Get News & Views Updates
Most Popular This Week
- A Culture That Condones The Killing Of Children And Teaches Children To Kill
- Slaughter in Connecticut: 20 Children, 6 Adults Dead in Kindergarten Massacre
- How the Mighty (Mississippi) Has Fallen: Historic Drought Plagues US
- 'I'd Rather Fight Like Hell': Naomi Klein's Fierce New Resolve to Fight for Climate Justice
- Study: World's Mighty Giants Dying off at Alarming Rate
- A Culture That Condones The Killing Of Children And Teaches Children To Kill
- 'I'd Rather Fight Like Hell': Naomi Klein's Fierce New Resolve to Fight for Climate Justice
- Remember All the Children, Mr. President
- Save the Children: Tears and Tragedy in Connecticut
- Thinking the Unthinkable: On Mental Health, My Son, and Gun Violence
Popular content
Today's Top News
Mourning Iraqi Wives, Children on Valentine’s Day
Twenty years ago, as Americans were celebrating Valentine’s Day, Iraqi husbands and fathers in the Amiriyah section of Baghdad were peeling the remains of their wives and children off the walls and floor of a large neighborhood bomb shelter.
The men had left the shelter the evening before, so their wives would have some measure of privacy as they sought refuge from the U.S.-led coalition bombing campaign, which was at its most intense pre-ground-war stage.
All of the more than 400 women and children were incinerated or boiled to death at 4:30 a.m. on Feb. 13, 1991, when two F-117 stealth fighter-bombers each dropped a 2,000-pound laser-guided “smart bomb” on the civilian shelter at Amiriyah.
It was one of those highly accurate “surgical strikes.” The first bomb sliced through 10 feet of reinforced concrete before a time-delayed fuse exploded, destroying propane and water tanks for heating water and food.
Minutes later the second bomb flew precisely through the opening that had been cut by the first and exploded deeper in the shelter creating an inferno. Fire rose from the lower level to the area where the women and children were seeking shelter – and so did the boiling water. Those who did not burn to death immediately or die from the bombs’ impact were boiled or steamed to death in the intense heat.
The bombs hit toward the end of a month-long bombing campaign to “soften up” Iraq before the U.S.-led ground invasion to drive Iraqi troops from Kuwait deep into Iraq. The aerial bombing had begun on Jan. 17, 1991; the coalition flew over 100,000 sorties, dropping 88,500 tons of bombs. U.S. government documents show that the bombs were targeted on civilian as well as military infrastructure. They were very accurate.
This is not to suggest that the targeters knew that some 400 women and children would be killed at Amiriyah. No, it was just one of those unfortunate mistakes to which many Americans have become accustomed, even inured – whether the unintended-but-nevertheless-dead victims be in Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Yemen, wherever.
Indeed, the stealth aircraft and the ordnance were a proud paragon of precision performing their mission. How was the Air Force to know that the targeting information was based on spurious “intelligence” reports that the shelter had become a military command site?
Actually, U.S. Brigadier General Buster Glosson, who had overall responsibility for targeting, later commented that the “intelligence” pointing to military use was not “worth a sh_t.”
Human Rights Watch noted later in 1991:
“It is now well established, through interviews with neighborhood residents, that the Amiriyah structure was plainly marked as a public shelter and was used throughout the air war by large numbers of civilians.”
A BBC correspondent, Jeremy Bowen, was among the first TV reporters to arrive on the scene. He was given access to the site and found no evidence of military use. The Pentagon later admitted that it had known that “the Amiriyah facility had been used as a civil-defense shelter during the Iraq-Iran war” from 1980 to 1988.
So who was held responsible for this horrible “mistake”? Are you kidding? What planet did you say you were from?
A Time to Witness
In “Death of a Salesman,” Arthur Miller puts the following words into the mouth of Willy Loman’s wife, Linda — words that I believe also apply to the “small” people huddled that night in the shelter in Amiriyah:
“I don't say he's a great man. … But he's a human being, and a terrible thing is happening to him. So attention must be paid. He's not to be allowed to fall in his grave like an old dog. Attention, attention must finally be paid to such a person.”
This imperative was brought home to me when my friend Art Laffin of the Dorothy Day Catholic Worker in Washington, DC, called me on Feb. 12, 2003, as a fresh wave of “coalition” attacks on Iraq loomed. Art had visited the huge underground coffin at Amiriyah. He said: “I was there, Ray; I saw it; I talked to the men.”
Art told me of a memorial liturgy to be held in front of the White House the next day, marking the 12th anniversary of the precision bombing at Amiriyah, lest the massacre be forgotten.
“You should come with us,” said Art in his soft-spoken but prophetically challenging way.
“But I am planning to write the kind of op-ed that might inform enough people about the lies upon which a new war on Iraq would be launched that the juggernaut might be stopped,” thought I to myself. “If people only knew the truth. …”
Then Linda Loman’s words started ringing in my ears — or perhaps they were coming from somewhere else — maybe a voice emerging out of my deep respect for the likes of Dorothy Day and Art Laffin. “Attention, attention must be finally paid.”
So there we stood marking the day, and praying that somehow future days like it could be avoided. The wind-chill factor was well below zero, so there was some solace to being put in the paddy wagon. It was my first arrest and (brief) imprisonment.
And it was exhilarating. I may be biased, given the experience of this first arrest, but if you are going to risk arrest via non-violent civil disobedience, you can’t have steadier, more prophetic companions than those of the Catholic Worker.
When we went to court for trial the new war had already begun. To our surprise, the judge announced that the arresting officer had not appeared and, thus, we were free to go. I rushed to get out the door, thinking the officer might still get there.
But Art blocked my way, turned to the judge, and asked if she would allow him to explain what we were doing on Feb. 13, 2003, and why. The crowded courtroom listened intently as Art held forth for about five minutes.
“Let’s have some coffee,” said Art as he caught up to me running down the street away from the courthouse. “Have you been able to reflect on what just happened? Do you remember how that African-American woman police officer was listening to us as we shared our hopes in the paddy wagon? Do you think she wanted her son to be recruited to serve in Iraq?
“Do you think, Ray, that non-violent civil disobedience could be contagious?”
A day or two later, a short passage in Luke’s gospel leaped out at me. Jesus of Nazareth is warning fledgling “Catholic workers” about what to expect if they remain faithful:
“Countries will fight each other … there will be terrifying things coming from the sky. Before all these things take place, however, you will be arrested and persecuted; you will be handed over to be tried … you will be brought before kings and rulers for my sake … Stand firm …
“This will be your chance to tell the Good News.”
Duh! My big chance to tell the Good News, and I’m running for the door. I was even more grateful that Art was big enough to block that door and courageous enough not to pass up this golden chance to witness — and to remind me, as well as the others, what witness is all about.
I’ve matured to the point where witnessing and risking arrest comes more naturally … and has become even more exhilarating. On the very snowy day of Dec. 16, 2010, when 131 witnesses against war were arrested at the White House gates at a rally arranged by Veterans for Peace, 42 of us insisted on standing trial.
The authorities, though, quickly lost their appetite for trying the likes of us, most of whom have defended our country and its constitutional guarantees of freedom of speech and assembly, for “failure to obey a lawful order,” i.e. not moving, after being ordered not to remain stationary on the sidewalk in front of the White House.
The “paperwork” on us 42 had been misplaced, we were told.
As we celebrate this year’s Valentine’s Day and other holidays that stress love and peace, let’s keep in mind that more painful anniversaries must also be marked; they must be witnessed to; attention must be paid the plight of “small” people still further diminished by the euphemism “collateral damage.”
This article originally appeared at Consortiumnews.com.
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...


15 Comments so far
Show AllA report recently published showed "Overall, 4.8 percent (11 million people) suffered serious mental illness, 8.4 million people had serious thoughts of suicide, 2.2 million made suicide plans, and one million attempted suicide, according to the 2009 National Survey on Drug Use and Health."
The weight of the blood of the innocent victims of the Empire is too heavy to carry around. Amerikans don't know it. They're completely oblivious to the bloodshed perpetrated in their names and with their money; however, they are paying the price unconsciously and the above proves it. Similar things are reported in Israel and are being attributed to the price the population has to pay for the brutality of the occupation. On the surface, it may seem that the populations of brutal forces such as the US and Israel are untouched by these tragedies, however, living among the lot and/or digging into their collective psyche shows a much different picture.
RB,
Well stated.
You’ve hit a nerve, Reverend. The US population is in an odd place. Bits of news of constant killings, little drone mistakes killing Muslims over there, somewhere, blip through the TV screen. The people aren’t sure what the wars are about, why they continue on, but they don’t question it. They dare not question it—no price is too great for the cause. Meanwhile, they are being told that there is no money—their states are facing bankruptcy, and they must pay. They must pay for the future of their children. After losing their 401-Ks, pensionless, they look forward to what they are told are necessary cuts in their Social Security. Social programs must be cut. Their children’s prospects look bleak; their sons and daughters are considering the military as their best option, and they have no alternatives to answer with.
How to make sense of it all? The media tells them that their leaders are keeping us safe, so there must be a great deal to fear. There is a great deal to be afraid of—unemployment, an illness that means bankruptcy, an unsecured future. And whenever there is a great deal to fear, there is a great deal of hatred, and that hatred is bent toward those very people they hear we are constantly killing. Not toward a MIC gone mad, not toward the corporations who have abandoned the US workforce and poisoned the earth, but toward the victims. Not just the victims of our wars, but the victims here as well—the uninsured sick, the unemployed, the powerless. These, they are told, are the problem.
Bits of news comes through the TV screens about the banks, but the people don’t understand banking. They are told that it was necessary to save the banks. They’re not sure why.
Perhaps, underneath the fuzzy understanding of their political lives, explained to them in ways that leave the dots disconnected, is a subliminal understanding of the complicity of lies and half-truths spilling out from the media which hide the fascism we live under and the horror our military is inflicting. Perhaps the coarsening of the US mind—through reality shows celebrating moronic behavior, through war video games and movies, through propaganda masquerading as education—fails to inure a significant minority. Perhaps for some, the nonsense of it all is too much to endure. And as you say, the burden of all the senseless killing is too much to endure.
Some of us see that it is a ruse, an Orwellian world where fascism is called democracy and innocent victims are called the enemy. It is hard to know. And hard to know how to act. Ray McGovern points to a way.
superlative scholium, 'elizabeth h'... as poignant as it is impressive in its sober, accurate portrayal of the dystopia the US has become over the past 2 centuries. fortunately, we live in cambodia.
Elizabeth:
You have gone into a much deeper analysis than mine and what you describe is the condition known as Empire or, more specifically, the last phase of empire when the forces start to run out of room abroad and turn inward, imposing on their populace the same horrors that they have imposed on others for hundreds of years. This is the truly ugly part! Chris Hedges describes this well in his "Empire of Illusions" essay. If you read the history of the Roman Empire, you can clearly see it there too. Amerikans, of course, are too stupid albeit too 'exceptional' to realize what is happening to them much less grapple with the ugly reality so they turn to something they're comfortable with: violence and hatred while telling themselves that the economy is getting better and, soon, they'll be able to shop till they drop again. The citizens (mini-versions of their empire) bestow on each other the same kind of treatment they have bestowed upon others since their creation back in 1621 from the Injuns to the Muslems. This, in a way, is Karma and payback is a bitch!
our family of 9 [parents+7 children] were regnant in jordan, first in amman, then in ferdous, on an IUCN contract, from 1988~1991 to prepare jordan's NES [national conservation strategy]. this coincided w/ the palestinian's first 'intifadah', which was mendaciously reported upon in the western mainstream press. it also coincided w/ the vicious US-led bombing campaign over iraq that deliberately targeted civilians as if they were the phantom 'weapons of mass destruction' the determined bush thugs vowed were extant. we were eventually evacuated to cyprus, but not before we wept and ululated w/ despair over the loss of an entire family, save the father, who had become our friends at the al-khalidi hospital in amman where our 7th child was birthed. our friends' father had accepted a one-year teaching sabbatical at the u.of baghdad's medical school, and moved his wife and 5 young children, ages 3~11, to baghdad w/ him. when the malevolent, savage, inhumane US bombing sorties began raining down on the helpless civilians to 'soften them up', our obstetrician friend herded his family into the el-amiriyah bomb shelter every night at dusk [male adults were proscribed from the shelter due to egregious space constraints]. needless to convey, his wife and 5 children were incinerated by those vaunted US 'smart bombs', ignescently ustulated and melted into a pool of flesh beyond recognition that made it impossible for him to identify them. this father was destroyed. his mind was so twisted, so deranged, he was never able to practice medicine again; he was rendered dysfunctional, which was an egregious loss to not only the medical profession, but also to humanity and those for whom he so selflessly cared.
Thank you for sharing this personal and horrific story. The folks on this site and all Americans need to be exposed to the personal horror that they fund everyday.
you're welcome, velvetmonkeywrench. your latter observation is an entreaty we must divulgate, but how to do so w/ efficacy, dispatch, and maximum impact bedevils me.
velvetmonkeywrench,
God, do I love that screen name. A parody on the empire's Iron Hammer wrapped in a Velvet Glove....
Or something like that.
Having been in this war, it is my considered opinion that torture and civilian slaughter are probably present in all wars. One of the Desert Storm motto's of the forward air attack base was: "I'd fly 10,000 miles to smoke a Camel". T-shirts with this slogan were on sale showing a civilian fleeing on a Camel with an armed F-111 swooping in inches behind him in Sept 90'. In other words: it doesn't matter who you shoot over there: "GET SOME". And the buzz I heard was that after they dropped their bombs on the assigned surgical sight; fighter pilots were considering nailing anything that moved on the refugee road to Syria; called "targets of opportunity". And all it took for that to happen is have one freaking military truck or tank in a line of thousands of civilians trying to escape Bagdad.
Let's face it. This slaughter of civilians wasn't likely a mistake.
Armies always kill civilians for sport. They ALWAYS do.
How else do we explain that 70 million killed in WW II were mostly civilians. I think something like only Nine million soldiers bought it. To the best of my memory.
How else do we explain the recently documented civilian genocide under the bridges in Korea? How else do we explain whole villages being burned and shelled in Vietnam?
It's a military culture of state-sanctioned slaughter/torture of civilians and I'm tired of paying for it.
It is dishonorable, and beneath contempt (no matter who orders it.) Drones are dishonorable too, imho.
Most of the colonial constitutions prior to the United States declaring Independence included the phrase: "And as standing Armies are Dangerous to Liberty; the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed."
That part didn't get left out until 1787.
Even George Washington pledged to the Continental Congress that he would "disband the [Boston] Army at the end of the war; as there is nothing more dangerous to free peoples everywhere as a large standing army." - paraphrasing.
Source: "1776" by historian David McCullough
TJ
"No nation can preserve its freedoms in a state of continuous war" - James Madison
as you exhort, 'thomas jefferson'... war is sanctioned murder, just as taxes are sanctioned theft, a standing military is sanctioned mind-control, public education is sanctioned brainwashing, politics is sanctioned duplicity, spy agencies are sanctioned antinomianism, religion is sanctioned delusion, and marriage is sanctioned copulation. our benighted species needs none of it
Thank you for this story of great tragedy.
And so it goes, but greed, wealth and power for the Oligarchy increases and they consider that all is well with the world.
There is no care at that level for any human being, individually or as a people. To them, we are serfs, or if not already so, we should be. To them, that is the natural order of things. "You can't make an omelet without breaking the eggs" carried to the nth degree.
so true, 'minitrue'... we individuals, oft-viewed as serfs by the rapacious global oligarchy, have no value beyond our contributions to the tax base and our 'skills as needed' and often not even these are of any consequence, because the power-mongers can always replace us w/ others sporting similar skills. as with our family's palestinian friends so dispiteously ignited, so cavalierly liquidated by lethal USAF hotdoggers ionized by misguided hate and zealotry, and whose depredations have been funded by us, we do not have a scintilla of control over these purveyors of death and despoliation. the only solution is to organize a national tax revolt. however, in order to gain maximum benefit, 50% of all US taxpayers would have to agree so there would not be sufficient cell space in our prisons to accommodate such numbers; we antinomianist tax recusants would overwhelm the heinous US incarceration systems..... but i am not optimistic. we posted hundreds of letters from jordan, to govt. agencies, the press and other news outlets in north america, throughout 1990 when daddy bush was pounding his war drums and 1991 when he launched his joy-sticking kill-brigades. our letters either went unread or were dismissively lobbed into the nearest trash-tip. w/ the election of obama in 2008, i sensed the social and political zeitgeist was transforming. alas, my premonition proved naught but pollyanna fantasizing; the zeitgist has transmogrified into a toxic 'tea party' hosted by the likes of gormless glenn beck, sarah pain-in-the-rear, bumptious bill o'reilly, raging rush limbaugh, and the anal shrew ann coulter. from what source does all their lambasting vitriol and subreptitious villifying derive? such unalloyed dyspepsia and unbridled mean-spiritedness in the right-wing msm defies understanding.
What an intense, horrific story. The American people need to be aware of what their tax dollars regularly subsidize.
Thanks for the great article. Most members of the Press get it wrong - and report that the war started in 2003. We have been bombing the children and other civilians in Iraq since 1991. Some estimates of the dead are as high as 3 MILLION. And we wonder why they hate us.
I, too, was arrested for opposing the war. A 15 minute protest led to an arrest and a 4 year legal battle. Only in the USA............