Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
‘Clean’ Energy and Poisoned Water
In the musical "Urinetown," a severe drought leaves the dwindling supplies of clean water in the hands of a corporation called Urine Good Company. Urine Good Company makes a fortune selling the precious commodity and running public toilets. It pays off politicians to ward off regulation and inspection. It uses the mechanisms of state control to repress an increasingly desperate and impoverished population.
The musical satire may turn out to be a prescient vision of the future. Corporations in Colorado, Texas, Louisiana, Pennsylvania and upstate New York have launched a massive program to extract natural gas through a process that could, if it goes wrong, degrade the Delaware River watershed and the fresh water supplies that feed upstate communities, the metropolitan cities of New York, Philadelphia, Camden and Trenton, and many others on its way to the Chesapeake Bay.
"The potential environmental consequences are extreme," says Fritz Mayer, editor of The River Reporter in Narrowsburg, N.Y. His paper has been following the drilling in the Upper Delaware River Valley and he told me, "It could ruin the drinking supply for 8 million people in New York City."
Trillions of cubic feet of natural gas are locked under the Marcellus Shale that runs from West Virginia, through Ohio, across most of Pennsylvania and into the Southern Tier of New York state. There are other, small plates of shale, in the south and west of the United States. It takes an estimated 3 million to 5 million gallons of water per well to drill down to the natural gas in a process called hydraulic fracturing, or fracking. The water is mixed with resin-coated sand and a cocktail of hazardous chemicals, including hydrochloric acid, nitrogen, biocides, surfactants, friction reducers and benzene to facilitate the fracturing of the shale to extract the gas.
The toxic brew is injected with extreme force deep within the earth. The drilling is vertical for about 5,000 to 7,000 feet. The technology, developed by Halliburton, allows drills to abruptly turn sideways when they reach these depths. The lubricant and biocides propel the sand on a horizontal axis for as far as half a mile. The fissures created are held open by the sand, and the natural gas flows to the surface through steel casings. Feeder lines run from the grid of wells to regional pipelines.
About 60 percent of the toxic water used to extract the natural gas-touted in mendacious commercials by the natural gas industry as "clean" energy-is left underground. The rest is stored in huge, open pits that dot the landscapes at drilling sites, before it is loaded into hundreds of large vehicles and trucked to regional filtration facilities. Such drilling has already poisoned wells in western Pennsylvania, Colorado, Alabama, Arkansas, New Mexico, Kansas, Montana, Virginia, Washington, West Virginia and Wyoming. Those whose water becomes contaminated, including people living in towns such as Dimock, Pa., must have water trucked in to provide for their needs. Farm animals that have drunk the toxic mixture that has leeched from gas drilling sites have died. Cattle ranchers in Colorado, where drilling is occurring in close proximity, have reported that their livestock birthrates have gone down and animals are bearing deformed offspring.
"The single biggest concern is the release of poisons into the environment and its impact on all that live in proximity to the drilling activity," the River Reporter's editorial this week read following a visit to local drilling sites. "Large pits, lined with sagging black plastic, did not instill confidence that it couldn't escape into the environment. And we wondered how migrating birds would know the difference between this body of fluid and an area pond. Ironically, the effect on animals became very real that afternoon when, upon our return, we received the news that in Caddo Parish, LA, 17 cows died after apparently ingesting fluids that escaped from a nearby gas pad."
The New York City watershed lies within the Marcellus Shale. This watershed provides unfiltered water to more than 14 million people in New York City, upstate New York, Philadelphia and northern New Jersey. It is the largest unfiltered drinking water supply in the United States. And if the federal government does not intervene swiftly, it could become contaminated. The nonprofit group NYH2O has begun organizing in New York City, calling for a statewide ban on natural gas drilling to protect not only the city's fresh water drinking supply, but everyone else's. But New York's notoriously corrupt state Legislature and feeble governor seem set to permit the drilling.
The natural gas companies, not surprisingly, insist that the millions of gallons of poisoned water left underground or collected in huge open pits pose no threat to watersheds. Let us hope they are right. The truth is, no one knows. And these corporations, in a move that suggests the drilling may not be as benign as they contend, had their lobbyists ensure that the natural gas industry was exempted by Congress in the Energy Policy Act of 2005 from complying with the Clean Water Act and the Safe Drinking Water Act, which is designed to regulate groundwater.
Environmental Protection Agency Administrator Lisa Jackson said in a congressional hearing on Tuesday that the agency would consider revisiting its official position that this drilling technique does not harm groundwater. A 2004 study conducted by the EPA under the Bush administration concluded that hydraulic fracturing causes "no threat" to underground drinking water. The study was used to support the provision in the 2005 energy bill that exempted hydraulic fracturing from federal regulation.
We do not know, because there is no federal oversight, the exact formula of the chemicals added to the water. We do not know, because the industry has been greenlighted through state regulatory agencies, what the millions of gallons of poison underground will do to our drinking water. We are told to trust the natural gas industry, as we were told to trust Wall Street. And if our drinking water becomes contaminated, then expect corporations to profit from the desperation.
Corporations like Bechtel have been buying up water reservoirs around the globe in anticipation of future water shortages. And what they will do when they control our water was illustrated in Bolivia a decade ago. The World Bank forced Bolivia to privatize the public water system of its third-largest city, Cochabamba. It threatened to withhold debt relief and other development assistance if the city did not comply. Bechtel, which was the only bidder, was granted a 40-year lease to take over Cochabamba's water through a subsidiary called Aguas del Tunari.
"Urinetown" was visited on Cochabamba in 2000 within weeks of the privatization. Aguas del Tunari imposed massive rate hikes on local water users of more than 50 percent, according to the Cochabamba-based Democracy Center. Families living on the local minimum wage of $60 per month were billed up to 25 percent of their income for water. The rate hikes sparked citywide protests. The Bolivian government declared martial law in Cochabamba and deployed thousands of soldiers and police to restore order. More than 100 people were injured in the rioting and a 17-year-old boy was killed. The Cochabamba project was abandoned, but Bechtel and other corporations are not done. Bechtel's control of the water supply in Guayaquil, Ecuador, a few years later resulted in water shutoffs, contamination, and a deadly hepatitis A outbreak. Water in a world of scarcity will be very profitable. And Bechtel is preparing for the bonanza at home and abroad.
Profit, even if it results in widespread human suffering, is the core of America's ruthless unregulated corporate capitalism. Our health care industry profits from sickness and death by excluding those who most need coverage. Our financial industry created perhaps the largest speculative bubble in human history and trashed our economy as well as looting our treasury. Our oil and gas industries, whose profits are obscene, wreck the environment and poison our water. And the worse it gets for us, the better it gets for them. You may not need to travel to a theater to see "Urinetown." It could soon be coming to you.
- Posted in


24 Comments so far
Show AllBut by golly, we'll have more energy for sumppin.
http://www.indianlaw.org/en/node/419
The Indian Law Center will present analysis of Principles for transnational banks at the UN Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues tomorrow 1:15 pm.
This is a human rights issue that speaks to all peoples. We would be wise to become familiar with these efforts.
The paper is posted in both synopsis and original form.
Thanks Old Goat.
"Profit, even if it results in widespread human suffering, is the core of America's ruthless unregulated corporate capitalism."
Profit is not at the core, in fact profit has absolutely nothing to do with the men and women who plague our societies. Show me the profit...anyone! Disease is at the core, followed by death and destruction. If we can't call a spade a spade, we, who supposedly can see, then we are all doomed to fall over the cliff with the rabid soulless ravagers of our planet.
Even with clean energy, there's always room for profit so you are correct to state that profit is not the dominant problem here. Until we find a perfect replacement for fossil fuels, that's what we're stuck with. I hate to say this but even putting solar, wind, tidal, geothermal, and biofuels together will not be able to meet the growing demands that fossil fuels provide. At some point, we will all be forced to cut back in so many facets of our lives. I think we have a conservation challenge still ahead of us.
When insanity becomes the norm life suffers greatly.
"Frankly, they own the place."
"They" being: the banksters, Big Energy, Big Health, Big Agriculture, Big Media, and Really, Really Big Military.
Apparently, the water supply for millions of Americans is not too big to fail...
There are no words to fully describe the insanity of destroying water supplies for the sake of fossil fuel extraction. We can live without the benefits of automobiles, central heating, even electricity and especially chemical fertilizers. But without water for drinking and raising food crops, we will all, without question, die.
Extraction of heavy oil from Canadian tar sands employs an analagous technology, fouling billions of gallons of fresh water and, not inconsequentially, destroying entire forest ecosystems in Alberta. For the natural gas companies to "insist that the millions of gallons of poisoned water left underground or collected in huge open pits pose no threat to watersheds" is patently ridiculous on its face, a cynical lie, and an insult to the public.
So, what else is new?
In all areas of human activity, the impact on fresh water supplies should be the primary and overriding consideration in the making of public policy and the granting of all manner of permits. This is particularly true of groundwater supplies, which cannot be decontaminated in situ and which, once contaminated, capture recharge flows and contaminate them as well.
Our political "leaders" seem to be, at best, only dimly aware of the looming water crisis and the urgent, urgent need to jump-start conservation and preservation efforts in all areas of water use -- from intensive agriculture to dry composting toilets. Their corrupted oversight and willful negligence on this issue is nothing short of criminal.
As the Bush administration has proven, it is FAR more expensive to deal with the fallout from such technologies after the fact than to be proactive with monitoring and control before the fact. Along with Big Finance, Big Health, Big Agriculture and Big Energy we need, sorry GOP, BIG GOVERNMENT (of, by and for the people) to keep the worst abuses from creating superfund sites in our future.
Sioux Rose
This will probably be THE issue that unites people across the globe. Since the elites rely upon armed guards to enforce policies beneficial only to themselves, it would seem that over the basic necessity of water, those guards normally paid to aim at the peasants/workers will at last turn their weapons in the direction of the true enemy to LIFE in all its myriad wonder(s).
WHY DO WE HAVE TO WAIT SO LONG? WHY?
(i wish i was one of the gun toting zombies, so I could fire the first round.)
Why are the stupid so powerful? The wicked so untouchable. and the wise so feeble and helpless?
Is it written in the stars?
Sioux Rose
XZ: I see fate and free will like a tango, sometimes a cha cha cha. Fate takes a step, we (out of what free will we own) respond, and sometimes vice versa. As a result of the interplay between these two "givens," sometimes the unexpected occurs, like a perturbation, or mutation. This happens in math, in the gene pool, and within the human discovery process. So there are very real inclinations set by the themes of time, but there is also the human responsibility angle. And sometimes, there is Grace, the unexpected Deliverance or Miracle that transpires. Some would attribute that to good karma, the help of an angel or spirit guide, the power of prayer, luck, or another explanation. I think we can agree that much of life is known and predictable, yet much a mystery. Everyone alive at this time came in for "the big one," a major age phase transition and all the turmoil and tumultuous events that are part of it. Please pass the popcorn.
You might be somewhat correct. Unfortunately, there are so many processed edible oil foods that even the poor today are addicted to and add in water bottles and I'm not so sure that they will clearly see the issue. Water is the necessity of life but unless people are well educated about the matter, the chances of uniting them are slim to none.
"...those guards normally paid to aim at the peasants/workers will at last turn their weapons in the direction of the true enemy to LIFE in all its myriad wonder(s)."
-- May this come sooner, rather than later.
Not only is water profitable, but now with the "cap and trade" giveaways, so is the air.
By the way, see my listings on eBay, I have some dreams up for auction.
So Bechtel is the new Halliburton? When will Riley become Secretary of War?
Bechtel is a very old Halliburton - lots of nuke contracts back in mid-century and 30 or so years after, swapping personnel with the NRC and so forth.
Wow.
To see just how gruesome this business can be ... see...
http://understory.ran.org/2009/05/15/epa-deems-42-of-48-mountaintop-removal-permits-environmentally-responsible/
EPA Deems 42 of 48 Mountaintop Removal Permits “Environmentally Responsible”
There is an incredible pic.
my understanding of how NYC gets its water is that it is "unfiltered", and as safe as any water around. pretty amazing.
and more amazing, in a ghastly way, is that it's about to be destroyed.
this water issue may be coming at us much sooner than we think. i live outside DC, and a horrible example of suburbia run amok a few miles west of here, aka Loudon County, VA, almost ran out of water last summer. i think this is happening in california and elsewhere.
europe, asia, africa have been home to peoples for thousands of years. in about 300 or so yrs, we will have totally despoiled much of the N. American continent.
Thank you Chris Hedges. If not for your article, this huge threat would be completely under the radar. Please everyone, call and write your news media to make sure this is properly publicized and stopped.
Joe
Re: "Profit, even if it results in widespread human suffering, is the core of America's ruthless unregulated corporate capitalism."
Yup. And the more ruthless and unregulated, the greater the profit. A portion of which can be strategically placed to ensure that business as usual remains so.
By the way, the Delaware River does not empty into the Chesapeake Bay. It empties into the Delaware Bay. (The Susquehanna empties into the Chesapeake, but it, too, could be effected by the activites discussed in this article.)
Which does not take away from Mr. Hedges' main point.
This is why I miss that randy old hypocritical bulldog Eliot Spitzer. Now that he is gone, nobody in government is minding the store here in New York State.
Joe
dumddown
Gas producing corporations do not drink the water. When the gas is exhausted the companies can dissolve or relocate to other gas sources.
Advice to waterless USANS from Corporate America:
There is a hell of a universe next door..Let's go!