Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Killing Yourself with Kindness
Will somebody please explain to me why Barack Obama is still on his bipartisan kick?
Ever since Obama's first efforts to reach out to Republicans, with his cabinet appointment of two Republicans, Gates at Defense and LaHood at Transportation, and his appeasement of Republican tax-cutting demands in the stimulus package, the Republican opposition has made it clear that no goodwill gesture, no effort to meet them halfway signals anything other than weakness. They are out to destroy his presidency, pure and simple. Nothing makes this clearer than the battle over health insurance reform.
Even Chuck Grassley, the rank (I mean ranking) Republican on the Senate Finance Committee and the great white hope of bipartisanship for his Democratic buddy Max Baucus, was giving aid and comfort to the Palin "death panel" nonsense. "In House bill there is counseling for end of life," said Grassley, "And from that standpoint you have every right to fear ... we should not have a government program that determines you're going to pull the plug on grandma." Maybe it's time to pull the plug on Grassley.
The White House Chief of Staff, Rahm Emanuel, is said to be a tough guy. And Obama's top political adviser, David Axelrod, is supposed to be some kind of tactical genius. What do these guys thing they are getting by continuing to kiss up to the Republicans?
I don't buy the claim that making nice got them any more Republican
votes for Sonia Sotomayor's confirmation. The handful of Republicans
who supported her were motivated either by demographics of their state
or by the fact that a few GOP senators are still willing to approve a
highly qualified centrist nominee and didn't want to alienate women
voters. Had Obama been playing hardball on other issues, it would not
have fatally damaged Sotomayor.
This weekend's op-ed piece "by" Barack Obama in the New York Times was the same old high-minded pabulum. It read as if it had been pureed several times by the speechwriting staff:
The long and vigorous debate about health care that's been taking place over the past few months is a good thing. It's what America's all about.But let's make sure that we talk with one another, and not over one another. We are bound to disagree, but let's disagree over issues that are real, and not wild misrepresentations that bear no resemblance to anything that anyone has actually proposed. This is a complicated and critical issue, and it deserves a serious debate.
That's great above-politics stuff if you are modeling high school civics, not so great if the other side is going for the jugular -- and winning.
Clearly, the administration playbook is to stick to the high road and not take the argument to the other side. But the strategy isn't working. The approval ratings for both the president and for his health plan are falling. He isn't even inspiring his own strongest grass roots backers to turn out in numbers at support rallies.
Obama's own gut instincts seem to be a little better than those of his astonishingly risk-averse advisers. At his own town hall meeting in Portsmouth, New Hampshire August 11, Obama was quite eloquent and detailed on the foolishness of the "death panel" lies, and he also said this:
Every time we come close to passing health insurance reform, the special interests fight back with everything they've got. They use their influence. They use their political allies to scare and mislead the American people. They start running ads. This is what they always do.We can't let them do it again. Not this time. Not now. (Applause.) Because for all the scare tactics out there, what is truly scary -- what is truly risky -- is if we do nothing. If we let this moment pass -- if we keep the system the way it is right now -- we will continue to see 14,000 Americans lose their health insurance every day. Your premiums will continue to skyrocket. They have gone up three times faster than your wages and they will keep on going up.
But, oddly, he didn't name the "special interests" (like the insurance and drug industry) because they are nominally part of his reform coalition. If anyone is killing somebody with kindness, it's the insurance industry backing Obama and slyly killing real reform.
Despite the lies, the real insecurity that people feel, and the shameless Republican opportunism, health reform will be a loser for Obama and the Democrats unless this president can shake off his delusion that bipartisanship works. So far, it works mainly to strengthen the far-right and weaken this president and what should be a reform moment.
- Posted in


11 Comments so far
Show AllThe author hit the nail on the head.
nailed it
People seem to have trouble wrapping their heads around the concept of a "duopoly".
Here's MC Escher's representation of a Möbius strip, complete with analogues to our Elected Misrepresentatives. It really helps to get a visual image of the essential structure of Amerikan "bipartisanship":
http://tinyurl.com/ogtt4t
· Yr Obd't Servant
"why Barack Obama is still on his bipartisan kick?"
How do you define 'bipartisan'? If bipartisan means between the far right and the center right or part of the corporate consenus, then Obama is bipartisan, otherwise the guy is right of center. Kindness has nothing to do with it. You sure don't sound like you know anything about the business world.
Killing yourself with kindness, or blindness?
“We can't let them do it again. Not this time. Not now. (Applause.) Because for all the scare tactics out there, what is truly scary -- what is truly risky -- is if we do nothing. ….”
Obama is not trying to do anything here except set up his supporters for his ongoing gigantic cave-in on the already-watered down “public option”. He’s saying “we have to do SOMETHING no matter how corrupt, coercive, and useless a sellout it is, even if it’s not the solution to any actual problem that exists, so let’s do my thing”, which is all of the above. Sibelius has been flogging the idea for days that “the important thing is that there’s some competition for private blah blah blah.”
The administrone (it’s hardly administering anything except its own wet-noodle defense) never quite got it that we might be better off entirely without a system of companies so evil they have to have government-sponsored competition, long ago retreated from the idea that the important thing was to get people some decent health care at a decent price, and recently retreated from the idea that the important thing was to LOOK like they thought that’s what was important.
Competition? for the sickest and poorest customers?
Competition in the race to the abyss of paying fantastically expensive premiums for the privilege of having all claims turned down? Competition for the insurance companies to vulture in and start buying up coops the week after the bill passes? Shameless REPUBLICAN opportunism?
Telecom immunity, torture, transparency, Gitmo, climate, energy, health… have they done anything non-Republican yet? Everybody get ready for the other Republicans to rule starting again in 2012, (if not 2010) because we need to abandon the Democrats in such huge numbers that they cease to exist as a party. We need to form a real opposition to the Republicans out of the shards of the left ¾ of the US population. Even if the price is President Palin. Because to continue like this is to doom the world to war, chaos and the fall of civilization by economic, ecologic and climate collapse. We have to choose between perpetual collaboration, or sudden disaster followed by possible quick recovery. No one is saying the 2 parties are the same; it will be HORRIBLE if the Republicans take back the Senate or either house (White or Rep). But the only other choice is to allow the 2 corporate parties to continue to slice off our limbs and carve up the world without stopping (and charging us for the service) until there is nothing left of either us or the biosphere.
"Your premiums will continue to skyrocket. They have gone up three times faster than your wages and they will keep on going up."
USans are quite proud of their "laissez-faire" capitalism. But apparently they don't even know how to operate their beloved machine. You have to demand best value in the markets, and USans fail chronically to demand best value in healthcare, and most other sectors.
Just love these Republican-lite shills from Huffington Post, I believe they are beginning to display the concept that Obama and the "Democratic" Party are not entirely on the level (after the betrayal has become total and undeniable and they are pissing on our feet).
Tony Vodvarka
Sorry to dissapoint you but Obama is on no bipartisan kick. He's on a corporate-sponsorship kick, the same as Bush, only he can lie about it better. He doesn't care about parties, he doesn't care about democracy, he doesn't care about anything which is not pleasing the corporate masters that put him in power. The end!