EMAIL SIGN UP!
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Horne’s Burden Then is Latinos’ Now
Ironically, Lena Horne was going to be honored at this weekend's Major League Baseball's Civil Rights Weekend in Cincinnati. The film and stage performer who died Sunday at age 92 was to Hollywood what Jackie Robinson was to baseball. Robinson broke baseball's color barrier and endured many indignities in doing so. Horne was the first African-American to earn a long-term contract with a major movie studio, yet primarily sang in MGM musical cameos that were cut when the films were played in the South.
Still, she set her own terms as much as the times allowed. Prior to her emergence, black women primarily were seen in subservient or primitive roles. In a 1997 interview with PBS, Horne recounted that her father negotiated with MGM in 1942 by saying, "I can get a maid for my daughter. I don't want her in the movies playing maids.'' Horne would write with melancholy in a memoir, "They didn't make me a maid, but they didn't make me anything else, either.''
She refused to comply with wrong customs in other ways. During World War II, she was censured by the USO after she refused to perform at an Army camp show in the South. She was incensed when she saw German POWs seated in front of black soldiers. When Robinson entered the major leagues in 1947, Horne said she was so "frightened'' for him because of the scrutiny he too would face as a pioneer. "You can never forget you're a Negro . . . It's our burden,'' she said.
Burdens
still remain for entertainers and athletes to shoulder in the spirit of
Horne. The most important issue of the moment is Arizona's new
immigration law that requires police to stop and force anyone on a mere
suspicion of being undocumented to immediately produce papers. The law
is so fraught with the potential for racial profiling that the
What Arizona is thinking is anyone's guess. It was so laggard in approving the Martin Luther King Jr. holiday that the National Football League removed a Super Bowl game from Phoenix. The immigration law is so primitive that baseball players, particularly Latinos, who comprise 30 percent of players, have begun saying that they will boycott the 2011 All-Star Game scheduled for Phoenix and are concerned about spring training next season. The baseball players union, noting that half of spring training sites are in Arizona, warned that it "will consider additional steps necessary to protect the rights and interests of our members.''
The next step is apparent. If Arizona does not rescind this law, baseball should move the All-Star Game to another state and baseball teams should set up spring training in other warm-weather states. The National Collegiate Athletic Association should move next season's national football championship game and other bowl games from the state. Even the most rabid right-wing anti-immigration politician might think differently.
What is refreshing is to see athletes as part of the protest. Horne once said, "Nobody black or white who really believes in democracy can stand aside now; everybody's got to stand up and be counted.'' She would find this challenge to democracy ironic as Latino immigrants, legal and undocumented, do so much of the dirty work of our wealthy society. According to the Pew Hispanic Center, undocumented workers make up 5.4 percent of the nation's labor force, but 28 percent of dishwashers and 27 percent of maids and housekeepers.
Horne became a pioneer by rejecting menial stereotypes. Today, athletes are beginning to speak out because they reject a law that lumps Latinos - from maids to millionaire ballplayers - into one brown mass. A threat to take away the All-Star Game should end this suspicious policy.
- Posted in
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...


2 Comments so far
Show AllHola hermanos y hermanas,
As a naturalized citizen who’s father served in World War II. I have always felt uncomfortable saying the Pledge of Alliance in grade school during my school days in Spanish Harlem. As, "and justice for all" had a hollow sound and really knowing that some were more equal than others...Well, we still have along way to go. As on a recent peace walk with Native Americans somewhere in the South, someone yelled out their vehicle window "Go back home???" Natives looked at each other and may have wondered where did this fellow get his education or lack of...Shame, America of the brave.
We're at a crossroads with immigration now. It's not really about Latinos as much as it is about cheap labor (both outsourcing and in-sourcing [whether legal or illegal]). It's really making what amounts to a class war about race. The upper classes and moguls of industry want to import cheap labor any way the can get it. The bottom line for them is to increase profits. Remember, most are psychopathic in that they do not care who or what they destroy or harm to gain them. In another post someone said that illegal immigration is not the problem, but NAFTA is. We cannot ignore the fact that in-sourcing plays a role in depressing wages as well. To completely dissolve the borders would in effect be economic suicide, where only the rich would ultimately benefit--if only for the short term; eventually, ALL boats would sink. To support illegal immigration is to indirectly support worker exploitation. While I believe the undocumented want to come out from the shadows, I do not believe that they want to allow even cheaper labor to undercut what they've worked to achieve. That said, we must address the WHOLE of the problem which includes immigration (in-sourcing) as well as the GATT and NAFTA (outsourcing). Those who most benefit from illegal immigration would like nothing better to make it about race.