now uses the phrase "God Bless the United States of America" at the end of EVERY public address? It is rote. It is ritual. It is enshrined Law now that this phrase MUST be invoked by all politicians every time they speak in public. It is fervent, masturbatory nationalism and it disgusts me. And you're right, pjd - be careful about not following the herd in such mass-nationalistic rituals like the national anthem. You just might find yourself ejected physically, or even beaten (I got knocked around by a crowd at a 4th of July fireworks display for not standing during the national anthem, then forced to leave).
from the article:
~ I always have the urge to shout: I’m here for a ballgame, not the Global War on Terror! Instead, of course, I just lift my arms and let myself be wanded. ~
so, is this protest-lite? the urge to shout suffices, in place of the shouting? your attendance encourages such offenses...why not stop going to the game?
what do you stand for, at all, Tom, as you raise your arms to be wanded?
the pride that flows from subjecting yourself to being wanded by your authorities, and overcharged for concessions, in return for your hard-earned money, yet finding yourself in no immediate danger of being murdered by them?
is that pride, or relief?
the pride that comes of watching dozens of millionaires meaninglessly win or lose a game, if not make blatant errors, for their incredible, fantastic salaries, and right in front of you?
is that pride, or pathetic?
when does acquiescing to increasingly invasive and pervasive security measures begin to equate to the liontamer putting his head in the lion's mouth? sure, the trick may go as planned for years, but one day, without warning, the lion simply changes his mind, and chomps...
what a sudden, and brief, awakening for the liontamer...
♪ Take me out to the ball game,
Take me out with the crowd.
Pat down my pockets and probe my butt,
Scan my eyeballs and squeeze my nuts!
Plan to root, root, root for the warlords,
Or you'll be sorry you came.
For the propaganda team's out,
At the old ball game. ♪
for the prop! a! ganda! team's out?
excellent, OS...
that, and $20, may get you a player's autograph...
wonder when a team will adopt camo as their uniform?
You two are too much!
Great tune O.S., but
Propaganda, come on, there wasn't even a fighter jet flyover.
hey dubet, the camo could catch on, but
instead of the streak of black under their eyes,
they should go with Rambo style full face grease paint.
If things continue,
they might really start killing the umpires,
even the blind ones.
Didn't I see this article on CD a week or so ago, maybe slightly more filled out?