EMAIL SIGN UP!
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Tunisian Protests Move Hillary's Line on Democratic Reform
Back in 1969, when Secretary of State Clinton was writing her senior thesis at Wellesley on Chicago community organizer Saul Alinsky, she must have come across this line on page 9 of Alinksy's book "Rules for Radicals":
"Revolution by the Have-Nots has a way of inducing a moral revelation among the Haves."
Thursday, Secretary Clinton delivered what the New York Times called a "scalding critique" to Arab leaders at a conference in Qatar.
"The region's foundations are sinking into the sand," Clinton said, calling for "political reforms that will create the space young people are demanding, to participate in public affairs and have a meaningful role in the decisions that shape their lives." Those who would "prey on desperation and poverty are already out there," Clinton warned, "appealing for allegiance and competing for influence."
As Secretary Clinton made her remarks, the Times noted, "unrest in Tunisia that threatened its government while serving to buttress her arguments" was among the events that "echoed loudly in the background."
Friday, Tunisian president Ben Ali has reportedly fled the country and the Tunisian prime minister says he is now in charge.
Popular protest can bring down the government in an Arab country. Who knew?
It's a whole new ballgame, as they say in Chicago. You think Friday's events in Tunisia are going to affect conversations in Algeria and Egypt? Maybe even in Haiti? I think they will. So does AP:
"The shakeup was certain to have repercussions in the Arab world and beyond - as a sign that even a leader as entrenched and powerful as Ben Ali could be brought down by massive public outrage."
Could Secretary of State Clinton's remarks in Qatar presage a shift in U.S. policy? It's not impossible to imagine. After all, Clinton's senior thesis pointed to the idea that there's another path to reform besides revolution in the street. Leaders can anticipate. You don't have to wait until protesters are at the gate. You could take the long view.
Today, U.S. policy in Haiti stands at a fork in the road.
One path away from the fork has been suggested by a draft report of a team from the Organization of American States that is trying to salvage Haiti's disputed November 28 presidential election. According to this proposal, Haiti's election commission would recalculate the preliminary results of the election so that a different two candidates would go to a run-off. If the U.S. backs this path, it would be backing an election in which nearly three-quarters of the Haitian electorate did not participate, either in protest at the exclusion of parties such as Fanmi Lavalas, the party of deposed former President Aristide, or because they were prevented from voting, or because they didn't see in any of the allowed candidates a realistic hope for addressing Haiti's problems.
Ratifying a recalculated result of this dubious election could lead to Tunisian-style protests in Haiti. Reuters notes Friday, reporting on a protest in which one Haitian was killed, that this happened "amid widespread concerns that an experts' report from the Organization of American States (OAS), which challenges the official results of Haiti's November 28 national elections, could spur fresh outbreaks of unrest."
The other path away from the fork would be to respond to the calls from Haitian civil society for a new election run by a new electoral council, a call recently supported by Representative Maxine Waters.
Some people in Washington say that a new election in Haiti would be too expensive. This argument is outrageously silly. The November election cost $30 million, a cost shared by the U.S. and other countries. The U.S. spends more than $30 million on the war in Afghanistan every three hours. Moreover, the next government in Haiti is expected to oversee $11 billion in reconstruction funds. A key means by which we can ensure that $11 billion will be well spent is "creating the space young people are demanding, to participate in public affairs and have a meaningful role in the decisions that shape their lives." $30 million is 0.27% of $11 billion. If a new election that seats a legitimate government saves 0.27% of that $11 billion from being wasted, the election will pay for itself.
If you agree with the demand of Haitian civil society for a new election, help the Center for Constitutional Rights tell Secretary of State Clinton to support this just demand.
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...

24 Comments so far
Show AllNaiman quotes Hillary's words to the Arabs but ignores her action in Honduras in which she supported an unconstitutional ouster of reformist Zalaya in favor of the usual right wing US allied undemocratic cabal.
What she is saying is throw the people a bone occassionally.
and only capitalists should prey on people's desperation and poverty
So what about this then?
http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/health-and-families/health-news/cuban-medics-in-haiti-put-the-world-to-shame-2169415.html
I hope Hillary is still SecState when the popular uprisings in this country are bearing down on the walls that protect the power and privilege of the elites in this country. The only real difference between the US and so many other countries is the illusion of democracy and the wealth won through economic imperialism that still keeps the populace fat, dumb and docile enough not to develop a class consciousness.
so do i.
There is to much state directed brutality in Honduras, Haiti and other states to move Hillary's line on democratic reform. Hillary clinton is no leader. According to her, terrorism is the greatest problem of these times. There has been no televised condemnation of dictatorships and the accumulation of great wealth by the few as the problems of democracy.
We don't need martians vs. venusians. We need individual people to balance these energies within for harmony and peace to become the norm.
NOTE:
When this article ran one day earlier on CD, the author Robert Naiman wrote this comment on his own article:
******************
AnachronisÂm alert: Secretary Clinton wrote her senior thesis in 1969. Rules for Radicals was published in 1971. I think that Alinsky used the quoted phrase earlier, and that anyone studying Alinsky would have known that he said that, but Secretary Clinton could not have read Rules for Radicals before writing her thesis, unless as a manuscriptÂ. My bad.
Tunisia and then barry is going to lecture China on human rights and we are supposed to take these hacks seriously? My mind reels and the world watches and giggles. Tony
no one takes these repugnant clowns seriously, yet they carry on business as usual, as they know no shame.
go on - buy 'em a new election.
the troops in Afghanistan could use a three-hour break.
Clinton said: "Even a leader as entrenched and powerful as Ben Ali could be brought down by massive public outrage."
________________*
Now, change Ben Ali for Obama.
Clinton said: "Even a leader as entrenched and powerful as Ben Ali could be brought down by massive public outrage."
________________*
Now, change Ben Ali for Obama.
I hope all the optimists for democracy springing up all over the place, remember "people power" in the Philippines. It is instructive to look at the U.S. role.
marc,
Didn't hear about anything recent so wondering if you are talking about the three-year Philippine-American revolution around 1900?
Googled Phillipines and found an information "Factbook" written by the CIA. I didn't know the CIA had developed a "Factbook" for online viewing.
No, the People Power revolution was the overthrow of the Marcos regime, in living memory.
i assume marc is referring to the fact that despite the popular uprising that overthrew the US-backed dictator, the people of the Philippines ended up sold out again, not liberated?
Deliciously bad news for Hillary Clinton. Another faithful client bites the dust!
At the very least we owe Haiti back the democracy that we (with some help from the French and Canadians) stole from them. Honduras is deja vu. When will our government ever end our Bad Neighbor policy toward the people of Latin America? The history is all in the books by Galeano and Prishad and updated on the websites, Upsidedown World and Narconews.
$33 Million dollars, are spent on the War in Afghanistan every 3 hours....America is behaving in a most pathetic way...the whole World is in crisis in one way or the other ,and we just keep waisting money, and prescious lives on All sides, for nothing, ego's wanting to save face, how imature. Even the average Joe, know's this is a no-brainer. We could be putting our efforts into really helping ,instead of being part of the solution, our Leaders keep making us part of the problem.
somehow i disagree with the writer about the rest of the arab world envisioned to emulate the tunisian revolution. on the contrary, i think that it will entrench the despot tyrants who exit only because the american armada, the air bases and the land bases that cover most countries in the arabian penunsula, whose main reason there is to protect and defends these rached poeple.listen to what qaddafi, how he pourd accolate on the deposed tunisian dictator and how he think it is best for tunisia to keep him to restore law and order. do you believe that the cia will let its pillars in the gulf states fall( wickileaks descibed how some of these rullers are cia informers)? would anyone ever envision mosad will let mubarek fall in disrace so that egypt will rejoin the rest of the arab cumunity to liberate jerusalem? not on your life.
How about the US policy in the United States? Shouldn't that demand some scrutiny? What are the leaders doing to stop protests in the street here?
Oh, that's wright, they've got Faux "news" on their side, brainwashing the multitudes.