EMAIL SIGN UP!
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
'Killing' Ourselves to Death
In 1985, Neil Postman's book Amusing Ourselves To Death was published. His thesis, in brief, is that television and the media culture have replaced thoughtfulness with entertainment. We are being converted from a critically minded inquisitive population enjoying informed discourse to a nation of passive retards.
Yesterday, May 26, 2010, the Yahoo! news headline was "BP plans a ‘Top Kill.'" Prior to going to my home page I had been reading Henry Miller's The Air-Conditioned Nightmare (first published in 1945). Passages such as this:
"This world which is in the making fills me with dread. I have seen it germinate; I can read it like a blue-print. It is not a world I want to live in. It is a world suited for monomaniacs [BP, my insert] obsessed with the idea of progress -- but a false progress, a progress which stinks. It is a world cluttered with useless objects which men and women, in order to be exploited and degraded, are taught to regard as useful."
I go from a passage like the above to the headline. "Kill?" "Top Kill?" Is BP hunting terrorists now, I wonder. Battered with too many Jason Bourne movies, living in the surround sound of Jack Bauer on television's "24 Hours," I am titillated to explore what is the nature of this "Top Kill." I click on the link. No, it's not Osama Bin Laden. It's an oil leak. BP's very own oil leak. The weapon of choice is mud. "The company will shoot high-pressure mud into the well, hoping the pressure of mud coming in will eventually overcome the pressure of oil shooting out."
I am struck by the language. What BP is intent upon "killing" is the very "lifeblood" of our civilization. Oil's roots, hydrogen and carbon, are the basis of all earthly life. Carbon fuels currently empower our civilization. Using terminology of execution to describe a strategy for containing a ‘livelihood leak' is peculiar indeed. What concerns is the language, the ecology of the language. Are we not able to catch the semantic overtones of "shooting mud?" Mud slinging? Mud in the face? Mud being slung in the face of the BP executives?
Language usage describing this contamination event is very revealing. Is a language contamination also operative? Is language being endangered? As "the limitations in our language is the limitations in our world," (Wittgenstein), we have a lot to be wary of. A lot to protect. When we speak of ‘killing' that which sustains us are we not revealing something very perverse about ourselves? To be sustained by that which hazards our health and our air, to that which has the capacity to devastate wetlands and wildlife, to that which when corrupted (leaks) corrupts, -- is this not corruptible?
Alternatively, one could have used expressions such as "get control of" the leak, "contain," "redirect," "repair," "regulate," "salvage," "stop," "reverse," ... but "Kill?" And a "Top Kill" at that.
"Kill" is also used to express annihilating time. "It killed time." "It killed the weekend." What bizarre commentary this is. A nation obsessed with longevity hell bent on "killing time?" Wow, we really beat the shit out of "Time."
I want to suggest a Language Leak. Here's Henry Miller:
"Tell me what it is that man can build, to protect himself, which other men cannot destroy? What are we trying to defend? Only what is old, useless, dead, indefensible. Every defense is a provocation to assault. Why not surrender? Why not give -- give all?" (from The Air-Conditioned Nightmare)
We won't surrender because we're in peak conditioning. We're in the Oil-Conditioned Nightmare -- enslaved to our cars, our blackberries, our cell phones, our kindles, our powerbooks & computers, our itunes and apps, our televisions & treadmills. We're a nation of Reactivity rather than Investigation and Reflection. A nation assaulting our environment. As the wetlands are being overcome with suffocating ooze, so our mental capacities are being smothered, shut down, diminished. Our interior landscape is vanishing. We're experiencing a perpetual leak, a prolonged erosion of our life sources, our domain of external and internal habitat. We buy and sell, we kill and defend, we update and install, we click and click ... our horizons are shrinking -- it is the Time of Shrivellization. Let this Leakage be a wake-up call, a last ditch alert -- if it's not too late already -- to look to new methods to nurture and fuel, to provide, to sustain ourselves. Let us seek out the subtle and the tenebrous, the non-palpable and invisible, the slight and the insignificant. Let us seek to use language more richly, with more consideration, with more tenderness, with more understanding, with more -- embrace.
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...

48 Comments so far
Show AllWell done.
Also from "Air-conditioned Nightmare", "America, you'll be the death of the world".
There already was a "dead zone" in the Gulf caused by all pesticides and fertilizer coming down the Mississippi.that was initially made from the oil by the chemical industry. Ironic!
"We have met the enemy, and he is us"!
Ethical distancing and ethical problems of scale are not limited to high-impact military technology. The behavior and nature of modern technocracies, business, and government organizations are equally illustrative of this. Witness how corporations, now working on the global scale, routinely make calculated decisions about the risks of the products they manufacture. Typically, they weigh the cost of adding important safety features to their products against the potential liability to victims and the environment and then make the best “bottom line” decision for the company. More often than not, safety or environmental measures lose out in this calculation. As for people or nature, they have been “distanced” into numerical units relegated to profit-or-loss columns. The corporations then decide how many units they can afford to have harmed or killed by their products.
Cicero: "Freedom is participation in power."
The wealthier the corporate entity, the more they also factor in legal or political resistance to these practices as a typically very affordable "cost of doing business" as I remember one '80s era Gordon Gecko type refer to the Exxon Valdez spill. A company like Exxon who makes upwards of $40 Billion dollars a year treats its annual regional environmental destructions and legally and politically countering all attempts to seek justice for those outrages as just another pre-factored-in annual business expense.
"Is a language contamination also operative? Is language being endangered?"
Do you really need to ask? Current usage of "killing" or any other single word is the merest symptom of a totally Orwellian revision of the entire American vocabulary and its semantics. At the risk of boring the regulars here, I'll re-reiterate just a few of the definitions employed in the modern linguistics of USA Incorporated and its imperial spokespersons as an integral part of its fantasy world creation and sustenance.
__
Democracy: the periodic legitimization by popular vote of the candidates vetted and put forward for high office by USA Incorporated, nominal party affiliations notwithstanding.
Freedom: the unfettered global rights of full spectrum dominance by USA Incorporated, especially the capitalist "free enterprise" right to exploit public resources for private gain regardless of nominal sovereignty or geopolitical boundaries and regardless of any alleged environmental consequences.
People (of, by and for the): an attribute that is enjoyed exclusively by USA Incorportated's legal personhood, specifically exclusive of any and all aincient rule-of-law charters and constitutions and previous erroneous interpretations thereof regarding natural persons or human rights.
Terror: any act, demonstration, plan, plot, or conspiracy, whether or not acted upon overtly, to inhibit or diminish the unquestionable rights and freedoms of USA Incorporated (see above), or that may be so attributed and ascribed by USA Incorporated for its own purposes regardless of any actual intent of the planners or actors.
Terror (war against): any utilization by any means of any national, sub-national or international body of military, quasi-military, mercenary, intelligence or counter-intelligence resources, not excluding the first use of nuclear weapons against non-nuclear powers and without distinction between military and civilian opponents, for the purpose of globalizing the full spectrum dominance of USA Incorporated.
We / Us / Our (as in "our" U.S. interests abroad): See people above. Must not be confused with any attribute or interest of any ordinary (i.e., non-corporate) U.S. citizens.
__
NOTE: "USA Incorporated" is used herein solely for convenient reference to the multinational corporate forces, most of which are nominally headquartered within the geopolitical entity currently known as the United States of America, but which in fact have no abiding allegience to any specific nation or citizenship. In particular, no national or citizenship immunity whatever to the implementation of its imperial will should be inferred.
May I add "Cartel"? The meaning of this word evidently must be destroyed, as the MSM is now doing by constantly referring to "gangs" or "syndicates", or "organizations" in Mexico that sell drugs as "cartels". Actually, they are the antithesis of cartels, which (by definition) cooperate to restrict the availability of some commodity. When you see them referred to as "cartels" you are watching the assassination of a concept in real time.
Cicero: "Freedom is participation in power."
I don't follow you here. The various cocaine and marijuana cartels war with each other to restrict the control of those markets to their growers, distributers and markets. If marijuana were nationally legalized and regulated in the U.S., then the pot cartels would be price crushed out of the market.
Health care: Medical services; the medical for-profit industry. (Health is what I enjoy and provide for myself with my own decisions and choices.)
And totally agree with the We/Us/Our thing.
RV,you really should submit those definitions to Wikipedia,excellant! Thanks.
peace
Feel free to do anything you wish with any or all of them. Attribution is of no importance. Never having made any prior Wikipedia contributions myself, I'm totally ignorant of the procedure and its governing rules.
Amurka is a Death Kulture to the tune of Sheena is a Punk Rocker by the Ramones:
Well the kids are all hopped up and ready to go
They're ready to go now
They've got Grand Theft Auto
And they're going to oil terror war a go go
But she just had to stay
She could not break away
Well Iraq's oil reserves really have it all
Oh yeah, oh yeah
Amurka is a death kulture
Amurka is a death kulture
Amurka is a death kulture
Amurka is a death kulture
Amurka is a death kulture
Amurka is a death kullture now
Well she's a death, death, a death monger
Death, death, a death monger
Death, death, a death monger
Death, death, a death monger
Well the kids are all hopped up and ready to go
They're ready to go now
They've got their Halo
And they're going to the AfPak a go go
But she just had to stay
She could not break away
Well Unocal's pipeline really has it all
Oh yeah, oh yeah
Amurka is a death kulture
Amurka is a death kulture
Amurka is a death kulture
Amurka is a death kulture
Amurka is a death kulture
Amurka is a death kullture now
Well she's a death, death, a death monger
Death, death, a death monger
Death, death, a death monger
Death, death, a death monger
Amurka is a death kulture
Amurka is a death kulture
Amurka is a death kulture
Amurka is a death kulture
Amurka is a death kulture
Amurka is a death kullture now [x2]
Well done, METAL, well done!
Wikipedia is a trash substitute for knowledge; this was recognized by a great ecologist and by Physicians For Orthomolecular Medicine. The latter is based in Ontario.
Good stuff RV.
The beginnings of a devil's dictionary.
Henry Miller we miss you.
Nice piece.
Bong Hits 4 Jesus Brigade
Henry Miller - You were not only the voice of your generation flying in the face of insanity... YOU were a voice for all ages.
You were and continue to be a source of inspiration in a global society going increasingly MAD. What a HEADRUSH it must have been to be part of your tribe.
Your SPIRIT is the engine which propells the Universe!
This isn't an article on the healthcare reform bill giveaway to the big insurance companies now is it?
Oh, yes, the killing of wildlife and precious species which man and woman couldn't care less about is certainly tragic. And the destruction to the environment is a crime and as evil as those who attacked America on September 11, 2001.
In my eyes, this oil spill is as every bit the tragedy of September 11, 2001 and the buck stops at the desk of President Barack H. Obama. The do-nothing President Obama for that matter......Wake Up Little Susies....
And, this ain't no Joke, Jack!!!!
We live in a bewildering current of objects and thought. The center cannot hold. While some on the right worry about a climate of trespass against private property, many fear the trespass against the Earth and true common sense. We are too often left with but shards of commonality, and perhaps more a "Time of Shrinkage." The water is cold, dark, and oily. Bang or whimper?
Well, this article just killed my day. Better get some more pain killer.
Excellent de-construction of word message delivered to us by those who would like to be kings of our dreams.
Language is structured in consciousness.
A mind and heart that resides in beauty, uses words that most closely describe the indescribable.
A heart and mind that resides in fear and aggression, uses language that reflects that condition, as in 'War on that and war on this" or "Top kill" or "fighting for peace" or "Spiritual warriors" UGH!
Very good comment and very true.
Cicero: "Freedom is participation in power."
No, it's only half truth. The Golden Mean is somewhere in between in the minds of people who live under forced harshness, cruelty and misery often beyond their control and who struggle in their minds and hearts for peace and beauty and a way to relate those ideas to their real, often negative experiences. The world is neither all bliss nor all ugliness. "The days are bright and filled with pain," and agony & ecstasy tumble together and transform one with suddenness and intensity that belies any insular inert state of bliss.
In the real world there very much is a need for spiritual warriors and people capable of some stoicism.
Or . . .
"We had to burn the village to save it . . . "
!!!
And really that's the point we've reached in this destruction ---
And if we don't stop capitalism it will take us right over the cliff --
.
"According to all myth, the female - not the male -- gives life"
Its just 'manly-speak'.
as we destroy the infrastructure of nature, the human infrastructure, which only seems to be dependent on oil/external energy , dies as well...
For tiny starters, how about a clothesline on the White House lawn?
Don't think it will happen? Then how about on yours?
http://right2dry.org/
The revolution has to start somewhere!
It IS on "ours".
"We are being converted from a critically minded inquisitive population enjoying informed discourse to a nation of passive retards." Heller, the conversion has reached the point of no return for the majority of the population.
"In saying that the television news show entertains but does not inform, I am saying something far more serious than that we are being deprived of authentic information. I am saying we are losing our sense of what it means to be well informed. Ignorance is always correctable. But what shall we do if we take ignorance to be knowledge?" Neil Postman, Amusing Ourselves to Death.
"I am struck by the language." Heller, I'm struck by it too. "It's an oil leak." No, it is not an oil leak. If you're concerned about language, why no comments about the use of "spill" and "leak?" I spilled a glass of juice this morning, and there's a leak from my bathroom faucet. I wiped up the juice and I probably need to replace a washer on the faucet.
Why do we continue using "spill" and "leak" when refering to the Gulf of Mexico's oil volcano?
In Iraq, Afghanistan and Pakistan, when they hear 'top kill,' they run for cover to avoid a couple of Hellfire missiles launched from American Hunter-Killer Drones aimed, more often than not, at a wedding for some reason...
Now it's time to roll a fatty with this killer weed...
Yup. When I first heard the words "top kill" I thought it was another description of our drone assassinations in Af/Pak.
Cicero: "Freedom is participation in power."
Sounds like a satellite weapons strike to me.
It's death kulture a go-go, empire over-extended almost gone, folks. You read it here first:
Paul B. Farrell of Marketwatch
MAY 25, 2010
WARNING: CRASH DEAD AHEAD. SELL. GET LIQUID. NOW.
Some excerpts:
"You remember [Barton] Biggs of Morgan Stanley: In his book "Wealth, War & Wisdom" he advises his high rollers [fat hedge fund manager billionaires--metal] to prepare for a "breakdown of the civilized infrastructure." Buy a farm: "Your safe haven must be self-sufficient and capable of growing some kind of food ... It should be well-stocked with seed, fertilizer, canned food, wine, medicine, clothes, etc. Think Swiss Family Robinson." Biggs is not advising small investors on what to do with their 401(k)s.
"More proof: Earlier economist Gary Shilling said price-to-earnings ratios are at a "nosebleed 22.5 level." The Dow was around 11,000. Money manager Jeremy Grantham recently said the market's overvalued 40%. That could mean a collapse to 6,600. Last week in Reuters' "Markets Could Be Derailed Again," George Soros echoed a "game over" warning with a "stark warning ... that the financial world is on the wrong track and that we may be hurtling towards an even bigger boom & bust than in the credit crisis."
"Now Dow Theory's Richard Russell is warning the public of an imminent crash: "Sell ... get liquid ... BY THE END OF THIS YEAR THEY WON'T RECOGNIZE THE COUNTRY."
[Source: http://www.marketwatch.com/story/crash-is-dead-ahead-sell-get-liquid-now-2010-05-25]
"We're a nation of Reactivity rather than Investigation and Reflection. "
I have sometimes thought that this nation was always like this even before 1980 but that it was obvious until 2008 and even then people are still in denial and protests are fixed and weak compared to protests in Greece. If people really cared about the damage BP has done to the environment, we would be seeing mass protests for alternative energies, improving public transportation, cutting down subsidies for Big Oil, etc... by now. Whether we are looking at $4/gal or severe environmental damage, people in this country still have "faith" that "things will take care of themselves". Oil prices would have to stay higher and/or people would have to be re-conditioned into understanding the real costs of drilling off the coasts, environmental and economical. Right now, with the illusion that the economy is supposedly getting better and Americans looking at Europe struggling, most Americans appear poised to foolishly believe that being reactive instead of thoroughly investigating and reflecting on the results is somehow the right thing to do. We here on CD are just a tiny minority battling the cornfed electorate.
To return to topic and take a tip from Sioux, when will people who write here stop referring to people THAT and corporations WHO?
It's really irritating, especially at a site where so many complain about corporate personhood.
-30-
Excellent point.
Language matters in all spheres of human interaction....and the propagandists are well aware.......
Let this oil gusher be a wake up call. PachaMama, or mother earth, is going to keep on increasing the intensity of the disasters until adolescent earthlings decide to grow up and wake up and act responsibly - by not continually soiling our nest. This is NOT optional.
If every bible in every hotel room were replaced with a collection of Henry Miller's writing, we may stand half a chance.
Though I doubt even that would do it....just too damn late.
Call me a wuss, but ever since Pro Wrestling made a comeback, I've winced whenever I hear the term "smackdown".
So it's hate America day, nice. Lets all leave. whoops can't do it, NASA just sold the pickup (Space Shuttle) and are out to replace it with a 65 vw bug. So nobody's getting off this rock anytime soon. Unless it's the Chinese, their hoping martains will work for yet less as the people over there are begining to wake up and smell the coffee, that they can't let afford.
Enough rambling! Don't worry be happy soon the gulf current will pickup the oil and take it to New York, Washington, and up and around to London the home of BP,, when the Themes catches fire you can be sure they'll do something then!
Oceanic karma what drifts around comes around. :)
>^^<
Useless consumer goods? Excuse me, I have to take this call...
FREE AMERICA
DIRECT DEMOCRACY
Very important essay, even if it only touches on the problem of how the language has been prostituted by the swarm of BPs, Halliburtons and Transoceans that now dominate the socio-politico-economic landscape. And for anyone who's read Henry Miller, Levinson couldn't have pointed to a better writer to help convey his argument. And since "top kill" is already a proven failure, so does it show the failure of our language to deliver anything authentic.
BP is a fraud that has been allowed to get away with murder and mayhem for countless years, just like its co-conspirators in the Big Oil mafia, just like AIG, Goldman Sachs, Big Pharma and all their sinister associates who've brought us "better living through chemistry" and the fundamental bullshit arts of marketing and salesmanship. They've all been killing us softly with their evil songs for decades, and getting richer by the minute, the only barometer of Success in this rotten-to-the-core society.
Why have we permitted this for so horribly long? If we simply can't learn, then one of the central messages of Neil Postman's critical book, Amusing Ourselves to Death, which Levinson begins this piece with, is undeniably true: we've let our adolescent culture of endless entertainment distract us from attending to what really matters for soooo long, that we're a nation of virtual retards. Or "passive retards," as Levinson puts it. How else can Sarah Palin and Bill O'Reilly possibly be explained? As just two glaring examples, I mean.
The USA exudes violence from every pore. We have become the Evil Empire.
Unfortunately, the entire premise of this Heller's piece is faulty. If he had done a little more research he would have found out that "kill" is a century-old oil-drillers term for stopping a flowing well.
But the rest of his points are well-taken.
Yes the world has literally gone to shit. People don't understand the meaning of energy anymore and think it's something magical.
There seems to be no understanding that depleting mother earth of her innards (oil) has consequences.
The other crazy thing is that our technology has reached the point where energy from oil is absolutely undeniably unnecessary.
We could panel the Majove desert with miles of solar panels and power the entire planet but no what is important is the dollar. What good would free energy do?
http://joyleftowsblog.blogspot.com
I forgot to mention that I re-read Miller's "The Air-Conditioned Nightmare" a couple of years ago and it was still prescient, and lively reading, decades after publication. Next? Nexus, Sexus, Plexus...brilliant stuff.
-30-