For Immediate Release
Senate Committee Will Take Up 'Reform' Bill That Would Protect Corrupt Gun Dealers
WASHINGTON - The Senate Judiciary Committee has announced plans to hold a hearing
next Tuesday on a bill that would severely undermine the powers of a key
Federal law enforcement agency to police the nation's most reckless gun
The Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF) "Reform
and Firearms Modernization Act," would severely undermine federal gun
law enforcement and protect corrupt gun dealers. The legislation would
make it virtually impossible for ATF to revoke the licenses of gun
dealers who violate federal law.
"This bill is only ‘reform' from the perspective of corrupt gun dealers
who want to be free from law enforcement scrutiny," said Paul Helmke,
President of the Brady Campaign to Prevent Gun Violence. "Almost 60
percent of crime guns are traced to just one percent of the gun dealers
in America. Those are the gun dealers that would benefit from this
legislation." Helmke has a new blog posted on the legislation: Read it
at http://www.huffingtonpost.com/paul-helmke/nra-campaigns-to-protect_b_710496.html or www.blog.bradycampaign.org.
On Monday, September 7, the Washington Post editorialized against the
bill, saying it would "force the ATF to provide repeated warnings before
moving against wayward dealers. The bar for action is set so high that
it would make it all but impossible for the ATF to press forward with
any case* The bill in some instances would give gun dealers who had
broken the law a free pass. For example, a dealer whose license had been
revoked would be given 60 days to liquidate his inventory."
ATF is already hamstrung by built-in protections for rogue gun dealers,
and this bill would tie them down them ever more. The problem of rogue
gun dealers is vividly illustrated by former NRA Board Member Sanford
Abrams, who owned Valley Gun shop near Baltimore, Maryland. His shop
violated federal law over 900 times, and after nearly a decade of
violations, ATF was finally able to revoke its firearms license. The
U.S. Department of Justice called Valley Gun an "irresponsible gun shop"
that engaged in "dangerous operations" as a "serial violator" of gun
Under this proposed legislation, in cases like Abrams' where an
irresponsible dealer was repeatedly violating federal gun laws, the
burden imposed by the legislation to show "willfulness" - defined in the
bill as requiring a specific intent to break specific law - would make
license revocation nearly impossible. Moreover, the legislation caps
fines at $7,500 per inspection, which in Abrams' case could have
amounted to less than $8.50 per violation of federal gun laws.
Some of the worst provisions in the bill:
- The legislation would make it virtually impossible for ATF to
shut down rogue gun dealers, including those who repeatedly violate
federal law. The legislation would require ATF to show that a dealer
knew the specific law he or she was violating and intentionally
disregarded the law. Under current law, ATF can revoke a license for
repeated violations of law without also proving that the dealer
specifically intended to break the law. This legislation also
re-classifies federal gun laws as "serious" and "minor" and allows
license revocation only for so-called "serious" violations. So-called
"minor" violations would include dangerous dealer conduct, such as when a
dealer "loses" hundreds of guns.
- The legislation would allow ATF to impose fines or temporary
license suspensions only if ATF proves that a dealer specifically
intended to violate the law, an extremely difficult burden of proof. If
ATF were able to meet this new burden, the maximum fine would be limited
to $7,500 for all violations found at an inspection of a gun dealer.
This is extremely low - sellers of unsafe products other than guns, for
example, face fines of $8,000 per violation, up to $1,825,000. ATF would
also have to postpone sanctions in most cases through years of court
- The legislation would allow most dealers who violate gun laws to
continue selling guns for 60 days after their licenses are revoked or
expire, even if they committed willful violations of federal law. It
also would allow dealers who violate federal law to evade closure by
transferring their businesses to friends or family. The legislation
would redefine federal law to make it more difficult to sanction dealers
who fail to keep proper records that are vital to enable ATF to trace
"The ATF needs more authority to build cases against the worst behaving
gun dealers in America, not less authority," Helmke said. "This bill
is appalling, and needs to be defeated."
As the nation's largest, non-partisan, grassroots organization leading
the fight to prevent gun violence, the Brady Campaign, with its
dedicated network of Million Mom March Chapters, works to enact and
enforce sensible gun laws, regulations and public policies. The Brady
Campaign is devoted to creating an America free from gun violence, where
all Americans are safe at home, at school, at work, and in our
The Brady Center to Prevent Gun Violence and its legislative and grassroots affiliate, the Brady Campaign and its dedicated network of Million Mom March Chapters, is the nation's largest, non-partisan, grassroots organization leading the fight to prevent gun violence.
We are devoted to creating an America free from gun violence, where all Americans are safe at home, at school, at work, and in our communities.