|FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
JUNE 12, 1998
|CONTACT: Death Penalty Information Center
Richard Dieter, DPIC, 202/293-6970
Rita Radostitz, Attorney for Henry Lee Lucas, 512/320-8300 (Austin)
Looms Even As State Admits Guilt 'Highly Improbable'
Henry Lee Lucas Scheduled for Execution In Texas on June 30 Despite Exculpatory
Investigation by Atty General's Office
- June 12 - One of the most important and compelling death penalty cases in years is
quickly progressing toward an execution in Texas. Henry Lee Lucas is to be executed
on June 30 for a murder which two successive Texas Attorneys General concluded he almost
certainly did not commit. While Mr. Lucas is probably guilty of other offenses for which
he will never be released from prison, the offense for which he now faces lethal injection
occurred at a time when he was hundreds of miles away in Florida.
Death row inmates often raise claims of innocence prior to their execution, but rarely
are these claims confirmed by the state's own investigation. And when that does
happen, the execution is stopped and the inmate is taken off of death row. But in a
strange legal irony, the state is claiming that it is powerless to stop Mr. Lucas's
execution, leaving the matter to the courts. The courts, on the other hand, are
consistently reluctant to entertain claims of innocence after a person is convicted. Mr.
Lucas's conviction was made easy by his own confession to the murder of the unnamed
hitchhiker 19 years ago.
For years, Mr. Lucas has said that his confession was made up. On this score, he is
extremely credible. Mr. Lucas, a former mental patient, confessed to literally
hundreds of murders, including the murder of Jimmy Hoffa and the murder of his
fourth grade teacher (who is, in fact, still alive), and it is well established that many,
if not all, of these confessions were fabricated. But neither the courts nor those
considering his possible clemency need take Lucas's word as decisive.
Texas Attorney General Dan Morales conducted an investigation of the alleged
murder by Lucas two years ago and concluded that it was "highly unlikely" that
he committed the murder in question. Numerous pieces of evidence, such as labor records
showing him working as a roofer in Florida at the time of the crime,
interviews with neighbors, and a cashed check, all indicate that Mr. Lucas was far
away from Texas. No physical evidence linked him to the crime and the only reason to
believe that Lucas committed the Texas murder was his own confession, which is clearly
Morales's investigation followed an earlier inquiry by then Attorney General Jim
Mattox who likewise concluded that "in all probability Henry Lee Lucas did not
commit this crime." In a deposition, Mr. Mattox stated that if impartial law
enforcement procedures had been followed, "no rational juror could have found
Henry Lee Lucas guilty . . . ."
Once before the U. S. Supreme Court looked at the issue of executing a man from Texas
whose chief claim was his innocence. In that case, Herrera v. Collins (1993), the state
had vigorously rejected the evidence of innocence which Herrera offered. The Justices then
concluded that the Constitution may indeed bar the execution of the innocent-but-convicted
defendant, but Herrera's evidence failed to convince them that his innocence was
established. Now there is a capital case where innocence is not seriously in dispute.
In Herrera, the Court held that even if the courts failed to provide an innocent
defendant relief, there was still executive clemency as a safety valve. But since that
decision, no Texas death row inmate has been granted clemency, nor have the courts stopped
an execution solely on the basis of the defendant's innocence.
In his dissenting opinion in Herrera, Justice Harry Blackmun said that "Nothing
could be more . . . shocking to the conscience, than to execute a person who is
actually innocent." Henry Lee Lucas may not be the most sympathetic defendant to
appeal to the nation's conscience, but he may be the most clearly innocent of the
crime for which he is about to be executed.
Since the death penalty was reinstated, about a third of all executions have occurred in
Texas, including 37 last year alone.
|Common Dreams NewsCenter is a non-profit news service
providing breaking news and views for the Progressive Community.
press release posted here has been provided to Common Dreams NewsWire by
one of the many progressive organizations who make up America's Progressive Community.
you wish to comment on this press release or would like more information,
please contact the organization directly.
*all times Eastern US (GMT-5:00)
E-mail us your news release! firstname.lastname@example.org
© Copyrighted 1997-2000
All Rights Reserved. Common Dreams. www.commondreams.org