March, 23 2011, 02:02pm EDT
For Immediate Release
Contact:
Ken Bossong 301-270-6477 x.11
142 Groups/Businesses Call for End to U.S. Nuclear Power
In a group letter sent to President Obama, members of his Administration, and all the Members of the U.S. Congress, 142 organizations and businesses wrote that the Japanese nuclear accident is a tragic reminder that it is long past the time to end U.S. reliance on nuclear power.
The groups argued that nuclear plants can never be designed to withstand all potential "acts of God," all instances of "human error," all types of "mechanical malfunction," and all forms of "terrorist attack."
WASHINGTON
In a group letter sent to President Obama, members of his Administration, and all the Members of the U.S. Congress, 142 organizations and businesses wrote that the Japanese nuclear accident is a tragic reminder that it is long past the time to end U.S. reliance on nuclear power.
The groups argued that nuclear plants can never be designed to withstand all potential "acts of God," all instances of "human error," all types of "mechanical malfunction," and all forms of "terrorist attack."
Moreover, the still unfolding nuclear disaster in Japan once again underscores that there is no such thing as "safe" or "clean" or "cheap" nuclear power.
Consequently, no new reactors should be built in the Untied States and existing nuclear reactors should be phased out as rapidly as possible. Instead, national energy policy and funding should be refocused on greatly improved energy efficiency and the rapid deployment of renewable energy sources which are far cleaner, safer, and cheaper than nuclear power.
The text of the letter and list of signers follows.
# # # # # # #
March 23, 2011
President Barack Obama
Secretary of Energy Steven Chu
U.S. Senator Harry Reid
U.S. Senator Mitch McConnell
U.S. Representative John Boehner
U.S. Representative Nancy Pelosi
Members, U.S. Congress
Dear Sir/Madam:
We, the 142 undersigned safe energy advocates, have been speaking out about the risks and dangers posed by nuclear power for years - for many of us, since before the 1986 Chornobyl and 1979 Three Mile Island accidents as well as the hundreds of other radioactive releases, unplanned shut-downs, and other mishaps that have continuously plagued both the U.S. and the international nuclear industries since their founding.
While nuclear power's unacceptable safety, environmental, public health, economic, and national security risks should have been self-evident long before now, the latest unfolding nuclear disaster in Japan once again underscores the following:
Nuclear plants can never be designed to withstand all potential "acts of God."
Nuclear plants can never be designed to withstand all instances of "human error."
Nuclear plants can never be designed to withstand all types of "mechanical malfunction."
Nuclear plants can never be designed to withstand all forms of "terrorist attack."
There is no such thing as "safe" nuclear power.
There is no such thing as "clean" nuclear power.
There is no such thing as "cheap" nuclear power.
Consequently, the Price-Anderson cap on liability in the event of an accident should be repealed, all proposed governmental financial and regulatory incentives for new nuclear plant construction - including loan guarantees, accelerated licensing, and inclusion in a "clean energy standard" - should be rejected, and no new reactors should be built.
Existing nuclear reactors should be phased out as rapidly as possible, beginning with the oldest and/or most unsafe, and no presently-licensed reactors should have their operating lives extended.
Safety standards for existing reactors should be substantially tightened while they continue to operate and federal nuclear funding should be redirected to the orderly phase-out of those reactors as well as the safe decommissioning of closed reactors and disposal of radioactive waste.
National energy policy and funding should be refocused on greatly improved energy efficiency and the rapid deployment of renewable energy sources which are far cleaner, safer, and cheaper than nuclear power.
Sincerely,
Michael Closson, Executive Director
Acterra: Action for a Healthy Planet
Palo Alto, CA
Aur J. Beck, Chief Tech
Advanced Energy Solutions
Pomona, IL
Lesley Weinstock, Coordinator
Agua es Vida Action Team
Albuquerque, NM
Rochelle Becker, Executive Director
Alliance for Nuclear Responsibility
San Luis Obispo, CA
Laura Filbert Zacher, CEO
ARE Systems, LLC
St. Louis, MO
Thea Paneth, Secretary
Arlington United for Justice with Peace
Arlington, MA
Mari Rose Taruc, State Organizing Director
Asian Pacific Environmental Network
Oakland, CA
Lara Morrison, Board Member
Beverly-Vermont Community Land Trust
Los Angeles, CA
Kay Martin, Vice President
BioEnergy Producers Association
Gualala, CA
Kay Firor, President
Blue Mountain Solar, Inc.
Cove, OR
Sandra Gavutis, Executive Director
C-10 Research & Education Foundation
Newburyport, MA
Laurent Meillon, Director
Capitol Solar Energy LLC
Denver, CO
Elizabeth C. Battocletti, President
The Carmel Group, LLC
Reston, VA
Gwen Ingram, Vice President
The Carrie Dickerson Foundation
Tulsa, OK
Don Timmerman, Roberta Thurstin Timmerman
Casa Maria Catholic Worker Community
Milwaukee, WI
Kieran Suckling
Center for Biological Diversity
Washington, DC
Andy Kimbrell, Executive Director
Center for Food Safety
Washington DC
Lenny Siegel, Executive Director
Center for Public Environmental Oversight
Mountain View, CA
Lucy Law Webster, Executive Director
Center for War/Peace Studies
New York, NY
David Hughes, Executive Director
Citizen Power
Pittsburgh, PA
Deb Katz
Citizens Awareness Network
Shelburne, MA
Janet Greenwald, Co-coordinator
Citizens for Alternatives to Radioactive Dumping
Albuquerque, NM
Caroline Snyder
Citizens for Sludge-Free Land
North Sandwich, NH
Robert Singleton, Nuclear Issues Chair
Citizens Organized to Defend Austin
Austin, TX
Charlie Higley, Executive Director
Citizens Utility Board of Wisconsin
Madison, WI
Pam Solo, President
(Co-convener, TheCLEAN.org)
The Civil Society Institute
Newton, MA
Norm Cohen
Coalition for Peace and Justice
Linwood, NJ
Cristina Castro, Coordinator
CODEPINK NYC
New York, NY
Medea Benjamin, Co-Founder
CODEPINK Women for Peace
Washington, DC
Bill Gallegos, Executive Director
Communities for a Better Environment
Huntington Park & Oakland, CA
Tam Hunt, J.D., President,
Community Renewable Solutions LLC
Santa Barbara, CA
John Calandrelli, Chapter Program Director
Connecticut Chapter of Sierra Club
Hartford, CT
Nancy Burton, Director
Connecticut Coalition Against Millstone
Redding, CT
Luke Lundemo, Director
Conscious Living Project
Jackson, MS
Lois Arkin, Executive Director
CRSP Institute for Urban Ecovillages
Los Angeles, CA
Stephen M. Brittle, President
Don't Waste Arizona, Inc.
Phoenix, AZ
Kathryn Barnes, Board of Directors
Don't Waste Michigan - Sherwood Chapter
Sherwood, MI
Lois Barber, Co-founder & Executive Director
EarthAction & 2020 Action
Amherst, MA
Jane E. Magers, Coordinator
Earth Care, Inc
Des Moines, IA
Chris Trepal, Executive Director
Earth Day Coalition
Cleveland, OH
Al Fritsch, SJ
Earth Healing
Ravenna, KY
Lester R. Brown
Earth Policy Institute
Washington, DC
Jim Bell, Director
Ecological Life Systems Inst. Inc.
San Diego, CA
Mahlon Aldridge, Vice President
Ecology Action
Santa Cruz, CA
Cara L. Campbell, Chair
Ecology Party of Florida
Ft. Lauderdale, FL
Dan Stafford, Organizing Director
Environmental Action
Denver, CO
William Snape
Environmental Law Program
American University Law School
Washington, DC
Lillian K. Light, President
Environmental Priorities Network
Manhattan Beach, CA
Don Ogden, Producer
The Enviro Show-WXOJ-LP & WMCB
Florence, MA
Jennifer Barker
EORenew/SolWest Fair
Canyon City, OR
Ben Mancini, President
EV Solar Products, Inc.
Chino Valley, AZ
Judi Poulson, Chair
Fairmont, Minnesota USA Peace Group
Fairmont, MN
Linda S. Ochs, Director
Finger Lakes Citizens for the Environment
Waterloo, NY
Dan Brook, Ph.D.
Food for Thought---and Action
San Jose, CA
Jon Blickenstaff, Treasurer
Footprints for Peace
Cincinnati, OH
Nick Mann, Legislative Program Assistant-Environment
Friends Committee on National Legislation
Washington, DC
Richard V. Sidy, President
Gardens for Humanity
Sedona, AZ
Amanda Hill-Attkisson, Managing Director
Georgia Women's Action for New Directions
Atlanta, GA
Peter Meisen, President
Global Energy Network Institute
San Diego, CA
Bruce K. Gagnon, Coordinator
Global Network Against Weapons & Nuclear Power in Space
Brunswick, ME
Casey Coates Danson, President
Global Possibilities
Los Angeles, CA
Barbara Harris
Granny Peace Brigade NY
New York, NY
Vicky Steinitz
Greater Boston United for Justice with Peace Coalition
Boston, MA
Alisa Gravitz, Executive Director
Green America
Washington, DC
Jennifer Olaranna Viereck, Executive Director
HOME: Healing Ourselves & Mother Earth
N. Bennington, VT
Bonnie A. New, MD MPH; Director
Health Professionals for Clean Air
Houston, TX
Dr. Kathleen Sullivan, Program Director
Hibakusha Stories
New York, NY
David Morris, Vice President
Institute for Local Self-Reliance
Minneapolis, MN
Jaydee Hanson, Policy Director
International Center for Technology Assessment
Washington, DC
Victor Menotti, Executive Director
International Forum on Globalization
San Francisco, CA
Christian May, Founder
iSupportSolar
Frederick, MD
Daniel Ziskin, PhD; President
Jews Of The Earth
Boulder, CO
Andy McDonald, Director
Kentucky Solar Partnership
Appalachia - Science in the Public Interest
Frankfurt, KY
Kay Tiffany, Steering Committee
Lexington Global Warming Action Coalition
Lexington, MA
Paul Gallimore, Director
Long Branch Environmental Education Center
Leicester, NC
Greg Mello
Los Alamos Study Group
Albuquerque, NM
Claudine Cremer, Owner
Meadow Cove Farm
Weaverville, NC
Linda Belgrave, Secretary
Miami for Peace & Justice
Coral Gables, FL
Barbara Jennings, CSJ, Coordinator
Midwest Coalition for Responsible Investment
St. Louis, MO
Mark Haim, Chair
Missourians for Safe Energy
Columbia, MO
Judy Treichel, Executive Director
Nevada Nuclear Waste Task Force
Las Vegas, NV
Lilia Diaz, Outreach Director
New Energy Economy
Santa Fe, NM
Penelope McMullen, SL
New Mexico Justice and Peace Coordinator
Loretto Community
Santa Fe, NM
Carolyn Treadway
No New Nukes
Normal, IL
Wells Eddleman, Staff Scientist
North Carolina Citizens Research Group
Durham, NC
Larry Bell, President
North East Arizona Energy Services Company
Concho, AZ
Barbara Haack, Member
North Shore Coalition for Peace and Justice
Ipswich, MA
David Borris, President
North Suburban Peace Initiative and Chicago Area Peace Action
Evanston, IL
Nina Bell, J.D., Executive Director
Northwest Environmental Advocates
Portland, OR
Alice Slater, NY Director
Nuclear Age Peace Foundation
New York, NY
David Krieger, President
Nuclear Age Peace Foundation
Santa Barbara, CA
Wendy Oser, Director
Nuclear Guardianship Project
Berkeley, CA
Jack & Felice Cohen-Joppa, editors
The Nuclear Resister
Tucson, AZ
Arn Specter, Editor
The Nuclear Review
Philadelphia, PA
Glenn Carroll, Coordinator
Nuclear Watch South
Atlanta, GA
Chris Daum, President
Oasis Montana Inc. Renewable Energy Supply & Design
Stevensville, MT
Philip Tymon, Administrative Director
Occidental Arts and Ecology Center
Occidental, CA
Patricia A. Marida, Chair-Nuclear Issues Committee
Ohio Sierra Club
Columbus, OH
Dave Robinson, Executive Director
Pax Christi USA
Washington, DC
Judi Friedman, Chair
PACE (People's Action for Clean Energy, Inc.)
Canton, CT
Aviv Goldsmith, President
Precursor Systems, Inc.
Spotsylvania, VA
Launce Rake, Communications Director
Progressive Leadership Alliance of Nevada
Carson City/Las Vegas/Reno, Nevada
Elizabeth O'Nan, Director
Protect All Children's Environment
Marion, NC
Joy Blackwood
Public Health Educator
Landover, MD
Anne Mitchell, General Secretary
Quaker Earthcare Witness
Burlington, VT
Tor Allen, Executive Director
The Rahus Institute
Sebastopol, CA
Michael Welch, volunteer
Redwood Alliance
Arcata, CA
Tena Willemsma
Religious Leaders for Coalfield Justice
Winchester, VA
Quintin Bullis, GC-Sales/Installer Solar Energy Systems
Renaissance Developers
Tunnel, NY
Ron Leonard, Founder
RenewableEnergyCoalition.org
Woodstock, NY
Gordian Raacke, Executive Director
Renewable Energy Long Island
East Hampton, NY
Andreas Karelas, Executive Director
RE-volv
San Francisco, CA
Peggy Kurtz, Co-coordinator
Rockland Sierra Club
Nyack, NY
Russell Lowes, Research Director
Tucson, AZ
Clare Ritchie, Chairperson
Salem Peace Committee
Salem, MA
Elaine Holder, President
San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace
Mothers for Peace Action Committee
San Luis Obispo, CA
David Brown Kinloch, President
Shaker Landing Hydro Associates, Inc.
Louisville, KY
Rabbi Arthur Waskow, Director
The Shalom Center
Philadelphia, PA
Dennis R. Winters, Chair
Sierra Club - Pennsylvania Chapter
Philadelphia, PA
Mark Dickson, Owner
Simple Power, LLC (Renewable Energy Design and Installation)
Stevensville, MT
Sr. Ellen Orf, CPPS; Leadership Team member
Sisters of the Most Precious Blood
O'Fallon, MO
Diana Oleskevich CSJA, Justice Coordinator
Sisters of St. Joseph of Carondelet, St. Louis Province
St. Louis, MO
Scott Sklar, President
The Stella Group, Ltd.
Arlington, VA
Stuart Magruder, AIA, LEED, Principal
Studio Nova A Architects, Inc.
Los Angeles, CA
Erika Schneider, Outreach Coordinator
Sundance Power Systems
Weaverville, NC
Ken Bossong, Executive Director
SUN DAY Campaign
Takoma Park, MD
John F Neville, President
Sustainable Arizona
(statewide), AZ
Rona Fried, CEO
SustainableBusiness.com
Huntington Station, NY
Ron Hubert, President
Sustainable Economic Development Initiative of Northern Arizona
(Managing Director - Hozho International)
Flagstaff, AZ
Karen Hadden, Executive Director
Sustainable Energy & Economic Development (SEED) Coalition
Austin, TX
Melissa Everett, Ph.D., Executive Director
Sustainable Hudson Valley
Kingston, NY
Charles Jansen, Initiating Group Member
Transition Asheville
Asheville, NC
H. Patricia Hynes, Chair - Board
Traprock Center for Peace and Justice
Greenfield, MA
Chuck Learned, Director
Tri Local Returns
Madison, WI
Marylia Kelley, Executive Director
Tri-Valley CAREs
Livermore, CA
Dr. Brian Moench, President
Utah Physicians for a Healthy Environment
Salt Lake City, UT
Dr. Don Richardson
Western NC Physicians For Social Responsibility
Brevard, NC
Chris Herman, Owner
Winter Sun Design
(Interim President - Edmonds Community Solar Cooperative)
Edmonds, WA
Diane Farsetta, PhD, Executive Director
Wisconsin Network for Peace and Justice
Madison, WI
Virginia Pratt, Chair
Women's International League for Peace and Freedom
Boston, MA
Suzanne Maxx, Founder/President/Ex.Dir.
World Team Now
Malibu, CA
Nathalie Worthington, Owner
Worthington Studios
St. Petersburg, FL
LATEST NEWS
Defeating 'MAGA Dark Money,' Summer Lee Wins Primary in Landslide
"This is a huge testament to our collective strength and resilience as a progressive movement," said the executive director of Justice Democrats.
Apr 24, 2024
U.S. Rep. Summer Lee, a member of the progressive "Squad," won the Democratic primary for Pennsylvania's 12th Congressional District on Tuesday, fending off an opponent whose campaign was backed by a billionaire Republican megadonor and ally of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
Lee, a vocal critic of the Netanyahu government and leading supporter of a cease-fire in Gaza, handily defeated Bhavini Patel, a borough councilmember in Edgewood, Pennsylvania whose effort to unseat the progressive incumbent was bankrolled by Jeffrey Yass, the state's richest man. Patel actively courted Republican and pro-Israel voters, characterizing Lee as "fringe."
With more than 95% of the vote counted, Lee is ahead of Patel by more than 20 percentage points.
"I am so humbled and proud to win my first primary reelection to be the congresswoman for this incredible district I've spent my life fighting for," Lee said after the race was called in her favor. "Our campaign was built on a record of delivering for our democracy, defending our most fundamental rights, and expanding our vision for what is politically possible for our region's most marginalized communities."
"Our victory is a rejection of right-wing interests and Republican billionaires using corporate super PACs to target Black and brown Democrats in our primaries—be it AIPAC or Moderate PAC or any other MAGA billionaire in Democratic clothing," Lee added. "Western PA is the blueprint for the future all of America deserves."
Opposing genocide is good politics and good policy. #CeasefireNOWÂ https://t.co/A7pnJNskWS
— Summer Lee (@SummerForPA) April 24, 2024
Through the misleadingly named Moderate PAC, Yass—a prolific tax dodger who has been floated as a possible treasury secretary pick if former President Donald Trump wins another term—spent hundreds of thousands of dollars boosting Patel and attacking Lee.
Rahna Epting, executive director of MoveOn Political Action, said that by ushering Lee to victory, residents of Pennsylvania's 12th District "soundly rejected MAGA dark money."
"MoveOn members are ready to defeat this dangerous flood of dark-money spending against progressive champions and ensure that we continue to elect working-class people to Congress," said Epting.
"Now that it's clear Summer won her primary, AIPAC's super PAC has already officially failed at their one goal for this cycle: taking out the entire Squad."
During her 2022 campaign, Lee faced and overcame huge spending by the powerful pro-Israel lobbying group AIPAC via its super PAC, the United Democracy Project. But the organization opted to stay on the sidelines this time around, even as it plans to spend $100 million to defeat progressives in this year's cycle amid growing public opposition to Israel's war on Gaza.
"They had every intention of spending in this race—but they didn't, because they realized they would likely lose," Justice Democrats executive director Alexandra Rojas wrote in an email late Tuesday. "And that is because all of us had Summer's back and supported her campaign to out-organize AIPAC in every way."
"This is a huge testament to our collective strength and resilience as a progressive movement," said Rojas. "Now that it's clear Summer won her primary, AIPAC's super PAC has already officially failed at their one goal for this cycle: taking out the entire Squad."
While AIPAC ultimately sat out the Pennsylvania race, it is devoting considerable resources to ousting other progressive lawmakers, including Reps. Jamaal Bowman (D-N.Y.) and Cori Bush (D-Mo.).
The pro-Israel lobbying group has endorsed Bush challenger Wesley Bell, calling him a "strong advocate for the U.S.-Israel relationship." As The Guardianreported last week, Bell has "raised more than $650,000 in earmarked contributions through the group Democracy Engine Inc. PAC—a donation platform that allows unpopular PACs to obscure their donations and lists AIPAC as a client on its LinkedIn page."
AIPAC is the largest donor to Bowman challenger George Latimer, who has supported Israel's war on Gaza and denied that Israel is committing genocide. The Democratic primary for New York's 16th Congressional District is on June 25.
We must be clear-eyed about what's next. @JamaalBowmanNY & @CoriBush are facing an existential threat from AIPAC, their GOP megadonors, and the politicians willing to compromise on core Democratic values to try to take a school principal & nurse out of Congress. #ProtectTheSquad
— Justice Democrats (@justicedems) April 24, 2024
Michele Weindling, political director of the youth-led Sunrise Movement, said Tuesday that following Lee's victory, "we're ramping up to take on AIPAC in Jamaal Bowman's race."
"With a candidate like George Latimer willing to sell their lies to the district, we are going to prove once again that a politician's commitment to their community beats dark money every time," said Weindling. "Whether it's in Pittsburgh or New York, Minneapolis or St. Louis, our generation is going to send billionaires packing and reelect the squad."
Keep ReadingShow Less
Critics Blast 'Reckless and Impossible' Bid to Start Operating Mountain Valley Pipeline
"The time to build more dirty and dangerous pipelines is over," said one environmental campaigner.
Apr 23, 2024
Environmental defenders on Tuesday ripped the company behind the Mountain Valley Pipeline for asking the federal government—on Earth Day—for permission to start sending methane gas through the 303-mile conduit despite a worsening climate emergency caused largely by burning fossil fuels.
Mountain Valley Pipeline LLC sent a letter Monday to Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) Acting Secretary Debbie-Anne Reese seeking final permission to begin operation on the MVP next month, even while acknowledging that much of the Virginia portion of the pipeline route remains unfinished and developers have yet to fully comply with safety requirements.
"In a manner typical of its ongoing disrespect for the environment, Mountain Valley Pipeline marked Earth Day by asking FERC for authorization to place its dangerous, unnecessary pipeline into service in late May," said Jessica Sims, the Virginia field coordinator for Appalachian Voices.
"MVP brazenly asks for this authorization while simultaneously notifying FERC that the company has completed less than two-thirds of the project to final restoration and with the mere promise that it will notify the commission when it fully complies with the requirements of a consent decree it entered into with the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration last fall," she continued.
"Requesting an in-service decision by May 23 leaves the company very little time to implement the safety measures required by its agreement with PHMSA," Sims added. "There is no rush, other than to satisfy MVP's capacity customers' contracts—a situation of the company's own making. We remain deeply concerned about the construction methods and the safety of communities along the route of MVP."
Russell Chisholm, co-director of the Protect Our Water, Heritage, Rights (POWHR) Coalition—which called MVP's request "reckless and impossible"—said in a statement that "we are watching our worst nightmare unfold in real-time: The reckless MVP is barreling towards completion."
"During construction, MVP has contaminated our water sources, destroyed our streams, and split the earth beneath our homes. Now they want to run methane gas through their degraded pipes and shoddy work," Chisholm added. "The MVP is a glaring human rights violation that is indicative of the widespread failures of our government to act on the climate crisis in service of the fossil fuel industry."
POWHR and activists representing frontline communities affected by the pipeline are set to take part in a May 8 demonstration outside project financier Bank of America's headquarters in Charlotte, North Carolina.
Appalachian Voices noted that MVP's request comes days before pipeline developer Equitrans Midstream is set to release its 2024 first-quarter earnings information on April 30.
MVP is set to traverse much of Virginia and West Virginia, with the Southgate extension running into North Carolina. Outgoing U.S. Sen. Joe Manchin (D-W.Va.) and other pipeline proponents fought to include expedited construction of the project in the debt ceiling deal negotiated between President Joe Biden and congressional Republicans last year.
On Monday, climate and environmental defenders also petitioned the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit, challenging FERC's approval of the MVP's planned Southgate extension, contending that the project is so different from original plans that the government's previous assent is now irrelevant.
"Federal, state, and local elected officials have spoken out against this unneeded proposal to ship more methane gas into North Carolina," said Sierra Club senior field organizer Caroline Hansley. "The time to build more dirty and dangerous pipelines is over. After MVP Southgate requested a time extension for a project that it no longer plans to construct, it should be sent back to the drawing board for this newly proposed project."
David Sligh, conservation director at Wild Virginia, said: "Approving the Southgate project is irresponsible. This project will pose the same kinds of threats of damage to the environment and the people along its path as we have seen caused by the Mountain Valley Pipeline during the last six years."
"FERC has again failed to protect the public interest, instead favoring a profit-making corporation," Sligh added.
Others renewed warnings about the dangers MVP poses to wildlife.
"The endangered bats, fish, mussels, and plants in this boondoggle's path of destruction deserve to be protected from killing and habitat destruction by a project that never received proper approvals in the first place," Center for Biological Diversity attorney Perrin de Jong said. "Our organization will continue fighting this terrible idea to the bitter end."
Keep ReadingShow Less
'Seismic Win for Workers': FTC Bans Noncompete Clauses
Advocates praised the FTC "for taking a strong stance against this egregious use of corporate power, thereby empowering workers to switch jobs and launch new ventures, and unlocking billions of dollars in worker earnings."
Apr 23, 2024
U.S. workers' rights advocates and groups celebrated on Tuesday after the Federal Trade Commission voted 3-2 along party lines to approve a ban on most noncompete clauses, which Democratic FTC Chair Lina Khansaid "keep wages low, suppress new ideas, and rob the American economy of dynamism."
"The FTC's final rule to ban noncompetes will ensure Americans have the freedom to pursue a new job, start a new business, or bring a new idea to market," Khan added, pointing to the commission's estimates that the policy could mean another $524 for the average worker, over 8,500 new startups, and 17,000 to 29,000 more patents each year.
As Economic Policy Institute (EPI) president Heidi Shierholz explained, "Noncompete agreements are employment provisions that ban workers at one company from working for, or starting, a competing business within a certain period of time after leaving a job."
"These agreements are ubiquitous," she noted, applauding the ban. "EPI research finds that more than 1 out of every 4 private-sector workers—including low-wage workers—are required to enter noncompete agreements as a condition of employment."
The U.S. Chamber of Commerce has suggested it plans to file a lawsuit that, as The American Prospectdetailed, "could more broadly threaten the rulemaking authority the FTC cited when proposing to ban noncompetes."
Already, the tax services and software provider Ryan has filed a legal challenge in federal court in Texas, arguing that the FTC is unconstitutionally structured.
Still, the Democratic commissioners' vote was still heralded as a "seismic win for workers." Echoing Khan's critiques of such noncompetes, Public Citizen executive vice president Lisa Gilbert declared that such clauses "inflict devastating harms on tens of millions of workers across the economy."
"The pervasive use of noncompete clauses limits worker mobility, drives down wages, keeps Americans from pursuing entrepreneurial dreams and creating new businesses, causes more concentrated markets, and keeps workers stuck in unsafe or hostile workplaces," she said. "Noncompete clauses are both an unfair method of competition and aggressively harmful to regular people. The FTC was right to tackle this issue and to finalize this strong rule."
Morgan Harper, director of policy and advocacy at the American Economic Liberties Project, praised the FTC for "listening to the comments of thousands of entrepreneurs and workers of all income levels across industries" and finalizing a rule that "is a clear-cut win."
Demand Progress' Emily Peterson-Cassin similarly commended the commission "for taking a strong stance against this egregious use of corporate power, thereby empowering workers to switch jobs and launch new ventures, and unlocking billions of dollars in worker earnings."
While such agreements are common across various industries, Teófilo Reyes, chief of staff at the Restaurant Opportunities Centers United, said that "many restaurant workers have been stuck at their job, earning as low as $2.13 per hour, because of the noncompete clause that they agreed to have in their contract."
"They didn't know that it would affect their wages and livelihood," Reyes stressed. "Most workers cannot negotiate their way out of a noncompete clause because noncompetes are buried in the fine print of employment contracts. A full third of noncompete clauses are presented after a worker has accepted a job."
Student Borrower Protection Center (SBPC) executive director Mike Pierce pointed out that the FTC on Tuesday "recognized the harmful role debt plays in the workplace, including the growing use of training repayment agreement provisions, or TRAPs, and took action to outlaw TRAPs and all other employer-driven debt that serve the same functions as noncompete agreements."
Sandeep Vaheesan, legal director at Open Markets Institute, highlighted that the addition came after his group, SBPC, and others submitted comments on the "significant gap" in the commission's initial January 2023 proposal, and also welcomed that "the final rule prohibits both conventional noncompete clauses and newfangled versions like TRAPs."
Jonathan Harris, a Loyola Marymount University law professor and SBPC senior fellow, said that "by also banning functional noncompetes, the rule stays one step ahead of employers who use 'stay-or-pay' contracts as workarounds to existing restrictions on traditional noncompetes. The FTC has decided to try to avoid a game of whack-a-mole with employers and their creative attorneys, which worker advocates will applaud."
Among those applauding was Jean Ross, president of National Nurses United, who said that "the new FTC rule will limit the ability of employers to use debt to lock nurses into unsafe jobs and will protect their role as patient advocates."
Angela Huffman, president of Farm Action, also cheered the effort to stop corporations from holding employees "hostage," saying that "this rule is a critical step for protecting our nation's workers and making labor markets fairer and more competitive."
Keep ReadingShow Less
Most Popular