EMAIL SIGN UP!
Most Popular This Week
- Corporate Win: Supreme Court Says Monsanto Has 'Control Over Product of Life'
- Cornel West: Obama 'Is a War Criminal'
- Patent Filing Claims Solar Energy ‘Breakthrough’
- Disaster Capitalism Strikes as Hedge Funds Circle Near-Bankrupt Municipalities Like Vultures
- Ignoring Bee Crisis, EPA Greenlights New 'Highly Toxic' Pesticide
Popular content
Today's Top News
The View on the Ground of the Palestine Papers
The Palestine papers may have sent shockwaves around the world, but they came as no surprise to most Palestinians, particularly those living out the horrific reality on the ground that has been "non-negotiated" over in the occupied territories, like my own family – or in refugee camps outside the occupied territories, like my husband's family in the sidelined camps of Lebanon.
More than anything, the details in the Palestine papers show just how out of touch with this reality the negotiators were, and how they chose to ignore this reality. It is this revelation – or reminder – that has most angered and distressed many Palestinians.
In Gaza, which has been blockaded with western backing and regional complicity since democratic elections five years ago, friends and family tell me the response is a mixture of anger, suspicion and uncertainty about the future. Fellow blogger Mohammed Suliman told me via Facebook that he found the revelations, chief among them that Mahmoud Abbas's Palestinian Authority offered to concede almost all of East Jerusalem, "shocking but not unpredictable", referring to them as a "tragicomedy". "I just can't understand who on earth nominated this man to speak for the Palestinians? When he says, 'WE' who the hell are we? Working 20 years in the field never gives him the right to give up on one metre of the land, to divide, bargain and sell."
The willingness to give up more than 10% of the West Bank and large portions of East Jerusalem, from where his family originally hails, is the most painfully startling part, he added.
The papers also confirm the intransigence of Israel in the face of the most compromising of Palestinians positions. Lina al-Sharif, a friend and author of the blog "360 Km2 of Chaos", told me she was irritated by the western media focus on Palestinian desperation and incompetency, rather than Israeli and American intransigence. "This shouldn't just be an expose of the PA, but also of Israel. And the US was witnessing all this and calling itself 'an honest broker'! This is just yet another hit to the already dead peace process."
Evidence has never been more compelling that the Israelis have always had their "partner for peace" – they have simply chosen to neglect them, and propose an alternative fiction in which there was none, irrespective of which Palestinian party was in power.
Because of this, some believe that the papers may actually be bolstering support for Mahmoud Abbas and his posse, whom they see as victims. True, the papers lay out the extent of the Palestinian Authority's complicity and capitulation. But journalist Fares Ghoul says they also serve to undermine what little credibility Mahmoud Abbas's Ramallah-based Palestinian Authority has, and questions the motives and timing behind their release. "We should focus on the day: what is going on today? The PA is doing well by resisting pressure to resume negotiations while settlement construction goes on."
In a bitter irony, and a stark reminder of the conditions many Palestinians in Gaza continue to live under, some cousins and friends there were not yet even aware of the revelations when I spoke with them, because they had no electricity.
"This might make you laugh or cry – or maybe both – but some people didn't hear about these documents yet because of the continuous power cuts in the Gaza Strip," my cousin told me.
Gaza continues to suffer from extended power outages since Israel bombed the only power plant there in the summer of 2006.
And although Palestine papers was a trending topic on Twitter, 25-year-old computer engineer Ola Anan says not everybody in Gaza cared to tune in. "Last night during al-Jazeera's broadcast, my father and I were the only ones interested in watching the whole program, my mother was rambling that it's not breaking news that the PA heads are traitors, and my brother asked me to put the volume down so that he could study for his exam!"
We are unlikely to ever learn who leaked the documents. An insider, an outsider … a combination? Some members of Fateh were quick to point fingers at one-time Gaza strongman Mohammed Dahlan, who is rumoured to be out of favour with Mahmoud Abbas. But there are enough disgruntled Palestinian negotiators with motives. One former negotiator with the PLO's British-Scandinavian backed Negotiations Support Unit (NSU), from where the leak is rumoured to have originated, told me "we always 'knew' but didn't really know the intimate details and the inside jokes. It is a level of unparalleled desperation." Another confided that several years ago they were fed up with the cronyism, incompetence and lack of leadership within the Palestinian Authority, saying: "I can't handle losing when my side doesn't even try."
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...

10 Comments so far
Show AllMaybe it is because of the mentioning of inter-family variations within this article, but all of this now reminds me of the emotional bonding that happens in "Stockholm Syndrome."
Beyond the revelations in the Palestine Papers, this "bonding" could be seen as a reason for why so many Israeli people have adopted Nazi behavior.
I am not trying to make excuses for anyone's behavior.
I'm only saying that this disfunction came to mind.
It seems like it could be applied to so many global dis-functions.
The Stockholm Syndrome is when the captive bonds and begins to sympathize with their captors. The PA is not the Palestinian people's captors, that role belongs to the Israeli government, whose actions have NOT - putting it far too mildly - inspired the sympathy of Palestinians. The PA are just another group of corrupt politicians that lie to those they ostensibly "represent" and otherwise cater to those with power - which is not really any different than what US politicians routinely do.
I could be wrong, but I took the "Stockholm Syndrome" reference to mean that the PA itself had gradually aligned its interests and come to identify with the genocidal policies of its Israeli captors.
I don't mean to speak for Birdbrain, or read into his comment, but this notion doesn't preclude a realization that "The PA are just another group of corrupt politicians..." Arguably, such corruption can actually facilitate the irrational identification and alignment.
Then are members of the PA "captives" of Israel? I don't think that is true let alone a very useful analysis. A more compelling explanation to me is that the ruling class interests of one society have more in common with the ruling class interests of another society than they do with their own domestic population. The Palestinian Papers have shown that the PA was willing to give away to Israel the soul of Palestine - for a song. Or, that in order to stay in power and relative privilege, the PA would happily sell out its own people - a very old characteristic of ruling classes.
"Obedient Servant"
Thanks for trying. That is what I was trying to say.
laila's absolutely right.
The spotlight needs to be shone on the atrocious and egregious conduct of the U.S. - let alone Israel.
Without our financing of Israel's extra-legal crimes against humanity, Israel would be forced to 'deal' with the reality of consequences of thits immoral conduct.
Does the the term Hannah Arendt coined ring any bells?:
"Banality of evi describes the thesis that the great evils in history generally, and the Holocaust in particular, were not executed by fanatics or sociopaths, but rather by ordinary people who accepted the premises of their state and therefore participated with the view that their actions were normal."
Our conduct in this case is only one of the egregious acys now ongoing.
With the exception of President Dwight Eisenhower's two terms administrations,all other American administrations since 1948 are complicit in the brutalization of the Palestinian people,the demolishing of their homes,the theft of their lands and the uprooting of their olive trees.
Without the American financial aids,Israel could not have done to the Palestinian what it has already done of brutality and humilation,on daily basis.
Stop aiding Israel and see what would happen in the next two to three years!
The free American money reaching the hands of the Zionist Fanatics,inIsrael,is the culprit. Period.
Progressive politicians, lets have some referendums on how to solve the Israeli/Palestinian conflict.
Cut the feeding tube to Israel. Completely. And you will need no referendums, the problem will solve itself.
I'm glad (or maybe sad, really) that Laila is validating what I have thought all along which is that to the Palestinians these are all news. The horror, the treachery, the deceit, the corruption, the weakness and the shameless behavior or their leaders is part of their brutal reality and has been for over 60 years. Nothing that any paper can say can top that. The papers do make it official and no one now can deny Israel's true intentions and what they are doing in only to accomplish their goal of absolute theft of whatever is left of the Palestinian land. The only thing left to do now is for the Palestinians to come together as one, barge in Fatah's offices and grab Abbas and the rest of his criminal cartel by the scruff of their necks and hand deliver them to Hamas in Gaza. Hamas will know what to do and they will do it with gusto on behalf of the Palestinians. Until such thing is done, the Palestinians will not be able to move become one people again, united in their cause and move forward. The world has their back now. This is no longer 1947. The victim has become the abuser as the tables have been turned.