EMAIL SIGN UP!
Most Popular This Week
- Eve of Destruction (or How to Destroy a Planet Without Really Trying)
- The World Economy Is a Ticking Time Bomb (and The Fuse is Burning)
- 'We Are Movement, Not a Moment': North Carolina Peaceful Uprising Continues
- President Obama Uses a Sledgehammer Against Dissent
- 'Beyond Orwellian': Outrage Follows Revelations of Vast Domestic Spying Program
- Eve of Destruction (or How to Destroy a Planet Without Really Trying)
- The World Economy Is a Ticking Time Bomb (and The Fuse is Burning)
- Is Enbridge Building a Secret Keystone Pipeline?
- President Obama Uses a Sledgehammer Against Dissent
- Victory: Connecticut Becomes First State to Require GMO Labeling
Popular content
Today's Top News
Boycott America
If, like me, you're a fan of the Financial Times weekend edition you've probably read Tyler Brûlé's Fast Lane column, even if you don't approve of the products and destinations he tends to push, or of his once-over-lightly approach to life in general. Sometimes I'm embarrassed to find myself enjoying Fast Lane, since Brûlé is mostly about surfaces - how things look, rather than what they really are - and his mad dashes by air and rail around the world often leave me wishing that he would sit still and express no opinions at all.
But lately I've come to take Brûlé's globalized views on consumption more seriously. For one thing, he really does have a good sense of what's right about a hotel, city or airline, as well as what's terribly wrong. Now, with the absurd, Bushian overreaction to the Christmas Day terrorist attempt, Brûlé has come up with a remedy for American stupidity that I find altogether brilliant: Boycott the United States.
Nothing else seems to be waking up the country: not electing a phony reformer as president; not gutting the economy with worthless mortgages, reckless banking and "free trade," not invading countries where no one is interested in our corrupted approach to "democracy" or in our "value system." No, we need outside pressure to save us, and Brûlé has offered a fine strategy.
Granted, Brûlé has a narrow interest, which is comfort and ease in airports and on airplanes. Mainly, he's responding to complaints from business travelers who want to cancel or put off trips to the land of the supposedly free and the home of the allegedly brave. Obviously, no one in his or her right mind wants to endure the added hours of waiting, the full-body searches and the arbitrary carry-on rules that the Transportation Safety Administration has now put in effect.
A friend, the mother of two young girls, tells me that on her flight back to New York from a vacation in Costa Rica, she was forbidden for the last hour of the journey to cover her sleeping 2-year-old in a coat or a blanket, so she had to remove the cover every time the flight attendant walked by, then put it back on. Two weekends ago, I nearly canceled what should have been an easy round-trip to Montreal, so fearful was I of delays by Newark Airport "security" (someone had shut down the airport a few days earlier when another passenger observed him sneaking into a terminal boarding area from the TSA-supervised exit lane, evidently to kiss his girlfriend goodbye). At first, I was pleasantly surprised that the Canadians apparently feel that they have nothing to fear from incoming New Yorkers; I got to the airport far earlier than necessary, zipped through security with my carry-on bag (a bag, by the way, recommended by Tyler Brûlé) and used the lavatory on my Air Canada flight just 20 minutes before landing.
Returning to New York the next day was another matter. I was compelled to check my carry-on (for some reason, they were allowing laptops only), told I couldn't board with a plastic bag carrying newspapers or books and was given a full-body frisk, front and back, once I got past the U.S. border guards stationed in Trudeau Airport. This was time-consuming, annoying and incoherent. Other passengers on my flight boarded with carry-on bags, and when I complained to the Air Canada gate clerk, she threw up her hands and said she didn't know the rules (presumably, the "rules" were being imposed on Canada by U.S. Homeland Security).
Brûlé isn't just a critic; he has good suggestions for improving airport security, such as better pay for screeners. Not only would this attract "brighter, more service-minded souls," but it would also build a higher-quality team who could be educated in the rudiments of good police work. (Brûlé would probably concur with a letter writer to the FT that whatever search techniques are applied, "the only serious way to screen travelers is at the boarding gate," since airports are filled with low-wage, high-turnover service workers who can't be thoroughly vetted.)
As dynamic as it is, though, Brûlé's radical idea "to stop flying on U.S. airlines and to shun the U.S." is too limited. As he correctly notes, "there's nothing like a lost commercial opportunity to get the U.S. thinking differently," and "a crippled civil-aviation sector is not good news for the likes of Boeing and its suppliers." But why stop at forcing America to make jet-plane travel less unpleasant and keep Boeing stock high? Why not go beyond the improvement of airport security?
As everyone in our promised land must have noticed by now, the public-school system is shot, the trains are slow and infrequent, medical care is an expensive crap shoot and lots of people are out of work. How serious is the crisis? Well, national security begins at home, and the misspelling (typo, if you're charitable) by somebody in the State Department of Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab's name, after his father warned our embassy in Nigeria about the terrorist danger his son posed, is emblematic of a deeper education crisis in America that is causing "intelligence failures" beyond the bungling of the computer match that might have revoked Abdulmutallab's U.S. visa.
These intelligence failures are most glaring in big, bloody, self-defeating disasters such as the American war in Afghanistan. But they're also manifest, less obviously, in your own hometown. These days, the worst local intelligence failure I can think of is the proposal by New York's Metropolitan Transportation Authority to eliminate free passes for students. Brilliant! Just when we need more people who know how to spell, the public transit system in the city with the biggest school system is discouraging kids, especially poor ones, from getting to class. Not only do schools teach spelling, but many also offer typing courses. I'll never forget my father insisting that I learn how to touch-type fast and accurately. If I did, he insisted, I could always get a job - presumably, even in the U.S. State Department.
Whatever the effect of "Boycott America" on plane travel, don't end it unless we continue free bus and subway travel for schoolchildren in New York. The security of the homeland demands it.
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...


50 Comments so far
Show AllBoycott Corporate America who buy off Congress and support the Amerikan war-machine. Let Boeing go belly-up (sorry, workers, but sacrifice is demanded). Close down bases. Pull troops from wars instead of surges.
Serve the people and consumers instead of exploiting them or face the consequences big business!
Love the title John but you didn't go near far enough.
Gary
The irony is, to fully boycott America, you'd have to stop buying Chinese crap... ;-)
NC-Tom: Excellent point!
Stop buying Chinese? I HAVE!
A few years ago I moved to a city. I had to buy some kitchen supplies and wound up buying dishes from a one of those stores that stocks linens and housewares, and then flatware from another store. It simply didn't occur to me to be concerned about where this stuff originated. Both were made in China.
Well, the dishes are beginning to look very strange, with discoloration. I started researching this, and it turns out that in all probability it's lead. So, I just began looking for dishes I could buy that are made in America. Decent dishes - not made from plastic - don't seem to exist in this country. There's a large well-known department store in the city where I live, and I went there, expecting to find American-made products. But there aren't any. All the dishes originate in China.
I finally located a store that stocks dishes made in another country and they do NOT have lead. So, I've started to buy, piece by piece, dishes from another country with no lead in them.
Wouldn' t it be nice if I could buy American, without lead?
The same goes for flatware. I'm throwing out what I have and will be buying flatware made in another country.
Wouldn't it be nice if I could buy American, without lead?
Impeachbushco
"Stop buying Chinese" is a nice sentiment but not, I find, to be very practical. My wife just showed me a very nice sweater that she had bought for a very good price on line that was made in China. I had received a nice pair of flannel pajamas [very warm in these winter months] a few days ago that I had purchased on line for only $19.99. They are also made in China and are manufactured by Hanes which apparently have been taken over by the Chinese. My wife did receive a belt that she had bought from Eddie Bauer on line and, to our amazement, was manufactured in the United States. But it would appear that there are so few items that one can purchase these days that are actually made in this country.
"These days, the worst local intelligence failure I can think of is the proposal by New York's Metropolitan Transportation Authority to eliminate free passes for students. Brilliant! Just when we need more people who know how to spell, the public transit system in the city with the biggest school system is discouraging kids, especially poor ones, from getting to class." -- John R. MacArthur
I completely agree! I live in NYC, and when I first read this news, I immediately thought -- who is running this city? The decision made no sense to me!
The MTA also, during the finiancial boom, so to speak, borrowed about $200 million dollars to invest in an Irish hedge fund -- which worked for a while, until the boom went bust. Last time I read a detailed account of this fiasco, the interest payment had ballooned to $12 million, but MTA claimed to still be within their budget. Rate hikes for public transportation -- of course, "we the people" pay for the mistakes of those who make the decisions. I'm waiting to hear who, exactly, made the decision to borrow the money to invest -- the money belonged to "we the people."
And, again this year, we have banksters raking in billions -- on the backs of most of us who live here and elsewhere, across this country.
Kay Johnson--I thought at first the author was joking about the bus passes for students. Now you say the MTA BORROWED MONEY to invest in a hedge fund? I hope New Yorkers find out who authorized something so stupid and simply tar and feather them. Then confiscate all their wealth to subsidize the bus pass.
People wonder how so many got sucked into the mortgage debacle. I would suggest they were following the example set by the top.
I think you will find a lot of us overseas folk have been avoiding American travel in case we get there and find we are on a list.
I would say you are very wise to do that. You never know when you get here you may get snatched up at the border and sent to another country for a rendition that I hear is quite extraordinary. Then when you arrive at that final destination, you will be interrogated in an enhanced way. I don't think even George Orwell could dream up newspeak like that.
Michael Hicks certainly is aware of the pitfalls of traveling on American airplanes. Michael Hicks, a New Jersey native, has been frisked every time he has gone through the inappropriately and ironically named Newark Liberty International Airport because Homeland Security has placed him on its watch list because his name is supposedly similar to someone else whose name is on a security list. Michael Hicks is also eight years old. It turns out, according to last Sunday's Oregonian, that Michael Hicks has had to endure this harassment since he was two years old when security personnel at the airport ordered him to spread his legs and felt at and around his crotch to make sure that this pint size supposed terrorist was not apparently harboring any grenades on his little person.
It should be obvious that al Qaeda and other terrorist organizations have most decidedly won their battle at intimidating Americans and their less than wise leaders. The dictum that FDR issued in the 1930s-you have nothing to fear but fear itself-apparently no longer applies in twenty first century America. Eight year old Michael Hicks knows all too well how true this is.
boycott amerika, don't pay your Federal taxes!!
I have been advocating such a boycott for some time now, but something broader based, and for reasons more far-reaching than are mentioned by MacArthur. Since the American political-media class will not wake up to the reality of the empire's tyrannical rampages across the world, the losses of life and resources and heritage, particularly in the Muslim world, and since the US's allies are too lily-livered (especially since Chirac and Schroeder have left the European scene) to stand up to the bully, consumers the world over should stop buying anything to do with the American economy and insist that their governments sanction the beast. The Boycott, Sanction, and Divest campaign with regard to Israel is fine, but it has to be extended to include the larger problem, USA, if it is to be really effective.
Yes. Boycott America but not because of the inconvenience of going through airline security. That's pathetic.
Airline security is one of the few things our government does right (or at least tries to do right). It's an example of what the government should be doing to protect the public. Most of the money the government spends to supposedly protect us (I suppose it's necessary to point out that that's what "defense" expenditures are for) it spends making enemies in foreign countries and thereby further endangering us.
Flying should be inconvenient. Considering the geopolitical consequences of our dependence on oil imports, flying is a luxury that should be indulged in infrequently. Someone should inform the author that Amtrak can take him from Penn Station to downtown Montreal in 11 hours for $62 with a smaller geopolitical and environmental impact.
We need to get over the idea that there is nothing wrong with flying around on a whim whenever we feel like it. There is certainly nothing wrong with having to endure heghtened security measures while doing it. In fact there is some justice in that since its this kind of extravagent energy consumption that gives the military-industrial complex an excuse to engage in the kind of meddling overseas that creates the security threat in the first place.
"Someone should inform the author that Amtrak can take him from Penn Station to downtown Montreal in 11 hours for $62 with a smaller geopolitical and environmental impact." -- tommy_slothrop
Is the $62 correct -- from Penn Station to Montreal? The last time I went to Philadelphia, from Penn Station, I had to pay more than $140 round-trip. I can't recall what the exact price was to D.C., but it was around $200, I think -- it's a four-hour trip.
Have prices been reduced?
"Is the $62 correct -- from Penn Station to Montreal?"
Yup. I just checked it again. That's one way, though.
The rates between NYC and Philly differ based on the time of day and whether or not you're travelling on the Acela, the "express" train. Right now, the cheapest rates are $45 each way and the most expensive $143 ($208 1st class) each way.
Isn't there still a somewhat cheaper alternative to travel between Philly and NY?
It used to be the case that one could take local SEPTA commuter rail line from 30th Street Station to Trenton, then a PATCO (NJ Transit) from Trenton to NY.
It's been a while, so I can't remember the savings. It's a decent alternative if you check the schedules to get the best connection.
Not so much if there's a service outage, I know from bitter experience-- but that's a risk no matter what you're riding.
· Yr Obd't Servant
"Personally I like the trains. You can sleep or enjoy the scenery, but if you have to get from point A to point B and they are more then 300mi apart, flying is the way to go."
If convenience is the only concern and you don't care about the consequences of your actions.
After my youngest left school, I had ten illuminating years of international travel before voluntary permanent grounding in disgust. When citing the nose-dives in airline profitability, why are Homeland Security harrassments not identified by the media as chief perpetrators?
Oops, I forgot, the media is controlled by those "perpetraitors"!
Seems there is an endless attempt to define the American people as The Enemy.
this is of course CLASSIC FASCISM which is of course a climactic phase of CLASS WAR by the powerful and rich against the people.
"THE LOSS OF liberties at home shall be charged to the waging of foreign wars , and securing our safety against foreign enemies or threats....they always come hand in hand"
JAMES MADISON.
"all foreign wars are really DOMESTIC POLITICS by other means...they are simultaneously wars against the people by the moneyed classes"...LUDWIG von MISES.
"governments always will find enemies - for that way - they will always make the people NEED them for protection...and where there are no enemies...they will create them"...
Vietnamese Buddhist Monk.
Boycotting Amerika may be a difficult thing to do (and impossible for people living in the US!), but selective boycotting is a great place to start.
How about WAlMart? How about McDonalds? How about Fox or USAToday? Selectively chosing to refuse symbolic representations of the Empire is not an insignificant action. Each of us can share our reasons why we won't walk into that WalMart with the people we meet.
We can all deny Caesar at least one pinch of incense - while we can. It may be a small thing for each of us but it is not a small thing for all of us to do.
As we all type our brilliance into Apple Macs and Dell PCs over wide- or broadband connections, enriching AT&T, Verizon, et. al., or into our smart phones or cell phones, enriching Apple, AT&T and Verizon, et. al., before hopping into our Toyotas or Hondas and running down to Whole Foods for groceries.
Look, that's me, too. I'm just saying gladtobeincanada is right. It IS a difficult thing to do. But, gee, gdgoodman: tell us how we can begin to extricate ourselves from the overgrown tentacled swamp that is the Amerikan corporate power structure. It is a step-by-sometimes-painful-step process. But every journey -- even one sidestepping the U.S. -- begins with that first step.
"no gods, no masters" --m. sanger
Way ahead of you.
Cancelled a holiday in San Francisco last year in favor of a trip through northwestern Canada.
This year, heading to a beach in the Caribbean, making damn sure there is no flight touchdown in the continental USA.
Call me when you guys get over your panic.
Actually? Don't.
Welcome to AmeriKKKa.
I've been doing this as best I can for years. I don't buy anything new except for my underwear and toothbrush. All my clothes come from Goodwill or the like. Recycle, reuse and reduce. There are already too many "new" items in the world. If we need furniture, housewares, vehicles, clothes, toys, etc. all can be found pre-used and in good shape. I shop for groceries at the farmer's market in the summer and at a locally owned health food store the rest of the year. I pay a little more for the food, but I pay a lot less for everything else. I've stopped using make-up and nail polish and other female "necessities." I don't drive if I can walk or ride a bicycle to my destination. I restrict the amount of time I use the computer. I don't watch television, don't buy newspapers or subscribe to magizines. The library has all of those for free. Well, except for the television and who needs that drivel anyway? While I do supplement my dogs diet with a good quality dog food, she eats most of what we eat. We only turn on the lights if we're actually in the room and turn them out when we leave. The thermostat is kept at a comfortable level, but you wouldn't want to run around naked in our house in the winter. We use fans in the hottest part of the summer, but I refuse to put in air conditioning. A waste of energy and nobody needs to be THAT cool. I also refuse to allow any store to put my purchases into those horrible and dangerous plastic bags. I save and reuse any jar, carton or wrap I can. We still have a long way to go, but you can reduce a lot of what you use if you just pay a little attention. We NEVER shop at Wal-Mart and haven't for years. We NEVER eat at McDonald's or any of the other toxic fast food places that are on every corner and we haven't for years. We brew our own coffee at home.
I, too, hate flying and it's not because I'm afraid the plane will crash. "Security" has gotten insane. When I think of my 80 year old parents standing in line in their stocking feet I'm outraged. And that's just the beginning. I do, however, fly once every year. I live in Colorado and my grandchildren live in Maine. Considering the time it would take to drive that distance, I fly in order to spend some time with them. I hope one day soon to move back to New England and that will end my relationship with the FAA.
Sioux Rose
BLY: Your post is almost a carbon copy of how I live... although I do fly once or twice a year. If more Americans lived this way, honoring conservation, perhaps the fossil fuels would last longer! And that would give the "Green Revolution" more time to get into gear.
MAY You have your fondest wish to be with your family.. Blythspirit..:-).
there are so many good, kind , conscientuous people in america. like yourself. People like yourself and so many others, including many I have met and become friends with are such wonderful people....i sometimes feel the urge to just HUG someone - and say: I so LOVE americans ...such generous hearted people...and yet when i look around -- it is a place that has become so CORRUPTED that any cohesion towards the greater good and bringing the best out of people rather than encouraging their insecurities and fears is lost. ..and people who would OTHERWISE be such exemplary citizens and human beings ...with real concern and decisions and actions towards betterment for not just themselves but OTHERS ...is lost or become an "endangered species"....or otherwise travel such lonely roads because most everyone else has become so FEARFUL and INSECURE - imposed on them by the system which they themselves have participated in - as part of what they THOUGHT is "the american way"...which has turned out to be UTTERLY CORRUPT and debased and a DESTROYER of things that are worthwhile for life...and simply SUCKS the JOY out of living.
and what dr Martin Luther King Jr said has become truer than ever before:
"WE ARE A NATION OF TECHNOLOGICAL GIANTS and INTELLECTUAL AND MORAL MIDGETS".
it is so sad that america has reduced itself to such a barbaric kind of society pretending to be civilized.
I stopped flying on September 12, 2001 because 4 planes were so easily hijacked and then 2 of them "vaporized".
I stopped flying long before Sept. 12, 2001, because flying was getting to be such a pain in the butt.
I have not flown since October 2001 when I found out that I was a suspect at the age of 65. Also, I am a white haired woman.
During nearly all the ghoulish 8 years of the Bush-Cheney crime family ruling and destroying much of the world, I was convinced that the only way to stop them was for other countries to coordinate an attack on Washington, because nothing was going to happen from within this country. Now, if most other countries would boycott the US because of our offically paranoid national security state making travel next to impossible here, or so unnerving and idiotic that you never want to get on a plane again, that might go a long way toward "waking up America."
On the other hand, maybe America is more awake than many of us ever believe, but are collectively convinced We Can't Do Anything About It. "It" being almost anything you can think of. So the "outside pressure" MacArthur speaks of could possibly go a long way toward shaking us from our slumber, but who is "us"? We don't make the insane TSA policies or any other policies that have made us the terrifying laughingstock of the world. Our misrepresentatives do, and so far we've proven totally incapable of doing anything about THEM.
Boycotting--don't know what to boycott, but I'll say this:
I'll never, ever boycott screenings of my alltime favorite film, West Side Story, when that comes around to independent movie theatres in our area, or on TV!
The irony of this article amuses me. People have an irrational fear of airport security, when will be people get over their irrational fear that brings said airport security?
This excessive airport security came about BECAUSE of people's irrational fears.
The fear most people have these day is not 'irrational." It has been carefully crafted and orchestrated by the MIC.
The 'War on Terror' is a machination of the corpora-fascists who own America.... and they have used it well to terrorize our own citizens into giving up not just their fortunes, but their civil rights and freedom as well.
Ha ha. But, seriously - the word 'boycott' no longer exists.
Because it's impossible to know who actually owns what any more, and the teams are constantly trading players. Plus, most of the teams are multinational, so unless a boycott was, like, off the scale massive and sustained, it wouldn't mean shit to Big Corporation X.
No, if Americans are sick of living in government-produced-and-maintained false-fear, then the first thing to boycott is airport security, not the airports or airlines.
Refuse the searches, bitch loudly in line, cause scenes and raise hell until 'our' government is forced to cede to our demands and stop with all the fear/control bullshit.
Demand No. 1: if there are No Fly Lists, then we want Can Fly Lists - there is no reason the 99.999% of us who are 'good guys' should ever have to be treated, repeatedly, as potential 'evil doers' in a country where we're still presumed innocent until proven guilty.
Frank 1569
Well said. As I attempted to point out in my comment at 10:11 am, if there were No Fly Lists, 8 year olds such as Michael Hicks would not have to worry about being terrorized because he keeps being confused by Homeland Security [now there is a name straight out of Nazi Germany] with being a supposed terrorist whose name appears on one of those infamous No Fly Lists. What makes it even more egregious is that Michael Hicks has had to endure being harassed ever since he reached the terrorist age of 2 years.
I have decided to boycott ALL flying until this nonsense ends!
Cicero: "Freedom is participation in power."
This is another example of the idiosyncratic fluff the CD eds are passing onto the site lately. Two or three grains of ideas worth sifting out of a mountain of scatterbrained excelsior.
Please spare us this stuff.
Wonder how 'stringent' security is on the other side of major air ports where the corporate jets ferry those privileged corporate terrorists and their families and friend in and out without scrutiny in anything like a small Lear to the big jumbo all the while laughing at the public side being stripped searched and harassed.
NC-Tom January 20th, 2010 9:47 am
**The irony is, to fully boycott America, you'd have to stop buying Chinese crap... ;-)**
u wanna execute an economic MAD ?
in that case, all bets are off
"when can china haul the United States before the UN Security Council or to take military actions in retaliation for this low-intensity war that has been waged upon it.?"
http://tinyurl.com/mumupz
We dont need to boycott america, america is boycotting itself!!
We all broke..
Cicero: "Freedom is participation in power."
Amurka isn't boycotting itself. Amurka gentrified itself beyond the means of its formerly working middle-class with the help of that corporately brainwashed formerly working middle-class itself.
Yes, it is ridiculous to fly now. We risk having athlete's foot because we have to take off our shoes and walk where everyone else walked with their fungi everywhere in order to go through security. Even if one carries only carry-on luggage because it's too long and too traumatic to have "real luggage", there is someone to ask "Why don't you have more luggage?" From now on, our naked bodies will be able to be viewed by the entire intelligence community of the entire world. My body is okay, but as I have been loathe to take showers in public even with my fellow basketball players, I hate that my privacy, for something as basic as my naked body, counts for nothing.
I remember a funny scene coming back from Lisbon a few years ago flying Lufthansa (the Germans were mad at we Americans for flying one of their citizens off to be tortured.)Well everybody was getting frisked including the mother with her baby hanging on her chest in one of those slings. The security girl was squeezing the little baby arms, the little baby legs looking for C4 I guess.
My last flight.
I remember the good old days when passengers from Central and South America could come to the good ole U.S.A. and buy everything. Of course, we other passengers from the good old U.S.A., had to wait in long, long lines while these people checked their goods. It was healthy that they found nice bargains in the U.S. Now everyone is just soured from shopping in the U.S. I, for one, would rather pay more in my country of residence than put up with airport security. Of course, I can't get grits in my country of residence; I can't get Coffee-Mate in my country of residence; I can't get good rice in my country of residence; I can't get baking powder in my country of residence...I am really deprived because the only way I can get those things is to try to get past security at the airport with them.
in the MEANTIME _ in CHINA........
where REAL FAMILY VALUES Actually EXIST and are the NORM.....more POWERFUL than the Communist Party, in fact.....
==============
Globalist
Single-Party Democracy
*
E-Mail
* Print
By ROGER COHEN
Published: January 21, 2010
BEIJING — I’m bullish on China after a couple of weeks here and perhaps that sentiment begins with the little emperors and empresses. In upscale city parks and rundown urban sprawls, I’ve seen China’s children pampered by grandparents, coddled by fathers, cared for by extended families.
Scarcity may explain the doting: China’s one-child policy makes children special. But there are deeper forces at work. The race for modernity has not blown apart the family unit, whatever the strains. After witnessing the atomization of American society, where the old are often left to fend for themselves, China feels cohesive.
It’s seeing that most natural of conspiracies — between grandparents and children — flourishing. It’s listening to young women in coastal factories talking about sending half their salaries home to some village in Guangxi where perhaps it goes to build a second floor on a parental house. It’s hearing young couples agonize over whether they can afford a child because “affording” means school, possible graduate education abroad, and a deposit on the first apartment.
The family is at once emotional bedrock and social insurance. “My” money equals my family’s money. All the parental investment reaps a return in the form of care later in life. “Children are a retirement fund,” a Chinese-American friend living here told me. “If you don’t have children, what do you do in old age?”
The Chinese, in other words, might be lining up to play karaoke after long factory shifts, but they’re not bowling alone American-style. They’re not stressing because they’re all alone. That’s critical. There so much heaving change here — China’s planning to open 97 new airports and 83 subway systems in the next five years — the family strikes me as the great stabilizer (even more than the regime’s iron fist).
As Arthur Kroeber, an economist, said, “High-growth stories are not pretty. If you’re growing at 10 percent a year, a lot of stuff gets knocked down.” It sure does: China looms through the dust. But the family has proved resilient, cushioning life for the have-nots, offering a moral compass for the haves (rampant corruption notwithstanding).
After the emperors and empresses, in my bullish assessment, comes the undistracted forward focus. After a while in Asia, you notice the absence of a certain background noise. It’s as if you’ve removed a negative drone from your life, like the slightly startled relief you feel when the hum of an air conditioner ceases.
What’s in that American drone? Oh, the wars of course, the cost of them, and debate around them, and the chatter surrounding terror and fear.
There’s also the resentment-infused aftermath of the great financial meltdown, navigated by China with an adroitness that helped salvage the world economy from oblivion. In the place of all that Western angst, there’s growth, growth, growth, which tends (through whatever ambivalence) to inspire awe rather than dread. The world’s center of gravity is shifting with a seismic inevitability.
I know, China has kept its foot on the gas of its stimulus package too long and there are bubble signs in housing and labor is no longer limitless, with resultant inflationary pressure. I also know there are tensions between state economic direction and market forces, with resultant waste. But my third bullish element is nonetheless an economy entering a 15-year sweet spot where rising disposable income will drive the domestic market.
Think of what Japan, Taiwan and South Korea went through decades ago, but with a population of 1.3 billion. Think of the 10 to 15 million new urban residents a year and the homes and infrastructure they will need. Think of all the stuff the world demands and can’t get elsewhere with the same quality, quantity and price. Think underlying drivers. They remain powerful.
Of course, political upheaval could unhinge all the above. Given that China’s open-closed experiment is unique in history, nobody can say how this society will be governed in 2050. Immense tensions, not least between the rage that corruption inspires and the difficulty of tackling it without a free press, exist. Still, my fourth reason for running with the Chinese bulls is perhaps the most surprising: single-party democracy.
It doesn’t exist. It’s an oxymoron (although a U.S. primary is a vote within one party). It can easily be the semantic disguise for outrage and oppression. But it just may be the most important political idea of the 21st century.
Rightful resistance is growing in China. Citizens are asserting their rights, not in organizing against the state (dangerous) but in using laws to have a say. Nongovernmental organizations are multiplying to advance agendas from the environment to labor rights. This is happening with the acquiescence of smart rulers.
“They know they cannot manage in the old way,” Ma Jun, a leading environmentalist, told me. “They cannot dam the water, but they can go with the flow and divert it to the places they want.”
Whether that place will ever resemble one-party democracy, I don’t know. But I no longer laugh at the idea. Harmonious discord is an old Chinese idea. The extended Chinese family is a daily exercise in just that.
Hi, Roger Cohen,
I, too, am impressed by China. It is more than amazing what they have done in Beijing.
I really like the fact that they don't let their truck drivers drive in the daytime. I wish that Europe would do the same...I hate these truckers with their "governors" set at 90 KPH trying to overtake other truckers with their governors set at 90 KPH, essentially blocking the auto-routes.
When I talked with some people from Beijing who had been in Europe, they really did not understand how expensive it is to live and eat in Europe.
I found China and the Chinese enchanting. It was my best vacation ever!
Hi, Roger Cohen,
I, too, am impressed by China. It is more than amazing what they have done in Beijing.
I really like the fact that they don't let their truck drivers drive in the daytime. I wish that Europe would do the same...I hate these truckers with their "governors" set at 90 KPH trying to overtake other truckers with their governors set at 90 KPH, essentially blocking the auto-routes.
When I talked with some people from Beijing who had been in Europe, they really did not understand how expensive it is to live and eat in Europe.
I found China and the Chinese enchanting. It was my best vacation ever!
One Fundamental problem with America is its MYTH of everything can be HAD under the sun...
"if you work hard enough" as part of that mythology. it is of course, WRONG, and MISLEADING and far from accurate. since america is really a land where to "succeed" is really an EXCEPTION rather than the rule...and
the RULE is "to live to WORK harder and harder" and get VERY LITTLE in return for you labor..whose real results in wealth creation are then sucked upwards to the upper class
which THEN is USED as a MODEL for all americans to EMULATE "if you work hard enough"......
examples of this mythology:
"yes-- yoU CAN be president of the USA"...
"yes you can be a multimillionaire TOO (just play the Lotto everything else fails"...
and so everyone is enjoined to LIVE the HIGH LIFE
even if the wages of americans can't keep up with the "model life" and as a result - the entire country and economy is based on
people living on DEBT.
indedted in education to "get ahead" - where the economy provides them with NO JOBS for all that education and expense and indebtedness - which makes Fannie Mae and its investors happy until of course THEY mismanage THEIR investments and run to the PUBLIC for bail-outs...among otther ongoing bail-outs in the form of "tax breaks" for corporations.
so - in the end - who are the LOSERS always and forever? Americans....
the COURAGEOUS , RUGGED INDIVIDUAL americans who behave like LEMMINGS being led by their COrporate "let's get rich" and "live the high life coz we got the choices in the land of the free and greedy"....
led by their Corporate Pied Pipers who make them sing songs of patriotism and FEAR and RELIGION and "morals"
that are all of them ...FAKE.
all i know - is i DISCOURAGE any relatives of mine from asia to EVER visit the USA or even THINK of going to america unless they absolutely must, say to visit a relative or business or something. i tell them - KEEP YOUR MONEY where it is - in asia. you wanna travel? see the world? education if you can afford? find jobs? go ELSEWHERE in asia, europe, south america.
there are PLENTY of places in the world OUTSIDE of the Land of the Frightened and the land of the Greedy and self-involved ignoramuses.
DON'T FEED the BEAST.