Six Lobbyists Per Lawmaker Work to Shape Health-Care Overhaul
Bloomberg News Investigation Finds Three New Health Lobbyists Register Every Day
It's clear at town halls around the country: An awful lot of people are invested in the fight for health care reform.
But the time, money and manpower that lobbying firms devote to courting
lawmakers reveals an investment inside the Beltway of staggering
For every lawmaker in Congress, there are about six lobbyists
pushing their health care priorities, according to a Bloomberg News
investigation released today. That's about 3,300 registered health care
lobbyists working Capitol Hill, hoping to put a bug in the ear of 100
senators and 435 congressmen.
Bloomberg also examined new lobbyist registrations since July 1
and found that, on average, three lobbying organizations per day, many
headquartered on Washington, D.C.'s K Street corridor, are lining up to
lobby Congress on health reform.
"I don't have a single client who has hired me to kill health
care reform," John Jonas, a partner with lobbying firm Patton Boggs
LLP, a firm representing 33 health care clients, told Bloomberg. "Quite
the opposite, they assume health care reform is going to happen and
they want to be protected."
"You're not going to get health care legislation without
involving the hospitals, without involving those that provide
medications, without talking to groups that represent doctors or
patients or seniors, nurses, what have you," said White House press secretary Robert Gibbs.
Spending on Health Lobbying Tops List of All Sectors
A total of $263 million has been spent on health lobbying in 2009, according to the latest data from the Center for Responsive Politics. That's more money spent on health than any other sector this year.
The list of the top 20 spenders in 2009 across all sectors includes the U.S. Chamber of Commerce at No. 1, spending more than $26 million, Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America (PhRMA)
at No. 3, spending $13 million, and Pfizer in the No. 6 spot, spending
$11 million. Also joining the ranks of the top 20 spenders this year
are Blue Cross Blue Shield, AARP,
American Hospital Association, American Medical Association and Eli
Lilly, each having doled out between $7 and $10 million this year.
"Whenever you have a big piece of legislation like this, it's
like ringing the dinner bell for K Street," Bill Allison, senior fellow
at the Sunlight Foundation, told Bloomberg.
Voicing Health Care Opinions Beyond Washington
"I've been in legislatures, county, state and federal, for a
long time, a large part of my life," said Rep. Louise Slaughter,
D-N.Y., at a Wednesday news conference, reflecting on this week's town
hall debates. "And I've never seen a major bill go through that didn't
have this kind of thing. And it's right. That's democracy."
Joining Slaughter Wednesday was Wendell Potter, a 20-year
health insurance veteran and former CIGNA vice president, who spoke out
about insurance companies operating behind the scenes.
Potter recalled previous health care fights, saying insurers have undoubtedly tried to shape the battle.
"It is usually done through the PR firms that work for them,"
Potter said. "They want to keep their fingerprints off stuff like that.
"With this history, you can rest assured that the industry is
up to the same dirty tricks, using the same devious PR practices it has
used for many years to kill reform this year, or even better, to shape
it so that it benefits insurance companies and their Wall Street
investors far more than average Americans," he said.
Money, time and resources spent on ads targeting those
Americans outside of Washington also illustrate how much various groups
will spend on the hard sell.
Supporters of President Obama had outspent critics on the
airwaves by two to one as of last week, according to Evan Tracey of the
Campaign Media Analysis Group.
Americans for Stable Quality Care, a coalition supportive of
the Obama administration's health care plans and largely funded by the
pharmaceutical industry, is spending $12 million over Congress' August recess to air an ad supporting Democrats' health care efforts.
In addition to PhRMA, the coalition includes the American Medical
Association, FamiliesUSA, the Federation of American Hospitals, and the
Service Employees International Union (SEIU).
"There's nothing wrong with different interests trying to
advocate their position," Larry McNeely, a health care advocate with
U.S. Public Interest Research Group, said to Bloomberg. "What's
different now is the sheer quantity of money that's sloshed around
Washington is drowning out the voices of citizens and the groups that
speak up for them."
ABC News' Dean Norland and Teddy Davis contributed to this report.