Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
New York's Rebatable Bailout
You can't make up the following realities in New York State! Note the following series of events driven by the preposterous plutocrats and see if you get steamed.
Greed, power, reckless speculation and theft of other people's money by Wall Streeters collapsed the U.S. economy into a deep recession that started in 2007-08.
These super-rich Wall Street banksters looted and drained trillions of worker pensions and mutual fund savings while nationwide eight million jobs were lost.
Panicked that their overweening avarice was pushing their companies over the cliff, the banksters rushed to Washington, terrified members of Congress with the help of ex-Goldman Sachs CEO turned Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson and propelled the Bush White House into a series of massive taxpayer bailouts and guarantees amounting to trillions of dollars during the last quarter of 2006.
By the end of 2009, the Wall Street welfarists were recording once again record profits and sky-high bonuses. Month after month it became clear that the banks were not lending to small and larger businesses to get the economy moving again-a major reason give for the bailouts.
A good slice of the money went to bonuses, mergers and other empire building by the remaining five giant conglomerate banks. Today these banks are sitting on mountains of cash and many credit-worthy businesses and startups still cannot get loans.
As the Fiscal Policy Institute wrote in April: "Essential services like fire departments and schools, recession-buffering social safety net programs like homeless prevention and senior services, and critical infrastructure systems like hospitals, roads and mass transit all face severe cutbacks.
"But Wall Street is not suffering from the budget catastrophe or from the crash. ...The financial industry rang up $61.4 billion in profits for 2009 alone-that is nearly triple Wall Street's previous record. These are truly windfall profits-they are courtesy of the taxpayer-funded bailout [and federal policies uniquely privileging the big banks with virtually free money] and not because the big banks made money from financing the recovery of American businesses. Never before has Wall Street made so much money from doing so little for economic and job growth."
Making money from speculation instead of from investment is exactly what the legendary British economist, John Maynard Keynes, warned about almost eighty years ago in arguing for a securities transaction tax.
The conditions where many regular New Yorkers live are grim. Poverty, unemployment, home foreclosures, and small business bankruptcies keep growing.
On the other side of the tracks, the top twenty-five hedge fund managers recorded an average of $1 billion each, or over $80 million each a month in 2009. Quite a quick rebound on the backs of American taxpayers and privileged tax policies.
Low-moderate and middle-income New Yorkers already pay a higher percentage of family income in state and local taxes than do the richest one percent of New Yorkers!
Surprisingly, there is a simple way to eliminate the state deficit and prevent tens of thousands of layoffs and large service cutbacks.
What most New Yorkers do not know is that for about a century there has been a state stock transfer tax on purchases of securities. This year, this tax, similar to ones imposed in 30 other countries, will amount to about $16 billion. Amazingly, since 1979, this tax has been instantly rebated by New York State back to the brokers or clearinghouses who paid it. A 100% rebate every year for the bailed out industry that caused the recession and its immense human damage.
Obviously the stock exchanges and their brokers wield big political power. Flush with arrogance, bailouts and profits, they have no shame. So after blocking a tax on those unconscionable bonuses that outraged so many Americans, the securities industry has made sure that neither the Democratic nor Republican candidates for Governor utter a peep about retaining this $16 billion in tax revenues to get the state out of its dire straits.
One man, Howie Hawkins from Syracuse, NY, is challenging both the big boys on Wall Street and the duopolists' candidates. He is the Green Party candidate for Governor, nicknamed the Green Hornet. Pollinating truth and justice across the State, this ex-Marine, author, long-time citizen advocate, working blue collar teamster and public interest thinker, challenged Mr. Cuomo's self-imposed taboo:
"Why is Mr. Cuomo, the anointed front runner, hiding the Stock Transfer Tax from the public when it is an obvious way to bridge the state budget deficit? Why does he rule out higher taxes on the rich when they have more money than ever, why won't he make them pay their fair share, when they'll still be rich after paying their fair share?"All the politicians in Albany act like we're out of money and debate over what services to cut, all the while refusing to tell New Yorkers about the $16 billion they hand back to Wall Street speculators," he added.
Mr. Cuomo is a recipient of campaign contributions from hedge fund managers.
Take any poll. Betcha New Yorkers overwhelmingly support Mr. Hawkins' position (see: www.howiehawkins.com). Unfortunately, the two major parties predictably exclude him from any debates this fall.
If you are a New Yorker, and after reading this you are less indignant than you would be were you overcharged by a cab driver or were hurled a racist or ethnic slur from some passerby, it is unlikely you'll hustle up a neighborhood or workplace petition to demand that your lawmakers in Albany legislate keeping that $16 billion and all the jobs that can be saved with that revenue.
My guess is that if a million New Yorkers sign such petitions in the next three weeks and talk it up where they live in city, town and countryside, they'll win. You'll also signal that you're ready to jettison your political servitude and assert the sovereignty of the people as expressed in our Constitution's preamble-"we the people."
If you can't wait, call your Albany legislators at 518-455-2800 (State Senate) or 518-455-4100 (State Assembly) to see when they will be near your town during this summer. Go and give them two earfuls and demand that they commit.
- Posted in


15 Comments so far
Show AllTransaction taxes should be just the beginning of a full restoration of FDR's New Deal regulations to control the financial industry.
Nader is a national jewel.
Again and again we here that the Economies of the USA and of the EU can not afford SOCIAL program spending and it this spending that causes deficits.
This an outright lie and distortion. It is not Socialism that is failing. It is CAPITALISM.
Social Security in the USA is in surplus and has been for years. Wall street WANTS that money.
Amazing they ( the oligarchs haven't killed this guy yet.) He always talks truth to power.
If he became President, I am sure they would try their best, SEAGLASS.
They don't have to. When the Democrats became "New" Democrats (read: not quite as Republican as the Republicans), they joined the Republicans in marginalizing Nader.
I hope people who have consistently ignored or ridiculed Ralph Nader over the years will take a moment and ponder for a moment. What more should he have done, do you think? Other than join your favorite party, that is.
I wish he would have run for office this year. Senate would have been great, but House of Reps would be good too. I would love to see him inside the capitol, writing legislation, instead of agitating from outside it. Not that his outside agitation isn't good, it just seems a lot less influential than it used to be.
I understand your desire to see Ralph in our govt, at any level. But, as a devotee of Mr. Nader's efforts, as one who voted for his candidacy three times ( and counting ) I believe he is best, and we are best served, as a voice outside of govt.
His voice would be stifled by his independent status, his committee appointments also doomed to inconsequence by that status as well. Just look at Al Franken as one example of someone who was rather effective as a voice on a dying progressive radio network and is now voiceless and lost as a part of the system.
>>If you are a New Yorker, and after reading this you are less indignant than you would be were you overcharged by a cab driver or were hurled a racist or ethnic slur from some passerby, it is unlikely you'll hustle up a neighborhood or workplace petition to demand that your lawmakers in Albany legislate keeping that $16 billion and all the jobs that can be saved with that revenue.
Enough said.
How about New Yorkers just leave that state and move out here to North Dakota, South Dakota, Texas, Florida, Iowa, Kentucky, Wisconsin, Michigan, and other great midwestern states. New York is too overcrowded to fix anything.
Edit: Why can't New York State have a state owned bank of its own just like my state of North Dakota? What's the matter with New York? I thought that they were more liberal than my state. Weird and yet interesting !
Here's another suggestion, if you're feeling depressed and hopeless: watch Ralph Nader's inspiring, tireless, and utterly truthful speeches on Youtube or other sites. Discuss them with your kids, friends, parents. Authenticity is energizing! Wallowing supports the status quo. Thank you, Citizen Nader.
RaydelCamino
"Transaction taxes should be just the beginning
of a full restoration of FDR's New Deal regulations
to control the financial industry."
Yes, this and the return of a graduated income tax
Will be a good start toward 'Social Commerce' and the end of bloody Capitalism.
Go Nader Go!
I was really happy to read this article. I did not know we had a Green Party candidate for Governor and, of course, the many other positions. I am adamant about not voting for any Dems or Repubs. At this point I don't care who they are. If there are progressive Dems who are serious then they should leave the Dem party.
HCR was the last straw for me. Watching all these so-called progressive fall in line behind Dear Leader for the sake of the party, for the sake of Dear Leader. And every piece of major legislation since HCR has been the same story -- and it will continue to be the same story. I have jumped off the Dem-Repub hamster wheel.
Not only do we have to clean up this Wall Street mess, but we also have a severe problem in New York with public-sector unions. These are not like the unions we've read about that are rising up in China. The unions in NYS do not give a crap about all of the workers in NYS, only their own members, at the expense of the taxpayer. Go to Newsday and read about the MTA, and the LIRR in particular. Having worked for the MTA in 1976 and at the same time knowing many members of the LIRR, I had a pretty intimate knowledge of the corruption at that time and the outrageous overtime situation, the pension padding that takes place in the last years of employment through the use of overtime, and cronyism at it's worst. It is virtually impossible to get a job on the LIRR unless you have connections -- political or familial. Yes, the stench has gotten worse over the years. All of the information on the income and overtime is listed at Newsday also.
So, unfortunately, many of our labor unions are just as corrupt as Wall Street in bilking the taxpayer. If you live on LI and use the LIRR at all you have seen how bad it is -- fares keep going up, service keeps getting cut back, trains shortened, stations closed, and one could go on and on.
This is just another outrageous example of the problems we have in NYS. There are many, many others.
And, frankly, I have also never forgiven the union attitude in HCR. The moment they got a special deal from Obama (no tax on their health care benefits) they all fell in lie, i.e. screw all the other workers who weren't so lucky. Unions had been start going back to the grassroots or they will be gone. There's a lot of animosity towards public-sector union workers right now -- and with good reason. They give all unions a bad name.
So, as long as Ralph is talking about the corruption of NYS, let's put all of it out there. It's not just Wall Street.
Meanwhile, it would be nice if Sheldon Silver were finally brought down -- the air in New York would smell fresher overnight.
Of course Nader is right about this, and so many other things. His ideas are obvious. We should slaughter (electorally, that is) any legislator that will not raise taxes on the rich and will not support the transfer tax. If we continue to be docile, to accept serious cuts in transit, higher fares, cuts in school budgets, hospital closings and so on while these Wall Street abominations strut around and collect salaries like they do, and pay less taxes than an ordinary worker, then we are too docile to qualify as citizens in a democracy. We have become the proles. But proles have heart and numbers. I would say vote Green or vote Working Families, although with them we have to keep an eye what they are doing. If all else fails, write in your favorite local hero.
(BTW - we are going to have the new scanning machines next election, so we need volunteers to monitor the vote through exit polls and other means. This is especially important if alternate parties and candidates become viable.)
Joe