Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Our Hands and Help for Haiti
Last week my daughter, Tanya, and I embarked on a trip to Haiti. We packed, with the help of some very good friends, 5 large duffle bags of food and medical supplies to carry to the people who were terribly stricken by the January 12th earthquake, and the ensuing aftermath.
It's very hard to put into words what we witnessed. We felt profound sadness and saw destruction of a magnitude that cannot be rivaled. I realize that we are not "disaster relief" experts, and therefore have not been around to see other tragedies, but I doubt that anything can match what we saw when we went into Port au Prince one month after the earthquake.
The two of us wanted to help with our own hands, not just by throwing money at the hundreds of NGO's and other groups who wanted donations from the world. We felt it was better for the people of Haiti to actually put a face to the help they wanted and needed desperately. Caring about humanity means more than shaking our heads in horror.
After speaking with Tyler Westbrook, a friend, we came up with a plan to travel to Santo Domingo, DR, and then to "Good Samaritan Hospital" located on the border of Haiti in Jimani, DR. Tyler and I know each other from years of anti-war protests and street activism. He has been documenting anti-war actions on WhyNotNews.org. Being the mother of a US Marine who did three tours, one in Afghanistan and two in Iraq, I am opposed to all wars and am against the growing US Empire. Over the last 9 years I have developed a perspective as to what has happened and will continue to happen to countries such as Haiti where US oppression and intervention has caused people so much pain and suffering.
Initial Greetings
When we left Santo Domingo early Tuesday morning we met Paul, who we didn't know at the time would be our guide throughout the trip. Paul was traveling home to Haiti to see his family for the first time since the quake. He didn't lose anyone, but this was his first time back and didn't know what to expect. It took us 6 hours on a long bus ride to Jimani, where we were met by Tyler and a priest from a Haitian orphanage, Rev. Bourdeau. Piling our supplies in the back of the pickup truck, my daughter on top, we drove to the hospital. A brand new structure the hospital sat alone amongst huts and shacks. Inside the compound were about 100 patients with all kinds of horrific injuries from the collapse of buildings inside Haiti, along with about 100 doctors, nurses, EMT's, and staff who volunteered on their own time and dollar to respond to this tragedy.
Three huge tents were arranged on the grounds, and inside, beds strewn about on top of dirt and rocks with patients ranging from infants to adults, all with broken bodies being mended by the adept hands of the medical teams. We were lucky to stay there. The hospital had rooms for us with beds and bathrooms. When we first started our trip we were prepared to sleep in a tent on sleeping bags in the middle of Haiti if we had to. But as luck would have it, that was not the case.
Upon our arrival, we jumped into medical scrubs and started working. Tanya assisted in the operating room, mopping up blood from an amputation which was performed on a young woman whose arm was infected. This, we found out, was the norm. A limb being taken to save a life was standard procedure in the aftermath of the quake. We witnessed it first hand on our first day. Later on that afternoon, a 6 month old baby died from internal infections. And so our trip started.
Dominican Republic Military Guards
The next day we discovered that the military was posted around the hospital to keep the patients from leaving. The local military chief stopped by to say that they were going to close the hospital to Haitian patients in 2 weeks. The medical staff was extremely upset, and were now rushed to care for the sick only to send them away.
Politics once again played a role. It seems that the DR's patience had run out for the Haitian community, and was chasing them out of the country. There was never any love lost between the two, but in a time of a disaster, you hope that barriers would be dismantled. That was not the case, and this particular hospital was in danger of being shut down much sooner than it had anticipated.
The Trip into Haiti
Paul returned on Wednesday morning to take us into Port au Prince. We had medical supplies and food we wanted to distribute. Heading into Haiti our first stop would be the orphanage. Our mission was to find a Haitian village that we could help rebuild or support, and we decided we would devote ourselves to helping these orphans. It was a 2 hour trip that rocked all of my senses. The border alone was enough to make you weep. People crawling all over each other, trying to buy food, ship food, sell food, and the border guards patrolling amongst the smells and dust. On our way into the city, we saw tents everywhere, along the side of the roads, and in open spaces. This was just the beginning.
We arrived at the orphanage
compound encircled by a gate, and when it opened, we were greeted with
dancing, smiling, singing children that brought an overwhelming feeling
of happiness as well as grief to all of us. They sang a
song that they had created, singing in French. The words
were of praise and hope for a better future; that we would help them
rebuild their roof that had collapsed in the quake, and get them beds to
sleep on. We shed tears for the millions of people who
were suffering. http://www.youtube.com/watch?
When they finished, we gave the Reverend rice, bandages, anti-bacterial ointments, baby formula, and an array of other things that they had never seen before. They cried for joy! I understand why people work in disaster relief because there is no other feeling like giving to those who need it most, directly from your hands to theirs.
We stayed for some time at the orphanage located in Croix des Bouquet, outside Port au Prince, in a bustling community, but eventually headed into the city.
Port au Prince
The drive took us longer than we expected and Paul was striken by what he saw. He said the streets of Port au Prince had gradually over the last 5 years become full of people selling their goods, but this was nothing like he had ever seen before. There were military trucks everywhere, with troops carrying machine guns, and they were from every nation. Stopping at the US Embassy we spoke with the marines who were on guard duty. I identified myself as the mother of a US marine, and they were happy to see us. They said "glad to see Americans." I asked them how they felt about being there and one young marine responded by saying "When they told me I was going to Haiti, I was excited. I thought I would be helping people but all I am doing is standing around in the heat with a gun. I'm ready to go home."
And that's what they were
doing. Everywhere. In trucks, humvees, on
the streets, standing around in flak jackets with guns. Or
sitting in the trucks with guns. While the Haitian people
were digging themselves out. I couldn't believe my eyes,
even though I half expected to see this scene. The streets
were teaming with dust, people, cars, motorcycles, dogs, goats, cows
and military vehicles. The smell ranged from putrid to
horrific. And mixed in was some food cooking. http://www.youtube.com/watch?
There were makeshift tents everywhere, people living on top of the rubble of destroyed buildings, with traffic all around them. The feeling in the air was one of desperation, even though those living on the streets were trying to put their lives back together. As far as the eye could see people were moving around, bathing, eating, sleeping, talking, singing, getting on with their lives.
The history of Haiti is one of constant upheaval, and oppression. On top of the abject poverty already in existence, people are living in the rubble of homes they were attempting to rebuild. Every single structure for miles had been damaged in one way or another. As we drove up the mountains, we saw Haitians still digging themselves out. Not once, and I mean not once, did I see anyone else helping them. They had small shovels, or buckets; they carried wood or bags of cement on their heads back to where their homes once were, trying to rebuild.
Where Has All the Help Gone
The world wept for Haiti on the evening of January 12th, and immediately donation lines were set up by every single NGO and then some, to collect donations to "help Haiti." Over $644 million, and possibly more, was collected worldwide.
The United States government announced that they would send $100 million in aid to Haiti, a fraction of the costs of the occupations being conducted in the middle east; and 2,200 marines, which then climbed almost immediately to 22,000 marines, soldiers and sailors. The troops began landing in Port au Prince on Sunday, January 17th, five days after the devastating quake. Defense Secretary Gates told reporters on a flight to India there would be a security element to U.S. relief efforts, but added: "I haven't heard of us playing a policing role at any point." Asked about rules of engagement, he said "as anywhere we deploy our troops, they have the authority and the right to defend themselves." "And they also have the right to defend innocent Haitians and members of the international community if they see something happen," he said. So much for humanitarian aid.
With the critical need for doctors and supplies, the US government chose to send in troops. What I personally witnessed was just the opposite of what Secretary Gates announced. The troops were policing. If they were participating in any relief efforts, it was minimal. Everywhere we drove we saw Italian, French, Canadian, and US military personnel and vehicles. Most of the time holding up the traffic, causing more congestion than was necessary, and not completely participating in relief efforts.
The non-military personnel were helping the most in the hospitals and clinics, as we found out not only with the DR hospital, but on our trip to the Haiti National Hospital close to the military controlled airport.
On our second day in Port au Prince, we transported medical staff to the orphanage to examine the 53 children who needed care. From there we travelled back into the epicenter of the quake. We got inside the National hospital, and spoke with the Chief of the Emergency Clinic. Since there were so many doctors at the hospital back in the DR, there was a possibility of getting some of the staff to the Haitian side if they needed more hands. Which they did. One month later, this hospital, that turned no one away, was overflowing with patients, inside and outside. Of course guarding it were marines and soldiers, who escorted us around the grounds. We saw hundreds of people mostly with leg, arm, body casts, broken jaws, facial restructuring with metal rods, and other monumentally horrible injuries. The mood in the hospital of profound despair, not only the medical staff but the patients. Although it was teaming with people, it was relatively quiet.
That's when it finally hit me. Between the oppressive heat and extreme dust in the air, I started to feel sick. Had this really happened? How would these people ever recover from this mess? Why aren't there more people helping? Where is all the aid and money donated from around the world? Why are they struggling so much, and are they angry or sad or both? This Country is ripe for revolution.
Driving back to the orphanage to pick up the rest of our team of medical staff, it started to get dark. There was no electricity throughout the city, and only random lights run by local generators. The orphanage was dark and the children were waiting for us outside. Massive mosquitoes swarmed us as we headed back for the border. However, it was 8 pm, and the border closed by 6 PM when the gates are locked. We were 2 hours away.
Once we arrived at the border gates the guards refused to unlock them. However, a medical technician with us brought medical face masks. He said the guards always needed them and our gift might get us through. Within a few minutes of showing them the masks, they opened up the lock, and allowed us safe passage.
Back to Port au Prince
On our third day into the epicenter, we once again transported medical staff, but this time they were four medical students. They had travelled on their own dime to help, and by now the hospital in the DR had less than 80 patients, and too many doctors. Our stop at the orphanage was a regular visit now, but these med students carried with them enough shoes, toys, candy and some soccer balls for the kids. The Reverend lined up the children, smallest first, and they received shoes, which they had asked for the day before. We gave them candy, and left for the national hospital while they were singing goodbye.
We drove past the palace again to show them the devastation and the tent city set up right across the street. I also wanted to hand out whatever medical supplies and food I had left in the bags, and thought that doctors in scrubs might do the trick. But when we arrived, people swarmed the truck. Leaving quickly, we took the med students to the national hospital. The marines let us in and we saw the Chief of the ER, who took all four of our passengers immediately and put them to work on setting up a new medical tent since 1,000 more patients had come in that day. One woman had her lower body crushed by the quake, but did not seek medical treatment until then and reports of typhoid and malaria outbreaks had just surfaced. The medical students thanked us for taking them there and told us that we had just helped save more lives.
We made our way to Paul's home to meet his mom and sister, who had prepared a Haitian meal for us. Their home was untouched, but his mother refuses to sleep inside any longer, so they pitched a tent in their front yard. She thanked us and was grateful that people like us would be willing to come there to help. She said, speaking French that we are all human and we must all care about one another especially in times of tragedy and for caring about the Haitian people enough to give up our time and spend it with them.
Winding back down the mountain on the rubble lined streets, we saw a few bulldozers that were being operated by people in the community. They worked on a few homes together to remove a building that hadn't yet fully collapsed. We stopped on the side of the road, watching them carrying shovels, cement and trowels, and the small dozers picked up rocks to dump in the truck. In the 3 days that we traveled, this was the first time I saw any heavy equipment . However, the Haitians were helping themselves with no one from other countries visible.
Left with two duffle bags of supplies Paul took us to visit a doctor, who was a friend of his family, Dr. Margarette Blaise Jean, who is a pediatrician at Unitemedicale De Lilavois, on the outskirts of Port au Prince. As we drove up to her clinic, we saw a small tent city outside the property. Dr. Margarette told us, in perfect English, how much she and her husband, Philippe, appreciated people coming to her country to help in whatever way we could. We took our supplies out and she wept with joy saying that she would be able to bring them to the tent city next to her. She had been caring for them, especially the women and children. The peroxide bottles, and bacitracin ointment were needed, but the feminine hygiene pads made her night since the women were always searching for them.
The Border Patrol
On our way back, once again it was dark and we were 2 hours late. The border had closed and this would be our third night of trying to get the gates open for us. Paul rushed us to the Haiti side of the border, but they wouldn't let us pass through this time. They said they had "orders" not to let anyone cross over to the DR side. We knew why. Paul told them what we had been helping in Haiti, and the guards again asked for our identification. I gave them my husband's NYPD Lieutenant identification card, and immediately they let us through!
We got to the DR gate and on the opposite side was our friend Jonathan who the night before had the face masks. He said the "commander" had kept the key that night, and the gate couldn't be opened. Again, we knew why. Then a guard said in Spanish "if we could fit through the hole in the fence, we could come in." I looked down to see a 2 ft. opening which my daughter could fit through, but I doubted I could.
It was the only way in that night, unless I wanted to sleep amongst the trucks and people trying to get across, so we laid down on the ground and shimmied our way in, laughing hysterically. We laughed so hard I couldn't move and was wedged between the poles. The Haitians, laughing as well, started to push me through. I made it, to the sound of applause, laughter and congratulations in 3 different languages!
A Week Was Worth It
Heading back to our base at the Good Samaritan Hospital in Jimani, we realized we had made new friends, and had brought whatever help we could to people in dire need of more.
Tyler and another friend remain at the Orphanage Notre-Dame of Perpetual Souls. Our mission now is to rebuild it through donations, help and hopefully more people who want to spend time doing the most important work that's possible.
For videos and pictures please check my blog at http://elaine.worldcantwait.net

15 Comments so far
Show AllElaine Brower is another person that just doesn't get it.
She's willing to travel all the way to Haiti to give medicine and supplies to people but probably hasn't given one red cent to help anyone in her own town.
"Screw America I'm giving my money to Haiti" right?
In America we identify with people far away much easier than we do with people in our own neighborhood.
There is no accountability for the money going to Haiti. Have any cargo ships or airlines volunteered free services to help the relief effort? Hell no because the American middle class is expected to shoulder the entire burden. Not only that, but 30% (or more) of everything you donate is going to line the pockets of those capitalizing on the disaster. WAKE UP.
Haiti is not our friend and never has been. There are PLENTY of other nations providing help. Withdraw all support immediately to Haiti. If you want to give away money, donate to a learning institution in your town. Help American homelessness. Give to scholarship funds. Do ANYTHING to help your own country. Use your head.
Since Ms. Brower is so keen on helping Haiti and forsaking her own nation, it's fair that she be given Haitian citizenship and barred from returning to the USA. (the country she cares so little about)
I really hate to justify your comment with a reply, but you don't know who I am or what I do for my community, my family, my friends, or this country. Sending a son off to 3 tours in immoral wars of occupation and aggression is just about enough for me. Time to give back to the world.
Sioux Rose
ELAINE: I HONOR You and your generous gift to others. I apologize on behalf of one of the posters. As you probably know, so many are angry in the U.S. due to the unfair policies of elites, policies that are doing a good job of setting those who feel powerless against each other. Many feel they must fight with others in the same boat... for relative crumbs. Still, ALL of us (for the most part) are so much better off then our Haitian neighbors, and now our Chilean neighbors. Americans use a disproportionate share of global resources, a fact that forms a chain reaction with direct impact being climate change (in part due to so much "development" of previously pristine sanctuaries, once safe spaces for the elemental kingdoms).
Maybe if you had raised hm better he wouldn't have gone off to 3 tours of killing people. I stand by my resolve.
Sioux Rose
LORAX: With all due respect your jingoism will kill your spirit. Elaine went precisely because, as you put it, "There is no accountability for the money going to Haiti." So she bravely and selflessly elected to give what little she could. Not only am I grateful for her work, and her account of what's actually going on over there; in reading it, it makes me wonder if I would have the resources to do some of the good work she's doing. In other words, shades of what Thoreau said to his buddy when he was arrested for his conscientious objection to war via tax "evasion," why aren't the rest of US over there, or in his case, in jail? Her altruism is remarkable, and all too rare.
Meanwhile, the US military is abhorrent. They stand around with their meals on hand, while others starve and suffer? Is that part of the "Be all you can be" prescription? It makes one believe there is more than rumor to this idea of elites wanting to genuinely reduce populations.
CEE MIRACLES: Moving post. I hear you.
You dishonor the Lorax. Why did you choose that name? The Grinch (whose heart was two sizes too small) would have been a more appropriate choice.
Joe
A woman and her daughter travel all the way to Haiti to distribute what help they can from 5 duffle bags of food and medical supplies. They view a massive scene of struggling humanity in conditions that are appalling.
In the meantime, 22,000 U.S. troops stalk around, sit in trucks, and while away the time with their heavy weapons always with them.
Contempt ... past contempt ... for my government, the President, the military, the nauseating constancy of words about American values and Christian principles and standing for the right, human rights, generosity, helping others ... and on and on and on.
I just saw "Avatar," and the Americans represented, except for a few, are dead-on in terms of their inhumanity, their insanity, their greed, their selfishness, their unconsciousness, their stupidity, their cruelty, their depravity and their indifference to the pain of others and the horrors and pain they themselves cause.
Why haven't maybe ten of these soldiers in Haiti been moved to act on their own initiative, deciding among themselves to do hands-on help and then convince/inspire their buddies to help too? A thousand troops out of 22,000 could sure do a lot.
Well, they are under orders to sit tight and keep order. Why haven't they revolted, and said, "We are going to help because this is crazy for us to just sit here."
It is now a month and a half since the earthquake. Houses are still lying on the ground in pieces, and rubble is all over the place. Strong young bodies could have done or still could do much to salvage wood and stack it, move stones and broken cement shards into some kind of order ... in other words, help the Haitian people clean up the debris. Instead of sitting in the trucks, the trucks could be used to carry away the debris to a few chosen locations outside of the city.
Who is in charge of our soldiers? ... The President of the United States, as Commander in Chief! Oh, but he's busy ordering the killing of other people in several countries and turning their homes and living areas into rubble.
Well, you get the picture. We are insane for tolerating the government that we have. Our government is insane and impotent in helping our own people. Money has been wasted on a bloated, humungous, costly bureaucracy called Homeland Security, and the quality of its efficiency and help is reflected in a famous hurricane named Katrina, and the record of helping in that event is deplorable ... and still. And Gangster Banksters and Corporate Thugs control the politics of mice and ineffectual, screwy old politicians and get away with major crimes.
The rainy season is coming to Haiti. Mud and mudslides from the hills will kill many of the Haitian people, along with typhoid, cholera, malaria, starvation, whatever. Is that part of the plan? The developers are around looking at the beaches just as they did in New Orleans.
Who is in charge? ... Oh, another puppet government of the U.S.A. who seems best at doing disappearing acts or making stupid decisions that increase the chaos and do not help the people, but, from what I've read, I'll bet they personally are benefiting from all the donations coming in.
"Avatar" ... It is as if those who govern us are from another planet and seem to take special delight in ravaging and abusing the planet all of us live on and killing off lots of people to get at whatever treasures they want to get at. Actually it is a film about the dark, dark shadow side of the History of the U.S. of A., and that dark, dark shadow side is beginning to blot out all the light of the bright side.
Psychopathic people, their pimps, their shills, their robotic followers, and an incredible number of stupid, ignorant, incompetent, greedy, fanatic, self-serving people are in charge. Somehow we have to get rid of them before it is too late for everybody.
Beyond contempt, cm
P.S. ... but blessings on you, Elaine and Tanya, and all the others who are voluntarily helping, for demonstrating the true humanity of The Possible Human.
Great great comment.
Joe
.
the national rifle association sent some of its members to haiti after its earthquake to offer security assistance. when the authorities told them that the last thing the haitians needed was guns and ammo, the members stammered around a little bit, but would offer no other assisstance. when pressed to help. the n.r.a. members did not oblige, but said, "earthquakes don't kill people, buildings do".
Elaine Brower does get it. She's a citizen of the world, not just of the United States. How do I know this? Because I know her. She is a true humanitarian. Her compassion does not extend only to those who live within the USA. You, The Lorax, write: "Use your head." You need to use your heart. Elaine uses her head, her hands, and her heart.
While the desire to help Haitians rebuild their society is admirable, it is one more instance of disaster "tourism"
America (and the west) now view disasters through the eyes of well-meaning news people and disaster tourists who have no idea what they are looking at. I don't need Anderson Cooper or Ms Brower to tell me what is going on in Haiti.
Haitians need employment to begin the long rehabilitation process. Well- meaning "volunteers" are taking "jobs" away from Haitians. Haitians can be paid several dollars per day to do the work of Ms. Brower (and family). When a Haitian earns several dollars, it is used to redevelop the informal private sector (micro financing). Thousands of Haitians employed for several dollars per day means thousands of micro businesses and a return towards normalcy.
Additionally, US Medical Schools should have courses and rotations for doctors who want to "volunteer" for disaster work. Unfortunately the US military gains this expertise through war conditions. Port au Prince is not appropriate for a Harvard Medical student who has barely been out of Cambridge. Disaster work requires seasoned medical experts. This can be developed before the disaster - never at a disaster.
The real tragedy of Haiti is just beginning. The entire subsistence economy which supports 90% of Haiti has been destroyed. Free food, clothes and medicine will serve as a bandage, but the day will come when Haitians must move beyond disaster dependency.
There were immediate reports of farmers "eating" their seed. Actually, farmers were selling their seed into the Haitian market where there was an immediate need for any food (including seed). Two thirds of Haitians are small farmers - now without seed. The rains are beginning and there has been little to no planting this season. Haiti will be dependent on food aid for several planting seasons. And, if you did save your seed, you cannot compete with free food from the US and other donors. The agricultural sector, home to a large part of the population has been destroyed.
PVOs and donor governments must shoulder the blame for the destruction of the Haitian economy. There have been hundreds of disasters over the past thirty years. In far too many instances, the local or real economy has been destroyed by good intentions.
In 1986, Africa ran out of seed. Many ask why Africa cannot feed itself. The well meaning destruction of local economies by aid organisations and donor countries should be examined.
Planning for future disasters must start today, before the next disaster. There is expertise that should be used for this planning.
And, we must end disaster tourism by celebrities, news orgnisations and well-meaning volunteers like Ms. Brower. It is time to get serious about the next Haiti.
ducksawce, I believe your comment is a sincere attempt to analyze the problems of Haiti. But perhaps it would be a good idea to read the history of Haiti when France claimed it as a colony and the United States took over after that.
The claim, for example, way back when, that Columbus "discovered" America, and came upon friendly, generous populations of several million people, it did not take very long to exterminate good portions of those populations. Columbus and his crew were after gold. There was very, very little gold on the island countries of Hispaniola [now Haiti and the Dominican Republic], but the native peoples were enslaved and made to dig for gold and were treated vilely and cruelly and many of them were taken back to Spain to be slaves. In not too many years there were 1,500 people of the original population left, and then maybe 500.
The white, Catholic and then Anglican, colonial powers of Europe overran the worlds of brown and black people. Remember, that at one time "the Sun rose and set on the British Empire," meaning that at that time the English had conquered and/or set themselves up as the Great White Fathers [emphasis Male] of wherever they went all over the globe.
The people who came to America from England and then western Europe had the same mentality that many still do: There is a superiority of the Christian religions and a superiority of having white skin, as if skin color was an indication of a well-functioning, intelligent brain. NOT! OBVIOUSLY!!! And these "superior" folk were big on SLAVERY! of brown and black people.
Yellow people were brought to the U.S. or came here and were the "coolies" who did backbreaking labor to build the railroad systems that connected the western U.S. to the eastern U.S. Their treatment and the conditions they lived in were similar to all those "inferior" people who came before them.
================
The Haitian farmers grew rice and vegetables and the people, when left alone as Haitians, ATE quite well and could export rice. You do know about NAFTA and the so-called "free" trade policies that have been in effect for quite some time now -- Multi-national Corporate Rule and ownership of land. The multi-nationals ... read U.S.A. and western European old colonial powers gobble up land, put local industries out of business, and the native peoples, wherever they are, end up trapped and working for slave wages. Right now African land is being gobbled up by multi-nationals. Various African countries also have untapped minerals up the ying-yang and its lands are being bought up by Monsanto and other such giants. Genetically-modified seed is being planted on thousands of acres, seed that requires oil-based fertilizers to grow. And those crops will be harvested and exported to the greater world. The local farmers? ... Africa, India, Asian countries, and other countries, like Haiti, formerly under the flags of Great Britain, France, Spain, the Netherlands, Belgium, et al., are not only out of business, but they can't even feed their families because the land itself has been ruined, and they don't own it anymore. Forget it and them.
In the late 1980's when I read that representatives of about seven major chemical corporations from the United States and western European countries were in Asia and in India and in Africa and elsewhere buying up all the indigenous seed from local farmers, giving them 50 bucks and the new "magic" seed that would give them better yields of rice and wheat and other grains, my hair felt like it was standing on end. Unbeknownst to the farmers was that hybrid seed would not reproduce more seed and required oil-based/chemical fertilizers for hybrid seed to grow. I knew these poor people's doom was sealed. Do you know the suicide rate of farmers in India because they can't even feed their families? The indigenous corn seed of Mexican farmers has been replaced now by GMO corn. Same here in the United States, and family farms have gone under one after the other.
When I read this back then about Corporations buying up seed and land, I said, "Oh, my god. These corporations will control all the food production" for export. Control the food production and distribution. Control the water by privatization. Control the land and its use. Control the utilities. ... CONTROL. CONTROL. CONTROL. Obviously MAKING MONEY, REAPING HIGH PROFITS ARE THE OBJECTIVES. What happens to the lives and livelihoods of indigenous peoples as they are replaced by CORPORATE INDUSTRIES is not a consideration.
In Haiti, like elsewhere, you'll find the poor people and the farmers and their families in the cities, working for the one or two bucks a day they can earn to keep themselves alive. It's not that they prefer it that way. It's that their life choices have been delimited by the greed of very rich people, shakey, often cruel and corrupt governments under the influence of unscrupulous major powers, such as the U.S. of A. and multi-national Corporate HOGS.
======== MORE ==========
======== CONTINUED =========
Read the history of Haiti. Who the U.S. supported; who they brought down and why. Many good essays appeared right here on Common Dreams just after the earthquake, providing good summaries of the history of Haiti, and especially after the U.S. "took over" from France when Haiti became "independent."
And when disasters come "the Ghouls," of "Shock Doctrine" Capitalism are ready to swarm in to exploit the situation for Corporations and financial institutions of the Western powers, primarily the United States. And Haiti has minerals and maybe even a pocket or two of oil.
And the celebrities who are raising money for the Haitian people in their current disaster? Good for them! A lot more and a lot better than 22,000 U.S. soldiers sitting in trucks.
===================
On the medical situation after the earthquake: that U.S.-depicted monster, Cuba, got there first with three field hospitals and that country's marvelously skilled doctors and nurses. You didn't hear a word about that on "our" news channels. Later Israel set up a field hospital. That was all over the news. All I could think of was the Israeli doctors with their skills and medicine treating the poor Haitians, with the public relations people ramping up the praise, but in their very small country of Israel, the indigenous people, called Palestinians, are being exterminated, and have been driven into a small area called Gaza where they are bombed and starved and deprived of health care and medicines and you name it. And it isn't an earthquake that bull-dozed down their homes and ripped up their farms and has left rubble wherever it rumbled. No, it is the Israeli DEFENSE FORCES, the IDF, intent on murder. HYPOCRISY, thy name is Israel; thy name is the United States of America.
And the young, newly minted Harvard doctors and medical people who went to Haiti to help. They have training and they could offer more hands and help. Nothing wrong with that under the circumstances.
=======================
Yes, future planning would be good, ducksawce. It just depends on who is doing the planning and why.
You say: "PVOs and donor governments must shoulder the blame for the destruction of the Haitian economy. There have been hundreds of disasters over the past thirty years. In far too many instances, the local or real economy has been destroyed by good intentions."
Read some history about the "good intentions" for Haiti and the Haitian people, ducksawce, and whose intentions and what intentions they were and are. Read about the cruel governments of Haiti -- the Duvaliers, father and son. Read about Aristedes who was returned to power by the Clinton administration, who was then toppled by the GWBUSH regime, and is in exile. Read about the governnments of Haiti that the U.S. favored and supported, and the ones they didn't and toppled and why.
Do understand that if you get your information from television news, it is distorted, incomplete, and in many cases worse than nothing because Truth is missing. That's the value of learning on your own, and you have to read background history and some foreign newspapers to get up to speed. But then when some U.S. MSM announcer says something, you will be able to say, "That's a lie" or "That's only a little bit of the story. The important facts are left out."
Look what's happening to us, the people of the United States. We are confused as the Haitians have been rendered confused, and over the years the poverty and the struggle has gotten worse for them. That's what is happening to us now, not to the extent the Haitian people have suffered, but it can happen. ... And what are we going to do about it? "Elect" the same people who got us in this mess in the first place? Rise up. Succumb. Even though most of us still have much more to work with, we have been rendered about as powerless as the Haitians in terms of their choices for good government, as it seems very few in positions of power are listening to We the People anymore and we, like the Haitians, are under Corporate Control more than anything else.
It's all connected, ducksawce. It's all connected.
peace, cm
The Cal Earth Institute is trying to raise money to send people to Haiti to teach them to build houses of earth. With only a few weeks' instruction, locals could build simple, durable earthquake and hurricane-resistant housing at little cost beyond labor.
The structures have been approved in California's high-seismic zones, not 20 miles off the San Andreas Fault.
Something of this nature seems to me the most productive kind of charity available. Such knowledge helps people try to put themselves out of harm's way, including out of the way of the IMF.