Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Grief and Solidarity on the Road to Gaza
The opening announcement at our first CodePink and Coalition of Women for Peace meeting was stunning and sobering: a 35 year-old Palestinian father of two children, with another child on the way, was killed at a nonviolent demonstration in Ni'lin.
He had been shot in the chest by Israeli Defense Forces (IDF). We had
been asked, as a means of introduction, to choose a word that best
described how we were feeling at the start of our delegation's efforts
to reach Gaza and to build a playground there. The word I chose was
"grieving," the only word I could think of after hearing of this young
man's death. 
On the plane ride to Israel, I had just begun reading Judith Butler's most recent work, Frames of War. In this book, Butler asks why it is that some lives are grievable and others not; why some lives are to be saved while others are shed, if even noticed, particularly during times of war. In one of the book's many memorable phrases, Butler claims that our efforts to build borders between one another would be better spent appreciating how "bound up we are in one another." This phrase has become a touchstone for me as I make my way through the early days of the delegation. It doesn't allow me to slip into the facile duality of "friend and enemy" but challenges me to live truthfully, as one who, indeed, is deeply bound to other human beings.
As we made our way round the communal introductions, I was deeply inspired by the stories and presence of those who gathered that evening. Among us were two young women of the Shministim (conscientious objectors), one of whom had just been released from a military prison for refusing to serve in the IDF. Others were Israeli and Palestinian women who work together in the Coalition of Women for Peace. On their way were three delegates from CodePink's Cairo delegation who had just finished building a marevelous "pink playground" for children in the Gaza Strip. Here were folks who well understood "being bound" to one another and who were determined to "pay up" in order to live that insight.
One of the delegates reminded us that 2009 was the last year in the decade that the United Nations declared was to be a decade devoted to the development of a culture of nonviolence for the sake of the world's children. I thought, once again, of that young father and of the children who were now left behind. Oh, how we adults have failed our children and one another! The consensus of the community gathered that evening was that each of us was responsible for helping to create this culture of nonviolence. I thought of this vow while listening to a conversation between one of our delegates and a young man working the desk at our hostel. For this young man, any effort to help the Palestinian people was seen as a threat to the security of Israel, which meant ultimately, to his family. My sense is that the Palestinian father was also working for the security of his family. I wonder why this common concern for security so often ends in the death of another? If we are bound up in one another, then how would killing another add to anyone's security? This is a question that I hope to dwell upon in the coming days.
As we make our way to Gaza, there will be plenty of ways to practice "being bound up in one another." One of the creative ways of doing this will be the practice of clowning, as we will join the Israeli Clandestine Insurgent Rebel Clown Army (ICIRCA) as well as our own delegation member, Patch Adams, in the effort to bring play and joy into the work of our peacemaking. Another way will be for me to confront the welling sense of fear that I am feeling in anticipation of our work in Bi'lin, a community that sits next to Ni'lin. I had joined a nonviolent demonstration in Bi'lin last summer only to be chased from the scene by the menacing fire of tear gas cannisters shot by the IDF, as it seemed to me, directly at us. I am feeling the desire to explore the energy of this fear, to see what's there and to find ways of encouraging connection to others and not flight from others. There is an opportunity here that I have vowed not to miss; it's the opportunity to build the beloved community that Dr. King so often spoke of, and to start that work right within my own heart.
- Posted in



11 Comments so far
Show AllKeep up the good work, Anna Brown.
· Yr Obd't Servant
Gaza - the return of a holocaust, but now the Israelis commit the genocide.
Solidarity with respect to the plight of Gazans?
If interested in that topic, then you should be very interested in "Our Convoy to Gaza", by George Galloway. ICH, InformationClearingHouse.info, provides this as a two-part article posted June 7th and the second page part has five video clips of the speech by George Galloway in Brooklyn, NY, May 26, 2009. Actually, I may as well provide the link for the first page.
http://informationclearinghouse.info/article22784.htm
There was also another "Hope Convoy" or FreeGaza convoy article posted at Uruknet.info over this past weekend, btw.
good work indeed
except when one starts to wonder why there is all of this conflict and oh - the inhumanity
let's rememer that israel is the aggressor nation here - armed to the teeth with american weapons - going daily into towns and villages and killing innocent civilians
israel keeps stealing land and killing palestinians
its pretty simple
While the likes of Obama lecture the Palestians for not engaging in nonviolence, the Palestinians engaging in non-violence are slaughtered.
Being bound up the other requires Jews to step away from their tribal elitism and entitlement as their g-d's chosen....and a brutal god of war and vegeance he is, too.
The monstrous crimes of the murdering and devouring thing which is the state that hides behind the name "Israel", come from a belief in he idea of us and them.-The enormity of those crimes makes it easy, looking at those who call themselves israelis, to fall into the same error and say "us and them". We americans have left over a million dead iraqis, millions of widows and orphans, millions of refugees, for power and oil.- Again, from a belief in us as opposed to them...Rather, let us all say to the palestinians "you are our brothers and sisters", ..Rachel Corrie and others have given their lives to say just that.,,to say so realizing that we are all of us together passengers on spaceship earth, as r.buckminster fuller has pointed out...
from my standpoint those israeli soldiers beating a child have been devoured by the "state hiding behind the name "israel"".
You may be familiar with "JFK and the Unspeakable: Why He Died and Why It Matters" by James W. Douglass. It's well worth the read!
The "Unspeakable" to which Douglass refers includes, in part, the vast Amerikan security state apparatus that mushroomed after WWII, and effectively staged a coup on November 22, 1963.
To Douglass' credit, he's careful not to jump on a soapbox and shake his fist at the Unspeakable; he instead points a careful and credible finger at its silhouette, and lets the reader connect the dots.
I've expressed what you wrote in many comments over the past few years. I've tried to make a distinction between the State of Israel itself-- which is certainly a problematic construct-- and the nefarious forces of genocidal oppression directing Israel's Unspeakable security state. Like you, I see the Unspeakable as a monstrous shadow state thriving like a malignant tumor deep within its host body.
Last time I expressed such thoughts here, I was unwise enough to use certain explicit terms, or labels, for the "hidden (in plain sight) state" you reference. It caused the comment to be banned and deleted, precisely because the Unspeakable in every nation-state casts a penumbra of fear and fecklessness that afflicts even venues trying to support open dialogue, and compels them to respect its taboos.
· Yr Obd't Servant
I think there is something very profound revealing itself in seeing all this as illness or pathology...W.B.Yeats pointed out that a cardinal at the time of the black death in Europe was able to draw a map showing its exact geographical limits before it had reached its peak!,,,,
Bound, blindfolded and beaten – by Israeli troops
"Children among Palestinian detainees abused during West Bank operation, according to soldiers' confessions"
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/middle-east/bound-blindfolded-and-beaten-ndash-by-israeli-troops-1700194.html
This should delight America's christians.
from the article mentioned by humbaba:
...In Hares, Ihab Shamlawi, a university student, recalled watching as a high school pupil asked soldiers permission to go to the bathroom. "They put him on the floor, they kicked his legs and beat him," he said. Ten or 15 other soldiers were watching, Mr Shamlawi recalled. "They all laughed," he said