Get News & Views Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Published on Tuesday, August 25, 2009 by CommonDreams.org
Coup Protestor Gang-Raped by Honduran Police
On Friday, Latin America scholars sent an urgent
letter to Human Rights Watch, urging HRW to speak out on
violations of human rights under the coup regime in Honduras and to
conduct its own investigation. HRW hasn't made any statement about
Honduras since July 8.
One of the things Human Rights Watch should be investigating is allegations by Honduran feminists and human rights groups that Honduran police are using rape and other sexual violence as weapons of intimidation against Hondurans nonviolently protesting the coup regime.
The Spanish news agency EFE reports:
The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights -- part of the Organization of American States -- also reported last week it had testimony from Hondurans alleging rape and other sexual violence by the Honduran police. If the IACHR can obtain this testimony, surely Human Rights Watch can obtain it.
One of the victims, Irma Villanueva, told her story to the Jesuit-run Radio Progreso. You can listen to the interview [Spanish] here. Here is an English transcript of the Radio Progreso interview with Irma Villanueva. [Translation by Maria Soledad Cervantes.]
Where is Human Rights Watch?
***
UPDATE: Human Rights Watch put out a very good statement today (8/25), highlighting the IACHR report, noting, among other things, the sexual assault allegations, and urging the U.S. to exert more pressure for the restoration of democracy. Kudos to Human Rights Watch.
Honduras: Rights Report Shows Need for Increased International Pressure
http://www.hrw.org/en/news/2009/08/25/honduras-rights-report-shows-need-increased-international-pressure
One of the things Human Rights Watch should be investigating is allegations by Honduran feminists and human rights groups that Honduran police are using rape and other sexual violence as weapons of intimidation against Hondurans nonviolently protesting the coup regime.
The Spanish news agency EFE reports:
The group Feministas de Honduras en Resistencia said Thursday that is has documented 19 instances of rape by police officers since the June 28 coup that ousted President Mel Zelaya. There have been many other cases of rape, but the women have not reported them out of fear of reprisals, Gilda Rivera, the executive coordinator of the Honduran Center for Women's Rights and head of Feministas, told Efe.
The activists say that women taking part in the resistance to the coup are being targeted. "We've obtained testimonials from women who've been sexually abused, beaten with cudgels on different parts of their bodies, especially the breasts and buttocks," adds the report presented Thursday at a press conference in Tegucigalpa.
The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights -- part of the Organization of American States -- also reported last week it had testimony from Hondurans alleging rape and other sexual violence by the Honduran police. If the IACHR can obtain this testimony, surely Human Rights Watch can obtain it.
One of the victims, Irma Villanueva, told her story to the Jesuit-run Radio Progreso. You can listen to the interview [Spanish] here. Here is an English transcript of the Radio Progreso interview with Irma Villanueva. [Translation by Maria Soledad Cervantes.]
Irma Villanueva: Good afternoon, last Friday we went to the march --
Host: Friday -- you're talking of the march at Choloma
Irma: Yes, that's right. We went to the march, we stayed there a while. All of a sudden we saw like a people stampede coming, -- All was confused, they brought tear gas canisters. Lost myself from my group in the confusion, they started grabbing us - other persons and myself, we were forced into a [police] patrol pickup. They said they were going to Choloma, they came out through some part behind, and I heard them ask a police officer: "Chepe Luis, and this here [woman], where is she going?" "She goes to San Pedro," he answered. -- And then -- only I remained on the flat part [on the bed] of the pickup [starts sobbing] and ... I don't know where they were bound, because, the cop kept me pinned face down, immobilized with his foot on my back [sobs], and they took me to a very cloddy, gritty place [sobs], then took me down and told me "Now bitch, now you're gonna see what happens to you for you being where you shouldn't be (starts weeping) I was raped by four police ... . I managed to see the name of two of them, one was Ortiz, another's name is Lopez, and the other was the one called Chepe Luis, the fourth one I couldn't -- didn't find out his name.
After they raped me [themselves], they stuck into me a ... ... that black thing police strikes you with. They left me lying down in the open [i.e. in the wilderness] - - I begged them "please, don't hurt me, I have little children, I implore you! And they insulted me and called me names, I only asked God to protect me for my children, because they're young. They left me all alone there. I was unconscious, I guess, don't know. Then I got up with with what strength I had [left] and managed to reach the curb of a highway, I walked for around half an hour. I fell and stayed on the ground because I couln't stand the pain in my private parts [weeping] ... and a lady picked me up, I told her please to take me with my mom, don't know how much time we took, the only thing I could see, we left through the side of Zincon[ph] ... and I was taken where my mom was ... My mom was already there, and my husband was looking for me. No ... Didn't want to go to the police, how could I if they had been the ones who injured me. Only -- [she can't go on]
Host: This is so difficult, Irma's situation, Irma Villanueva, 25 years old, a mother of four kids -- and girls? How many [girls] -- ?
Irma: A boy and three girls.
Host: A boy and three girls. She has come here to Radio Progreso station in order to give her testimony, that we listen to her, that you our friends, women and men who tune in with us, listen to what happened to her, what has not come out to the mainstream media, what everybody keeps silent, in this country, under this de facto government -- and you do not remember exactly the place where they took you? and were taken you alone?
Irma: Me alone, several persons were going, men for the most part, because -- I was going in a corner but me they left on the bed of the pickup -- and they took only me, I guess me, I was the only woman. I only remember the place full of branches, trees, with mounts, for as long as I walked, the mountain blocked the view, and it - When I managed to get out, I had to walk over some ditches, then like a little lagoon and I knew it was Ticamaya where I got out as I noted that we left on the side of Zincon.
Host: And who helped you?
Irma: A lady who was passing by, I stayed lying on the ground as I couldn't stand the pain in my abdomen [sobs]
Host: Yes
Irma: and she saw I was fallen, and got down and helped me, I asked her to help me please, and [she asked] could she take me to a hospital and I said no, that I wanted her to take me with my mom because -- what could I get in forensic medicine? that they took me with the police, when they were the ones who did this to me.
Host: That they mock, make fun!
Irma: Yes ... yes, for they were telling horrible things to me, and I was frightened.
Where is Human Rights Watch?
***
UPDATE: Human Rights Watch put out a very good statement today (8/25), highlighting the IACHR report, noting, among other things, the sexual assault allegations, and urging the U.S. to exert more pressure for the restoration of democracy. Kudos to Human Rights Watch.
Honduras: Rights Report Shows Need for Increased International Pressure
http://www.hrw.org/en/news/2009/08/25/honduras-rights-report-shows-need-increased-international-pressure
Comments are closed
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...

44 Comments so far
Show AllNo human rights abuse. Nothing to see here. Just the legal government of Honduras enforcing the law.
-- right wingers.
right-wingers: 99% of Republicans and 85% (or more?) of Democrats
I see that the CIA has been at work for Chiquita and Dole.
It's no wonder that the South American Continent dreads Plan Colombia.
and so it goes. While Obama, one man who could actually make a difference in the situation in Honduras, is on vacation on that well ordered and organized little island off the coast of mass. He is silently enjoying his family time while this shit goes on around him. Oh, he did step into the spotlight to reappoint Bernanke(sp). sad, isn't it?
Discussion of Honduras has effectively disappeared from the MSM. Thanks Robert Naiman and CD for keeping us informed. Pages and pages about the protests in Iran, yet there is nothing in any of the newspapers about the death of democracy in Honduras.
Yeah, and Obama is on record as supporting the military take over. Bush light stirike again.
landmark: if you want to keep abreast of late developments in the Honduran coup, you pretty much have to go to Narco News for their near-daily dispatches: http://narconews.com/
If you want to read fascist propaganda, check the Miami Herald.
The Miami Herald...Yikes ~makes sign of the cross~ Nobody can top those crazy right-wing Cubans at that!
True--I post there regularly to jam the site.
Excellent link Jerry thanks.
Dennis B. has mentioned it on the Flashpoints radio program (KPFA) as well.
The rapists are graduates of the SOA...
They are trained by US Intelligence to use rape as a tactic for evoking terror and control of their populations... Don't expect Shillary to do a damn thing about any of this... She is as corrupt as WJC...
Anyone remember the scandals of the Mena, Arkansas airport cocaine network with Bobby Seals... While Clinton was the Governor?
How Hillary's Rose Law Firm and the ADFA were used to launder a $100 million daily by providing "loans" to their cronies to buy influence and power and cover up Slick Willie's Sexcapades...?
Whitewater was a red herring whitewash investigation to cover up these crimes, and the trail of bodies of witnesses left in their wake... Same goes with the "wag the dog" Lewinsky affair...
Hillary is also a member of "The Family"... The fascist Prayer Breakfast group that was recently revealed for running a prostitution ring out of the C street house where she would go to pray... The Family is notorious for their CIA ties and for giving hundreds of millions of dollars in "aid" to brutal dictators of Somalia, Liberia, Indonesia, and elsewhere while they kill hundreds of thousands of their own citizens...
They are just as corrupt as the Bush Crime Family who they work for... But Liberals are quick to dismiss all this as a right-wing witch-hunt, for they can't handle the truth that they were suckered into voting for a pathological liar twice...
Google the "Clinton Chronicles" for details and documented evidence, and come to your own conclusions...
Hillary praying! ROFL! The mere thought...she couldn't even get on her knees to give Bill a BJ which is the reason why he had to go to Monica for that and she's praying...Oh, lord! The hypocrisy of these people is sooooo painful...
As soon as I read the first paragraph of the article I thought of SOA. Good old School of the Americas alumni doing their jobs. Gosh, it's nice to know that we can still train butchers and rapists with impunity. Do us proud, compadres.
But but in Iran the US press reports, its elected by fraud Government is sending arms to yemen to foment rebellion!!!
It should be apparent to anyone that given the spate of articles on Iran by "well meaning Journalists" concerned with the plight of the iranian people and comparing it to what we see on the Honduras or even Afghanistan, the news is being filtered.
I am suspect of ANY Journalist who leaped into the Iran debate proclaiming fraud that remains silent on places like the Hondura's. Failure to spend equal time on the Honduras shows a deliberate attempt to SHAPE opinion rather then to inform the people.
Yemen has become one of those places that everybody forgot about. When I was last there, the major perceived enemy of ALL the Yemen people was the US--hence the bombings of the US embassy in Sa'ana and the kidnappings of gringos in the "Death Triangle".
Looks like they really don't need much from Iran to keep them going.
Yeah, but the Empire supports dictatorships when it benefits corporate interests, so what else is new?. Nothing to see here, everything is fine.
It's not like there is a long-standing and clear historical precedent for supporting human rights abuses right?
Even to this day, the top recipients of US taxpayer money are among the world's worst human rights abusers and criminals: Egypt, Colombia, Israel, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan etc.
Oh and I almost forgot the world's #1 terror nation itself. If we add up all the deaths caused directly by US military aggression, and the deaths caused by regimes supported and armed by the US since WWII we are already into the 10s of millions.
US tax dollars at work: promoting rape and pillage by the gorilla goons in Honduras.
Way to go, folks!
Well you know the corporcracy has been going crazy about the wave of progressive leaders emerging in the region and had to do SOMETHING about it. Can't let the people control their own resources don't-cha-know.
I can answer one of the now most requently asked questions: Where is Human Rights Watch?
On the US government payroll, that's where. They are only visible when it's time to invent stories about Chavez in Venezuela--or when the hue and cry about human rights abuses like mass killings daily here in Mexico gets to the point that folks start riding their ass about their funding.
Yet, looking at their Americas page, there is only one piece on Chavez, with multiple pieces on Mexico, pieces on El Salvador and Columbia.
In the face of evidence like this documentation of a radio broadcast by Jesuit run Radio Progresso, I am humbled to hear about the suffering of Irma Villanueva. I wish to help her and all of the victims of this kind of abuse. I will contact the organizations that are responsible for bringing this kind of attention to us in the CD community and offer to help in any way that I can. Thank you for your courage and belief in this person to be able to respond in a human way to the malevolent organizations that are responsible for these atrocities.
This is a classic example of how we undermine women's rights when we abet the violent replacement of legally elected progressive governments with right wing thugs who will support American corporations for a price.
We allow the country to be overtaken by kleptocrats and criminal elements, including our corporations. Add Honduras a long list of other countries in which democracy, the rights of the poor and the status of women suffered as a result of such US inspired coups.
But we could send in the US Army to do some sensitivity training. That would make it alright.
Joe
Human Rights Watch obvious attempt to ignore human rights crimes in Honduras is typical behavior for them. HRW strikes me as a front organization for the CIA and/or State Department, posing as an independent human rights organization in order to legitimize U.S. foreign policy, and Israeli misconduct, while demonizing regimes the US doesn't like, such as Cuba, Venezuela, Iran, etc., etc.
Here's the tried and true HRW formula in dealing with U.S. and Israeli misconduct, which most American media adopt uncritically:
1. ignore it as long as possible, or issue a few ambiguous vanilla press releases and hope the news worthiness gets old and goes away
2. after other legitimate rights organizations have already take the initiative to condemn and demand investigation, then HRW jumps in and pretends it was there all along.
3. issue reports accusing leftist regimes of fundamental and pervasive misconduct, while limiting reports condemning the US, Israel, or its friends of one relatively narrow aspect or another -- that way HRW can always point to reports criticizing both parties, while glossing over the fact that it's criticism of foes of the US is much, much broader than criticism of its friends. When issuing reports criticizing the US and its friends, it also tends to pick issues which other rights organizations have already documented and publicized, so that HRW is really adding little or nothing to disclosure of misconduct which can no longer be hidden or plausibly denied.
4. use "balancing" to equate horrendous war crimes by the U.S. or Israel against much lesser crimes by the victims (e.g., in one breath criticizing Israel for its invasion of Gaza, which destroyed Gaza and killed 1,300+ people, mostly civilians, and also criticizing the Palestinians for firing rockets which killed three or four civilians. HRW also seems to think an oppressed, occupied people such as the Palestinians have no right to resist by force, even though Israel uses much greater force to maintain its conquest.
5. focus criticism disproportionately on the misconduct of leftist regimes unfriendly to the US, such as Venezuela, Cuba and Honduras, Iran, and others, while at the same time ignoring condemnable conduct on the part of right wing opposition groups in those countries and others which is criminal or involves destabilization of the government. HRW devotes huge resources to investigating and publishing not only legitimate criticism, but often false reports about Venezuela, while never investigating the right wing opposition ties to US intelligence and think-tanks, acting to destabilize Venezuela and other Latin America regimes the US doesn't like.
I'm surprised the US media takes HWR seriously. On the other hand, considering the US media's performance under Bush, the Iraq and Afghanistan wars, the adulation for the "War on Terror", etc., I take that back. The US media's failure to recognize that HRW is little more than a shill for the US Government and corporate / foreign policy lobbies is par for the course.
The US media take HRW seriously because HRW is US-government owned.
I thought that HRW was a wholly-owned subsidiary of the UN, correct? If so, that would explain their bias and wimpiness since the UN is a wholly-owned subsidiary of the US Federal Government with the Israelis sitting on the board of directors.
And when HRW reportedly reports on torture and detention without trial by the US?
I'm not surprised to note that HRW is disliked by right wingers, and also by some anti-imperialists, when it criticises people they support.
You might want also to take a look at:
You might want also to take a look at:
Well, there is an Aug. 25 report here...http://www.hrw.org/en/news/2009/08/25/honduras-rights-report-shows-need-increased-international-pressure
for all of you to look at the doc about. The report details the many violations and is being used at this moment to develop a coordinated response by the OAS.
David,
Thank you for the link. Good for HRW. HRW has now spoken out forcefully on Honduras. Let's hope they keep it up. (I notice that Mr. Naiman has also picked up the link.)
Since the CIA overthrew the Honduran Democracy for Chiquita and Dole the price of bananas has collapsed. I don't know if it's just me or if nobody is buying their bananas.
No doubt Micheletti was a top student at the School of the Americas, he learned his craft well and his CIA teachers must be very proud of him!
where is a rendition when you really need? these cops
need to be kidnapped and tried in international court
for their inhuman actions!obama where are you on this one?
He's on vacation. Golfing with his highest campaign contributor. You know, important stuff like that.
Hard to break 100 with your head up your ass.
The USA cannot sponsor international law and order in regard to the Honduran coup because law and order does not apply except where it serves the interests of US elites. Instead, US elites work to convince average USans that imposing law and order on average USans is the top priority cuz failure to achieve elite status is the primary motivator behind street crime. By the same token, the Honduran coup is the Honduran people's comeuppance for their chronic economic failure. US elites need to see if the coupsters are going to be friendly allies to advance US elite interest, that is, law and order for people, and liberty/privilege for elites. US elites are counting on you to show your support for elite interests by voting elite candidates in the next election. Do it to preserve YOUR chance to become an elite one day.
To HRW, the US-European occupations of Iraq and Afghanistan do not constitute a crime against humanity. To HRW, Afghanistan has 'elections' that are valid though 'marred'. To HRW, US and Israeli threats to start a war against Iran simply do not exist.
Somalia? 'Human Rights Watch says failed US policy has escalated the conflict in Somalia. Jessie Graham reports.' and that from their website. I on the other hand personally had rather thought that the US had used Ethiopia as a surrogate to occupy the country and tear it apart for the US government? It is a mere 'escalation' to HRW though! That is how HRW spins their supposed concern over human rights in the world and it is often not a very pretty sight.
Why would anybody think that HRW will go against US foreign policy objectives in Latin America rather than aiding and abetting US government policies and goals there? Human Rights Watch? More like Human Rights Apologists for US foreign policy objectives, and that's why Noam Chomsky and others have to periodically now call them on the carpet about what they really do and don't do. It has simply become necessary to repeatedly expose this group's true agenda which is most often not that of promoting human rights much at all.
The agenda of HRW usually is to shill for a perverted version of human rights as being something that the Big Capitalist Powers (especially the US and Britain) supposedly promote in other places, rather than persistently destroy through their eternal war making and imperialism.
Visiting their homepage, these are the items that are prominently displayed:
Getting Away with Torture?
Command Responsibility for the U.S. Abuse of Detainees
"They Want Us Exterminated"
Murder, Torture, Sexual Orientation and Gender in Iraq
White Flag Deaths
Killings of Palestinian Civilians during Operation Cast Lead
Americas »
*
Honduras: Rights Report Shows Need for Increased International Pressure
etc.
Too bad they don't have a photo of the doorknob that hit Vivanco in the ass when Chavez booted him out of Venezuela!
This is the same crew that brought you police dogs raping twelve-year-old girls ("suspected communist sympathizers") in Pinochet's Chile!
As several posters have already said, there's nothing new in an imperialist government brutally repressing anyone who opposes it - anywhere in the world. Why would the MSM or most people in the "free world" care? After all, it's not their daughters, sisters, mothers, wives etc who are being brutalized ... oh, and the women obviously "deserve" it for "trying to sabotage the efforts of the World's Only Remaining Superpower to do good."
Hillary: Your dogs have gotten off-leash.
Honduran cops? Figures! Something which Common Dreams and Human Rights Watch should have courage to raise hell about is to be found at :http://antiisgood.wordpress.com/2009/06/12/sex-slavery-the-growing-trade-in-israel/
While speaking of the coup in Honduras are we forgetting the coup in the United States that Bush and Cheney, the nasty five of the surpreme court pulled over us? Why havent these thugs been hung? After all they raped and destroyed this whole nation. I have been to Hunduras and there are certainly enough people to over power and kill the C.I.A led thugs.