Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Oklahoma City, Columbine, Virginia Tech and Now Ft. Hood
They are each sites where Americans killed Americans in a culture whose violence extends from here to places like Iraq and Afghanistan. They are symptoms of a deep problem not likely to disappear without serious intervention.
Connections exist among the violence here at home and American violence in wars abroad, which indicate a pattern. These incidents are among growing signs that we should analyze carefully, now, before additional warnings happen and perhaps even worsen. The root causes of such eruptions should be studied.
Responses to Ft. Hood could develop into what is described as a "tipping point" in the best-selling book of that title by Malcolm Gladwell. Others describe such a time as a "turning point." Perhaps we could turn away from such extreme violence.
Where might terror strike next and who might be the perpetrator(s) and victims? More students, soldiers, or some other group? How is such domestic terrorism bred and what can we do to interrupt it? It's time to look inside, rather than seek outside scapegoats. Raising haunting questions is more important now than rushing to facile answers and seeking revenge.
At Oklahoma City an anti-government activist detonated the bombing of a federal building. At Columbine two high school students pulled triggers on other students and a teacher. At Virginia Tech a college student killed other college students. At Ft. Hood the suspect is an Army physician who killed five other psychotherapists and an additional eight people, and wounded some 31.
What does it say that a mental health professional seems to have endured so much trauma that he broke under the stress and engaged in a mass shooting? It is too easy to just blame these individuals.
As a former Army officer whose military family gave its name to Ft. Bliss, Texas, who was raised partly near Ft. Hood, this massacre struck close to home. As a college professor, when I read about shooting at schools, I think about my responsibility to help protect students.
The American shoot-‘em-up approach to solving problems is not new, especially in Texas and the remaining Wild West. These recent tragedies have lessons to teach us, so that the likelihood of other such incidents can be reduced.
Rather then merely indict the individuals that committed these heinous crimes, we could benefit from looking beyond them to consider our own responsibilities as citizens to reduce such violence and improve the context that spawns it.
It is easier to demonize the killers, rather than try to understand why these desperate men felt driven to such violence that would likely take their own lives or lead to extreme punishment. Their anguish and agony must have been substantial.
Punishment of the perpetrator alone is unlikely to break the cycle of violence that Americans commit here at home and carry abroad. A careful study of patterns would be more helpful.
The recent violence at Ft. Hood and in the town of Killeen, where it is located, is not new. The area "has been beset by crime and violence since the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq began," according to the "New York Times" on Nov. 10. "Reports of domestic abuse have grown by 75 percent since 2001," it continues. Soldiers come home from combat and beat their wives, sometimes to death. 76 suicides by personnel assigned to Ft. Hood have occurred since 2003.
There is no one to blame other than Americans. We did it. Not Muslims, Arabs, or outside "terrorists." Not external enemies. "We have met the enemy, and it is us," asserts a famous line from a Pogo cartoon from my childhood. It is time for us to reflect on the context that breeds such self-destructiveness.
From the day after the Ft. Hood massacre on Thursday to Sunday I mainly read and clipped many articles, while continuing my regular life. I was especially struck by the heroism of civilian Sgt. Kimberly Munley, who bravely took the shooter down, even as she went down with four bullets in her body.
It was not until Sunday night that I really felt the horror. I became numb, immobilized, depressed.
Fortunately, earlier that day I emailed my Sonoma State University students toput Ft. Hood on the lesson plan for my "War and Peace" class. I wanted to gently encourage them to get beyond denial to express their feelings, develop opinions, and engage in critical thinking. The students were attentive and thought deeply about the implications of Ft. Hood and what it reflects about us as a nation and our future.
"It takes a little while before the grieving starts," reads the last quotation in a Nov. 8 article in our local daily "The Press Democrat." It opened me to my own grief. The words are those of Col. Bill Rabena, who runs the new post-Ft. Hood massacre Spiritual Fitness Center. It offers counseling, soothing music, a religious library and meditation space, among other services, to help survivors cope with psychological trauma.
While I was in the Army during the l960s and the American Wars in Vietnam, Cambodia, and Laos we did not have such centers. So I have felt mainly alone during the some 40 years after my discharge and having to de-militarize myself and deal with my own trauma. I am still recovering and easily triggered, especially by loud sounds.
We need to work to enhance the safety of our students, soldiers, and citizens as a whole, or future similar incidents are likely. Public places-such as schools, government buildings, and even military bases-have become less safe during this 21st century.
Perhaps the Ft. Hood massacre can awaken us to the pain and suffering of our military personnel and the lives that they touch overseas and in their families. On the other hand, a Nov. 16 "Newsweek" column on the new book "American Homicide" by Ohio State professor of history and criminology Randolph Roth notes "that gun and ammunition sales are up nearly 50 percent from a year ago." What does that say about the state of our union and our future?
Now is a time to grieve our national losses and work to minimize such losses in the future. Such collective grief can inform and educate us.
- Posted in

17 Comments so far
Show Allnot listed: Waco.
is the omission because these murders were "legal"?
Good point.
Of course, if we list "legal" murders, pretty much every single non-accidental fatality in all of the last 65 or so years of American military involvements have to be included, and a goodly percentage of those before as well.
With so many supposedly moral killings, it's little wonder people take the judgements of morality onto themselves, badges or no badges.
we see it all around us: the easy "pre-emptive" resort to violence as a solution.
it never is.
Master - thank you for the kind words. To be brave, one must overcome fear, of which I have none in this forum.
Gee, could it be that there is a down side to quiet desperation?
It is interesting that so many should single out this one particular incident as indication that "something is wrong."
It does indicate something wrong, of course. But it is really not clear why shooting up a military base in the United States is more crazy than shooting up a town in Iraq and Afghanistan. Surely Sgt. Kimberly Munley deserves all the citation and applause that might be mustered for her heroism in this event, but assuming she did sign on to fight overseas in a war of occupation, why should I assume that the gunman "snapped" before killing and she did not snap before volunteering?
Surely had Munley been armed, she would have reasonably been excused for shooting the gunman dead on the spot, thereby probably sparing lives and certainly sparing herself 4 bullets she surely did not need.
Does not the same argument absolve the gunman, who shot people destined to participate in an illegal and murderous occupation?
We read that the gunman quietly put his affairs in order before the shooting. If he's crazy, it is not clear how his craziness separates him from the people he shot. Might we not conclude that he was guilty of what was probably a tactical error by shooting underlings when a nonviolent protest would have likely been more effective?
Let us mourn the soldiers, whatever side they imagine that they are on. May we move with caution for the ends of our actions.
Sgt. Kimberly Munley is a civilian Department of Defense police officer at the base.
Still working for the war machine . . .
So STOP the Manifest Insanity of the Obama Bush Wars, NOW!
More evidence that America is dying from within.
It is now so unconsciously repellent that it perversely tires to put itself out of its own misery.
Self administered karmic retribution for the hovering ghosts of the dead and soon to die.
In acts of pure solipsism the murderers assume the role in themselves of a constituted, symbolic America which they internalize, then project outward.
Kill me, before I kill again. I guess someone has to do it.
Expiation of the damned. –(Jill Bains)
If ever there was proof of karma, it is the United States, a country which thinks it can profess modernity, democracy, and humanity at the same time it murders people by the millions overseas, and allows death by raw capitalism and an unfettered gun industry at home.
America is going to keep suffering through these insanely tragic, ironic and horrific incidents until we stop playing the world's policeman and put the domestic arms industry on a leash, something which millions of paranoid idiots are never going to allow. Maybe in another generation we'll get there, unless civil war breaks out first.
Times like these make we wish webshooters were real and bullets were only in the comic books.
I noted above the omission of Waco from the list of American-upon-American murder.
I had also considered Wounded Knee but realized that your people slaughtered would never have felt themselves to be Americans.
Nor should they today.
We are all people on the same planet, no more, no less.
I did not choose the colour of my skin or the country of my birth and need neither to know who I am.
My purpose is to help.
(With a side order of bitter twisted humour.)
"Now is a time to grieve our national losses and work to minimize such losses in the future. "
It is time to ELIMINATE such losses.
Today, most happened thing is, to build the partu communal revolution It is capitalism that killed those soldiers at Ft. Hood, as well as the legions of humans in Iraq. It was rotten, illegitimate imperialism that spawned GWB, and the current war criminal president. We want universal peace, sustainability, equality and affluence, but capitalism cannot bring us even ONE of those desires, It is theoretically and practically impossible in a system based upon domination, and every half-educated person knows it. There are only communist solutions to the world's major problem. Anyone who says otherwise or fails to call it out is a fool, coward, liar, sociopath, or some combination of same.
_____________________________
Christopher here, Remote access computer repair
Capitalism "offers" equality of opportunity,i.e. HOPE©, much in the way a fish is offered the bait.
Socialism provides equality of existence.
lf those men at the processing center had their side arms with them locked and loaded they probably could have taken out the Major before he got more than one or two.