Get News & Views Updates
Most Popular This Week
- Wealthiest Kissed, Weakest Kicked: Obama's Ugly 'New Deal' Offers to Cut Social Security
- What If All the World’s Debt Just Went Away
- Bolivia's Morales Calls for New Era of 'Peace and Unity' to Break Greed of Capitalism
- Sen. Bernie Sanders: 'Mr. President, I am Disappointed'
- Gun Lobby Speaks: We Need More Guns, Especially in Schools
- Wealthiest Kissed, Weakest Kicked: Obama's Ugly 'New Deal' Offers to Cut Social Security
- Bolivia's Morales Calls for New Era of 'Peace and Unity' to Break Greed of Capitalism
- Remember All the Children, Mr. President
- What If All the World’s Debt Just Went Away
- 8 Deficit Reducers That Are More Ethical—And More Effective—Than the 'Chained CPI'
Popular content
Today's Top News
Cairo in Wisconsin: Eating Egyptian Pizza in Downtown Madison
The call reportedly arrived from Cairo. Pizza for the protesters, the voice said. It was Saturday, February 20th, and by then Ian's Pizza on State Street in Madison, Wisconsin, was overwhelmed. One employee had been assigned the sole task of answering the phone and taking down orders. And in they came, from all 50 states and the District of Columbia, from Morocco, Haiti, Turkey, Belgium, Uganda, China, New Zealand, and even a research station in Antarctica. More than 50 countries around the globe. Ian's couldn't make pizza fast enough, and the generosity of distant strangers with credit cards was paying for it all.
Those pizzas, of course, were heading for the Wisconsin state capitol, an elegant domed structure at the heart of this Midwestern college town. For nearly two weeks, tens of thousands of raucous, sleepless, grizzled, energized protesters have called the stately capitol building their home. As the police moved in to clear it out on Sunday afternoon, it was still the pulsing heart of the largest labor protest in my lifetime, the focal point of rallies and concerts against a politically-charged piece of legislation proposed by Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker, a hard-right Republican. That bill, officially known as the Special Session Senate Bill 11, would, among other things, eliminate collective bargaining rights for most of the state's public-sector unions, in effect eviscerating the unions themselves.
"Kill the bill!" the protesters chant en masse, day after day, while the drums pound and cowbells clang. "What's disgusting? Union busting!"
One World, One Pain
The spark for Wisconsin's protests came on February 11th. That was the day the Associated Press published a brief story quoting Walker as saying he would call in the National Guard to crack down on unruly workers upset that their bargaining rights were being stripped away. Labor and other left-leaning groups seized on Walker's incendiary threat, and within a week there were close to 70,000 protesters filling the streets of Madison.
Six thousand miles away, February 11th was an even more momentous day. Weary but jubilant protesters on the streets of Cairo, Alexandria, and other Egyptian cities celebrated the toppling of Hosni Mubarak, the autocrat who had ruled over them for more than 30 years and amassed billions in wealth at their expense. "We have brought down the regime," cheered the protesters in Cairo's Tahrir Square, the center of the Egyptian uprising. In calendar terms, the demonstrations in Wisconsin, you could say, picked up right where the Egyptians left off.
I arrived in Madison several days into the protests. I've watched the crowds swell, nearly all of those arriving -- and some just not leaving -- united against Governor Walker's "budget repair bill." I've interviewed protesters young and old, union members and grassroots organizers, students and teachers, children and retirees. I've huddled with labor leaders in their Madison "war rooms," and sat through the governor's press conferences. I've slept on the cold, stone floor of the Wisconsin state capitol (twice). Believe me, the spirit of Cairo is here. The air is charged with it.
It was strongest inside the Capitol. A previously seldom-visited building had been miraculously transformed into a genuine living, breathing community. There was a medic station, child day care, a food court, sleeping quarters, hundreds of signs and banners, live music, and a sense of camaraderie and purpose you'd struggle to find in most American cities, possibly anywhere else in this country. Like Cairo's Tahrir Square in the weeks of the Egyptian uprising, most of what happens inside the Capitol's walls is protest.
Egypt is a presence here in all sorts of obvious ways, as well as ways harder to put your finger on. The walls of the capital, to take one example, offer regular reminders of Egypt's feat. I saw, for instance, multiple copies of that famous photo on Facebook of an Egyptian man, his face half-obscured, holding a sign that reads: "EGYPT Supports Wisconsin Workers: One World, One Pain." The picture is all the more striking for what's going on around the man with the sign: a sea of cheering demonstrators are waving Egyptian flags, hands held aloft. The man, however, faces in the opposite direction, as if showing support for brethren halfway around the world was important enough to break away from the historic celebrations erupting around him.
Similarly, I've seen multiple copies of a statement by Kamal Abbas, the general coordinator for Egypt's Center for Trade Unions and Workers Services, taped to the walls of the state capitol. Not long after Egypt's January Revolution triumphed and Wisconsin's protests began, Abbas announced his group's support for the Wisconsin labor protesters in a page-long declaration that said in part: "We want you to know that we stand on your side. Stand firm and don't waiver. Don't give up on your rights. Victory always belongs to the people who stand firm and demand their just rights."
Then there's the role of organized labor more generally. After all, widespread strikes coordinated by labor unions shut down Egyptian government agencies and increased the pressure on Mubarak to relinquish power. While we haven't seen similar strikes yet here in Madison -- though there's talk of a general strike if Walker's bill somehow passes -- there's no underestimating the role of labor unions like the AFL-CIO, the Service Employees International Union (SEIU), the American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees, and the American Federation of Teachers in organizing the events of the past two weeks.
Faced with a bill that could all but wipe out unions in historically labor-friendly states across the Midwest, labor leaders knew they had to act -- and quickly. "Our very labor movement is at stake," Stephanie Bloomingdale, secretary-treasurer of Wisconsin's AFL-CIO branch, told me. "And when that's at stake, the economic security of Americans is at stake.”
“The Mubarak of the Midwest”
On the Sunday after I arrived, I was wandering the halls of the Capitol when I met Scott Graham, a third-grade teacher who lives in Lacrosse, Wisconsin. Over the cheers of the crowd, I asked Graham whether he saw a connection between the events in Egypt and those here in Wisconsin. His response caught the mood of the moment. "Watching Egypt's story for a week or two very intently, I was inspired by the Egyptian people, you know, striving for their own self-determination and democracy in their country," Graham told me. "I was very inspired by that. And when I got here I sensed that everyone's in it together. The sense of solidarity is just amazing."
A few days later, I stood outside the capitol building in the frigid cold and talked about Egypt with two local teachers. The most obvious connection between Egypt and Wisconsin was the role and power of young people, said Ann Wachter, a federal employee who joined our conversation when she overheard me mention Egypt. There, it was tech-savvy young people who helped keep the protests alive and the same, she said, applied in Madison. "You go in there everyday and it's the youth that carries it throughout hours that we're working, or we're running our errands, whatever we do. They do whatever they do as young people to keep it alive. After all, I'm at the end of my working career; it's their future."
And of course, let’s not forget those almost omnipresent signs that link the young governor of Wisconsin to the aging Hosni Mubarak. They typically label Walker the "Mubarak of the Midwest" or "Mini-Mubarak," or demand the recall of "Scott 'Mubarak.'" In a public talk on Thursday night, journalist Amy Goodman quipped, "Walker would be wise to negotiate. It's not a good season for tyrants."
One protester I saw on Thursday hoisted aloft a "No Union Busting!" sign with a black shoe perched atop it, the heel facing forward -- a severe sign of disrespect that Egyptian protesters directed at Mubarak and a symbol that, before the recent American TV blitz of “rage and revolution” in the Middle East, would have had little meaning here.
Which isn't to say that the Egypt-Wisconsin comparison is a perfect one. Hardly. After all, the Egyptian demonstrators massed in hopes of a new and quite different world; the American ones, no matter the celebratory and energized air in Madison, are essentially negotiating loss (of pensions and health-care benefits, if not collective bargaining rights). The historic demonstrations in Madison have been nothing if not peaceful. On Saturday, when as many as 100,000 people descended on Madison to protest Walker's bill, the largest turnout so far, not a single arrest was made. In Egypt, by contrast, the protests were plenty bloody, with more than 300 deaths during the 29-day uprising.
Not that some observers didn't see the need for violence in Madison. Last Saturday, Jeff Cox, a deputy attorney general in Indiana, suggested on his Twitter account that police "use live ammunition" on the protesters occupying the state Capitol. That sentiment, discovered by a colleague of mine, led to an outcry. The story broke on Wednesday morning; by Wednesday afternoon Cox had been fired.
New York Times columnist David Brooks was typical of mainstream coverage and punditry in quickly dismissing any connection between Egypt (or Tunisia) and Wisconsin. On the Daily Show, Jon Stewart spoofed and rejected the notion that the Wisconsin protests had any meaningful connection to Egypt. He called the people gathered here "the bizarro Tea Party." Stewart's crew even brought in a camel as a prop. Those of us in Madison watched as Stewart's skit went horribly wrong when the camel got entangled in a barricade and fell to the ground.
As far as I know, neither Brooks nor Stewart spent time here. Still, you can count on one thing: if the demonstrators in Tahrir Square had been enthusiastically citing Americans as models for their protest, nobody here would have been in such a dismissive or mocking mood. In other parts of this country, perhaps it still feels less than comfortable to credit Egyptians or Arabs with inspiring an American movement for justice. If you had been here in Madison, this last week, you might have felt differently.
Pizza Town Protest
Obviously, the outcomes in Egypt and Wisconsin won’t be comparable. Egypt toppled a dictator; Wisconsin has a democratically elected governor who, at the very earliest, can't be recalled until 2012. And so the protests in Wisconsin are unlikely to transform the world around us. Still, there can be no question, as they spread elsewhere in the Midwest, that they have reenergized the country's stagnant labor movement, a once-powerful player in American politics and business that's now a shell of its former self. "There's such energy right now," one SEIU staffer told me a few nights ago. "This is a magic moment."
Not long after talking with her, I trudged back to Ian's Pizza, the icy snow crunching under my feet. At the door stood an employee with tired eyes, a distinct five o'clock shadow, and a beanie on his head.
I wanted to ask him, I said, about that reported call from Cairo. "You know,” he responded, “I really don't remember it." I waited while he politely rebuffed several approaching customers, telling them how Ian's had run out of dough and how, in any case, all the store’s existing orders were bound for the capitol. When he finally had a free moment, he returned to the Cairo order. There had, he said, been questions about whether it was authentic or not, and then he added, "I'm pretty sure it was from Cairo, but it's not like I can guarantee it." By then, another wave of soon-to-be disappointed customers was upon us, and so I headed back to the capitol and another semi-sleepless night.
The building, as I approached in the darkness, was brightly lit, reaching high over the city. Protestors were still filing inside with all the usual signs. In the rotunda, drums pounded and people chanted and the sound swirled into a massive roar. For this brief moment at least, people here in Madison are bound together by a single cause, as other protesters were not so long ago, and may be again, in the ancient cities of Egypt.
Right then, the distance separating Cairo and Wisconsin couldn’t have felt smaller. But maybe you had to be there.
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...


14 Comments so far
Show Allhttp://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/02/27/that-iraq-feeling/
A short little piece by Krugman calling the media blackout of the protests in Wisconsin comparable to the media blackouts of the of the Iraq war protests, and refers to both situations as being spooky.
My respect has gone way up for Mr Krugman over his recent writings. I suspect we will probably see less of him on the Sunday morning bobble head talk shows. He is getting outside the views that are allowed on M$M.
All my life I have been hearing "It Can't Happen here!" "people are too apathetic to rise up!"
Madison, WI, (right here for me) is a city of less than 250,000 people
Saturday, depending on which report you read, 100-150,000 people rose up in 15 degree (F) weather and snow!
It is not that "people are too apathetic to rise up." We have proven that. Now, if you are anywhere other than Madison right now, it is your turn!
(Don't worry, we'll still be at it till Walker and his Lt Governor step down at this point.)
Jon Stewart is a heavy-hitting Zionist supporter of Israel's barbarism against the Palestinians. He does not dare allow any Arab to look good, so he ridicules comparisons between Egypt and Madison. He's disgusting.
Please bear with me and understand that I am thankful to see the people in Wisconsin rising up in protest, but
there is a greater problem inadvertently highlighted by these protests.
Bill Clinton is credited with once saying, "It's the economy, stupid."
This belief underlies most of the prioritizing by voters in the United States of Global Domination. Obama would call it being "pragmatic" and the majority of voters seemed to think this added credibility to Obama's campaign.
So much so, that the majority of voters willingly overlooked and continue to overlook actions which are much more insidious and degrading. The majority of us are willing to protest when we feel financially threatened and abused, and, in its own, shortsighted way, this is good.
The more dangerous aspect that these protests illustrate however is that there was little or no protesting when candidate Obama blatantly lied and then voted against the Bill of Rights along with his com"patriots" in the ruling class. If you aren't sure as to what I am referring to, THAT is another indicator of degeneracy.
The recent re-endorsing of the so-called "Patriot Act" is another example of the further dis-emboweling of the Constitution.
I suspect that the majority of those protesting now CHOSE to disregard the attack on their Constitutional Rights because they thought that they would benefit economically.
Protests such as these should have been happening at every event where Obama-Biden and McCain-Palin appeared. Both of these campaigns and their fellow established conspirators in corporate sabotage and deceit were and are much, much, much greater threats to fundamental rights which are beyond economic value.
We have been brainwashed into believing that the monetary effect is of the utmost importance. This must be a lie or we are of no more value than the money we adore.
Money is a means to comfort, but is that comfort worth your humanity?
So, yes, stand your ground, people of Wisconsin (and elsewhere), but PLEASE see that the decency which you are demanding is actually less than that which you have already willingly surrendered.
Our struggle must be much greater than economic.
The purpose of the program by the ruling class is economic. Fighting back on economic issues gets to the root of the problems.
The people in power are not starting wars, suppressing civil rights, and destroying the environment to advance an ideology they are doing it for wealth and to protect the system that is making them wealthy.
You have this exactly backward when you imagine that economics is a small subset of the struggle. All of the things you are talking about are subsets of the economic struggle.
The way you have portrayed the issue absolutely insures that the general public would never rally behind you. You are placing effects above causes, and that makes people suspicious that your complaint is with the effects and not with the causes. That thinking supports the ruling class and is shared by many liberals and progressives. They want to keep the system in place, while being against the inevitable effects of that system. The ruling class would much rather fight us on the grounds you tell us we must fight, because they will win that fight.
"Two Americas"
I do not separate one from the other.
My point is that the attack on the Constitution and civil rights is and has been accepted as necessary by the majority of people and they do not make the connection to their own lives - until it blatantly grabs their wallets and purses.
The voters have been building their own slave-house by not holding these greedy whores accountable for blatantly traitorous actions in the name of greed.
Yes, it is greed which is behind it all. THAT is my point.
It is behind it ALL.
I do not expect anyone would "rally" behind my assessment and you are merely proving how well the brainwashing has worked.
I don't think you read what I wrote very carefully.
It is not greed, but rather power that motivates people. In this system, money gives one power over another.
I do not agree that the working class people are to blame for their own misery. I do not agree that "they" are too stupid to make the proper connections, the proper connections according to you.
You write "the majority of voters willingly overlooked and continue to overlook actions which are much more insidious and degrading. The majority of us are willing to protest when we feel financially threatened and abused, and, in its own, shortsighted way, this is good."
I am disagreeing with that analysis. I don't believe you have defended it. I am saying that the other things that you think are more important than economics, and that people should have been protesting, are not more important. The main program of the opposition is to exploit people, and Obama's various actions and policies are for the purpose of advancing that goal. It is not the other way around as you suggest.
Financial harm is the main problem, and fighting back against that is the most important way to fight back.
Besides, this is a different type of action then the ones you think people should have been protesting. Those other protests were about self-expression - "speaking truth to power" and hoping that this would somehow influence policy. That will never be effective, and it was not. It will never attract large support, and for good reason.
This action in Madison is infinitely more powerful than the things you think we should be protesting. It is more radical. It is more sophisticated and intelligent. It is better targeted. It has a much more solid foundation.
"Two Americas"
You insist and you impugn that I am wrong.
So be it.
You have my sympathy.
We disagree, that's all.
I'm very disgusted with Jon Stewart, I used to enjoy his show but this is the last straw. He had made other comments a few months ago that were also very disappointing and disturbing, equating far right wingers with liberals and progressives. I guess now that he's a multi-millionaire he doesn't give a f**k, as he would say, about ordinary working people. Doesn't he belong to a union himself?
What Jon Stewart and Mark Kelley (see Disconnect) ignore is that labour was a component of the Egyptian revolution. The revolution was won, in part, because labour joined the protest - that, despite the fact that the Egyptian Military was trying to tell them not to strike, the Egyptian works went on strike em mass.
Disconnect
http://www.cbc.ca/video/#/News/TV_Shows/Connect_with_Mark_Kelley/1305591601/ID=1804012174
Kelley omits that Mubarak, like Walker is, was a puppet to larger financial interests.
Wisconsin will soon have to return the favour - Tunsia and Egypt need food to the refugees from Libya - and they need it soon.
What an irony we have to read about pizza eating in the middle of fighting to hold on to the last vestiges of the identity of labor unions. It's bad enough that most younger Americans know nothing about labor unions. A typical youngster telling me that labor unions will help them enjoy more pizza and macaroni and cheese is very disturbing ! Ask them about child labor laws and they're clueless. Efforts to undermine and get rid of unions and labor laws that kept this country's economy from skidding and crashing as often appear to be paying off.
The pizzas were all about solidarity. I think it may spark interest to ask why the Egyptians and people from many countries all over the world sent pizzas to the Wisconsin protesters. I believe that people all over the world see resistance to policies like Walker's is important to their own struggles. I happen to agree with them.
For example, surveys show that more than half of the people in the US favor withdrawing from Afghanistan right now and more than 70% want to speed up withdrawal. The majority favor the right to organize and engage in collective bargaining. There is increasing understanding of the role of Wall Street and its enablers in the regulatory bodies for creating the economic collapse that has injured so many and has created the local budget problems in cities and states. It is not Miss Peach, the union teacher, who caused the looting of the economy and the transfer of funds to the rich, but Summers, Geithner, Volker, Phil Gramm, Bernanke, Hank Paulson, Rubin, Bill Clinton and now the Obama administration,
But US public opinion is not influential in US policy. The problem is that we do not have democracy here, and whenever we fight for it, the whole world benefits.
Cairo, Illinois?