September, 15 2008, 01:43pm EDT
For Immediate Release
Contact:
Jeffrey Buchanan, Gulf Coast Civic Works Campaign 202-463-7575 ext 241
buchanan@rfkmemorial.org
Charles Jackson, ACORN 504-943-0044
communications@acorn.org
Evangelical, Mainline Protestant, Catholic, Jewish, Muslim Leaders Call for Moral Response to Hurricanes
Rebuilding and Human Rights Are National Moral Priority
WASHINGTON
Today, 107 leading religious
officials - including, Rev. Richard Cizik, National Association of
Evangelicals; Richard Stearns, President, World Vision; Rabbi Steve Gutow, Jewish
Council for Public Affairs; Rev. Dr. Michael Kinnamon, National Council of
Churches; Dr. Ingrid Matterson, Islamic Society of North America; Fr. Larry
Snyder, Catholic Charities USA; Rev. David Beckmann, Bread for the World; and
Rev. Jim Wallis, Sojourners - are calling for not just a charitable
response but for a just moral response to driving for resident-led human rights
based federal solutions helping families.
Three years after the current administration first promised
to rebuild the region devastated by Hurricanes Katrina and Rita, the slow pace
of recovery and recent devastation of hurricanes Gustav and Ike have created a
moral crisis in the Gulf
Coast. The collapse
of local institutions, homelessness, internal displacement, poverty, abusive
labor practices and environmental degradation in the Gulf Coast
demands a powerful response from people of faith. Diverse faith leaders
have partnered with the Gulf Coast Civic Works Campaign to call for bi-partisan
resident-led federal solutions helping families return and participate in
rebuilding their communities, creating living wage jobs, restoring the coastal
wetland and ensuring human rights in the Gulf Coast
region a national priority.
The Gulf Coast Civic Works Campaign is a
nonpartisan partnership of community, faith, environmental, student, and human
rights organizations in Alabama, Louisiana, and Mississippi and their national
allies advocating for federal legislation based on HR 4048, the Gulf Coast
Civic Works Act and urging national leaders to make creating jobs, rebuilding
infrastructure and affordable housing, and restoring natural flood protection
along the Gulf Coast a national priority.
Support this effort by contacting your member of Congress
at: https://www.colorofchange.org/gulfcoast/message.html.
[Copy of Statement]
Gulf
Coast Civic Works
Campaign Interfaith Statement
Supporting Human Rights in Gulf Coast
Recovery Is a Moral Priority
As Hurricanes Ike and Gustav
hit the Gulf Coast,
internally displacing over one million people, we as a nation were reawakened
to the needs of the Gulf
Coast. Three years after
Hurricanes Katrina and Rita struck and the levees breached, the slow pace of
recovery and the new needs caused by Ike and Gustav's destruction have
created a moral crisis along the Gulf
Coast that demands a
powerful response from people of faith.
While the nation has
learned to better prepare for this latest hurricane, whether by inaction or
injustice, we have still failed to protect the wellbeing of Gulf Coast
survivors, new residents and their families, especially the children, the poor,
the sick, and the vulnerable through just long term rebuilding policies which
fully support human rights. The collapse of local institutions, homelessness,
internal displacement, poverty, abusive labor practices and environmental
degradation mean they continue to suffer and struggle unduly. A spiritual wound
remains open across the region, one felt in God's creation and every community
across this country.
Our God is a God of
justice, of humanity and of healing, and this moral injustice calls each of us
to bold action in support of the common good. We must act to justly
rebuild communities, restore the Gulf
Coast, and empower
families to overcome the devastation they suffered in our nation's worst
natural disasters.
As people of faith and
as Americans we believe in transcendent human dignity and place our trust in
basic human rights. Many of the survivors of these disasters lack the resources
to return to their communities to reunite with their families. Many families
still have not recovered and have not been able to resume their lives with the
dignity and safety that are their right. New residents who came to work
in the recovery face hardships and abuses.
Gulf
Coast
communities continue to suffer from toxic trailers; closed schools, police
stations, and hospitals; a shortage of affordable housing; crumbling roads and
water systems; and workplace abuse.
As we have seen during
Hurricane Gustav, an inadequate flood protection system and accelerating
erosion of the wetlands left residents vulnerable to this and future disasters.
Through years of improper stewardship, preventable coastal erosion has
destroyed billions of dollars worth of natural flood protection and threatens
the homes, places of worship, schools, and businesses of those who live along
the Gulf Coast. This also threatens the security
of the majority of our nation's energy infrastructure, parts of which were
once built above land and now reside below salt water. The result is an
American human rights and national security crisis that requires the attention
all Americans, regardless of where they live, their faith, or their political
party.
Together Hurricanes
Katrina, Rita, Ike and Gustav killed more than 2,000 people. They destroyed
thousands of homes, businesses, and places of worship, causing over $150
billion in damages and displacing hundreds of thousands of families. Members of
diverse faith communions have responded generously, volunteering thousands of
hours to rebuild lives across Alabama, Louisiana, Mississippi
and Texas and
giving millions in charitable donations. Faith groups have formed powerful new
partnerships with local community leaders, non-profits, and other
denominations, to lead some of the most successful efforts in the recovery.
We have learned that
acts of faith and mercy alone, no matter how profound, cannot provide
everything needed for a sustainable recovery. Gulf Coast
families deserve a federal government that recognizes their needs by rebuilding
their communities, supporting basic human rights of all communities, addressing
poverty and displacement, and confronting coastal erosion. The government must
empower local communities to take the lead in rebuilding their neighborhoods,
renewing their lives, and restoring God's creation. We believe it is a
moral obligation for the federal government to fulfill its promises for Gulf Coast
recovery: empowering residents to return and participate in equitably
rebuilding their communities.
Now we are joining
community and faith leaders across Alabama, Louisiana, Mississippi
and Texas and calling on people of faith to
form a new partnership for a renewed and just federal Gulf
Coast recovery policy to put all Gulf Coast
communities, regardless of race, ethnicity or income, on the path to an
economically, socially and environmentally sustainable recovery.
We ask national leaders
of both parties, Democrats and Republicans, as they discuss the future of our
nation, to honor the third anniversary of Hurricanes Katrina and Rita and the
survivors of Hurricanes Ike and Gustav by pledging to fulfill these obligations
in the next Administration and Congress, including:
-
Passing policy based on the Gulf Coast Civic Works Act for a resident-led
partnership to rebuild vital public infrastructure, restore the environment,
and create good jobs and economic opportunities for residents and returning
displaced families to help create stronger, safer, and more equitable
communities;
-
Increasing funding for federal, state, and local partnerships in the Gulf Coast
to create more affordable housing and promote home-ownership for returning
families, workers, and residents moving out of unsafe FEMA trailers; and
-
Supporting federal funding to restore the coastal wetlands and barrier islands
that form the Gulf Coast's natural barriers to flooding and to build
improved levee systems to create a comprehensive flood control system which could
protect all Gulf Coast communities from another Category 5 storm.
Signed,
Rev. Richard Cizik, Vice President, National Association of Evangelicals*
Rabbi Steve Gutow, Executive Director, Jewish Council for Public Affairs
Rev. Dr. Michael Kinnamon, General Secretary, National Council of Churches
Dr. Ingrid Mattson, President, The Islamic Society of North America
Fr. Larry Snyder, President, Catholic Charities, USA
Rev. David Beckmann, President, Bread for the World
Richard Stearns, President, World Vision
Rev. Jim Wallis, President, Sojourners
The Rt. Rev. Wayne Burkette, President, The Moravian Church, Southern Province
The Rt. Rev. David L. Wickmann, President, The Moravian Church, Northern Province
Rev. Jacob Jang, General Secretary, Korean Presbyterian Church in America
The Most Reverend Dr. Katharine Jefferts Schori, Presiding Bishop, The Episcopal Church
Stanley Noffsinger, General Secretary, Church of the Brethren
Rev. Dr. John H. Thomas, General Minister and President, United Church of Christ
Rev. Dr. Sharon Watkins, General Minister and President, Christian Church (Disciples of Christ)
Rev. Jim Winkler, General Secretary, The United Methodist Church General Board of Church and Society
Dr. Robert C. Andringa, President Emeritus, Council for Christian Colleges and Universities
Roberta Avila, Executive Director, Mississippi Coast Interfaith Disaster Task Force
His Eminence Archbishop Vicken Aykazian, President, National Council of Churches
Dr. David R. Black, President, Eastern University*
Rev. Dr. Ken Brooker Langston, Coordinator, Disciples Center for Public Wellness, Church of Christ
Sr. Simone Campbell, Director, NETWORK, A National Catholic Social Justice Lobby
Dr. Tony Campolo, , Eastern University, St. David's, PA*
Dr. Iva Carruthers, General Secretary, Samuel Dewitt Proctor Convention
Rev. Alfred Carter, President, Bayou Interfaith Shared Community Organizing
Rev. Noel Castellanos, CEO, Christian Community Development Association
Charles Clements, President and CEO, Unitarian Universalist Service Committee
Dr. Luis Cortes, Executive Director, Nueva Esperanza
Dr. Paul Corts, President, Council for Christian Colleges and Universities*
Sr. Anne Curtis, RSM, Leadership Team, Institute of the Sisters of Mercy of the Americas
Marie Dennis, Co-President, Pax Christi International and Director, Maryknoll Office for Global Concerns
Rev. Dr. Bob Edgar, President, Common Cause, Former General Secretary of the National Council of Churches
Rabbi Jerome M. Epstein, Executive Vice-President, United Synagogue of Conservative Judaism
Rabbi Marla J. Feldman, Director, Commission on Social Action of Reform Judaism
Mary Fontenot, Executive Director, All Congregations Together
Rev. Dr. C. Welton Gaddy, President, Interfaith Alliance
Sharon Gauthe, Executive Director, Bayou Interfaith Shared Community Organizing
Sr. Donna Graham, OSF, Franciscan Justice and Peace Office and OFM for Province of St. John the Baptist
Dr. David Gushee, Presidents, Evangelicals for Human Rights*
Rev. Dr. Derrick Harkins, Treasurer, Senior Pastor, World Relief, Nineteen Street Baptist Church*
Rev. Dr. Leo Hartshorn, Minister of Peace and Justice, Mennonite Mission Network, U.S. Ministries
Dr. Frederick Haynes, III, Senior Pastor, Friendship West Baptist Church, Dallas, Texas
Dr. Obery Hendricks, Professor of Biblical Interpretation, New York Theological Seminary, Author of "The Politics of Jesus"*
Bishop Thomas J. Hoyt, Co-Chair, National Council of Churches Special Commission on the Just Rebuilding of the Gulf Coast
Dr. John Huffman, Senior Pastor, St. Andrew's Presbyterian Church*
Dr. George Hunsinger, Professor, Princeton Theological Seminary, Founder, National Religious Campaign Against Torture
Dr. Joel C. Hunter, Senior Pastor, Northland, A Distributed Church*
Dr. Ada Maria Isasi-Diaz, Professor of Christian Ethics and Theology, Drew University, Madison, NJ*
Rev. M. Linda Jaramillo, Justice and Witness Ministry, United Church of Christ
David E. Jehnsen, Chair of the Board, Every Church a Peace Church
Ven. Michael S. Kendall, President, Episcopal Network for Economic Justice
Hon. Kathleen Kennedy Townsend, Author of "Failing America's Faithful", former Lt. Gov. of Maryland and Board Member, RFK Memorial
Rabbi Asher Knight, , Temple Emanu-El, Dallas Texas
Chris Kromm, Executive Director, Institute for Southern Studies, Author of "Faith in the Gulf"
Rabbi Irwin Kula, President, The Center for Leadership and Learning
Dr. Peter Kuzmic, Distinguished Professor, Gordon Cornwell Theological Seminary
Rabbi Michael Lerner, Founder, TIKKUN and Network of Spiritual Progressives
Rev. Michael E. Livingston, Co-Chair, National Council of Churches Special Commission on the Just Rebuilding of the Gulf Coast
Dr. Jo Anne Lyon, Founder and CEO, World Hope International
Renaye Manley, Organizaing Director, Interfaith Worker Justice
Bishop A.C. "Chip" Marble Jr., Assisting Bishop, Diocese of North Carolina, Greensboro Office*
Dr. Molly T. Marshall, President and Professor of Theology and Spiritual Formation, Central Baptist Theological Seminary
Rev. Timothy McDonald III, President, African American Ministers in Action
Dr. Brian D. McLaren, best-selling Author, Pastor and intellectual leader of "emerging church,"*
Rev. LeDayne McLeese Polaski, Program Coordinator, Baptist Peace Fellowship of North America
Fr. T. Michael McNulty, SJ, Justice and Peace Director, Conference of Major Superiors of Men
Rev. Gail E. Mengel, Ecumenical and Interfaith Officer, Community of Christ
Rabbi Jack Moline, Chair of the Board, Interfaith Alliance and Senior Rabbi, Agudas Achim Congregation
Rev. Jethroe Moore, II, President, San Jose NAACP
Imam Abdul Malik Mujahid, Chair, Council of the Islamic Organizations of Greater Chicago
Dr. Pamela Nath, , Listening & Discernment, Mennonite Central Committee
Sr. Ann Oestreich, IHM, Congressional Coordinator, Congregation Justice Committee, Sisters of the Holy Cross
Vicky Partin, Lay Missioner, Chattahoochee Valley Episcopal Ministry
Dr. Ron Patterson, Executive Director, Christian Disaster Response
Sara Pottschmidt Lisherness, Director, Compassion, Peace, and Justice Ministries, Presbyterian Church USA
Sr. Claire Regan, Office of Justice and Peace, Sisters of Charity of New York
Rev. Carl W. Rehling, Director, Episcopal Diocese of Maryland, Diocesan Liaison for Justice and Peace
Sr. Jane Remson, O.Carm. Main Representative to UN, Carmelite NGO Congregation of Our Lady of Mount Carmel
Dr. Meg Riley, Director of Advocacy and Witness, Unitarian Universalist Association Congregation
Bill Robinson, President, Whitworth University*
Rev. Samuel Rodriguez, President, National Hispanic Christian Leadership Conference
Robert S. Runkle, Chair, Social Justice and Outreach Ministries Commission, Episcopal Diocese of Spokane
Dr. Andrew Ryskamp, Director, Christian Reformed World Relief Committee
Rev. Gabriel Salguero, Director, Hispanic/Latino Leadership Program, Princeton Theological Seminary*
Rev. Dr. Virginia Samuel, Interim Dean of Campus Life and Student Affairs, Drew University, Madison, NJ*
Sr. Marylin K. Scheib, Regional Administrative Office, Sisters of Mercy of the Regional Community of St. Louis
Rev. Bill Schulz, Chairman, Unitarian Universalist Service Committee Board of Directors
Rev. Dr. Ronald J. Sider, President, Evangelicals for Social Action
Dr. Ann E. Smith, President, Gamaliel Foundation
Rev.Dr. Cory Sparks, Chair, Commission on Stewardship of the Environment, Louisiana Interchurch Conference
Dr. Glen Harold Stassen, Lewis B. Smedes Professor of Christian Ethics, Fuller Seminary*
Rev. Ron Stief, Organizing Director, Faith in Public Life
Russ Testa, Executive Director, Franciscan Action Network
Rabbi Uri Topolosky, Senior Rabbi, Congregation Beth Israel, A Community Synagogue in New Orleans
Rev. Romal Tune, President, Clergy Strategic Alliances
Sr. Mari Turgi, CSC, Director, Holy Cross International Office
Rabbi Stewart Vogel, President, Southern California Board of Rabbis
Rabbi Brian Walt, Executive Director, Rabbis for Human Rights
Rabbi Arthur Waskow, Executive Director, Shalom Center
Alix Webb, Program Manager, The Poverty Initiative, Union Theological Seminary
Rev.Dr. C. David Williams, President, Union of Black Episcopalians
Dr. Lauren Winner, Assistant Professor of Christian Spirituality, Duke Divinity School, Duke University*
Rabbi David Wolpe, Senior Rabbi, Sinai Temple*
Dr. Aidsand Wright-Riggins III, Executive Director, National Ministries, American Baptist Church, USA
Dr. Amos Yong, Professor of Theology, Regent University School of Divinity*
Susan Youmans, Executive Director, Environmental Partnership
* Organization is listed for identification purposes only
LATEST NEWS
South Korean Court Hears First Asian Youth Climate Case
"Carbon emission reduction keeps getting pushed back as if it is homework that can be done later," said one plaintiff's mother. "But that burden will be what our children have to bear eventually."
Apr 23, 2024
One of South Korea's two highest courts on Tuesday began hearing Asia's first-ever youth-led climate lawsuit, which accuses the country's government of failing to protect citizens from the effects of the worsening, human-caused planetary emergency.
Nineteen members of the advocacy group Youth4ClimateAction filed a constitutional complaint in March 2020 accusing the South Korean government of violating their rights to life, the "pursuit of happiness," a "healthy and pleasant environment," and to "resist against human extinction."
The lawsuit also notes "the inequality between the adult generation who can enjoy the relatively pleasant environment and the youth generation who must face a potential disaster from climate change," as well as the government's obligation to prevent and protect citizens from environmental disasters.
"South Korea's current climate plans are not sufficient to keep the temperature increase within 1.5°C, thus violating the state's obligation to protect fundamental rights," the plaintiffs said in a statement.
South Korea's Constitutional Court began hearing a case that accuses the government of having failed to protect 200 people, including dozens of young environmental activists and children, by not tackling climate change https://t.co/XRIGE23KGMÂ pic.twitter.com/snvqBaGGe9
— Reuters (@Reuters) April 23, 2024
Signatories to the 2015 Paris agreement committed to "holding the increase in global average temperature to well below 2°C above preindustrial levels and pursuing efforts to limit the temperature increase to 1.5°C."
According to the United Nations Environment Program's (UNEP) most recent Emissions Gap Report, the world must slash greenhouse gas emissions by 28% before 2030 to limit warming to 2°C above preindustrial levels and 42% to halt warming at 1.5°C. UNEP said that based on current policies and practices, the world is on track for 2.9°C of warming by the end of the century.
A summary of the lawsuit notes that South Korea is the fifth-largest greenhouse gas (GHG) emitter among Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development nations, and that the government is constitutionally obligated to protect Koreans from the climate emergency.
Instead, the plaintiffs argue, the Korean Parliament "gave the government total discretion to set the GHG reduction target without providing any specific guidelines." Furthermore, they contend that the government's downgraded reduction targets fall "far short of what is necessary to satisfy the temperature rise threshold acknowledged by the global community."
Lee Donghyun, the mother of one of the plaintiffs, toldReuters: "Carbon emission reduction keeps getting pushed back as if it is homework that can be done later. But that burden will be what our children have to bear eventually."
The South Korean case comes on the heels of a landmark ruling by the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR), which found that Switzerland's government violated senior citizens' human rights by refusing to heed scientists' warnings to swiftly phase out fossil fuel production.
The ECHR ruled on the same day that climate cases brought by a former French mayor and a group of Portuguese youth were inadmissible.
Courts in Australia, Brazil, and Peru also have human rights-based climate cases on their dockets.
In the United States, a state judge in Montana ruled last year in favor of 16 young residents who argued that fossil fuel extraction violated their constitutional right to "a clean and healthful environment."
Meanwhile, the Biden administration is trying to derail a historic youth-led climate lawsuit against the U.S. government.
Keep ReadingShow Less
UN Rights Chief Demands International Probe of Mass Graves Near Gaza Hospitals
"Hospitals are entitled to very special protection under international humanitarian law," said Volker Türk, the United Nations high commissioner for human rights.
Apr 23, 2024
The United Nations' human rights chief on Tuesday called for an international investigation into mass graves discovered at two Gaza hospitals that Israeli forces recently assailed and destroyed, further imperiling the enclave's barely functioning healthcare system.
Volker Türk, the U.N. high commissioner for human rights, said in a statement that he was "horrified" by the discovery of mass graves at the Nasser and al-Shifa medical complexes, which the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) reduced to ruins.
More than 300 bodies were reportedly discovered in the mass grave near the Nasser facility in Khan Younis, Gaza, and eyewitnesses said Israeli soldiers executed civilians during their two-week-long raid of al-Shifa last month.
Türk demanded an "independent, effective, and transparent" probe into the killings and mass graves, adding that "given the prevailing climate of impunity, this should include international investigators."
"Hospitals are entitled to very special protection under international humanitarian law," he added. "And the intentional killing of civilians, detainees, and others who are hors de combat is a war crime."
"Every 10 minutes a child is killed or wounded. They are protected under the laws of war, and yet they are ones who are disproportionately paying the ultimate price."
The IDF's destructive attacks on Nasser and al-Shifa were part of a broader Israeli assault on Gaza's healthcare system. An analysis released Monday by Save the Children found that the rate of monthly Israeli attacks on healthcare in Gaza since October has exceeded that of any other conflict around the world since 2018.
The group estimated that Israel has launched an average of 73 attacks per month on healthcare in Gaza—and at least 435 attacks total since October.
"After six months of unimaginable horror, the healthcare system in Gaza has been brought to its knees," said Xavier Joubert, Save the Children's country director in the occupied Palestinian territory. "Healthcare workers are risking their lives daily to give Palestinian children a chance at survival. The constant attacks on healthcare are simply unjustifiable and must stop. Palestinian children must have unimpeded access to services, including healthcare and education."
Türk also used his statement Tuesday to condemn Israeli forces' killing of women and children in airstrikes on the southern Gaza city of Rafah in recent days. The human rights official noted that Gaza doctors rescued a baby from the womb of her mother as the latter succumbed to head injuries from an Israeli strike.
"The latest images of a premature child taken from the womb of her dying mother, of the adjacent two houses where 15 children and five women were killed—this is beyond warfare," said Türk. "Every 10 minutes a child is killed or wounded. They are protected under the laws of war, and yet they are ones who are disproportionately paying the ultimate price in this war."
Keep ReadingShow Less
'Shameful': UK Conservatives Push Through Plan to Deport Asylum-Seekers to Rwanda
"The U.K. government could literally pay every refugee a £30,000 annual salary for life, and it would be cheaper," said one critic. "We're burning money just to enjoy the cruelty."
Apr 23, 2024
Legal and human rights experts on Tuesday said the British Conservative Party's decision to push through a bill allowing the government to deport asylum-seekers to Rwanda—effectively overriding last year's Supreme Court ruling—represented a "desperate low" from lawmakers eager to exploit migrants ahead of elections expected later this year.
"A lot of this is performative cruelty," Daniel Merriman, a lawyer whose clients have included some asylum-seekers whom the Tories tried to deport after it first introduced its plan in 2022, toldNPR. "The elephant in the room is the upcoming election."
After a prolonged debate, the unelected House of Lords cleared the way to pass the Safety of Rwanda bill early Tuesday morning, after dropping several proposed amendments including one that would have required independent verification that the central African country is a safe place to send migrants.
The House of Commons then passed the bill, and King Charles III is expected to formally approve the legislation in the coming days.
The bill requires courts and immigration officials to "conclusively treat the Republic of Rwanda as a safe country" to send asylum-seekers, even though the Supreme Court ruled in November that people deported to the country would face a significant risk of refoulement, or being sent back to the countries where they originally fled persecution or violence.
The Conservative government signed a treaty with Rwanda last December to strengthen protections for asylum-seekers, including a provision that partially bans Rwanda from sending people back to their home countries.
But the United Nations Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) called on the U.K. to abandon the plan and instead "take practical measures to address irregular flows of refugees and migrants, based on international cooperation and respect for international human rights law."
"The new legislation marks a further step away from the U.K.'s long tradition of providing refuge to those in need, in breach of the Refugee Convention," said Filippo Grandi, the U.N. high commissioner for refugees. "Protecting refugees requires all countries—not just those neighboring crisis zones—to uphold their obligations. This arrangement seeks to shift responsibility for refugee protection, undermining international cooperation and setting a worrying global precedent."
"The U.K. has a proud history of effective, independent judicial scrutiny," Grandi added. "It can still take the right steps and put in place measures to help address the factors that drive people to leave home, and share responsibility for those in need of protection, with European and other international partners."
Dorothy Guerrero, head of policy and advocacy at Global Justice Now, noted that "disastrous foreign and economic policies of successive governments have contributed to the need for people to seek refuge."
"These same people's lives are continually used as a political football, after years of being scapegoats for bad government decisions," said Guerrero. "Statements from politicians are now even more blatantly devoid of any pretense of care for human rights. We will not stop pushing for a change of course, with safe routes to seek asylum in the U.K. so that people no longer have to risk their lives in the Channel."
"The passing of the Rwanda Bill is a shameful day for the U.K.," she added.
Hours after the legislation was passed, French officials announced that at least five people, including a seven-year-old child, had been killed while attempting to cross the English Channel, bound for the U.K. in an overloaded inflatable boat.
At The New Statesman, associate political editor Rachel Cunliffe wrote Tuesday that the tragedy reveals "the flaws of the Rwanda plan," which proponents say could deter migrants from seeking refuge in Britain.
Proponents of the Rwanda plan will inevitably point to today's disaster as further evidence that strong measures are needed to address the issue of Channel crossings. They will accuse Labour and opposition parties of ignoring the human cost of letting this crisis continue and argue that lives are at stake if the government does not act.
[...]
The reality is that a substantial number of people who pay people traffickers large sums of money to crowd them on to a tiny boat do so because they feel they have no other option. Fleeing war and persecution, they are desperate. And so they are prepared to take desperate measures. Measures that sometimes lead to tragedy, but which are deemed necessary given the hopelessness of their situation.
It is hard to see how the threat to send a tiny fraction of those who arrive (Rwanda has said it will only take 150-200 migrants) changes this calculation.
The Labour Party, which is leading Conservatives in polls ahead of the expected elections, has vowed to scrap the legislation if it wins control of the government later this year, and critics have expressed doubt that Prime Minister Rishi Sunak will actually secure deportation flights before Britons vote.
One flight was grounded in June 2022 after the European Court of Human Rights intervened, and on Monday the OHCHR warned aviation authorities that they would risk violating international law if they allow "unlawful removals" of asylum-seekers to Rwanda.
Critics have also pointed to a finding by the National Audit Office that the deportations would cost £1.8 million ($2.2 million) per person.
"The U.K. government could literally pay every refugee a £30,000 annual salary for life, and it would be cheaper than sending them to Rwanda," said David Andress, a history professor at the University of Portsmouth. "We're burning money just to enjoy the cruelty."
Keep ReadingShow Less
Most Popular