EMAIL SIGN UP!
Most Popular This Week
- The Bill of Rights Exists: An Open Letter to Dianne Feinstein
- Major Loss to Organic Farmers as Court Rules in Favor of Monsanto
- NSA Whistleblower Revealed: Q&A with Edward Snowden
- One American Who Isn't For Sale
- 'Reprehensible, Reckless, Illegal': Washington Officials Slam Heroic NSA Surveillance Leaker
Popular content
Today's Top News
Truth Wasn't Murdered May 4. People Were
In October 2009 I received an e-mail from one Jonathan Hartley that reproduced the header of my Common Dreams essay of May 7, 2004, "What Really Happened at Kent State" (http://www.commondreams.org/views04/0507-01.htm ) followed by this paragraph:
"What really happened at Kent State was that the truth was murdered, and the vicious, evil, immoral march of Marxism around the world found its first foothold in America. But the truth can't be buried, because even after all these years, we are going to preserve it forever. The misinformation and lies won't stand. I teach my 14 year old about the brave people of that town who endured a year of intimidation, assaults and persecution at the hands of communist militants. A year of abuse before something was finally done to defend them from the "liberators of mankind." All of the Kent State traitors owe an abject apology to the people of Kent State and to America. And they should have been prosecuted for murder."
[last sentence printed in red]
My first reaction was to respond: "Were you in Kent in May of 1970? Can you name some "brave people of the town" and document the persecution they endured? Just who would you prosecute for murder?" But I quickly realized the futility of challenging Mr. Hartley. I can't square his truth with my experience, but nothing I could say would change his mind.
I lived in Kent through the protests. It's true that misinformation and lies circulated around town: the SDS is going to blow up the Main Street Bridge on Friday; Black Panthers have taken over Hudson (a neighboring town); the rioters are controlled by communists from a Soviet submarine in West Branch Reservoir; Allison Krause "was so eaten up by venereal disease she would have died anyway."
It's also true there were outsiders on campus, perhaps hoping for glory by organizing the students to some newsworthy action. If so, they failed miserably: whatever other words might describe the student protests, ‘organized' is not one. For that matter, the response of the university and the local, state and national officials can hardly be described as ‘organized' either.
The ensuing events, though unplanned, were certainly newsworthy, but they arose more from misunderstanding and mismanagement than from communist plots or authoritarian repression; more from internal dissonance than outside agitation; more from official arrogance, bureaucratic disorder and student frustration than calculated organization or communist militants, more from rumor than reason, more from fear than fact.
Truth wasn't murdered at Kent State. People were murdered; people were wounded, hurt, frightened and bewildered, and much damage was done across the community and university.
At a forum at the Unitarian Universalist Church of Kent on May 2, 2004, a Kent veteran of Vietnam spoke out:
"I'm still trying to reconcile my hometown to what happened here ... I can't understand ... [near tears]... understand it, and it's not finished yet. Kent State is my Vietnam Wall .... and Kent State belongs to everyone in this country, in the world .... And now we're still going through the same thing in Iraq to obtain peace.... In 1972 I voted for Nixon. But May 4 followed me everywhere. People would say "Where are you from?" and when I said "Kent Ohio" they always said, "Oh, that's where they shoot students." ... It needs to be embraced. I can't be responsible for all the babies and bombs of Vietnam, of Iraq. But we have to take it ... we have to walk with it."
Finally, in 2010, we have an opportunity to take hold of some truths about what happened here and seek some rapprochement we can live with. This year Allison Krause's sister Laurel and their mother Doris have initiated a Kent State Truth Tribunal to document the personal narratives of participants and witnesses to the campus events of 40 years ago. Stories will be recorded in downtown Kent May 1 - 4, and will be available as streaming video on the web site www.MichaelMoore.com. (more information: http://truthtribunal.org/about )
The Krause family is seeking restorative justice, not Bad Guys to blame, or traitors to prosecute. They hope to shed light on the causes of and responsibilities for the tragic events of May 4, and clarify the role of protest and civil rights in our democracy.
Also this year, in another unique project, Kent residents are being invited to submit fabric squares reflecting their memories of May 4 to create a community story quilt that will engage people and get them talking about healing, hope, and peace.
It is a strong metaphor: truth as a quilt assembled from patches of personal memories and pieces of shared dreams, stitched together with mutual respect and kindness into a usable reality that protects and warms us.
The Kent veteran was right: we need truths about May 4 we can talk about, take in our arms , and walk with into the future.
But he also reminded us: "And now we're still going through the same thing in Iraq to obtain peace."
... and who should be responsible for the babies and bombs of Iraq, of Afghanistan?
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...




14 Comments so far
Show AllI take it your correspondent withdrew his child from school so that he could teach him or her this insane and malicious parcel of lies. America is going mad.
This is a very powerful piece, Caroline. Thank you for writing and sharing it.
Challenging Mr. Hartley is indeed futile. And, dismissal of such lunatics with a nod and a mildly sarcastic "yeah, sure thing, buddy" would be the right thing to do if there weren't so many of them.
The only killing of truth was that done by the national guard after the killings. The entire city of Kent was blocked off via checkpoints until May 8. Even small gatherings of young people were dispersed. The campus was completely shut down and any attempt to enter the campus - even by faculty meant arrest and a trespassing charge and possibly deadly force. Many campuses around the US also closed and students were banned from entering.
These sort of things seem to have been quietly removed from the history books.
The students nowadays are particularly clueless. Last year an article in the Kent State Newspaper, the author student likened the Kent State killings to the Virginia Tech shootings. She said the campus was closed for the rest of the year because of a well-meaning but excessive effort to allow bereavement time for the students. I'll try to find the article presently.
Unfortunately, the wimpering, "passivist" (not to be confused with "pacifist") actions of this oh-so-typical Unitarian church-going liberal will do NOTHING to effect real change. In fact, these action sabotage any prospect of change.
Change happens when people get angry and take effective actions that have a real on the ability of the powerful to pursue their agenda.
I did some research on Kent State a few years ago, and found an angle I rarely have ever seen mentioned in reports about the shootings. Those shootings took place just days before the election for Governor was to take place, and then Gov. Rhodes was in danger of losing to his Democratic rival. The student protesters were quite unpopular, and part of the calculus in bringing in the troops was political. (Those troops, by the way, were returning from a deployment to suppress urban rioting, and were not too happy over their Kent State detour.) Rhodes' strong stand against the protest gave him an up tick in the polls, and he was re-elected the following Tuesday.
For me, as a freshman in college that Spring, the sight of the body of Jeffery Miller in that iconic photograph was a part of a commitment to a life of political awareness and activism. He might well have been me, and I carry on partly in his memory.
*Comment deleted by site administrators for violating our Comment Policy*
see: http://www.commondreams.org/comment-policy
Oh my! It looks like Ms. Arnold has a "fan club" among the tea partiers. That part of Ohio is a pretty much dominated by the knuckle-dragging right. Glad I don't live there.
Sorry about my earlier comment. Anyone with enemies like Jeff Farmer is a friend of mine. Power to the People!
My then-young blue collar parents, neither of whom went to college, were precisely the kind of people that Nixon & Agnew and speechwriter Pat Buchanan determined to appeal to in 1968 and after, as they lay the blame for everything on spoiled students, and when the students were shot their feeling was 'Well, if they didn't protest, they would'nt have been shot, would they?' and I didn't question that till more thean two decades later.
We need to remember that the occasion for the protests was a continuing, seemingly endless war that Nixon was prosecuting even more ruthlessly than his predecessor had.
"The students nowadays are particularly clueless."
What about those Pitt students who got gassed and beaten during the G20?
These types of things are hate crimes. They send a message. "Don't protest!"
Let me protest the headline's seeming intent just a bit.
The truth was indeed murdered, as well as people, human beings - starting with people of Mr. Hartley's beliefs. He clearly is a murderer of truth, no wonder that is the charge he brings as distraction for lies rather than truth. Here we are 40 years on trying to get the truth into the record. That is 40 years of truth murder including the libel and defamation of the murdered humans.
I cannot imagine where Mr. Hartley or others get this nonsense anymore than the tea baggers make any kind of sense. And after watching so much obfuscating, lying and covering up I've reached the conclusion that these enforced lies make no sense even to the agents of the state who are lying. They too would be better off with the truth. But damn, they resist.
I remember 5/4/70. Dick Nixon had run for election promising to end the Vietnam war. After his election he expanded the war into Cambodia and the American people, especially our young students who were being drafted into that illegal meatgrinder, rose up against the war. But the Republican President and Republican Governor of Ohio denounced all opposition to their war. The slaughter of our innocent youth resulted. Which Republican State will be the next to slaughter it's unarmed people for corporate profit? Arizona perhaps.
Amerika isn't going mad, it is mad. I was a typical apolitical high school senior on May 4, 1970. The murders spurred me to investigate the history of the Vietnam War which led to my opposing it. My sense of political awareness began that awful day. The ensuing four decades saw a dumbing down of the population and a myth developed that Amerika was stabbed in the back by liberals and communists at home which resulted in the loss of the war. I can't believe how many people fell for this myth (including many who actually protested the war). Many times I feel we're doomed, but then I go to this website and my spirits improve. Keep the faith everybody.
I suspect the truth is the version that can be repeated most often by the most media outlets owned by the most obscenely rich.