February, 04 2010, 01:45pm EDT
Patient Safety Advocates Launch Campaign to Reduce Resident Physician Fatigue, Boost Patient Safety
Groups Call for Shorter Shifts and More Supervision, Create Web Site to Solicit Public’s Involvement
WASHINGTON
A coalition of public interest and patient safety groups launched a
campaign today to increase public awareness and gather stories about
patients who have received inferior medical care from fatigued
physicians.
At www.WakeUpDoctor.org,
which went live today, the public can get background information about
the correlation between physician sleep deprivation and patient safety,
share stories and sign on to a letter expressing support for
commonsense regulations to reduce the number of work hours and enhance
supervision of resident physicians.
Public Citizen, Mothers Against Medical Errors and other patient
advocates also sent a letter to the Accreditation Council on Graduate
Medical Education (ACGME), the group that oversees the training of
physicians in the U.S., calling for shorter shifts and more supervision
of resident physicians (also known as medical residents) in an effort
to boost patient safety. More than 40 health care, patient safety and
other public interest advocates have signed the letter.
In a telephone news conference today, residents and experts spoke
about the dangers posed by medical residents working shifts as long as
30 hours, frequently with limited support or supervision, leaving them
exhausted and prone to mistakes. Residents may work as many as 10 of
these 30-hour shifts a month.
"Few, if any, people would fly on a plane whose pilot had been awake
and working for 25 to 30 hours. Federal regulations prohibit pilots
from flying more than 30 to 35 hours a week," said Dr. Sidney Wolfe,
director of Public Citizen's Health Research Group. "But because
medical residents work on shifts lasting as long as 30 hours straight,
they become fatigued, making them more susceptible to making errors
that greatly harm patients. It is likely that there are more deaths in
U.S. hospitals each year caused by sleep-deprived doctors than the
total annual deaths from plane crashes and train accidents."
The scientific evidence linking acute and chronic sleep deprivation
with preventable medical errors has mounted steadily over the years,
Wolfe said. "Reducing the length of their shifts is the commonsense
approach that both the medical field and consumers need."
The Institute of Medicine (IOM) in December 2008 issued a landmark
report, "Resident Duty Hours: Enhancing Sleep, Supervision and Safety."
The comprehensive review listed 10 recommendations for change,
including an increase in supervision of junior residents and a
significant reduction in work hours - from 30-hour shifts to shifts no
longer than 16 hours. The ACGME board of directors will meet Feb. 7-9
to discuss changing its policy on work hours in light of this report.
Ample evidence has shown that marathon shifts in excess of 16 hours
can have a detrimental effect on a physician's abilities and judgment.
"After 24 hours without sleep, attentional failures at night double
and impairment of reaction time is comparable to the impairment induced
by drinking alcohol," said Dr. Chuck Czeisler, a professor and director
of sleep medicine divisions at Harvard Medical School and Brigham and
Women's Hospital. "The clinical performance of physicians - who are
used to being at the top of the class - drops to the seventh percentile
of their rested performance. Yet, as with alcohol, those affected by
sleep loss often do not recognize their impairment."
In 2006, the Harvard Work Hours, Health and Safety Group at Brigham
and Women's Hospital in Boston reported that one in five first-year
resident physicians admitted making a fatigue-related mistake that
injured a patient. One in 20 admitted a fatigue-related mistake that
resulted in a patient's death.
"Considerable scientific evidence backs up what common sense tells
me: that life and death decisions should not be made by someone who is
sleep-deprived," said Dr. John Ingle, fourth-year ear, nose and throat
resident at the University of New Mexico and regional vice president of
the Committee of Interns and Residents/SEIU Healthcare. "My patients
are consistently horrified when they learn that I haven't gone to sleep
since they saw me the previous day."
Many suspect that a major factor leading to these exorbitantly long
shifts is tradition in the medical field; because seasoned doctors had
to endure long hours when they were training, they believe incoming
physicians should be subject to the same conditions.
Helen Haskell, the founder and president of Mothers Against Medical
Error, became involved in patients' rights after her 15-year-old son
died from a preventable medical error. When her son went to the
hospital for an elective procedure in 2000, he died from "failure to
rescue," or failure to recognize and act upon the signs of serious
decline in a patient.
"I know that fatigue must have played a role in my son Lewis's
intern's judgment and in her inability to buck the system for the sake
of a patient," said Haskell. "There is no way I can ever know how large
a role it played, but I do know that in those hours of crisis, the last
thing we needed was to have an exhausted, unsupervised young trainee as
my dying child's only lifeline."
Another well-known case of a fatal medical error was that of Libby
Zion, an 18-year-old whose 1984 death in a New York City hospital
spurred new limits for resident work hours. After Zion's death, her
father, journalist Sidney Zion, brought charges against the hospital
and the physicians, indicting the medical training system for excessive
work hours and poor supervision that, he argued, contributed to poor
judgment and medical negligence. As a result of Zion's crusade, New
York state has stronger work hours rules than the rest of the country.
For current and future resident doctors, these are cautionary tales.
"Medical training must promote supportive teamwork, not rugged
individualism," said Daniel Henderson, health justice fellow at the
American Medical Student Association. "Try as we might to ignore our
own limits, all doctors are humans, and we all need sleep."
Other industries impose limits on the hours employees work in a
given shift to prevent fatigue-related accidents. It's time for the
medical field to follow suit.
"Federal regulators and the airline industry long ago recognized
that pilots and crews should not have unlimited duty hours. As a
result, flight crews' duty time is closely regulated so as to minimize
the potential for crew fatigue and its potential lethal consequences,"
said Art Levin, director of the Center for Medical Consumers and a
reviewer of the IOM report. "Patients and medical residents deserve the
same protection."
To learn more, to share stories and to sign the letter to the ACGME, visit www.WakeUpDoctor.org.
Public Citizen is a nonprofit consumer advocacy organization that champions the public interest in the halls of power. We defend democracy, resist corporate power and work to ensure that government works for the people - not for big corporations. Founded in 1971, we now have 500,000 members and supporters throughout the country.
(202) 588-1000LATEST NEWS
Amid Spying Fight, House Passes Fourth Amendment Is Not For Sale Act
"As FANFSA and the 702 reauthorization move to the Senate, lawmakers in that chamber need to take a stand for the rights of people in the United States," said one advocate.
Apr 17, 2024
While applauding the U.S. House of Representatives' bipartisan passage of a bill to ensure that "law enforcement and intelligence agencies can't do an end-run around the Constitution by buying information from data brokers" on Wednesday, privacy advocates highlighted that Congress is trying to extend and expand a long-abused government spying program.
The House voted 219-199 for Fourth Amendment Is Not For Sale Act (FANFSA), which won support from 96 Democrats and 123 Republicans, including the lead sponsor, Rep. Warren Davidson (R-Ohio). Named for the constitutional amendment that protects against unreasonable searches and seizures, H.R. 4639 would close what campaigners call the data broker loophole.
"The privacy violations that flow from law enforcement entities circumventing the Fourth Amendment undermine civil liberties, free expression, and our ability to control what happens to our data," said Free Press Action policy counsel Jenna Ruddock. "These impacts affect everyone who uses digital platforms that extract our personal information any time we open a browser or visit social media and other websites—even when we go to events like demonstrations and other places with our phones revealing our locations."
"We're grateful that the House passed these vital and popular protections," she added. "The bill would prevent flagrant abuses of our privacy by government authorities in league with unscrupulous third-party data brokers. Making this legislation into law with Senate passage too would be a decisive and long-overdue action against government misuse of this clandestine business sector that traffics in our personal data for profit."
Wednesday's vote followed the House sending the Reforming Intelligence and Securing America Act to the Senate. H.R. 7888 would reauthorize Section 702 of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA), which allows for warrantless spying on noncitizens abroad but also sweeps up Americans' data.
The House notably included an amendment forcing a wide range of individuals and businesses to cooperate with government spying operations but rejected an amendment that would have added a warrant requirement to the bill, which the Senate could vote on as soon as Thursday.
Noting those decisions on the FISA reauthorization legislation, Ruddock stressed that "today's vote is a victory but follows a recent loss and ongoing threat as that Section 702 bill moves to the Senate this week too."
"As FANFSA and the 702 reauthorization move to the Senate, lawmakers in that chamber need to take a stand for the rights of people in the United States," she argued. "That means passing FANFSA and reforming Section 702 authority—and prioritizing everyone's First and Fourth Amendment rights."
Jeramie Scott, senior counsel and director of the Electronic Privacy Information Center's Project on Surveillance Oversight, also praised the House's FANFSA passage on Wednesday.
"The passage of the Fourth Amendment Is Not For Sale underscores the extent to which reining in abusive warrantless surveillance is a bipartisan issue," Scott said. "We urge the Senate to take up this measure and close the data broker loophole."
Kia Hamadanchy, senior policy counsel at ACLU, similarly said Wednesday that "the bipartisan passage of this bill is a flashing warning sign to the government that if it wants our data, it must get a warrant."
Hamadanchy added that "we hope this vote puts a fire under the Senate to protect their constituents and rein in the government's warrantless surveillance of Americans, once and for all."
Sen. Ron Wyden (D-Ore.), a critic of the pending 702 bill and FANFSA's lead sponsor in the upper chamber, called the the House's Wednesday vote "a huge win for privacy" and said that "now it's time for the Senate to follow suit."
Keep ReadingShow Less
Leaked Cables Show Biden Pressuring Nations to Oppose Palestine's UN Membership
"This is the evidence that President Biden's talk about a two-state solution is nothing but idle talk," said one former Lebanese diplomat.
Apr 17, 2024
As the United Nations Security Council prepares to vote Thursday on Palestine's bid to become a full U.N. member, the Biden administration—which claims to support Palestinian statehood—is lobbying UNSC nations in an effort to wrangle enough "no" votes so that the United States can avoid resorting to a veto.
Leaked cables obtained by The Intercept show U.S. pressure on Security Council members including Malta—which currently presides over the body—and Ecuador.
While claiming that President Joe Biden backs "Palestinian aspirations for statehood," one of the cables asserts that "it remains the U.S. view that the most expeditious path toward a political horizon for the Palestinian people is in the context of a normalization agreement between Israel and its neighbors."
"We therefore urge you not to support any potential Security Council resolution recommending the admission of 'Palestine' as a U.N. member state, should such a resolution be presented to the Security Council for a decision in the coming days and weeks," the document advises.
The U.S. argument essentially is that the U.N. should not create an independent Palestinian state by fiat—even though that's precisely how the world body voted in 1947 to establish the modern state of Israel.
The renewed push for Palestine's U.N. membership comes as Israel wages a genocidal war on the Gaza Strip. The Palestinian Authority, which hasn't controlled Gaza for nearly two decades, rejected the Biden administration's requests to hold off on seeking full membership.
"We wanted the U.S. to provide a substantive alternative to U.N. recognition. They didn't," one unnamed Palestinian official toldAxios on Wednesday. "We believe full membership in the U.N. for Palestine is way overdue. We have waited more than 12 years since our initial request."
As The Intercept's Ken Klippenstein and Daniel Boguslaw noted:
Since 2011, the U.N. Security Council has rejected the Palestinian Authority's request for full member status. On April 2, the Palestinian Observer Mission to the U.N. requested that the council once again take up consideration of its membership application. According to the first State Department cable, U.N. meetings since the beginning of April suggest that Algeria, China, Guyana, Mozambique, Russia, Slovenia, Sierra Leone, and Malta support granting Palestine full membership to the U.N. It also says that France, Japan, and Korea are undecided, while the United Kingdom will likely abstain from a vote.
Along with the United States, China, France, Russia, and the United Kingdom are permanent members of the UNSC, so they also have veto power.
Ahead of Thursday's planned vote, Spain has been doing its own lobbying in Europe to build greater support for Palestinian statehood. At a joint Tuesday press conference with Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez, Slovenian Prime Minister Robert Golob said the question is "when, not if, but when is the best moment to recognize Palestine."
Belgium—which is seeking economic sanctions against Israel in response to its genocidal war on Gaza—is expected to join Spain's push for Palestinian statehood after the country's European Union presidency expires in June.
Currently, 139 of the U.N.'s 193 member states recognize Palestine as an independent state.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu—who has also claimed to support a so-called "two-state solution"—has alternately boasted about thwarting Palestinian statehood.
Critics pointed to the leaked cables as more proof of U.S. duplicity and double standards on the Israel-Palestine issue.
"This is the evidence that President Biden's talk about a two-state solution is nothing but idle talk," Massoud Maalouf, a former Lebanese ambassador to Canada, Chile, and Poland, said on social media.
Keep ReadingShow Less
Database Exposes 'Illicit Network Undermining Democracy Around the World'
Yanis Varoufakis hailed the effort as "a treasure chest of well-researched reports on how the reactionaries of the world unite."
Apr 17, 2024
"Coups. Assassinations. Riots. Detentions. Disinformation. We know the tactics that have been deployed to undermine our democracies. But who is behind them?"
Progressive International (PI) asks and answers this and other questions with an extensive new database published Wednesday that connects the dots in what the leftist group calls the "Reactionary International"—a loose global network of right-wing leaders and organizations working to subvert democratic institutions.
PI calls it an "illicit network undermining democracy around the world."
"Today is a mask-off moment for the Reactionary International and the parties, politicians, judges, journalists, foundations, think tanks, tech platforms, NGOs, activists, financiers, and entrepreneurs that comprise it," PI said.
"After a year of preparation, we finally open the doors to our new research consortium, exposing the global network of reactionary forces that corrode our democracies, destroy our planet, and drive us closer to world war," the group added.
"The twin insurrections at the U.S. Capitol in 2021 and Brasília's Three Powers Plaza in 2023 left no doubt about the international coordination of reactionary forces," PI argued. "Yet far too little is known about the entities of this network, their sources of financing, and their institutional allies operating inside our political systems."
Ultimately, PI aims to "support democratic systems to become more resilient to their insidious tactics."
From leaders like Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, and former U.S. President Donald Trump—the presumptive 2024 Republican presidential nominee—to evangelical Christian groups influencing laws in African countries criminalizing LGBTQ+ people and tech companies empowering ubiquitous state surveillance, Reactionary International is a who's-who of the world's right-wing forces.
A cursory search of the database's contents shows users can:
- Learn about Israel's NSO, Rayzone, and Team Jorge, and how a team of Tel Aviv tech entrepreneurs fuel unrest in Latin America;
- Meet the Grey Wolves, Turkey's roving death squad with links to President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and the ethno-nationalists in his governing coalition; and
- Explore the global network of the Falun Gong, its Trump-connected media outlet The Epoch Times, and its traveling dance troupe known as Shen Yun.
Yanis Varoufakis, a PI member and secretary-general of the left-wing Democracy in Europe Movement 2025, called the database "a treasure chest of well-researched reports on how the reactionaries of the world unite."
PI invites the public to contribute to the database.
"Together, we will not only name, shame, and expose the forces of the far right—but also dismantle their network of complicity," the group said.
Keep ReadingShow Less
Most Popular