Iraq Withdrawal: Amid Heat and Broken Promises, Only the Ice Man Cometh
After seven years and $53bn of US reconstruction money, Baghdad still relies on slabs of ice to keep cool
On a pot-holed backstreet in eastern Baghdad, Saad Turki is
sweltering under a corrugated tin roof, manning a giant pulley. The
grime of yet another merciless summer day has stained his shirt ochre
and he is parched from the rigour of a Ramadan fast.
But Turki –
unlike the stream of customers lined up outside his workshop – is not
complaining. Business is buoyant in his rudimentary line of work. The
insufferable heat of Iraq seven years after the invasion has helped transform him from a youth in the city's downtrodden fringes into a man on the make.
is producing large slabs of ice, which most Baghdadis have been using
since mid-June to cool their houses. He has been selling up to 6,000
each day to families who have no other means of making their homes even
remotely livable in the face of a relentless three-month heatwave.
never had a summer like this," he says, as a police pick-up truck pulls
up to collect a half-metre slab of white ice that has freshly spouted
from a rusting foot-wide pipe (the policeman doesn't pay). "On some days
we can't produce enough to satisfy everyone."
supposed to be this way. After seven years of hopes and $53bn of US
reconstruction money, it has come to this — an ice machine in a city on
fire. Iraq in 2010 is far from the middle-income utopia envisaged by
some American officials in the early days of the occupation.
country under Saddam was a command economy ravaged by war and sanctions,
which had taken a particularly heavy toll as the technology driving
civic infrastructure had forged ahead throughout the west during the
As US forces steadily withdraw, George W Bush's notion of a
new Marshall Plan, the blueprint that helped rebuild western Europe
after the second world war, for Iraq is increasingly looking illusory.
Key benchmarks reveal that all aspects of civic infrastructure have
either stagnated or only inched ahead since 2003.
"A lot of the
reconstruction has been posited on things that haven't happened, such as
the reconditioning of major power stations," says Christine McNab, the
resident representative of the United Nations Development Programme in
"A lot of what is wrong with infrastructure is from the
sanctions period, when people couldn't order spare parts and couldn't
Access to potable water had been another key goal of
US and Iraqi administrators. And while there has been progress at a
micro-level, such as a US-built water treatment plant in Sadr City and
work by the US Army Corps of Engineers in other deprived regions, an
overhaul of Iraq's moribund water delivery system has not happened.
United Nations says 79% of Iraqis now have improved access to drinking
water compared with 2003. However, separate figures reveal that only one
in four households have access to tap water in their homes.
is a serious environmental threat – more than 60% of households dump
untreated waste on open land. Electricity remains a major problem.
streets of Baghdad are strung with a spider's web of makeshift wires,
leading eventually to a Dickensian structure belching black smoke into a
hazy sky from four stacks. This is Baghdad's only power station, in the
southern suburbs of Dora, the engine room of a city that was supposed
to power the nation towards a long-promised new beginning.
Dora station has been providing most households with no more than three
hours of electricity a day this summer. It is running at maximum
capacity, generating 3,500 megawatts, which supplies roughly 60% of
Baghdad's daily needs.
Ghazi Essa, the station director, says all
his pleas for new technology or spare parts which could boost output
have been ignored for a long time, but particularly in the past six
months, when Iraq has been without a functioning government, or anyone
to give executive direction.
"We cannot reach more than 70% of the
design load," he says. "It has never reached 51C [124F] in Baghdad
before. For each degree increase in temperature there is an extra 100
megawatt demand. It is very, very hot and there is so much suffering for
"I feel sorry because we are leaving them many problems and there is nothing we can do."
is generating only 8,000 of the 13-15,000 megawatts of daily power
needed to meet its needs. Supply has increased by around 30% since early
2003, but that is nowhere near enough to keep up with demand, which has
soared as people have snapped up cheap Chinese white goods that now
flood local markets. The Iraqi government has spent $22.7bn on the
electricity sector since 2006, 42% of which has been used for salaries.
US government has also chipped in, spending $5.3bn on 550
energy-related projects. But even so, it now faces the galling prospect
of Iraqis receiving less electricity per day than when US forces arrived
Since the inconclusive general election of March 7,
ministries have ground to a halt and the parliament has not convened as
the country continues to wallow in a political quagmire that started
when the incumbent prime minister, Nour al-Maliki, was edged out in a
primary vote by former leader Iyad Allawi.
Neither man has been
able to form a government since, and much of the goodwill of the March
election, which saw a strong turnout across much of the country, has
"Delay in the formation of the government has delayed
payment," says Essa. "We are just hanging on now. This period [of
indecision] has delayed everything. It is not only the Dora station.
Everything has been affected very badly.
"The ministry cannot give me a decision now. There is no money. There is no budget."
Iraq's myriad bureaucracies, it is the same story. Bills are not being
paid, contracts are often not honoured and decisions to lead the nation
forward are not being taken.
Parliament has not passed a law in
almost nine months. There is no agreement on volatile issues such as
Kirkuk and other disputed territories, or on a hydrocarbon law that was
supposed to act as a blueprint for the development of Iraq's oil wealth.
relationship with the restive north is still tenuous, and especially so
since the oil auctions of late last year, which will bring into play
revenues from the giant Kurdish oilfields. Both sides remain deeply
suspicious of each other on all matters to do with how Kirkuk and the
territories are administered. It's very hard to find an Iraqi flag in
the north, except above government buildings – and even then, it is
always considerably smaller than the Kurdish banner flying next to it.
of governance are of critical concern to the steadily rotating senior
diplomats who roll through the giant US embassy in Baghdad. They are
even more of an issue to Iraqis, many of whom have little access to the
security, rights and services that they were told to expect from
democratically elected governments and the institutions that are
supposed to serve them. Herein lies one of the greatest fears for
"It is deeply ingrained that unless you have
someone strong at the top of an institution it is not going to
function," says McNab.
Throughout the past seven years, ministries
have been run in effect as party fiefdoms. None have become anywhere
near as strong as the minister who runs them.
"They need to create
ministries that have no party role at all, rather than being used as a
means of patronage," says one senior western diplomat of Iraq's fiercely
"I don't think they really understand what
politics is really about. They behave like it's about carving up the
country and sharing the goodies, not about running the country and good
"The fact that key legislation has not been passed means they have not taken on board the full responsibility."
whose bid to lead Iraq for a second time helped create the political
stalemate, said Iraq's institutions were being used as a tool of
regional groups who were determined to use Iraq to further their
agendas. "There are elements that are poisoning the well," he said.
is the time. This is the moment. Either we want democracy to succeed,
or we want the ganging of groups against other groups to succeed."
health, some projects have taken root, such as new, desperately needed
hospitals in areas including Basra and Falluja. There has also been more
primary healthcare delivered to most Iraqis nationwide. However, the
number of doctors per capita remains low by regional standards, as does
the quality of care in many Iraqi districts, according to a UN
The brain drain of Iraq's professionals has taken an
especially heavy toll on doctors. Up to 60% of GPs and specialists
present when Baghdad fell have either fled out of fear for their lives
or become economic migrants. Doctors were ruthlessly hunted down by
militias from 2005 to 2008 and remain attractive targets even now.
security was supposed to change all that. And despite a sharp rise in
violence in the past four months, the numbers killed and maimed have
dropped in most areas of Iraq by up to 70% compared with the
blood-soaked days of mid-2006. The Iraqi army has been heavily mentored
and trained by departing US forces and has emerged as a credible
institution – perhaps one of the few in the land. Iraqis tend to trust
the military, but not the police, whose ranking officers are seen to
have facilitated the sectarian war.
In total there are more than
600,000 members of Iraq's security forces. Though strong in number, they
are hindered by a brittle rule of law and a judiciary that has
struggled to assert its independence in the face of political
Many western diplomats believe the judiciary is
reluctant to take on the government, in particular the prime minister's
office, and is very susceptible to influence from Iraq's power base. All
judges get around in armoured convoys because of a very real risk to
their lives. The car park outside Baghdad's central court is littered
with up to 30 blown-up four wheel drives as a reminder of what is at
stake for them.
Adnan al-Baderi, a judicial investigator who deals
with terrorism cases, says his family have twice been targeted. "They
tried to kidnap my oldest son last year. He was in a group of many
people and he was the only one that they went for," he says from his
home inside Baghdad's fortified Green Zone. "This is something we all
must live with."
Seven years of war have also undoubtedly opened
doors and given Iraqis a worldview. The internet is popular with the
country's young, travel to Lebanon, the Gulf, or Europe, is now in reach
for a slowly growing middle class, and freedom of expression has
replaced fear of who might be listening. But hardships are likely to
remain a huge hindrance for many years to come. Even if Essa, the Dora
power station director, had the authority to order spare parts to
increase Baghdad's power output, two of the four giant turbines in use
there are so old that their Italian manufacturer has no replacements in
"They told us they would have to make them," says Essa.
"That could take a year at least. Also, the turbines are being run on
diesel and heavy fuels, when they were designed to be run on gas. Only
the Kirkuk plant is running on gas, because there are no gas lines
elsewhere in the country."
The gas that Essa needs is being burnt
off in giant flares from refineries around the country that have been
wasting around $50 a second, largely because legislators have not been
able to agree for years on who should be allowed to harness the gas and
develop the desperately needed distribution pipelines.
fact that individuals are having to spend their own money on buying
generators means there is that much less money in the economy," says
McNab. "It is the height of absurdity in such an oil-rich country that
they don't have the right oil grades to run these stations properly.
get investors to come, there needs to be electricity 24/7, with no
breaks," she says. "They also want a water supply. They need hygienic
solutions and that means the sanitation services need to be working."
Across Iraq, the US withdrawal is increasingly seen as a rush for the exit, when there remains much work to be done.
want it to be over, but it doesn't mean it is," says the ice-maker,
Turki. "It doesn't bother me though, because I'll be making ice for a
decade to come.
"Look at the mess that is Iraq. Do you think they
will somehow get it together when the strong man leaves town? No, Iraqis
will eat each other for power."