March, 08 2010, 10:29am EDT
For Immediate Release
Contact:
Jerry Phillips (850) 877-8097; Kirsten Stade (202) 265-7337
EPA Sets Clean Water Bar for Forida Too Low
Proposed Federal Standards Ignore EPA Guidelines and Bypass Peer Review
TALLAHASSEE, Fla.
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency ignored its own scientists
and quality control procedures in formulating proposed numeric
standards to regulate nutrient levels in Florida waters, according to
testimony submitted today by Public Employees for Environmental
Responsibility (PEER). As a result, if adopted, the EPA standards will
classify waters that are impaired as healthy.
Forced by
successful environmental lawsuits citing its failure to enforce the
federal Clean Water Act in Florida, EPA announced in the waning days of
the Bush administration that it would act to set "numeric" pollution
standards for nutrients, such as phosphorus, to replace subjective
"narrative criteria" used by the Florida Department of Environmental
Protection (DEP). Even under the state's current lax methods, one-third
of all Florida lakes, one-quarter of its estuaries and one-sixth of its
rivers are officially classified as "impaired" by pollution -
proportions likely to go much higher under rigorous numeric standards.
An "impaired" designation triggers legal requirements for pollution
discharge reductions and other measures to bring the water-body back to
a healthy, functioning (swimmable and fishable) condition.
Rather
than set rigorous, science-based numeric criteria, PEER has charged EPA
officials in its Atlanta regional office with overriding the agency's
technical experts and proposing standards that are so weak they would,
in essence, legitimize unreasonably high pollution levels as protective
of water quality. Among improprieties cited by PEER are that EPA -
- Ignored its own guidelines for how to set such ecological standards;
- Bypassed peer review of the proposed standards, instead developing standards in closed door meetings with state officials; and
- Eschewed
applying a safety factor that EPA normally uses to set water quality
criteria so as to provide water-bodies with breathing room if they are
absorbing pollution right up to the limits.
"These
standards are like the phony exams given to basketball players with
questions like how much is a three-point basket worth," stated PEER
Florida Director Jerry Phillips, a former DEP water enforcement
attorney, noting that the Obama administration has yet to select an EPA
Regional Administrator for the southeastern states, including Florida.
"Here we have the same holdover EPA managers who presided over
deteriorating Florida water quality committing professional malpractice
to cover their past failures."
Florida DEP, which put out a
joint press release with EPA in 2009 to herald this effort, has since
changed its public posture. It has joined industry groups and other
current and former state officials who have protested proposed EPA
standards as unnecessary and expensive.
"Opponents are shedding
crocodile tears, knowing that if they bawl loudly enough the politics
will water down any changes to the point where they are meaningless,"
Phillips added. "PEER supports numeric criteria provided that they are
strict enough to actually protect Florida's waters."
See the January 2009 joint Florida-EPA announcement of numeric standards
Look at worsening Florida water pollution
Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility (PEER) is a national alliance of local state and federal resource professionals. PEER's environmental work is solely directed by the needs of its members. As a consequence, we have the distinct honor of serving resource professionals who daily cast profiles in courage in cubicles across the country.
LATEST NEWS
'There Is No Defense for Forced Famine,' Says Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez
"Starving a million innocent people to death by halting and slowing U.S. humanitarian assistance is a massive, deliberate choice."
Mar 25, 2024
U.S. Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez on Sunday reiterated her description of the Israeli military's actions in Gaza as a "forced famine" and pushed back on the Netanyahu government's claim that it is targeting militants who carried out the October 7 attack.
"There is no targeting of Hamas in precipitating a mass famine of a million people, half of whom are children," Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) told CNN's Jake Tapper just two days after she delivered a floor speech characterizing conditions on the ground in Gaza as "an unfolding genocide."
The New York Democrat said Sunday that she believes the Israeli government's conduct in Gaza—from obstructing aid shipments to bombing densely populated areas—"have crossed the threshold of intent," a necessary condition of genocide.
"It is horrific," she said, noting that the even U.S. State Department has admitted the Israeli government is intentionally stonewalling aid deliveries, fueling starvation across the territory.
Asked to respond to the Israeli government's claim that the war would end within a day if Hamas released all the remaining hostages and dropped its arms, Ocasio-Cortez said, "The actions of Hamas should not be tied to whether a three-year-old can eat."
"The actions of Hamas do not justify forcing thousands, hundreds of thousands of people to eat grass as their bodies consume themselves," she continued. "The Israeli government has a right to go after Hamas, but we are talking about a population of millions of innocent Palestinians. We are talking about collective punishment."
CNN with all the resources can't determine if Israel is intentionally causing this famine, which UN and EU top diplomat & others said it's a ‘Man-made famine’ that led AOC to believe that's a genocide "I think with a forced famine is beyond our ability to deny or explain away" https://t.co/NwIMvnkB3l pic.twitter.com/48W73D3bsT
— HalalFlow (@halalflow) March 24, 2024
In a social media post following her CNN appearance, Ocasio-Cortez wrote that "starving a million innocent people to death by halting and slowing U.S. humanitarian assistance is a massive, deliberate choice."
The post came in response to criticism from the Anti-Defamation League (ADL), which has been described as "Israel's Attack Dog in the U.S." The group declared that the Israeli military is working to "cripple Hamas terrorists" and said those warning of genocide "merely perpetuate false claims and foster hate."
Ocasio-Cortez replied that the starvation Israel is inflicting on Gaza civilians with its suffocating blockade is both "irrelevant" to the government's stated objective of targeting Hamas and brings it "further out of reach and endangers hostages."
"There is no defense for forced famine," Ocasio-Cortez wrote.
The New York Democrat's assessment of the dire humanitarian crisis in Gaza mirrors that of United Nations experts, aid agencies, and humanitarian organizations.
On Sunday, the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA)—the primary humanitarian aid organization operating in Gaza—said the Israeli government has informed the U.N. that it "will no longer approve any UNRWA food convoys" to the northern part of the enclave, which is facing famine.
In recent weeks, dozens of people have died of starvation and dehydration—most of them in northern Gaza.
"This is outrageous and makes it intentional to obstruct lifesaving assistance during a man-made famine," Philippe Lazzarini, UNRWA's commissioner-general, said of Israel's decision to fully cut off UNRWA food shipments to northern Gaza.
"By preventing UNRWA to fulfill its mandate in Gaza, the clock will tick faster towards famine and many more will die of hunger, dehydration, and lack of shelter," he warned. "This cannot happen, it would only stain our collective humanity."
Keep ReadingShow Less
Sanders: 'The Netanyahu Gov't Should Not Receive Another Penny from US'
The bill passed the Senate in a 74-24 vote at 2:03AM
Mar 23, 2024
Following the passing of the U.S. government appropriations bill early Saturday morning, Senator Bernie Sanders said:
I voted NO on the appropriations bill that the Senate passed last night. While hundreds of thousands of Palestinian children face starvation in Gaza, this bill actually prohibits funding to UNWRA, the key United Nations aid agency delivering life-saving humanitarian support. This will only intensify the already horrific situation in Gaza. This bill also provides another $3.3 billion in U.S. military aid for Netanyahu’s right-wing government to continue this barbaric war. The Netanyahu government should not receive another penny from U.S. taxpayers.
The bill passed the Senate in a 74-24 vote at 2:03AM Saturday morning following hours of intense negotiations.
Later on Saturday, President Biden signed the $1.2 trillion government funding bill to stave off a government shutdown.
Keep ReadingShow Less
Modi Government Crackdown on Dissent Hits 'Crisis Point' Before Indian Elections
"The growing crackdown clearly shows the authorities' blatant disregard for human rights and rule of law," said one Amnesty International campaigner.
Mar 22, 2024
As India's right-wing government cracks down on opposition ahead of next month's general elections, Amnesty International on Friday urged authorities to "stop weaponizing the criminal justice system to intimidate and harass" political candidates, activists, and others.
Protests broke out in the capital New Delhi and other Indian cities after police on Thursday arrested Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal, an opposition leader from the Aam Aadmi Party, over corruption allegations AAP members say are politically motivated. Two other AAP leaders were previously arrested in connection with the same case, which involves the alleged favoring of certain alcohol vendors and illegal campaign financing.
Authorities also froze the bank accounts of another leading opposition party, the Indian National Congress, over a tax dispute that dates back to 2018. Party leader Sonia Gandhi accused Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi's Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) party of perpetrating "a systematic effort to cripple the party financially."
“They want to know we are corrupt like them, which is not the case.” – AAP chief spokesperson Priyanka Kakkar on the BJP’s crackdown on opposition politicians.
AAP leader Arvind Kejriwal was arrested just today on charges of corruption.
The India Report: https://t.co/rxPr6zKnWx pic.twitter.com/P3eSbxVTVm
— Al Jazeera English (@AJEnglish) March 21, 2024
Gandhi, Kejriwal and others have repeatedly accused of Modi's government of misusing federal agencies and resources to repress opposition figures as elections loom. The BJP denies the allegations.
"The Bharatiya Janata Party-led Indian government's crackdown on peaceful dissent and opposition has now reached a crisis point," Amnesty International India board chair Aakar Patel said in a statement.
"The authorities have repeatedly exploited and weaponized various financial and terrorism laws to systematically crack down on human rights defenders, activists, critics, nonprofit organizations, journalists, students, academics, and political opposition," Patel added. "The arrest of Arvind Kejriwal and the freezing of Indian National Congress' bank accounts a few weeks before India holds its general elections show the authorities' blatant failure to uphold the country's international human rights obligations."
Patel continued:
What we are witnessing is a brutal crackdown on human rights including through the misuse of central investigative and financial agencies, attacks on peaceful protests, arbitrary arrests, use and export of invasive spyware for unlawful surveillance, [and] systematic discrimination against religious minorities to feed into their majoritarian Hindutva politics and targeted suspension of opposition leaders from the Parliament who dare to hold the authorities to account.
"The growing crackdown clearly shows the authorities' blatant disregard for human rights and rule of law," Patel added. "Authorities must respect, protect, promote, and fulfill the human rights of everyone in the country including human rights defenders, activists, and opposition candidates before, during, and after the general elections which are due to begin in April 2024. Authorities must also ensure access to justice and effective remedies for victims of human rights violations."
On Thursday, the U.S. House of Representatives' bipartisan Tom Lantos Human Rights Commission held a hearing on the situation in India.
The commission noted that in recent years, as Modi and the BJP have consolidated power, "concerns about human rights abuses in India have grown" over "a wide range of significant rights issues, including restrictions on religious and press freedoms, violence or threats of violence targeting members of national/racial/ethnic and religious minorities, harassment of and restrictions on civil society and human rights organizations, corruption, and lack of accountability."
Keep ReadingShow Less
Most Popular