Get News & Views Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Windows Into Gaza
Two years ago, I lived and worked in the West Bank. My time there was certainly a window to understanding the occupation, but one that I could open and shut at my own convenience. Because of that, I never really understood. I could go to the beach in Israel while my Palestinian friends had never seen the sea. I promised myself that I would not go, but one hot summer day got the better of me. The idea of swimming in the turquoise Mediterranean waters was so appealing that I disappeared one Friday to join my Israeli friends in Tel Aviv. I returned to work the next day three shades darker to which my colleague promptly replied without a hint of jealously in his voice, "Go again next weekend, but this time do it for me."
And then there is Gaza. I had been to Gaza once as a student in Egypt seven years prior to moving to the West Bank at a time when settlement expansion was their primary fear. It was just months before the second Intifada, and I remember Yasser Arafat's brother Fadi telling me that things were about to get much worse. He spoke from the terrace room of the Palestinian Red Crescent Society (PRCS) in Gaza City that he was running at the time. In between sips of whiskey he would point at the crowded camps beneath us where children were chasing each other in and out of narrow streets and partially shelled buildings and talk about their future. "Children shouldn't have to grow up like this," he sighed, "but Insha'Allah (God willing) it will get better for them after it gets worse."
When I returned to Gaza this March, I visited PRCS again to interview the director, Dr. Bashir Awdad who was describing in detail attacks on his ambulance drivers and the Al Awda Hospital during the war. We walked through the children's ward that had been totally destroyed and I ironically tripped over a box of charred burn salve. At one point, I snuck away to climb the ten flights of stairs to the terrace room where I had that conversation so long ago. Fadi Arafat is dead now, but his words blind-sided me when I finally emerged from the staircase. The space was totally gone, brightly painted walls and ceilings replaced by open sky. I walked across the top of the building in the rubble to the place that we had looked down at the children of Gaza. All of those buildings -- almost an entire block -- were gone.
Minutes later, I was in the back of a PRCS ambulance with a few of their volunteers on the way to spend time with the Samouni family in Zaytoun. Their story is one of the most egregious in this recent military assault, where at least 29 members of their family were killed. Nothing could have prepared me for hearing it first-hand.
We joined them where their house stood six weeks before, and their stories began to fill the space. I could tell they had done this before. I could also tell that their words were raw but they wanted to talk about what had happened to them, especially to international visitors. It was appalling. Sometimes it is so real that I experience it with them in my dreams and at other times I am numb. In any case, this is not about my nightmares. It is about their reality.
The sun started to set and PRCS rushed us out of the area because Zaytoun is near the constantly moving buffer zone, which increases the risk of air strikes despite the ceasefire. (The shape of the buffer zone keeps changing as Israeli authorities unilaterally determine the zone's boundaries.) One of the older women in the family grabbed my hand on the way out and softly asked me to return the next day. I gave her my word.
The next day I returned to Zaytoun, determined to suck it up and do some good reporting. We walked carefully from shelled house to shelled house, from where more of their stories unfolded. There was the boy who was trapped for days without food and water with his dead mother and siblings, the old man who "couldn't walk because there was a missile in his head", and the son who was buried alive up to his neck. Somewhere in the middle of the story, someone would usually pull out a gruesome photograph to prove that it was real and then pull out another one of that same person smiling and full of life. Children would run in and out, lifting up their shirts to show off their cuts and burns and bullet holes.
This little girl kept gently pulling on my blonde hair and dissolving into laughter. She would take my camera, run out of the room, and return with bunches of ridiculously blurry pictures and more little girls. I decided to take a break and spend some time with the children. I was looking for that line of balance between remembering the dead and celebrating life through the laughter of children.
All of the stories in Gaza obviously were not as heavy as those of the Samounis but they all shared in common a certain weight that comes with living in a fresh war zone.
A few nights later, I wound up in the home of a young Palestinian hip-hop group. Khaled and his crew had ‘the look' of rappers anywhere. They performed their latest song, all the time a proud mother cheerleading in the background. Their music was so enjoyable that it took me a moment to notice the pain under the surface. Lyrics about bombs and blasts, life under siege, and wanting freedom carried over into our conversations that lasted well into the night. "My parents always tell me to get off MySpace and Facebook," he said, "but what can I do? I am trapped here in Gaza and this computer is the only window for me to know what the normal world is like." (Khaled and I have been chatting on Facebook ever since.)
I think of these stories and so many others as I try to understand life in war and occupation and work to keep the window open while watching from the outside.
- Posted in
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...


75 Comments so far
Show AllSo, you are not only hard core anti-Semite, (Most Jews always want war) but also anti free speech.
I can't say I'm surprised.
More anti-Semites? Wow you racist right-wing hate mongers are so pathetic. You are so daft you don't even realize that calling folks names reveals your desperation, the weakness of your arguments, and the fact that you are a RACIST IMPERIALIST.
socialist: "More anti-Semites? Wow you racist right-wing hate mongers are so pathetic. You are so daft you don't even realize that calling folks names reveals your desperation, the weakness of your arguments, and the fact that you are a RACIST IMPERIALIST."
Once more, socialist, your imagination works extra hours.
Wanderer said an anti-Semite comment (That most Jews always wanted war)
I told him that he is anti-Semite. Then you, socialist, jump up - Ha, you call someone anti-Semite - therefore you are Racist Imperialist. (And right-wing hate mongers)
There is something wrong with you logic, socialist, outside your imagination, exposing an anti-Semite for what he is, does not turns a person to a right-wing hate mongers pathetic racist imperialist.
By the way, I found another flaw in your highly imaginative "logic". You, socialist, claim that "calling folks names reveals your desperation."
Well... you called me names, (a right-wing hate mongers pathetic racist imperialist) which means, according to your own words, that it reveals your desperation.
The arrogance you exhibit is astounding, but par for a Zionists.
Bigotry knows no shame.
It is no different than a KKK supporter coming on and then asking us to prove he's a racist. He is a racist, and it's so obvious that it is shameful he would even pretend otherwise.
How dare you? Isn't it enough that by cloaking your evil with the language of morality, you handicap those who are actually moral?
The definition of racism according to the dictionary:
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/racist
hatred or intolerance of another race or other races.
Wanderer - Most Jews always wanted wars (Just because they are Jews). All Jews must be exposed for what they are (Evils)
Letto – All humans are equal. All nations are equal (Yes, even Jews).
All the evidences suggest that you, Wanderer, are a racist, and not I. You, Wanderer , are more like KKK than I (Though KKK also hate black people and not just Jews.)
Anti-Semite have no shame. No shame at all.
According to Webster's a Semite is "a member of any of the peoples speaking a Semitic language, including Hebrews and Arabs."
How can a person be anti-semitic when they are defending the freedoms of ALL people, both Jewish and Arab? Not just one, at the expense of the other.
Go away, you ignorant semitic fool.
Oh, and living in Los Angeles, I grew up loving all things Jewish. I also learned to QUESTION EVERYTHING, from my Jewish brothers and sisters. Something you don't seem to understand, my so-called Jewish-defending brother.
Thank you for checking in Webster's dictionary the meaning of the word "Semite"
Did you also check the word "anti-Semite"?
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/anti-semite
"–noun a person who discriminates against or is prejudiced or hostile toward Jews."
Neverthaless, if you don't like the commonly used word "anti-Semite" you can use instead "anti-Jew" to describe Wanderer.
(Wanderer is not defending the freedoms of ALL people, both Jewish and Arab. He falsly claim that most Jews always, thoughout history, always, wanted wars. He also wants to expose all the Jews in the states as evil. He claimed that Israel is the world's worset problem and that Israel should be exterminated. This is not defending both Jews and Arabs.)
Lie, lie, lie away. It only shows how you've lost your arguments, and have nothing left to argue but continued distortions.
Operation "Cast Lead Hearts"
I shall never forget the slaughter of children in occupied Palestine.
I shall never forgive the genocidal monsters behind this atrocity
nor their Congressional supporters.
A somber but touching account.
Well done, Salena Tramel. And thanks.
· Yr Obd't Servant
Bring America Back !!!!.........Thanks to Salena and CD for this insight on windows.
**There is an oxymoron to Salena's account where she tells of
being in a "..fresh war zone..." !! Fresh indeed.
**Woe be to former King George the Bush, who could not utter one word of protest or restraint against his little Zion sister Israel in the Genocide of innocent Gazan peoples.
**Woe be to the new US President Obama, whose Inaugural Balls were dancing upon the Fresh Graves of over 1500 dead
innocent Gazans, including 300 to 400 innocent children.
That is, if they are lucky enough to have graves. He too,
failed to utter one word of Protest to Israel.
Remember the Genocide at Gaza !!!!
Letto-Remember:
JewsOnly.com or ZionazisRus.net
Go make your own site where you can pass off this insensitive, passive-aggresive, smarmy garbage.
Listening to you is like watching larry David in'Curb your Enthusiasm' (a hilarious show, BTW). He goes about starting trouble, and then doesn't understand why he's getting yelled at!
Do you appose free speech, Dead Cell?
If you don't like the facts I bring, you are free to bring other facts and prove me wrong.
bligh4
Good God, you all sound like a bunch of argueing 4 year olds.
My question on the whole Israel/Palestine question is this: Why is it consistently treated as the worst human disaster currently ongoing in the world by Common Dreams and its posters? It doesn't even make the top 20 by death toll...
Just one example- Congo has a death toll over 1000 TIMES the death toll in the West Bank and Gaza. Yet nary a peep from anyone. Articles about the palestinians outnumber articles about the inhabitants of the Congo by at least 100-1.
Selective racism anyone?
bligh4, you may see my comment to Letto and I will repeat it again.
The fact of the matter, is that America gives Israel BILLION$ of OUR TAX-PAYED dollar$, every year. Therefore, all Americans have every right to judge Israel and what it does.
CD are not racists. I don't reacll any recist article published by CD. They do however have a very strong biased voice against the US government and its allies (Including Israel), which in some case is unjustified.
Like any media (left, right or other), CD have an agenda. And they publish articles that promotes that agenda.
Noam Chomski wrote about how madia, all madia, workes in his documentary "Manufacturing Consent: Noam Chomsky and the Media (1992)"
CD are not racists, but they do try to manufactor unti-Israeli and anti-US concent.
Gaza And The Warsaw Ghetto
same place
different time
as the world stood by
genocide
live
Did Israel exterminated 99% of the Palestinians in Gaza in extermination camps, gas chambers crematorions etc?
Did the Jews of Warsaw Ghetto fired 10,000 rockets and mortar bomb on German civilian targets?
Did the Jewish leadership in Warsaw Ghetto claimed they have natural right to kill Germans, and that Germany should be obliterated by Jewdaism?
Warsaw Ghetto and Gaza are the same only in your imagination, yourstruly.
Gazans are prisoners. Whether it is because of their own leadership or the wrath of the Israelis, the fact remains. Walling in entire populations was done to Jews and now they do it to Palestinians.
The fact of the matter is that America gives billions in taxpayer dollars to Israel. Therefore all Americans have the right to be critical of Israel.
The Holocaust was slightly more than just keeping people as prisoners (or under blocade).
If you want to learn about it, you can start here:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holocaust
"After having struggled for more than a century trying to hold onto &/or get back their birthright, Palestine, the Palestinians are not about to trade it in for a modified version of the nightmare that is their day to day experience. It all gets back to the matter of uninvited Eastern European Jews barging in and taking over. The answer, of course, is for Palestinian and Jew to sit down together and figure things out."
"Based on?"
"One equals one."
"Anything else?"
"LIberty and justice for all."
Fair enough.
By the way, that was what the Libreal Zionists wanted all along.
Check the Faisal - Weizmann agreement from 1919.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Faisal-Weizmann_Agreement
- Palestine will be homeland to Jews and Palestinians.
- No one will be forced out of his land.
- Jews will help the Arabs throughout the Middle-East.
---
Too bad so much blood had been spelled since 1919.
And too bad you Zionists are military expansionists...
for an illegal and immoral, genocidal invasion.
It is the right of the victims of this oppression to resist to the best of their ability the invaders.
It's the slow strangulation of those now trapped in Gaza that's a reprise of the Warsaw Ghetto. Besides, genocide is not only the systemic killing of an entire racial, ethnic or religious group, it's also the attempt to do this, whether "successful" or not.
The Hamas can end the Gaza blocade anytime they want. (By accepting a few conditions set by the UN, EU, Russia, and USA). The last war in Gaza, which claimed the life of 1,400 people, could have been avoided if the Hamas would have chosen not to fire rockets on Israeli civilian targets.
The Jews in Warsaw Ghetto didn't attack Germany, and they were not given any choice on how to end the blocade (or the extermination).
---
Israel is not trying to systemicly killing an entire racial people.
The Nazis, during the Holocaust did.
There is a lot of available material on the Holocaust. This is one of the most documented genocide in history. If interested, you can learn about it.