Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Delusional in Davos
Why the global business elite feel no remorse about the damage they've done.
Everything has to change in order for everything to stay the same," wrote the Italian author Giuseppe Tomasi di Lampedusa in his famous novel The Leopard. The novel is set in 19th-century Sicily, but Lampedusa could just as easily have been describing the 2009 World Economic Forum in Davos.
You notice it more in the corridors and the cafes of this exclusive Swiss hamlet rather than in onstage debates. Publicly, the discourse is all about the dangers of "false market assumptions" and the now-infamous "financial engineering." (I seem to remember it being called "financial innovation" last year.) But offstage, top bankers, private equity bosses, and hedge fund stars keep chitchatting and socializing, just as if banks had not had $1 trillion write-downs, the financial markets had not lost $25 trillion, and up to 30 million jobs were not at risk around the world.
To achieve this state of mind, any human being probably needs to construct a formidable mental shield. A survey I personally conducted at Davos this year of 60 top central bankers, financial market regulators, fund managers, and industry opinion-makers gives an idea of what this shield looks like.
When participants were asked whether they think they have done something in their career which "might have contributed, even in a minor way, to the financial crisis," 63.5 percent opted for a clear "no"; 31.5 percent went for a "yes," often adding in the same breath that nobody in the industry can honestly claim otherwise; and 5 percent said "maybe."
The "yes" people were then asked to explain what triggered their wrong decisions. They had three options: "too much optimism" (68.7 percent), "I felt I had to keep dancing while the music was playing" (31.3 percent), or "greed" (0 percent).
David Rubenstein, cofounder and managing director of the Carlyle Group, expressed surprise at the results. "How strange," he said. "I thought 100 percent of them would say they had nothing to do with it."
For all his wry humor, Rubenstein has a point. Psychological self-defense, a Darwinian instinct, is part of human nature, and "Davos Man" is no exception. Feelings of personal responsibility after a collective catastrophe are a matter for psychologists rather than World Economic Forum conversations, but the answers to the survey should come as no surprise.
For all the talk of the more "somber" mood at this year's event, there were about 100 more private jet movements
at the Zurich airport last week than during last year's event. I'm not sure if the irony was lost on the organizers who handed out pedometers to forum participants, to encourage them to walk and reduce their carbon footprint.
The conflicting attitudes of contrition and denial were evident at a special event on the "36 hours in September," when Lehman Brothers collapsed and the world changed. Nassim Nicholas Taleb, author of the bestselling The Black Swan, a book about hard-to-predict events, gave a presentation. The participants enjoyed his talk, which was brilliant and provocative as usual, but as he spoke, one couldn't help wondering if what they were actually enjoying was the simplistic comfort that Taleb's message could provide.
The audience seemed to enjoy the idea that the current crisis is a "Black Swan," a very unlikely, though possible, event. The alternative view is that of a train driven full speed into a wall. Thinking that way requires one to ask who was in the driver's seat, and just maybe recognizing one's own fingerprints on the wheel.
- Posted in



14 Comments so far
Show AllWell, I guess the good news is that their "mothers" didn't get blamed for their lack of remorse.
Or is that another chapter?
The "black swan" of downturn under capitalism is, in fact, an inevitable event. No one wants to be the "chicken little" who first sees the black swan, so they pretend not to notice until it grows to the size of a white elephant.
Hi Class Act: I don't agree with the author that this is a "Black Swan" event. A "Black Swan" implies that this was something unexpected. What had happened in the past year or so was a "White Swan" event. It was completely anticipated, which makes it all the more criminal. Regards.
Sioux Rose
W.T. Great point. What a conceit to think history does not apply to one's person. The deregulation of the banking industry allowing it to bet OTHERS' financial portfolios (and futures) on Wall St is what largely did U.S. in. And it's not like similar trends did not show how and why this can happen, given the financial events that led to the Great Depression. What will this then become, the Greater Depression? Buy your anti-DEPRESSION medication at wholesale prices now?
Years ago I joked with a friend that if a person lost a lot of money, they could go to a shrink for their "depression" or spend the same money getting a better accountant. How we treat symptoms without addressing cause(s) is a major American high art, also known as deception (or marketing, the terms are largely interchangeable).
Thanks Sioux Rose. Great response. Peace!
I do not think these ghouls will feel any remorse until they feel a pain in the neck and see a basket rapidly approaching.
As long as the ruling crass can keep showing us pictures of rich people living in luxury and pretending that we too can have a private jet if we just work hard enough, sheeple will remain docile defenders of the plutocratic system.
2015 - China keeps growing at a reduced rate of 5% as manufacturers everywhere continue to pile in. China & India are now like two huge black holes that are sucking the life out of the west. In the end 2025 the wealthy will have totally Chinese and Indian work forces and illegal So. American servant staffs. The rest of us will all ride be riding cheap Chinese bicycles and wearing hand made and discount store clothes and we'll be trying to feed our families from our own gardens. The state will educate our children just enough so they can read the street signs so they don't get run over by the speeding electric Mercedes and BMWs of the rich. Soylent green will still be made from people.
well--the IRONY of this is -- it was the WEST that IMPOSED the GLOBAL ECONOMIC ORDER of capitalism DEMANDING cheap labor and resources FROM countries like china and india and others - and has brought about these things.
china's cheap labor? US corporations DEMANDED it - as an OUTGROWTH and natural component of US capitalism , western economic "dominance" imposition through THEIR own colonialisms for decades and even centuries and policies that are ANTI LABOR and ANTI high wages -- and WHERE does it come from?
THE US and WESTERN CAPITALIST structure that spans the globe FORCING countries like china to "adopt" as PART of western imperialism - LED by the USA!!
it is simply the CHICKEN COMING HOME TO ROOST.
you see- THIS is a result of US imperialism: as General Smedley Butler nearly 100 years ago said:
"OUR FOREIGN POLICY has ALWAYS been geared towards gathering as much of the world's resources UNTO OURSELVES at the EXPENSE of OTHER , weaker nations.........the TRUE purpose of our Military is to make the world SAFE for Capitalism and the EXPLOITATION by OUR Businesses...and to do the bidding of our Chamber of Commerce....the US military is the BIG Muscle of our BIG MONEY and BIG FINANCE...I was ITS ENFORCER....it has nothing to do with Justice and Fairness...
and all in SERVICE of OUR BIG BOSS..........our Supernationalistic Capitalism".
Liberty must be taken for it to be liberty. People need to take their liberty from those who will abscond with it by exercising it daily.
good piece and, after reading cj's piece, it was a pleasure for it's brevity
look these guys just don't give a fuck
nothing more than that
they have created a pile of worthless debt which they dumped first on their investors and then incredibly - on the taxpayers
while they fly around in the planes and sit in the front row to watch rafa play tennis, licking their bonbons
they think we are assholes
and i got to say that paying off their scams with my tax dollars does make me feel like an asshole
cheers, b
The elite here are plotting to take advantage of the coming meltdown. They will consolidate their power during and after the mess they created. Fewer corporations mean more power. They have won we just don't want to see it.
Greed is the god of G8 leaders and Davos elitists. All of you are correct, they do not give a damn and will not until it effects them directly. Sort of like regular USA'ns dont care about foreign policy until it hits them directly. Then of course we all look to someone else for the blame.
I was on another site reading posts complaining about the continuing excessive bonus pay given out with taxpayer money. Amazing as it sounds regular employees of these large financial organizations were on the list making a case for recieving their share of the bonus. Posters pointed out a bonus is for good work, increasing the value of your company. Yet these regular cubicle drones, even as their company is worth half or less than a year ago claimed they deserve a bonus. Just for showing up every day! Detachment from reality runs throughout these organizations, lead of course by the leaders who have a complete disreguard for their fellow man.