Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Chasing Mirages in The Middle East
I remember learning at school about the mirage effect. It never struck me as real or possible, but only theory. Later as a young diplomat I drove repeatedly from Amman to Kuwait, via Baghdad. In the endless flat desert, I saw large areas covered with what appeared to be blue, gently moving water. I could never reach the water, but it never disappeared. Thanks to those early physics lessons, I remembered enough to know it was indeed a mirage. So there was fascination without any deception.
The peace mirage, however, is all deception with no fascination. The so-called "peace process" and the resulting negotiations long ago became ends in themselves: profitable or self-serving for the participants and failure-disguising for all concerned. For Israel, it is ideal to give the impression that it is engaged in peace talks while it continues to occupy and colonize Palestinians and deny their rights, as if the situation on the ground would have no effect on any negotiations. And for the Palestinian Authority which failed completely (due to its own corruption as well as Israeli occupation) to establish any real gains for the Palestinian people, the continued negotiations became the sole reason for its existence and the only way for those who control it to earn a living.
When the peace process relaunched at Annapolis in 2007 hit the wall, those who rallied massive international support behind it, claiming it was the last best chance to realize the Bush vision of a two-state solution, had nothing to show for all their promises. So they made vague claims that it had laid the foundation for the envisioned peace, which could yet be built upon. Former United States President George W. Bush's promise to establish a Palestinian state before he left office morphed into a promise merely to "define" such a state. Yet even that vague and insignificant goal could not be achieved.
Annapolis was just an exercise to buy time for a horde of international operators whose sole concern was reduced to repeatedly reviving and reinventing the peace process without ever undertaking a meaningful assessment of why all their efforts failed, or of the dangers of continuing on the same path. Annapolis never carried any promise and laid no foundations for peace. If anything, it provided Israel with the needed assurance that it was immune for at least another year from any pressure to curb its settler-colonial aggression against Palestinians with the cover of sterile, though regular meetings between Israeli and Palestinian officials.
For all the rest, including the so-called international community and the Arab states, the concept that the parties are engaged in negotiations -- transparently fake though they have been -- has been enough to exempt them from any real action in pursuit of peace. This might include, for example, actually holding Israel accountable for its endless violations of international law, and recognizing that all actions must be based on the recognition that there is an occupier and an occupied, violator and violated, aggressor and victim, as opposed to continuing to pretend that there are two equal sides (or as became fashionable recently that the Palestinians are the aggressor and Israel is the victim that needs to be protected with European warships and "monitors").
Hence there has been endless chasing after the mirage by people who know or should know the mirage is just that, but who nevertheless insist that the water is real and they will soon drink it. The peace process industry have now transferred their attention to US President Barack Obama. They continue to scrutinize every "helpful" gesture or insignificant "move," reading into them mountains of hope and expectation -- while any much clearer and more pronounced indications that there will be no change of direction in US policy are conveniently ignored or explained away as campaign rhetoric.
We have reached the point now where every setback is reinterpreted as a "window of opportunity." Take for example the recent Israeli elections. As if the crowds of "experts" showing up on hungry satellite channels around the clock to analyze and assess could not cope with the demand, the search for new recruits has been on. Except for once when I answered some questions by phone for the Jordanian daily Al-Ghad, I declined numerous offers to participate in discussions of the Israeli election results. I expressed my standing belief that the Israeli election results will have no effect whatsoever on the peace process simply because the peace process has long been dead and a more extremist Tel Aviv regime would not make a dead thing more dead.
The leaders of the three biggest parties: Kadima, Likud and Yisrael Beitenu have not only been proclaiming loudly and clearly their adherence to policies that make peace impossible, but outbid each other with promises to back away from any minor hints of a more peaceful direction by previous administrations. There is no choice in Israel between moderation and extremism, but only between different flavors of extremism.
The truth which no one would dare to speak is that Hamas, with its offers of a long-term truce with Israel, and its readiness to recognize the 1967 borders is much more moderate and conciliatory than any significant Jewish Israeli party.
But the peace process industry will always be ready to deny reality and chase the mirage. Israel as a whole is so extremist and intransigent that even a right-wing, settlement building, warmongering national unity government of Kadima and Likud would be welcomed warmly by the "international community" as a peace government for which we should be thankful and eager to engage. Of course they will say -- as always -- that now is not the time for pressure on Israel or we might end up with a worse government! Even the months it might take for any Israeli government to be formed are no problem. This will provide a perfect alibi for the show to go on.
I wish we could dismiss these failed policies and their practitioners as the joke that they are. But those who pay the price for so much international negligence, complicity, lack of courage and accountability, are innocent people, most horrifyingly in Gaza. But their reality, their anger, their resistance is one that the mirage cannot conceal any longer.

14 Comments so far
Show AllI entirely agree with this author. I came to the same conclusion soon after the Oslo accords. Many among Palestinians have also more or less arrived at same inference that is why they are beginning to talk about a one state solution. Facts do not matter any more especially if we closely examine the progression of events in Gaza/Israeli border since the first truce was reached a few years ago.
The truth of the matter is that Israel is not willing to relinquish any land for peace and that the idea that Israel is waiting for the other side to stop violence is a farce. Most peace agreements that I can think, including Vietnam, South Africa, were negotiated as the violence continued. The occupier has systematically used the pretense for peace negotiations to make sure that any appropriated land will never be returned.
I recall that when apartheid South Africa acquired nuclear weapons, they and others believed that there is no way that a freedom movement would change the equation. What most did not understand is that whites in South Africa were minority and they could not be able to sustain eternally, the suppression of a majority.
I believe the best strategy is to revert to a one state solution because it is now clear that Israel will not relinquish land to 1967 borders that would enable Palestinians to form a viable state. It may take 50 or another 100 years for things to change but eventually the majority and righteous will prevail. So as the writer alludes, let us not pretend that there is a peace agreement in progress and that US will at some time in future pressure/persuade Israel to sign a peace agreement. But without the return of occupied land, Israel will never live in peace.
You see how easy it is to tell the truth
The Israelis are gaming the Palestinians – subterfuge while they steal more and more of Palestine
The want the whole thing – Gaza, the west bank and for those who read the Israeli policy Jordan as well
In addition the Israelis have sent delegations to Mosul and Baghdad to look into settlements in Iraq
No secrets here – its policy for those who read it
Not unlike the “full spectrum dominance” of the American military. How much confusion can there be about that
Throw in the EU - NATO - American plans to re-militarize the whole planet in a the modern digital colonization of the world
Against the background of environmental devastation, water wars, climate wars and general human misery and you begin to see the fruits of the Rothschild debt and war machine
Good morning Amerika
cheers, b
Israel is an illegitimate terrorist state holding Palestine (and the world) hostage, just as it did during the initial Zionist invasion. To expect violent terrorists to contemplate 'peace' is insane - we're talking here about people who hold the Nazis in high regard, and have stated so on many occaisons. Most Israelis obviously hold Nazi ideology as superior - after all, it has worked for over 60 years - and are NEVER going to give it up willingly. Terrorism works. Israel has proven that over and over again. Restoring Palestine is the ONLY hope for peace - and no terrorist worth his salt will EVER accept peace. So go figure.
The only hope for peace is democracy - goverment of the people, by the people, and for the people. ALL the people - not just the ones of a particular race. There will never be peace in Israel or the middle east until the people who live there give up tribalism. And that means turning their backs on that bogoted, frothy-mouthed, lunatic old racist: Jehovah.
http://www.users.bigpond.com/pmurray
http://www.paulmurray.id.au/ageofworms
bryan; i agree, i believe the break up of iraq, has a lot to do with more land for israel. biden is and was all for this breakup. he himself said [i am a zionist, one does not have to be a jew to be a zionist]. eventually the zionists will want lebannon, syria, jordan, parts of egypt, and their share of iraq. think [water].
You are very confused and weave together a most elaborate plot to wrap together a few discrete facts along with an overblown theory of Zionist intentions.
Yes, there are those in powerful positions within both the Israeli and US governments who prefer any potentially independent Arab state be shattered into a "failed state." This is true of Iraq. It is true for Lebanon.
It is also reasonable to conclude that Israel's REAL policy, as demonstrated by the actions of every Israeli government, is to talk of "peace" while "creating facts on the ground": meaning the continued annexation of the remaining Palestinian territories. The Israelis don't need to steal water from those other countries, so long as they can control the Jordan. To do this, they have to ignore or neutralize the Palestinian claims.
The Israelis do not want "Lebanon, Syria, Jordan, parts of Egypt and their share of Iraq." They only want compliant regimes in those countries. Stable, if compliant. Failed states, if they might be troublesome.
The Palestinians will not be allowed a viable state. They MAY be allowed dependent, disarmed "bantustans," in Netanyahu's phrase, similar to the "homelands" created by the apartheid regime of South Africa for black tribes within that country.
The reality of Israel's policies is bad enough. You needn't attribute superhuman, super evil plots to them.
bryan; i agree, i believe the break up of iraq, has a lot to do with more land for israel. biden is and was all for this breakup. he himself said [i am a zionist, one does not have to be a jew to be a zionist]. eventually the zionists will want lebannon, syria, jordan, parts of egypt, and their share of iraq. think [water].
I am a strong advocate for peace negotiations, even between mortal enemies.
But whenever you hear the three words uttered, "the peace process," check to make sure you still have your wallet. For the speaker is dishonest.
shliapnikov; it is not your wallet you have to check, it is what is inside your pants that you have to check.
When a young man, I fought (and bled) to save Israel from the world.
Then somewhat older, I worked trying to save Israel from itself.
Now aging on, I find myself wishing the world be saved from Israel.
I look into Palestinian eyes and I meet the souls of my poor forsaken brethren
from a fascist Europe to who's memory I swore never again.
This - as then- will not end well.
Pan
There is Hope .
Freedom and Liberty for ALL<<<<<< start there , and the word will get out and
a little trust will grow and maybe if we play by the same rules we can trust each other again.
God Bless, Allah bless, George Mitchell who has to deal with the most intractable problem in foreign affairs. (Ireland was a piece of cake compared.) There is no hope for a change in US policy as long as there is absent an outcry from American citizens about the Israeli/Palestine dispute. The mirage as desribed by this author continues as long
as folks refuse to recognize this issue as the prime motivator
of international terrorism and hatred of the USA.
Since most public opinion is formed by the media which cannot and will not (for reasons of powerful pressure)report the truth, that groundswell of support for a balanced foreign policy is absent. Only viewers and listeners of international news outlets, such as the BBC, even know that European outlook on Israel is different from our own.
A friend who frequents only major TV networks spoke recently about the need for a two-state solution. She was totally surprised when I argued that most thoughtful analysts of the situation say now that it will NEVER happen, and that a single state is the only solution. Obviously, she, like most Americans, are handed unworkable "mirage" answers which as unattainable as the so-called "peace process".
Couldn't agree more. What is needed now is, not more negotiations with the intransigent, fascist Zionists but, an ultimatum along the lines of: "Make peace with justice within the year or you will face a blockade of Gazan proportions and you will be shunned by the world as the rogue state that you are!"
By the way, if the Israelis worry about demographics, let them make more love and less war and they may well keep up with the birthrate of the Palestinians.